Welcome to RPG Superstar 2023: Elemental Storm!

Wednesday, March 15th, 2023

Hi everyone, Mark Seifter here. I’m excited to announce the hotly anticipated 2023 edition of RPG Superstar, as the premiere Tabletop RPG design contest returns for another great year! For those of you who aren’t familiar, RPG Superstar is a contest for aspiring designers, originally created by Paizo and licensed by Roll for Combat for the last few contests. Like in the last contest (RPG Superstar Strange & Unusual, whose final bestiary is coming out very soon), I’ll be your head judge again this year, and we’re gathering a bigger and broader group of judges than ever before, including some new surprise faces on the panel.

RPG Superstar! 2023: Elemental Storm. Presented by Roll for Combat

RPG Superstar! 2023: Elemental Storm

As for this year’s RPG Superstar contest, you can submit up to three monsters written for Pathfinder 2nd Edition while following this year’s theme – Elemental Storm! After you’ve submitted your monsters, there will be two rounds of judging, first by the community to whittle down the submissions to the best of the best and then by a group of professional judges with a broad set of skills in the TTRPG industry. The top entries, as determined by the judges, will receive prizes, ranked from lowest to highest: copper, silver, gold, platinum, and grand. If you win a prize, your monster will be published in our next Battlezoo Bestiary, and if you win a platinum or grand prize, you’ll get to expand your monster into a whole family!

This year’s theme, as we announced at PaizoCon 2022, is called Elemental Storm! However, these are not exactly the same elements found in the usual elemental planes. To win, you’ll need to submit a monster associated with one to three of the twenty elements detailed below. For more information, including a list of all the contest’s rules, check out https://rpgsuperstar.com/!

RPG Superstar! 2023 Elemental Storm and the 20 elements: Fire, Water, Earth, Air, Wood, Ice, Lightning, Force, Life, Death, Light. Darkness, Mind, Spirit, Body, Music, Metal, Time, Space, and Poison

RPG Superstar! 2023 and the Elemental Storm elements!


  • Fire is the element of flames, heat, and burning. Creatures associated with fire usually have the fire trait or special abilities with the fire trait.
  • Water is the element of water, rain, and bodies of water. Creatures associated with water usually have the water trait (and often the amphibious or aquatic trait too), and they might have special abilities with the water trait.
  • Earth is the element of earth, rock, soil, and the like. Creatures associated with earth usually have the earth trait or special abilities with the earth trait.
  • Air is the element of air, wind, and the sky. Creatures associated with air usually have the air trait or special abilities with the air trait, and can often fly.
  • Wood is the element of wood, plant life, and flora of all kinds. Creatures associated with wood usually are plants, have special abilities associated with plants, or both.
  • Ice is the element of cold, ice, snow, and other frozen substances, but not liquid water. Creatures associated with ice usually have the cold trait or special abilities with the cold trait.
  • Lightning is the element of electricity and lightning. Creatures associated with lightning usually have the electricity trait or special abilities with the electricity trait.
  • Force is the element of mystical telekinetic force. Creatures associated with force usually have some kind of telekinetic abilities or other special abilities with the force trait.
  • Life is the element of raw life force, birth, and vital essence. Creatures associated with life usually have the positive trait or special abilities with the positive trait.
  • Death is the element of death, quietus, and the natural order of the reaping of life. Creatures associated with death usually have abilities with the death trait. They are very rarely undead (as undead have found a way to escape the fate of the death element), but they might be psychopomps or other natural bringers of death.
  • Light is the element of light, illumination, and vision. Creatures associated with light usually have special abilities with the light trait.
  • Darkness is the element of darkness, the absence of light, and sometimes the shadows that play upon the liminal spaces where light and darkness meet. Creatures associated with darkness usually have special abilities with the darkness trait or shadow trait.
  • Mind is the element of thoughts, emotions, and mental effects. Creatures associated with mind usually have special abilities with the mental trait. They might potentially have the astral or dream trait.
  • Spirit is the element of disembodied spirits built out of spiritual building blocks. Creatures associated with spirit are usually incorporeal spirits themselves, though perhaps they might not be if they have notable special abilities involving spirits.
  • Body is the element focusing on raw body, muscle, and the physical building blocks that make up a creature’s form. Creatures associated with body usually have strong martial attacks with the brute roadmap, or perhaps the soldier roadmap.
  • Music is the element of music, harmony, and sound. Creatures associated with music usually have auditory or sonic abilities, which often (but not always) include a musical motif.
  • Metal is the element of ore, smithing, and metal. Creatures associated with metal usually have abilities associated with metal, which might include the ability to create or boost metal items, or the ability to make attacks that mimic certain types of precious metals.
  • Time is the element of the past, present, and future. Creatures associated with time usually have some abilities to manipulate time. Be cautioned if you write a creature for this element that time abilities are especially difficult and tempting to write something too complicated or powerful; a true Superstar can write a time ability that is elegant and easy to use without breaking the action economy.
  • Space is the element of distance, the concept of three dimensional space, as well as the emptiness of space that contains nothing else. Creatures associated with space usually have abilities with the teleportation trait, abilities based on entering or living in outer space, or perhaps both.
  • Poison is the element of poisons, toxins, venoms, and other such substances inimical to living things. Creatures associated with poison usually have special abilities with the poison trait.

