Pathfinder Unchained and the Terrible, Awful, Real Bad Bloat


Product Discussion

51 to 77 of 77 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

Umbral Reaver wrote:
There's probably a way to exploit this bloat bonus stacking to win at DPR and thus be the best roleplayer.

But then the roll-players would complain!


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Skylancer4 wrote:
Umbral Reaver wrote:
There's probably a way to exploit this bloat bonus stacking to win at DPR and thus be the best roleplayer.
But then the roll-players would complain!

That's fine. They were having badwrongfun anyway.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Kobold Cleaver wrote:
...And the bloatfighter, and the bloatpriest, and then we're all set to fight some normalorcs (sorry, Mikaze, no bloat for you).

Unfair! Orcs are players too. We deserve to be as bloated as Gothmog

...but whatever bloats your float

Scarab Sages

2 people marked this as a favorite.

*Crazy Look in Eyes* I'm mighty afeared of "the Unchaining", I'm stockpiling CRBs in my basement (secured with copious amounts of chain of course). Laugh at me now, but once it happens, you'll all be sorry and begging at my front door for core rule books. *Scurries away to buy more chains*

Liberty's Edge

Don't forget it's all piazo fault for making people buy new material. It's all their fault because DMs can't say no to their players. Or that gamers are not responsible with how their money is spent. That somehow new material equals forced to purchase. Option paralysis I'm not to sympathetic. Once or twice I can understand. More than that get over it, grow a pair and pick something already. It's playing a rpg. Not saving the world.


So, is bloat an AC bonus or does it ad to DR?


Prince Yyrkoon wrote:
So, is bloat an AC bonus or does it ad to DR?

Bloat is a skill that only the unchained Monk, Barbarian, Summoner and Rogue have as class skills. This skills value automagically adds stacking Bloat bonuses to all AC and DR : )


Bloat Class is your character's imperviousness to GMBWMC (GM b8tch*ing whining moaning and complaining). It functions as additional bonuses to AC, Touch AC, CMD, SR, energy resistances (all), all checks [yep, ALL d20 rolls] *and* it permeates printed character sheets out-of-game in such a way that it adds DR/-- and resist fire.

No one is sure how the last one happens, but it does.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Kieviel wrote:
We've actually been using that squirrel rule at our table for about six months now. I was skeptical at first but it's really grown on me as a way of providing a more immersive experience. We're experimenting with electrodes, matches and liquefied sour gumballs for our wizard to apply to himself whenever he uses an appropriate spells.

Sunstone...SUNSTONE! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD SUNSTONE!!! (TaT)


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Ashiel wrote:
Kieviel wrote:
We've actually been using that squirrel rule at our table for about six months now. I was skeptical at first but it's really grown on me as a way of providing a more immersive experience. We're experimenting with electrodes, matches and liquefied sour gumballs for our wizard to apply to himself whenever he uses an appropriate spells.
Sunstone...SUNSTONE! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD SUNSTONE!!! (TaT)

I understood that reference!


SiuoL wrote:
Kobold Cleaver wrote:
SiuoL wrote:
Well, until we get the book and have a review about it, we can't really make a judgement yet.
You have to leave now.
Unreasonable demand, at least state the reason why with a reasonable reason.

No.

SiuoL wrote:
Oh, thanks for not saying mean things to me like Kobold Cleaver and actually telling things! I wouldn't know that if you haven't told me. Interesting...

Also, mreow!

But s'all good, I know I can be inscrutable sometimes. Ooheeheeheehee.


Durngrun Stonebreaker wrote:
Irontruth wrote:
Peas and carrots, peas and carrots.
I say carrots and peas, carrots and peas!

Rhubarb, rhubarb.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Adventure, Rulebook Subscriber
wraithstrike wrote:
chbgraphicarts wrote:
christos gurd wrote:
wraithstrike wrote:
TOZ wrote:
Dude, your username is the poster child of bloat.

What? I don't know spell you are talking about. Oh crap you did not even mention a spell did you? Um well I uh have to go now <backs out of thread>

Off-topic-->Real story: I was in a debate on the wizards 3.5 forums a few years ago, and someone tried to dismiss my arguments by stating that my name was the same as that spell. :)
It wasn't even a debate on something being OP or broken, and I would suggest that none of you ever let this spell into your PF games.

gotta ask...what did it do?

