David knott 242 |
5 people marked this as a favorite. |
I am now picturing the different core races being scandalized by one another. We already knew that the Kasatha disapprove of the way other races go around with their mouths fully exposed, while the Shirren are shocked by the way Kasatha expose their lower arms.
I guess that means that the Shirren illustration from the GAMA presentation is pornographic by Shirren standards?
Voss |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
"While often displayed, these “mating arms”..."
Exposing them isn't a big deal. And I doubt they'd mistake the bulging muscular things the kasatha are using as 'sexy arms.' They'd more likely wonder where everyone else is keeping theirs. Or if the people they see walking around are eunuchs, and the other species are keeping their viable breeders hidden somewhere.
I kinda like the idea of a Shirr (?) wandering around asking the human drones why they come in multiple types, and what their actual males, females and hosts really look like. Bonus points for assuming lashunta, elves and half-elves are yet more genders, drones or castes of the human species, and lamenting at how complicated it all is to keep track of.
Curaigh |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
What pronouns do hosts use? I feel like that's important for both role play and not confusing players.
Me, I, we, us, they, them. They will also 'use' she, he, him, her & it. :P
Going off of LeGuin's Left Hand of Darkness, the default sex could be neuter with male & female only coming about during mating season. Or using Moffet's Pennterra it goes the other way, when a 'neuter' gets pregnant and becomes 'parent'. Considering 'host' and carrieng their young around for a couple years, this is how I saw it. & plural pronouns seem a safe bet for now. EDIT: I assumed the containers were biological, but on re-read, mechanical containers is probably accurate.
Using LeGuin & Moffet might not be intended, but Paizo's sci-fi/fantasy cultural literacy is a large part of why they continue to impress me. :)
Cthulhudrew |
Interesting. This sounds a lot like the concept of the ludic loop that I just read about in a New York Times article.
When I read that, I was actually thinking that many Shirren must be on a near-constant high, just judging by the tremendous number of options available to us pre-trans-light cultures here on modern day Earth. "Overchoice" is a concept that's been around for a long time, and there are a lot of psychological studies on how it can overwhelm just regular old, non-choice-stimulated humans.
Also, when I read this:
"Addicted to the new drug of individualism, these renegades rejected the Swarm's mindless consumption..."
I initially read that last word as "consumerism," which put a whole different spin on the Swarm. ("It's a vast shopping hive mind, that visits planets and devastates their economies, leaving nothing in its wake!")
Then again, when I read this:
"While often displayed, these “mating arms” are extremely weak and used only for ceremonial and reproductive purposes..."
I thought- drinking alcohol often plays a part in the reproductive process/mating ritual among humans, so can these guys hold their beer in their mating arms? :D
Richard Redmane |
4 people marked this as a favorite. |
"So... how many different shades of blue can I paint my gun again?"
I can so see that trait becoming extremely annoying or incredibly hilarious in the wrong/right hands. Imagine a Shirren mechanic with the handles of all their tools lavishly colored and every new purchase results in several hours just deciding what color to paint the handle. Do I want red or do I want blue?
Matthew Shelton |
THEY'RE ADORABLE!
I want a buddy cop pair of a shirren and vesk...
Vesk: "Greetings new partner. My name is Kartchak."
Shirren: *snort* *snicker*
Vesk: "What is it? What is funny?"
Shirren: "Oh. Please forgive. Your name, it sounds like 'Kthar'k'chak' in my language."
Vesk: "Really. What does that mean?"
Shirren: "You don't want to know."
DM_aka_Dudemeister |
5 people marked this as a favorite. |
KSF wrote:Interesting. This sounds a lot like the concept of the ludic loop that I just read about in a New York Times article.When I read that, I was actually thinking that many Shirren must be on a near-constant high, just judging by the tremendous number of options available to us pre-trans-light cultures here on modern day Earth. "Overchoice" is a concept that's been around for a long time, and there are a lot of psychological studies on how it can overwhelm just regular old, non-choice-stimulated humans.
Also, when I read this:
"Addicted to the new drug of individualism, these renegades rejected the Swarm's mindless consumption..."
I initially read that last word as "consumerism," which put a whole different spin on the Swarm. ("It's a vast shopping hive mind, that visits planets and devastates their economies, leaving nothing in its wake!")
Then again, when I read this:
"While often displayed, these “mating arms” are extremely weak and used only for ceremonial and reproductive purposes..."
I thought- drinking alcohol often plays a part in the reproductive process/mating ritual among humans, so can these guys hold their beer in their mating arms? :D
The Hive: "Didn't we banish you to Foodcourtia?"
Zim: "Oh I quit that."The Hive: "You QUIT being BANISHED?"
thecursor |
Matthew Shelton wrote:So context, but I like to imagine you just said Finns aren't humans :D
Referencing someone in pronoun by gender is habitual in human culture
I've been to Minnesota. Based on all evidence available, Finns, Sweds, and Nords are not human because they can live comfortably in Minnesota.
