From the beginning of 2e it was obvious they wanted to get away from the idea that casters could do everything better than martials. As such there had to be give and take. If you want spells to do single target massive damage I think you'll be disappointed in SoM as that would make just "better" versions of existing spells. Martials rule for single target damage and I can't see casters catching up on that. However AoE spells ultimately total more damage, just spread out and I can see more of those spells. Additionally, damage spells with debuff affects (think Vomit Swarm) will also be prevalent in SoM I think. You just can't expect the damage to be amazing when they also debuff. I have a few minor gripes (why can't I stand on my floating disk anymore?!), but overall they fixed the D&D and PF1e issue of casters just being better than martials at everything. And this coming from a player who plays casters primarily.
vagrant-poet wrote: I just hate when my subscription ships after the street date. It's not part of my subscription to get the pdf early (though it's obviously exciting), but it really sucks to know it almost would be more satisfying to not subscribe. I want this physical book, and mostly that makes the subscription worthwhile, but it will be feelbad to have my subscription ship on the 25th or later. This exactly. I already struggle with the idea of having my subscription because I'm not supporting my local gaming store by having it (who always has the books available on the street date). Even the free PDF isn't a huge value as the shipping cost is almost the price of the PDF. I'm not complaining or trying to put down the subscription, but I've already been questioning it and weighing the pros and cons for me personally.
Paul Watson wrote:
It's that last part that has me worried. It was immediately added after the thread went up. I'm hoping it just means they hadn't taken full inventory yet and are just covering themselves. We'll know soon enough I suppose.
Paradozen wrote: I wonder if the magic-focused fey summoners will be comparable to full casters or if they will be in a bit of a side-niche magic wise. I could see the eidolon effectively supplementing the summoner's spell slots so they have as many as a full caster, with the eidolon having the low-level tricks and the summoner having the upper wave slots. But I also wonder if maybe it'll be in some side niche, similarish to how alchemist fits into a side niche where it isn't a martial or a spellcaster but it is a unique type of support. I've been wondering about this as well. I mean a full caster has somewhere between 27 and 36ish spellslots at the end compared to 4 for typical Summoner. I can't see the Fey Eidolon giving nearly enough to catch up in total and they will probably give up much of their martial prowess too. So, to be worthwhile at all the class/Eidolon is going to have to have some sort of niche.
Romão98 wrote:
Barring any more delays, they should start shipping this week or early next. Let's hope there are no more delays.
Riddlyn wrote: As long as people continue to try and compare the classes in 2e to 1e classes they are always going to be unhappy. Personally I'm super excited for SoM, I'm playing a modified version of the playtest Magus. I hope they kept the arcane fist. I haven't seen much in the way of support for an unarmed magus They have specifically said that the current Magus fully supports unarmed. I think it was mentioned at Paizocon and they said it is baseline now that spellstrike can be done with a melee weapon or melee unarmed strike.
Longevity really depends on how well the wave casters can use cantrips. If all they are doing is using a cantrip and not much else they will suck, however that doesn't seem to be how they are built. Both the magus and summoner seem to be built around the idea that you will cast a cantrip and also have something else going on too. If a Summoner's Eidolon is strong enough in melee (or some other form of combat) then casting a cantrip while somewhat weak (though not horribly so) combined with their attack makes all the difference. If a Magus can cast a cantrip and combine that with a decent attack then that is ultimately a good combo. With wave casters I think the main thing is they are splitting their turn between multiple things and so that cantrip combined with the other is a decent damage output. This vs. a full caster that will cast a cantrip, then not have much else offensively to do (perhaps debuff with demoralize or something, but no damage). Ultimately, we shouldn't look at the cantrip casting in a vacuum with wave casters and ask ourselves whether that is the whole turn or just part of a turn. I wasn't a fan at first, but I'm starting to be won over since the playtest. Then, with the high level slots, they can do big short bursts for big payoff. The Magus in the liveplay is certainly showing that potential. The Summoner hasn't yet, but part of that may be opportunity and part is due to the player (Bonnie) just really doesn't understand the game or her character (though she has a wonderful role-play mind making it still enjoyable to watch).
Squiggit wrote: Damn, Factotum and Occultist? He's got a good sense of style. Agreed. Factotum was my favorite 3.5 class and I still play one to this day in my on-again-off-again D&D 3.5 game (at 40+ years old I'm the youngest in this group...so we're still playing the last edition they were comfortable with).
I love these livestreams. Here are a few questions of mine to pick from hopefully (mostly geared towards the SoM team): 1. We just heard the Eidolons will each have two stat-blocks. What do these look like and what drove the decision this way vs. having a variable stat-block for people to use? 2.The live-play happening on Thursdays is really showing off the magus as a pull away damage dealer. He's been dishing out tons more than any other character in that group. Is this representative of the design in general and is this what the class is expected to do at most tables? 3. Can we expect more Eidolon choices in the future (Elemental, Aberration, and Devil are most prominently missing)? 4. Do you have to take specific archetypes to use things like Shadow Magic, or are they just spells added to the spell-list with a new Shadow Magic trait? How do these new magic styles work? 5. Will Eidolons be able to take advantage of Summoner feats? Specifically, if I take the Fighter dedication, will the Eidolon get to take advantage of the feats I choose from that line? 6. What is your favorite single thing in SoM? 7. Prepared casters are getting cool Grimoires to use, are spontaneous casters getting any such item love? 8. Who is your favorite NPC from Strength of Thousands so far? 9. Aside from Blood Magic, what didn't make it to SoM that you hope to fit elsewhere? 10. What was one thing that you learned from the SoM playtest that really stuck with you?