Good luck to everyone! We can’t wait to see what you come up with!

Mark Seifter
Director of Game Design, Roll for Combat

Author Bio:
I'm Mark Seifter, Roll for Combat director of game design and Paizo’s former design manager, and one of the four leads on the creation of Pathfinder Second Edition. I’m @markseifter on Twitter. Check out my Twitch stream with Linda Zayas-Palmer, Arcane Mark, Tuesdays at 7 PM Pacific and Saturdays at 10 AM Pacific at https://www.twitch.tv/arcanemark, as well as my Roll for Combat Live youtube stream with Stephen Glicker at https://www.youtube.com/c/RollForCombat/. Both shows cover a variety of RPG and Pathfinder topics! You can also join my discord at https://tiny.cc.arcanemark!

More Paizo Blog.
Tags: Pathfinder Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Pathfinder Second Edition
Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

Hoping to see if I can this year finally get all three monsters or at least improve from silver last year :'D

Wayfinders Contributor

3 people marked this as a favorite.

Good luck, everyone! I hope to share a Table of Contents with each and every one of you.

Hmm

Grand Lodge Contributor

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Best of luck to everyone that enters!

And, if you're on the fence about it: definitely enter. Just crank something out and see what happens. You'll discover if you love creating when there are timelines and guidelines and external feedback in place - a big part of freelancing.

(Although I have to say, in my experience the guidelines and feedback Paizo staff provide are so awesome they inspire creativity instead of limiting it.)

DO IT.

Grand Lodge

3 people marked this as a favorite.

You forgot that Metal is the only element with the "Power cord" trait.


I was very happy with my entries last year, but let's see if I can push for gold this time :).

Looking forward to reading your entries, everyone ^^

Radiant Oath

6 people marked this as a favorite.

Metal + Music + Death

My monster will be called: Slayer.

The Exchange

Pathfinder Maps Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

If there isn't some kind of Morris Day themed Elemental that is Music and Time with a Funky Aura, I will riot.


Aristophanes wrote:

You forgot that Metal is the only element with the "Power cord" trait.

Correction: The power cord trait is clearly from the Lightning element.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

This blog is dated 2022?

Wayfinders Contributor

6 people marked this as a favorite.

Fact: You cannot make deadlines as a freelancer without a proven method of time travel.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Vardoc Bloodstone wrote:
This blog is dated 2022?

That's a prompt for a chaotic time elemental that publishes retroactive documents.

Dark Archive

PossibleCabbage wrote:
Vardoc Bloodstone wrote:
This blog is dated 2022?
That's a prompt for a chaotic time elemental that publishes retroactive documents.

So a Time elemental might include a PFe1 stat block as well.


Sooo...fun fact, our PC's are facing a main antagonist who has fused the elements of life and death to both his left and right arms. So far he and he has have kicked the party's butt twice already (once when the PC's were 8th level and another time when the PC's were 12th level).

The first time his elemental power became unstable and the second time he stopped short of outright killing us and instead captured us to try and torture information out of us. We ironically escaped before he could even get the time to begin via a betrayal of one of his most trusted minions (a powerful devil).

Our party then decided that "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" and we signed an infernal contract (but made absolutely sure the Devil could not cause us or innocents ANY harm, it pretty much wanted a secure catch of magical items it could use as bargening chips, bribes, and personal empowerment back in the 4th circle of Hell).

Now we've got a decent ally who is bound to pretty much kill anyone we want who we encounter that is willingly helping the main bad guy. Unfortunately, the big bad is gaining more and more CONTROL over his arms. His last act was to use his left arm (aka Death) to turn the corpse of an Elysian Titan into a colossal zombie which is now marching towards a village! He wants to send a MESSAGE to us not to cross him!

It's gonna be a HELLUVA FIGHT!


Ashbourne wrote:
PossibleCabbage wrote:
Vardoc Bloodstone wrote:
This blog is dated 2022?
That's a prompt for a chaotic time elemental that publishes retroactive documents.
So a Time elemental might include a PFe1 stat block as well.

It was actually in Bestiary 1 in 2009 and you can't prove it wasn't.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Admittedly, I wasn't a big fan of the eldamon but this contest has me very excited for the next Battlezoo Bestiary. The categories of elements should make it easy as a GM to find the right monster for a lot of different contexts.

RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16

Is there a discussion page for the entries? I remember all the chatter going on during the old Superstar contests was one of my favorite things :)


I don't know of any such discussion but I feel it's forbidden by the rule 6 of the contest: During public voting rounds, contestants are prohibited from any public discussion that could be considered as adding to, expanding upon, or clarifying the content of their current submissions. This applies to (but is not limited to) interviews, personal blogs, and messageboard posts on paizo.com or elsewhere. Any such discussion may result in disqualification, in the sole discretion of the judges and/or Skyscraper Studios, Inc.

I don't know if this rule is new or if I don't understand it properly (I'm no lawyer), but it looks like it may disqualify any creature in case of public discussions. As such and without a clarification from RPG Superstar, I'm wary of having such a discussion.


SuperBidi wrote:

I don't know of any such discussion but I feel it's forbidden by the rule 6 of the contest: During public voting rounds, contestants are prohibited from any public discussion that could be considered as adding to, expanding upon, or clarifying the content of their current submissions. This applies to (but is not limited to) interviews, personal blogs, and messageboard posts on paizo.com or elsewhere. Any such discussion may result in disqualification, in the sole discretion of the judges and/or Skyscraper Studios, Inc.

I don't know if this rule is new or if I don't understand it properly (I'm no lawyer), but it looks like it may disqualify any creature in case of public discussions. As such and without a clarification from RPG Superstar, I'm wary of having such a discussion.

Specifically, the contestants themselves are forbidden from such discussion. People who are not the contestants are allowed to chat about them all they like.


Yeah, but how do you know who's the contestant on a public forum?


SuperBidi wrote:
Yeah, but how do you know who's the contestant on a public forum?

Some times its really easy "well I meant...", other times its really difficult "well that is clearly meant to...".

So I guess that is something that they will have to check?


Temperans wrote:
SuperBidi wrote:
Yeah, but how do you know who's the contestant on a public forum?

Some times its really easy "well I meant...", other times its really difficult "well that is clearly meant to...".

So I guess that is something that they will have to check?

That would be a total mess. Contestants will ask people to shut up about their monsters, some will try to pass as contestants to disqualify potential winners, etc...

Unless the organizers explain what the point 6 is about, I think there shouldn't be any discussion about the monsters.


I gotta say.. that's kind of a weird take to me. Like, "This small group of people has agreed to not talk about X. Therefore no one should talk about X, and we should immediately shut down any attempt to talk about X, because it might be one of them." That's... I mean, that level of self-censorship just seems all out of proportion.

I don't care personally, I'm not particularly interested in being part of said conversation. It just seems like a really bad precedent to set. I want more people talking about more things - discussing and considering and learning from one another. Preemptively shutting down entire topics of conversation because a few people shouldn't be involving themselves? I can't agree.


Sanityfaerie wrote:
I gotta say.. that's kind of a weird take to me. Like, "This small group of people has agreed to not talk about X. Therefore no one should talk about X, and we should immediately shut down any attempt to talk about X, because it might be one of them."

That's not what I said. I said the contestants won't want the discussions because it may be considered expanding or clarifying their monsters and as such may disqualify them. Unless there's a clear definition of what "expanding and clarifying" means, people will prefer to be careful.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Adventure, Adventure Path, Starfinder Adventure Path Subscriber
Hilary Moon Murphy wrote:
Fact: You cannot make deadlines as a freelancer without a proven method of time travel.

Ooooofff, big yes.

Liberty's Edge

1 person marked this as a favorite.
SuperBidi wrote:
Sanityfaerie wrote:
I gotta say.. that's kind of a weird take to me. Like, "This small group of people has agreed to not talk about X. Therefore no one should talk about X, and we should immediately shut down any attempt to talk about X, because it might be one of them."
That's not what I said. I said the contestants won't want the discussions because it may be considered expanding or clarifying their monsters and as such may disqualify them. Unless there's a clear definition of what "expanding and clarifying" means, people will prefer to be careful.

The contestants are forbidden to discuss their creation in public. People who are not contestants can discuss whatever they like.


This sounds like a good way to add spells from specific elements as well. Here's hoping it inspires creators ^_^

RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Now that judgements are out for first wave, can we share with people what we made? Or is it still hush hush?


Do we know what creatures have been selected by the public voting?

Dark Archive

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Petty Alchemy wrote:
Now that judgements are out for first wave, can we share with people what we made? Or is it still hush hush?

I mean, you could share it even during audience round, only thing was that you couldn't explain your design decisions

(there is lot of active conversation in roll for combat discord)

RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 16

CorvusMask wrote:
Petty Alchemy wrote:
Now that judgements are out for first wave, can we share with people what we made? Or is it still hush hush?

I mean, you could share it even during audience round, only thing was that you couldn't explain your design decisions

(there is lot of active conversation in roll for combat discord)

Thanks, I was trying to find by Google search for any discussion of the contest, but couldn't find it in forums or the PF2e discord.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / General Discussion / Paizo Blog: Welcome to RPG Superstar 2023: Elemental Storm! All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.