archmagi1 |
Arya totally owned one of the seven kingdom's premiere tourney fighters and arguably one of the baddest asses ronining around the countryside. And the quiver on LFs lip afterward when she gave him the nobody face? Priceless.
This episode, while definitely not pushing plot as fast as other weeks, was amazing. Also, this was the short one at the 47ish minute mark. And they still managed to put in an awesome battle between the early kindlings of an aunt-nephew hookup (and dammit we were cut to blacked on her what's more important speech) and Sansa realizing her family has been utterly ruined by this series.
archmagi1 |
Oh, and fun reminder of Season 1, when Nymeria got chased off. The Arya and the boy were searching for jewel's from Raegar's encrusted breastplate, as the late prince drowned in the waters of the Trident near the end of Robert's Rebellion. Such a sad way to see a brother of a (future) queen, in the case of Raegar, meet his ends.
Irontruth |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Part of LF's lip quiver is how obviously his attempt to befriend Bran failed. He gave this priceless artifact to the potential "Lord of Winterfell" and the guy gave it away to his little sister... who also looks like she might have been able to kill one of the best fighters in Westeros.
He had a moment of realizing how little control he is when it comes to these "children".
Set |
Spoilers, for those who haven't seen it yet.
On the other hand, her gold sure did get out of there fast, and it's a trifle convenient that the army decided to send the gold ahead, unguarded, despite the heavily-laden gold-wagons logistically probably moving at half their speed, just so it could be conveniently not there for when they got ambushed...
The ornery part of me wants to hear, "Yeah, the gold we so cleverly sent ahead of our army got stolen by highwaymen, and now we got nothing for the Iron Bank." To which Cersei, being Cersei, would reply by killing the Iron Bank representative, because she doesn't handle disappointment (or smug bill-collectors) well.
In other news, I wonder if Bran already knows all about Littlefinger's past shenanigans, and is just playing dumb because there's no tactical reason to kill him just yet (at least, not while they could still his Vale resources)?
I really wondered for a moment if Arya was going to have another 'it's not you' moment and just leave Winterfell, without reconnecting with Sansa (and Bran), and go back to her mission of checking names off her list. I kind of prefer the direction she chose, simply because it's a good step to re-humanizing her. The more she rejects Arya and just is the faceless nameless killer, the less sympathetic she seems. Then again, she did maintain a certain distance and look of regret even during the reunion (indeed, the only time she really looked happy in Winterfell was fighting Brienne!).
And Arya's 'needle' can parry Brienne's enormous sword without snapping like a twig (or her arm similarly failing). Whatever. I don't even care. :)
Set |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Set wrote:You have to know how to use a foil well for that. You can't actually expect the weapon to completely stop the huge sword you just slow it down and misdirect enough so you can get out of the way. Its a little like Tai chi.Spoilers, for those who haven't seen it yet.
** spoiler omitted **
Yup, and that's what I would have preferred to see.
If Arya was consistently angling the hits so that the big sword is sliding past, using her tiny blade to deflect the force of the blow past her, that would have been a teensy bit more plausible. (And she did do that a few times, causing Brienne to sort of stumble past her, caught up in the momentum of her swing.)
Instead, she sometimes seemed to be just holding it up at a 90 degree angle to the incoming blow and somehow causing all the force of that blow to magically go away, which, whatever.
I'm just here to watch Drogon burn stuff, at this point.
It's a song of fire and ice, I'm ready for some fire and ice. :)
Mark Moreland Developer |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Spoilers, for those who haven't seen it yet.
** spoiler omitted **
Bran did spit Littlefinger's words right back at him, didn't he? I believe he said "Chaos is a ladder" to Sansa a while back. Bran seems to be weirding a lot of people out by casually referring to things he has no way of having heard or seen, and that one did get a reaction out of Littlefinger.
As far as Bran was concerned, I was most upset that he and Meera seem like they aren't going to get together like I (and Meera, apparently) had shipped. Oh well. They're all going to die in the end anyway, so who cares, right?
Addams Family DM |
Vidmaster7 wrote:Set wrote:You have to know how to use a foil well for that. You can't actually expect the weapon to completely stop the huge sword you just slow it down and misdirect enough so you can get out of the way. Its a little like Tai chi.Spoilers, for those who haven't seen it yet.