Deriven Firelion wrote:
Well your comment was odd then if that's what you meant. The OP had already been educated and even stated they knew where they went wrong before you ever made your comment. So, it is quite understandable that this person thought you were confused about how stances work.
WWHsmackdown wrote:
I dont disagree. It is a nature vs nurture thing for me. Some societies in fantasy settings, like Golarion, are evil by most standards. It is what they know based on their teaching (murder as appropriate, slavery, underhanded tactics to get the upper hand, xenophobia, etc.). In those societies, most of the individuals will be evil as well and will display it rather prominently. However there are always going to be exceptions. I know it's D&D, but Dritzz is the perfect example of this. The opposite holds true too of course. However it has never been as big an issue to people when a single bad guy emerges from an otherwise good community. I never understood why a small group of "good" guys emerging from a generally "evil" community triggered some people.
Wow, this is an old thread to revive. Thought this was talked to death before, but the short version is that it seems Paizo has went down the road of believing if a Creature is sentient it can make its own decisions and go with or against cultural norms. In cases of goblins specifically, they are typically short lived which also tends to mean they can evolve culturally much faster. A few individuals and then some tribes started being less aggressive and actually found that life expectancies of the ones that adapted to work WITH other races extended and so that life style caught on even more. Outside of the game, there has been a push in the real world to understand other cultures and realize that people may be different, but that doesn't equate to good or bad. Paizo is tapping into real world move for tolerance and taking that into their game world. Plus...goblins are very fun to role-play!
HeHateMe wrote: I understand we're getting two new classes with this book, but will there be any new builds for existing classes? Like Cleric Doctrines or Barbarian Instincts or Druid Orders, etc? Druid, Monk, and Wizard are getting class specific content. All other additions are either class agnostic or archetypes that can be applied to multiple classes (but perhaps not all). An example of the latter is Wellspring magic can be applied to any spontaneous FULL caster. I note "full" caster as they are distinguishing Magus and Summoner as not being "full" casters. They said they avoided class specific options for the most part in order to use page space on things more people can enjoy rather than only specific classes.
HumbleGamer wrote:
I see 2 reasons. 1) the lore of the land puts specific emphasis on Wizards and Druids as well as the history of the school 2) it is a SCHOOL. Wizards and Druids are traditionally taught their magic. Sorcerers instinctively manifest their magic and Witches have powerful magic thrust upon them by their patron. As such neither Sorceror nor Witch particularly fit into a magic academy.
Hillis Mallory III wrote:
I'd echo this as well. I also want to say that I love and would really like to play things like Strength of Thousands, unfortunately it is hard to join those games online when you don't have a home group. PFS scenarios really help keep the game alive for me as I can typically play weekly or every other week in a pick-up-game. The one shots seem good (I've played the first), however I really want to A) play my PFS character and B) receive reputation for playing. That said, I'll remain cautiously optimistic as I love what you've done so far and thus you've earned credit in my book.
Mark Seifter wrote:
Great team effort! I can't wait for the Summoner class itself keep theory crafting with the trickle of info that keeps coming. Ija and Tuku are absolutely incredible as the Summoner iconic and loved this read. Please keep it up as I don't think I'll ever get tired of reading about their exploits and "hearing" their banter. Thanks Mark, Lu, and team!
Dave2 wrote:
The release was pushed back due to printing delays and they don't want to release the PDF until the book hits the street (which has always been their stance). I work in an industry that relies heavily on print materials and can definitely attest to the fact that there are major delays across the board for print materials. The original release date was July, that got pushed to August 5th, then that to August 25th. Hopefully it doesn't push any further back.
fanatic66 wrote:
A) the live play has already shown the Magus gets AoO by at least 6th level. B) there is no doubt there as they said the playtest was just a small sample of the final product C) from what we've seen so far, they are pretty solid with most being action compression.
Ezekieru wrote:
This ^ At Paizocon we were told the lowest level Incarnate spell was lvl 6 (though maybe 5, he couldn't remember at the time).
