Star Voter Season 8, Dedicated Voter Season 9
|
Seeing one item I helped through workshopping. And upvoted, even though my advice was patently ignored :-P
The other item does something quite similar to one I kept. But it is far less elegant and concise, so no real difficulty choosing here. (Ie : no voting cabal, sorry guys)
Same workshopped item. And better again. Here, get an upvote :-)
Every time I see you, I'm impressed. And then I read the last little bit again and cringe. Why did you put that terrible and unnecessary drawback in there? You're still getting the upvote because your opponent is boring.
|
RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16
,
Marathon Voter Season 9
aka Thrawn007
|
Every time you come up, I try to figure out why you picked that spell for construction. Another similar spell is a much better fit both mechanically and thematically, so I find myself wondering why you didn't go with the obvious choice.
It's a small thing that I shouldn't be concerned about...and I'm upvoting you anyway, but it will drive me nuts again next time I see you.
Contributor
,
Marathon Voter Season 9
|
Every time you come up, I try to figure out why you picked that spell for construction. Another similar spell is a much better fit both mechanically and thematically, so I find myself wondering why you didn't go with the obvious choice.
It's a small thing that I shouldn't be concerned about...and I'm upvoting you anyway, but it will drive me nuts again next time I see you.
Is the other spell on the PRD?
Marathon Voter Season 8, Marathon Voter Season 9
|
| 5 people marked this as a favorite. |
Greenwood vs Greenwood o-O What are the odds ?
SUUPAAAAAHH GREEEEEENN
Just the the SUPER-GREEN GEMINI CROQUET CONTEST! YOU WIN A TRIP FOR 2 TO PHLOSTON PAAARAADDDIIIISSSSEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!
I rigged the contest so you can save the world, by the way. <.<
*runs*
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Greenwood vs Greenwood o-O What are the odds ?
SUUPAAAAAHH GREEEEEENN
Just the the SUPER-GREEN GEMINI CROQUET CONTEST! YOU WIN A TRIP FOR 2 TO PHLOSTON PAAARAADDDIIIISSSSEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!
I rigged the contest so you can save the world, by the way. <.<
*runs*
CORBEN? CORBEN?
|
Marathon Voter Season 8, Marathon Voter Season 9
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
CORBEN? CORBEN?Greenwood vs Greenwood o-O What are the odds ?
SUUPAAAAAHH GREEEEEENN
Just the the SUPER-GREEN GEMINI CROQUET CONTEST! YOU WIN A TRIP FOR 2 TO PHLOSTON PAAARAADDDIIIISSSSEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!
I rigged the contest so you can save the world, by the way. <.<
*runs*
WATCH OUT CORBEN! They're warriors. They got ugly teeth, and big bald heads, and they ugly, and they STANK!!!!
|
RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16
,
Marathon Voter Season 9
aka Thrawn007
|
Is the other spell on the PRD?Every time you come up, I try to figure out why you picked that spell for construction. Another similar spell is a much better fit both mechanically and thematically, so I find myself wondering why you didn't go with the obvious choice.
It's a small thing that I shouldn't be concerned about...and I'm upvoting you anyway, but it will drive me nuts again next time I see you.
Yes it is. I went and looked it up, because I thought they might be trying to get around PRD stuff by not using the obvious spell. However, after checking, the other spell is not only PRD, it's existed almost as long as Pathfinder has been around.
Every time I see you, I'm impressed. And then I read the last little bit again and cringe. Why did you put that terrible and unnecessary drawback in there? You're still getting the upvote because your opponent is boring.
What item? I just saw one that might fit that description. PM me?
Cudgel vs Cudgel...
It's sure to be a beatdown.
I just got that same combination I think. Like the other pairing like that I got, they have a surprising amount in common...
Star Voter Season 8, Marathon Voter Season 9
|
Every time I see you, I'm impressed. And then I read the last little bit again and cringe. Why did you put that terrible and unnecessary drawback in there? You're still getting the upvote because your opponent is boring.What item? I just saw one that might fit that description. PM me?
I too would be interested to know?
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"Item of Keeping My Character Sheet Easier to Manage"
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Every time you come up, I try to figure out why you picked that spell for construction. Another similar spell is a much better fit both mechanically and thematically, so I find myself wondering why you didn't go with the obvious choice.
It's a small thing that I shouldn't be concerned about...and I'm upvoting you anyway, but it will drive me nuts again next time I see you.
Being obvious is no fun
My first thought upon reading your item should be that I want to bask in it's radiance, not that I need to find out how many uses it takes before the item pays for itself. Extra negative points if I can count the uses till the item makes me free money on my fingers. Get rich quick schemes are the last thing Golarion's poor stained fictional economy needs.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Item that makes the game more fun to play vs. item that makes the game "easier to win."
Guess which one got my vote?
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
So what DC for my perception skill do I need to be astute?
So what DC for my perception skill do I need to be astute?
I think I would make that an Intelligence check. Perception to notice things happening, but intelligence to put it all together. (Maybe wisdom. Maybe.)
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"This item appears to be..." vs. "This item appears to be..."
Authors of all races, be they Greeks, Romans, Teutons or Celts,
Can't seem just to say that anything is the thing it is but have to go out of their way to say that it is like something else.
My item almost certainly gone - 322 items listed after 3rd cull, but not mine.
And yet...
weapon in perhaps the most overused design space **ever** that does literally nothing unexpected, just that one super-overused power, is still humming along?
Ugh.
In other news? I'm sure the grapes served in the top 32 green room are actually quite sour.
I have added 2 in last 15 minutes to the sheet, so don't give up hope just yet.
My item almost certainly gone - 322 items listed after 3rd cull, but not mine.
And yet...
weapon in perhaps the most overused design space **ever** that does literally nothing unexpected, just that one super-overused power, is still humming along?
Ugh.
In other news? I'm sure the grapes served in the top 32 green room are actually quite sour.
It's a little early for your pity party. The list of post-cull items has risen to 331 in just the last 15 minutes.
Seeing new items, yay
My item almost certainly gone
...
In other news? I'm sure the grapes served in the top 32 green room are actually quite sour.
No one reads Aesop anymore?
Self-deprecating humor ain't a thing around here?
Okey-dokey, artichokey.
The moment you said Aesop, I realized... I realized so hard your reference.
I feel dumb for not getting it sooner. You clever little man you.
I'm sure that dog has bigger cut of meat than you too!
Charge!
Huh, I just saw an item that missed the correct Crafting Feat. I am REALLY surprised you made it this far little buddy.
Don't worry: You've gone quite the distance with that error.
hmm... still having aura strengths not matching caster levels. Good item. Bad form (and other errors to boot).
My item almost certainly gone
...
In other news? I'm sure the grapes served in the top 32 green room are actually quite sour.
No one reads Aesop anymore?
Self-deprecating humor ain't a thing around here?
Okey-dokey, artichokey.
Not when there's still a good chance your item could be seen, no. One of the key elements to successful humor is timing.
And now just noticed a big error in an item I workshopped that I thought was corrected (per my advice even). I guess that edit got lost. Shame. Crying shame even.
*sigh* There are always those items that seem like real gems until they slip that final sentence in that make you go: 0_o
Ugh. Three culls, yet you are still here.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Crows vs crows? Where's Tom Servo & Joel when you need them?
I wonder if the Snarkspire will tower to 50 pages.
It might, if these particularly noisome items that are left continue to pop up for voting.
| 5 people marked this as a favorite. |
I wonder if the Snarkspire will tower to 50 pages.
You've just invented a new profession: Snarkitecture.