Kalindlara Contributor |
KingOfAnything |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I find myself oddly annoyed by them being described as arthropods. Insect is perfectly acceptable, describes what they are, and doesn't mean they're being described at the phylum level which if applied generally means humans and Vesk are both being called chordates.
Insect would be the wrong class for an eight-limbed alien. And I wouldn't call them particularly arachnid. There is a limit to how specific you can be the further you get from Earth biology.
lordofthemax |
So me and my buddies have been talking about this game for a while, and are already planning out our party. Right now our group plan is: two Ysoki twins (envoy and technomancer, envoy being the captain of le ship), a Kasatha mechanic, a Human operative (think black ops), and now I have decided to be... a Shirren hipster. Complete with a boombox, denim jacket, fake dreads and beard, a wool cap, and cargo pants. We decided to go either mystic or just tranfer over the bard class.
Opsylum |
Sooo been waiting for this! The flavor for Shirren is better than anything I expected. The "option junkie" bit was particularly funny. I can't decide now whether I want to play a Shirren or an Android for my first campaign. Decisions!
So, being terribly obtuse and ignorant of Shirren anatomy, I am entirely unable to tell whether we are observing two different Shirren sexes in this post or one. At GAMA, we got a peek at what I assume to be an alternate Shirren sex:
https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-3VgP44iw_08/WMy4rddVa0I/AAAAAAAAAEs/l5QfqXNvyL8_ XV69Tjd2HeIkPQY2c2rrQCLcB/s1600/12662.jpg
Kind of looks like a cat. I am okay with this. Can anybody confirm whether the Shirren displayed above are male, female or host?
Also, any chance we might get more write ups for the various races between now and August? We've yet to see proper art of a Lashunta since this game was announced, despite having artwork depicting every other core race. After Erik and Crystal's recent teases about how Lashunta culture has evolved since Pathfinder days, I'm more intrigued than ever to learn about them.
RogueMortal |
Will there be any mechanical effect from their "pleasure of choices", and if so any alternate traits for a more traditional sort of bug folk?
Seriously, all I can see shirren doing is causing problems because "You're not my host! Don't tell me what to do!" Though I suppose the "gets along with everyone and puts the group first" is a have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too way around that.
Matthew Shelton |
Yayyyyyy! And I really can't emphasize my joy enough through text alone. But I've been waiting for an official insectoid race from Pathfinder. While sadface that its in Starfinder in Pathfinder, it does make a lot more sense to have them in the scifi setting. Looking forward to playing as one!
I would say pull a "Divinity" and make your ancient shirren crashland on ancient Golarion, but it's unclear when their maverick mutation happened. Still, the shirren that you play might be among the very first to arrive.
David knott 242 |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Will there be any mechanical effect from their "pleasure of choices", and if so any alternate traits for a more traditional sort of bug folk?
Seriously, all I can see shirren doing is causing problems because "You're not my host! Don't tell me what to do!" Though I suppose the "gets along with everyone and puts the group first" is a have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too way around that.
To be suitable player characters, the Shirren require free will -- they cannot be part of a hostile hive mind.
However, since they derive pleasure from making choices, I can see them getting overly excited over choices that do not really matter, or for which there is obviously a single right answer with numerous inferior alternatives. I would guess that one sign of maturity among them would be learning to focus on the choices that actually matter even if they don't come along as often as they would like.
Matthew Shelton |
Will there be any mechanical effect from their "pleasure of choices", and if so any alternate traits for a more traditional sort of bug folk?
Seriously, all I can see shirren doing is causing problems because "You're not my host! Don't tell me what to do!" Though I suppose the "gets along with everyone and puts the group first" is a have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too way around that.
If there was ever a point to adding a 'useless trivia' skill, this race would be the reason. :)
RogueMortal |
To be suitable player characters, the Shirren require free will -- they cannot be part of a hostile hive mind.
However, since they derive pleasure from making choices, I can see them getting overly excited over choices that do not really matter, or for which there is obviously a single right answer with numerous inferior alternatives. I would guess that one sign of maturity among them would be learning to focus on the choices that actually matter even if they don't come along as often as they would like.
A fine point about hostile hive minds, but other insect races have certainly existed without being such things. Thri-kreen spring to mind, and Dragon Magazine had a race that while normally hive minded, could adapt to individuality if seperated from it. Or maybe those were robots, it was a decade ago. And those are just two of more than a few from d20 games. Not to mention many hive dwellers are't nearly as much mindless cogs as they seem. Bees are actually quite democratic and ants have tirned out to be along the lines of "anarchists with common goals".
For now I take it that the shirren will not have a more traditional option though.
KingOfAnything |
Seriously, all I can see shirren doing is causing problems because "You're not my host! Don't tell me what to do!" Though I suppose the "gets along with everyone and puts the group first" is a have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too way around that.
Just don't give them direct orders, and you'd be fine. Phrase everything as a choice between two superficially different options. The same as dealing with young children.