30) Misty the Sprite has recently become very curious in her first world heritage. She was born on Golarion, but her mother came directly from the first world and now that Misty is older she has become more and more interested in where her family came from all those years ago. As her curiosity swelled, so did some innate magical abilities that had been lying dormant all her life. These powers continued to grow and one day, out of the blue, a large (at least to her eyes) fey was there in her house when she woke up. As they talked, it became apparent they were family and that somehow she had called her brother (which she never knew she had) from the first world into Golarion. In the form of an Eidolon, her brother is just as curious about Golarion as Misty is about the first world. Now they are inseparable as they travel together to quell their curiosity and deepen their family ties.
vagrant-poet wrote: Subscribers don't always actually get the pdf early, some lucky few do. The further you are from the Paizo office, the later they tend to ship your order, so if you're outside the US don't get too excited. Which is crazy considering the farther you are the longer it would take to ship and thus the sooner they should ship. Unless of course it is shipping from another location (very possible and likely). If your observation is accurate, the only thing I can think as to why, would be if they want to give preferential treatment to those closer to the office to create more buzz in their geographical area. of course, it could be as simple as a sort by zip/regional code starting with theirs (odd way to sort, but possible).
One shots can be fun and as long as the GM doesn't restrict it to just the pre-gen characters in it then I can always "recreate" my appropriate PFS character to run in it at the appropriate level. Unfortunately, as others have said, they don't reward reputation which is somewhat off-putting. That is why I haven't bought the two that are out as I run games almost exclusively for society play now and that is a tough pill to swallow. Solution - for Nethys' sake, have the one-shots reward the same reputation as a PFS scenario! How does that unbalance anything? I mean, I ran my home group (the one exception to my society play) through Extinction Curse and THAT gives reputation. So it obviously isn't due to the player might not being a society member as EC doesn't assume that either. Honestly, the 1 shots not getting reputation seems more like an oversight than anything.
Xethik wrote:
I believe that isn't the case though. In the discord panel at Paizocon they said most focus spells for the magus would recharge spellstrike but not all of them would. In fact, I believe that they used this one as an example of one that doesn't recharge it.
I agree that I hope dedication feats can apply to your Eidolon. However I believe the class feats will give diverse things to do. For example, we know from Paizocon that one will give it Trample. We also know from the live stream another class feat gives the beast Eidolon an altered attack type. That said, I would like to take a Fighter dedication and give my Eidolon AoO makes sense as my Summoner himself has no business in melee.
Malfinn Eurilios wrote:
While I wish it wasn't so as I liked the Quest format better than Bounties, Quests are a discontinued series. They were replaced by Bounties.
wegrata wrote: I'm excited to see what grimoire can do and what new attack spells are going to be in there to support magus. Plus all the new magic items especially the new components. I'm really excited for grimoire's as well. I'm thinking they will help empower specific spells. Perhaps something like making a single casting of an attack spell do half damage on a miss. Things like that. Unfortunately, based on what we learned at Paizocon, they are strictly for prepared casters. I really hope that spontaneous casters get some neat toys like that to play with and empower their spells. I've come to this party for the Summoner, however I have to say that the information given and the live plays we've seen, and even the designer enthusiasm all seem to be playing up the Magus much more than Summoner. Grimoires are just one more thing that seem to push things towards Magus over Summoner.
Really hope there are more repeatable scenarios with the reduced number. Season 2 was very disappointing in that regard. As for bounties they are fine, but I don't like how they are for a single level as my society characters graduate out of them quickly combined with the regular scenarios. Personally I preferred the quest format, but then I have a feeling I'm not the target demographic.
Laclale♪ wrote: Who ignored me and made this? Not sure if this is to be funny, but it doesn't come off as such. That thread is about Guns & Gears specifically. This thread seems like you want to talk about some unannounced future theory crafting. Numeria and technology is probably beyond steam punk is likely far off or will be in small pieces in APs.
Ashanderai wrote:
This is true, however this is also where the rarely used 1 action Heal spell could shine. No matter what, 1 of the 4 actions (due to Act Together) has to go to the Summoner himself, so using that for battle medicine or a 1 action heal spell still gives the Eidolon 3 actions to play with. Not to say having somebody else do it isn't just as good if not better, but it does make for an interesting mechanic.
HumbleGamer wrote:
Well, from what we know the Summoner will have a good chunk of HP since they have 10 per level. We also know that the Eidolon will have a stat with 18, so making it melee as either STR or DEX based is pretty good. So they should be pretty durable, especially if you can give them support with spells/focus. The Summoner+Eidolon seem to be a different type of GISH so when combined with your other party members I think they will do fine if you build for durability in the front with the Eidolon.
coriolis wrote:
It is in on Archives of Nethys. You just need to go to the Animal Companion section, then click on "unique companions" and it is the only one listed since it is the only unique companion currently released.
Secrets of Magic is about all I can think about. New spells (most of my Big Baddies are spellcasters) along with the different magic types to add to the world will be fantastic. Not to mention all the additional lore and understanding of Magic in the world. I'm also exited for the new classes as my players will certainly want to play them and I want to see them in all their glory.
WatersLethe wrote:
Yes, it was mentioned in the Live Stream. Basically the AP takes place at a magic school so everybody needs some sort of magic to get in. As such, they give the archetype for free at first level to meet that requirement.
Guntermench wrote:
I believe that is geomancy. Elementalist seems to be a specialized caster of elemental trait spells like fire, water, etc.
|