Second level spell; swift action personal spell that allows melee attacks to be resolved as touch attacks for 1 round. Thus it ignores any armor, shield, & natural armor bonuses.

Apply it to Gloves as an at-will ability for a custom magic item that costs all of 12,000gp and watch the DM cry tears of blood.

I always wanted to use it once, just to see the looks on the faces of the players, but I just could not bring myself to do it.

It's like Pandora's box, only with stabbings.


TriOmegaZero wrote:
It's like Pandora's box, only with stabbings.

Who said I can't do stabbings?

Dark Archive

SHARE WITH ME YOUR SECRETS!


Icyshadow wrote:
Kobold Cleaver wrote:
SiuoL wrote:
Well, until we get the book and have a review about it, we can't really make a judgement yet.
You have to leave now.
Come now, we do need some common sense to balance out this madness.

No we don't! Don't you get it? The universe is doomed! DOOOOMED! Dogs and cats living together, mass hysteria!


I don't even know how there CAN BE more bloat! I mean, for Erastil's sake, we already have a class literally named the BLOATMAGE How do you get more bloated than that!?!?

Also, I suspect that the New Rogue will be so underpowered, inefficient, and generally useless that people will be begging to switch back to the old version. Paizo will now issue reprints of the CRB featuring "Rogue Classic", the messageboards' most popular class ever.


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

LOUD NOISES!!!


I need more bloat. I allow any and all books in the d20 system. As a GM I use rules at random when adjudicating actions.

It seems to be working because I have yet had to deal with players who were not foaming at the mouth from an option driven seizure.

I can only hope the bars on my door can prevent James Jacobs from burning down my collection of CRBs (at various stages of errata, versions used at random), forcing me to only use the new unchained material.


bugleyman wrote:

Alternatively we could acknowledge that bloat and character class power levels are matters of opinion. The world has plenty of real conflict without us inventing more.

Personally I find the idea that Pathfinder doesn't have a bloat problem patently ridiculous. And judging from so-called "conga line of bloat threads" it would appear I'm not the only one.

And yet somehow I'll refrain from passive-aggressively insulting anyone's parentage. Carry on.

How dare they create optional rules that we're paradoxically forced to buy and use to increase some undefinable and subjective bloat! Time to pull out something MORE restrictive than core! Everyone's a human commoner without feats! :P


The Unwritten Feat of Commoners: Gather Large Mob. Uses the troop rules .

Silver Crusade

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Bloat isn't an issue in Pathfinder until the other five volumes of the Advanced Class Guide Adventure Path are released. Then we will have bloat.


graystone wrote:
How dare they create optional rules that we're paradoxically forced to buy and use to increase some undefinable and subjective bloat! Time to pull out something MORE restrictive than core! Everyone's a human commoner without feats! :P

The author builds a nice, classic straw man. Unfortunately, he then veers into pandering, leaving the work ultimately unsatisfying. Shows promise, but needs to learn to appreciate subtlety. I would be willing to review this author's future trolling.

** (out of *****)

Silver Crusade

This is where I come to cry


1 person marked this as a favorite.

As a newcomer, this thread fascinates me. I've vaguely managed to piece together the meaning of "bloat" within the context of PF (I think), and I find it hilarious that anybody could argue that too many options are a bad thing.

3.5e was the most popular edition of D&D and it had enough splatbooks to actually bury you.

Clearly, people's fear of change, innovation, progress and good things are making them drive straight down Irrationality Lane.


Umbral Reaver wrote:
Do bloat bonuses stack, like dodge bonuses?

No. You don't add them; you multiply them.

Designer

Guys, I know it's a parody, but this thread isn't going to go anywhere good, especially if the sentiment is that there isn't going to be bloat. Please be respectful of the opinions of others. Thread locked.

51 to 77 of 77 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Paizo Products / Product Discussion / Pathfinder Unchained and the Terrible, Awful, Real Bad Bloat All Messageboards
Recent threads in Product Discussion