** spoiler omitted **
Yup, and that's what I would have preferred to see.
If Arya was consistently angling the hits so that the big sword is sliding past, using her tiny blade to deflect the force of the blow past her, that would have been a teensy bit more plausible. (And she did do that a few times, causing Brienne to sort of stumble past her, caught up in the momentum of her swing.)
Instead, she sometimes seemed to be just holding it up at a 90 degree angle to the incoming blow and somehow causing all the force of that blow to magically go away, which, whatever.
I'm just here to watch Drogon burn stuff, at this point.
It's a song of fire and ice, I'm ready for some fire and ice. :)
On the one hand, I kind of agree. I would have like to see her use it "properly" more,; on the other hand, I can't really expect more than a passable swordfight with 20 year old with no martial arts training.
Also, agree 100% about being here to see some fire and ice.
Matthew Downie |
I suspect the Iron Bank rep will slip away with his gold 'Debt paid, future investments unlikely'
I think we're going to see Cersei borrow more money and hire an army of mercenaries.
Though I think it would have been wiser for her to leave the existing debt unpaid. It makes Westeros "too big to fail" from the bank's perspective.
While I'm thinking about GoT economics: don't burn the supply wagons, Dany! You're winning the battle, why destroy the loot?
Set |
While I'm thinking about GoT economics: don't burn the supply wagons, Dany! You're winning the battle, why destroy the loot?
Yeah, but armies of Unsullied and Dothraki (and their horses) have never needed to eat or drink (or any other supplies, notice the lack of packs full of supplies on those Unsullied) before, so why should she start worrying about logistics now? :)
Bran is The Three Eyed Raven so whatever was there with Meera is now gone. Meera's role is pretty much done now.
He might have seen ahead (or just deduced, based on past events, like her brother or Hodor's fates) that she'd be safer the hell away from him, and been encouraging her to be anywhere but at his side.
Matthew Downie |
Yeah, but armies of Unsullied and Dothraki (and their horses) have never needed to eat or drink (or any other supplies, notice the lack of packs full of supplies on those Unsullied) before, so why should she start worrying about logistics now? :)
Just about plausible with the Dothraki. The Mongol hordes used to travel with plenty of spare mares. If they ran out of food, there was always horse milk and horse blood.
Irontruth |
MannyGoblin wrote:Bran is The Three Eyed Raven so whatever was there with Meera is now gone. Meera's role is pretty much done now.He might have seen ahead (or just deduced, based on past events, like her brother or Hodor's fates) that she'd be safer the hell away from him, and been encouraging her to be anywhere but at his side.
I'm with Pan. Bran's connection with all of the world's events and the flow of history separates him from those around him. I think part of it is that Bran underwent the transition too quickly, he went from 12 y/o boy to ancient being who knows all of history in under a year. Who knows how long the previous 3-eyed raven had for his transition, plus the old man had hundreds of years to adapt to complete knowledge.
When Bran looks at the people around him, he views them exactly like he would as if he were in a vision, except that he interacts with them to some degree. He's no longer a member of the world of the individuals in his physical presence, but a part of something much bigger and more important. Bran doesn't care about the safety of an individual; he's concerned with the survival of entire species.
edit: Cersei didn't mention the Second Sons, she talked of hiring the Golden Company.
edit 2: Rewatching right now. I like the construction of the loot train fight scene. Theon says "Where did she go?" giving us a strong indication she'd be in the next scene, but then they cut to a decent length conversation between Jaime and Bronn, just long enough to help let the line fade before the battle starts and Dany shows back up. It's nice crafting of the scenes.
MMCJawa |
MannyGoblin wrote:Bran is The Three Eyed Raven so whatever was there with Meera is now gone. Meera's role is pretty much done now.we still need her so that her father can confirm, that she's Jon Snow's sister
All seeing Bran can do that, can't he?
In the books the Three Eyed Raven isn't nearly so powerful. I think he can observe events through the weirwoods, but not like...everywhere. So Howland Reed is need in the books where he probably isn't in the show.
Skeld |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Look at what's going on in Winterfell. There's a gathering of Starks.
Once Jon returns, we'll have:
Jon - Warrior (and reluctant leader)
Sansa - Diplomat (and schemer by necessity)
Arya - Assassin (and deceptively deadly)
Bran - Mystic (and creepy as hell)
Collectively, they're a classical adventuring group.
archmagi1 |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Look at what's going on in Winterfell. There's a gathering of Starks.
Once Jon returns, we'll have:
Jon - Warrior (and reluctant leader)
Sansa - Diplomat (and schemer by necessity)
Arya - Assassin (and deceptively deadly)
Bran - Mystic (and creepy as hell)Collectively, they're a classical adventuring group.
Jon - Gotta love the 8CHA face of the party. Man's only ever failed one saving throw (vs Ygritte's charm spell, pre- Iron Will which was taken after the seige of Castle Black), and has gotten to where he's at on his WIS and CON alone.
Sansa - Backup face and under the table deal maker. She's the gnome who converses in Sylvan to the elven barkeep to negotiate quest details while Jon is reluctantly listening to the farmer whine about wyverns in the woods.
Arya - Every group needs a murderhobo to roll those intimidate checks constantly, including against party members. She's just glad they added those DEX to damage feats in a few seasons ago.
Bran - He's gotta be a WIS or INT based caster, bc that guy has less CHA than Jon. Though he really doesn't fit the typical mystic archetype, as he doesn't play "mysterious" as much as he does the PC of someone who just finished philosophy 101 and is going through an existentialism phase.
Ambrosia Slaad |
re: Bran:Bran did spit Littlefinger's words right back at him, didn't he? I believe he said "Chaos is a ladder" to Sansa a while back. Bran seems to be weirding a lot of people out by casually referring to things he has no way of having heard or seen, and that one did get a reaction out of Littlefinger.As far as Bran was concerned, I was most upset that he and Meera seem like they aren't going to get together like I (and Meera, apparently) had shipped. Oh well. They're all going to die in the end anyway, so who cares, right?
Baelish will stay put though, because he is still thinking he is the smartest bro in the room. He claims he fights every battle all the time in his mind, and that it will save him. Except it won't. He keeps finding ways to escape his death from all the way back in season 1, and has still completely failed to learn the lesson.
Maybe it's cliched and closes the circle too easily, but I expect he's gonna get stabbed by the very dagger with which he tried to have Bran murdered. And I expect Bran has already foresaw it, which is why he gave it to Arya. Pride goeth and all that, and Littlefinger, it's a long way down off The Ladder.
Edit: OK, maybe I'm wrong about Baelish's fate. But he is such a smarmy smug thinks-he-knows-it-all *sshole, always underestimating people especially women. I think I hate him more than Euron or Ramsay.
Matthew Downie |
Jon - Gotta love the 8CHA face of the party.
Why do you think Jon has low Cha? He was made leader of the Night's Watch at a ridiculously young age. Later he was acclaimed King of the North despite lacking any legitimate claim and having exhibited some pretty poor battle tactics. High charisma is really the only explanation.
Matthew Downie |
I actually adore Euron and I generally hate bad guys.
It is weird, isn't it, that he's kind of likeable? He's probably as vicious as Joffrey and Ramsay were, but they were entirely hateful.
I think it's that he's more open about being Chaotic Evil, while they were putting on a handsome-prince act in order to marry Sansa.
Nobody likes a hypocrite.
Set |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Euron seems to be living up to the 'Iron Code' of take what you want, and anyone not strong enough to keep something you are trying to take from them doesn't deserve it anyway. Regardless of whether it's a sane or likable code, he's totally living it, which, as steeped as this show is in treacherous creeps who aren't living up to their code, makes him seem 'noble' somehow (in the same way that Ned Stark lived up to his code, even if it proved terribly ill-suited to keeping him alive in the snakepit that was King's Landing, and seemed kind of noble, if foolish and naïve, when he walked up to Cersei and told her what he knew and that he was going to blab, sealing his fate...).
The elder Greyjoy, Theon and Yara's dad, on the other hand, blathered on about Theon not paying 'the iron price' for every article of clothing he wore, taking it to an absurdist level that he himself didn't live up to, since he sat around and ate food from fishermen he hadn't murdered with his own hands. (Since that's how he was judging Theon, for not taking everything he ate, wore, etc. by force, making him, IMO, an enormous hypocrite, as well as a terrible dad.)
Euron's a terrible person, but he seems honest, which is at least refreshing.
I'm still gonna cheer if Yara murders him in glorious comeuppance. :)
archmagi1 |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
archmagi1 wrote:Jon - Gotta love the 8CHA face of the party.Why do you think Jon has low Cha? He was made leader of the Night's Watch at a ridiculously young age. Later he was acclaimed King of the North despite lacking any legitimate claim and having exhibited some pretty poor battle tactics. High charisma is really the only explanation.
Because he is the stereotype reluctant leader trope. He struggles through speeches and conversations. He carries himself mopily. Everything he *does* screams low CHA high WIS.
He gets promotions in the Night's Watch from 1) his prowess in battle vs the wights, 2) his experience dealing with wildlings, and 3) a successful media campaign put on by mental stats only Sam Tarly. And later he gets MDK'd because his CHA can't keep the restless troops in line when his WIS makes decisions with foresight.
He gets appointed KOTN by right of conquest. Prior to ascension, the wildling army is with him out of 1) trust in his prowess, and 2) life-debt. The Northmen are with him because 1) Davos and 2) a few lucky speeches rallying the right Lords. The Vale is with him because of Sansa looking too much like Cat.
GM Niles |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Matthew Downie wrote:archmagi1 wrote:Jon - Gotta love the 8CHA face of the party.Why do you think Jon has low Cha? He was made leader of the Night's Watch at a ridiculously young age. Later he was acclaimed King of the North despite lacking any legitimate claim and having exhibited some pretty poor battle tactics. High charisma is really the only explanation.Because he is the stereotype reluctant leader trope. He struggles through speeches and conversations. He carries himself mopily. Everything he *does* screams low CHA high WIS.
He gets promotions in the Night's Watch from 1) his prowess in battle vs the wights, 2) his experience dealing with wildlings, and 3) a successful media campaign put on by mental stats only Sam Tarly. And later he gets MDK'd because his CHA can't keep the restless troops in line when his WIS makes decisions with foresight.
He gets appointed KOTN by right of conquest. Prior to ascension, the wildling army is with him out of 1) trust in his prowess, and 2) life-debt. The Northmen are with him because 1) Davos and 2) a
few lucky speeches rallying the right LordsLady Lyanna Mormont is a boss. The Vale is with him because of Sansa looking too much like Cat.
I helped you out there.
Pan |
Littlefinger: I will predict everything that could possibly happen and lay out all possible...
Bran has come back from the dead
Littlefinger: G!!!%$it it
And he's omnicient
Littlefinger: well @(*#@$
Honestly, he did predict everything up until recently. Who can see dragons, worgs, and wights coming? I think that makes his scene with Sansa so great because we get to see what littlefinger does when all his predictions turn pear shaped. Though my guess is we are waiting for Jon's return so they can simply kill littlefinger off despite being the most compelling villain of the series, even more so than cersei.
Irontruth |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
BigNorseWolf wrote:Littlefinger: I will predict everything that could possibly happen and lay out all possible...
Bran has come back from the dead
Littlefinger: G!!!%$it it
And he's omnicient
Littlefinger: well @(*#@$
Honestly, he did predict everything up until recently. Who can see dragons, worgs, and wights coming? I think that makes his scene with Sansa so great because we get to see what littlefinger does when all his predictions turn pear shaped. Though my guess is we are waiting for Jon's return so they can simply kill littlefinger off despite being the most compelling villain of the series, even more so than cersei.
I still think he lives to next season. He's not really doing anything lately that compares to his villainy of the early seasons.
As I've said I think he solves your problem with Cersei being dead. When the white walkers attack, LF is dumb/ambitious enough to throw people under the proverbial bus in order to advance his position. He'll be the season 8 "human villain".
Plus he still has to survive long enough to become the mayor of Baltimore.