
![]() |

Rhaegal is ready.
He had a horde of gold sitting, so I made some major purchases:
Resilient rune
Dread (lesser) rune
Charm of Acid Resistance
scrolls of Sound Body and Clear Mind at rank 4
Now he'll be saving up for his own Wyrm on the Wing tattoo next level.

![]() |

The Remastered, New and Improved Callaverthorna is ready also!
I dropped all the Medicine skill feats that he'd only used once or twice. He's also found Jesus ... umm, no certainly not. Though he's decided to start following Nivi Rhombodazzle. Even got a little dice-shaped tattoo to go with his dragon tat. (Swapped in Pilgrim's Token.) And still had room for Slippery Prey and Rolling Landing.
No changes to his class feats, and the only gear change was getting a starknife in place of the throwing knife.

![]() |

Level 9 Pathfinder Provisions has the option of taking a 5th rank scroll of Breath of Life (divine tradition only).
1) How do scrolls of spells that are cast as Reactions work? You draw it and immediately use your reaction to cast it?
2) Is this a better choice (either generally or for our current party composition) than a Rank 5 heal?

![]() |

Level 9 Pathfinder Provisions has the option of taking a 5th rank scroll of Breath of Life (divine tradition only).
1) How do scrolls of spells that are cast as Reactions work? You draw it and immediately use your reaction to cast it?
2) Is this a better choice (either generally or for our current party composition) than a Rank 5 heal?
1) You need to keep them on hand to use them as a Reaction.
2) That's impossible to answer. I've saved a character's life (twice) with Breath of Life, but I've cast much more Heals.

![]() |

I would think Breath of Life is less useful than in 1e with the dying rules and the ranged option on the Heal spell. You essentially get a few round buffer before someone needs Breath of Life (in fact you can't cast it at dying 1), and during all that time a normal Heal spell works.
I guess there are certain instances where someone becomes at threat to die very quickly (persistent damage, having been at wounded 2 before), and if you had just 1 action left, you could draw the scroll and wait to see if they make their recovery check. If not, then you cast as a reaction. But that seems a very niche instance.
It would be nice for BoL to say that scrolls of it can be drawn as a part of the reaction (like healer's tools). Or just make it a talisman instead of a scroll.
So my vote is for a Rank 5 Heal if you're deciding between them.

GM Watery Soup |

I have four PCs ready, waiting for Isaku and Crunch.
I'm still working on slides, so no time pressure yet.

Watery Soup |

Posting with my main for spell advice.
I've never found Breath of Life to be particularly useful. I have it on higher level characters when 5th rank spell slots aren't as valuable, but I can't imagine taking up one of my top rank slots or holding a scroll in my hand at all times in case I need it.
On top of that, for Pathfinder Society, I think I've literally only seen 2 PCs ever die. One died specifically because none of us were in range to heal them, so I don't even know if Breath of Life would have saved them. The other died to the "massive damage" rule, before scenario writers stopped putting Level+3 monsters as bosses. (Both were Level 1-4 scenarios, so BoL wouldn't have been available.)

![]() |

signaled that Isaku is ready here. Is there something I need to do?
Provisions are the same for lvl 8. 2 x Moderate Healing Potion.
To use a scroll I need to be able to cast the spell, right? So if Isaku can't cast Lightning bolt, he can't use the scroll?

![]() |

I think Crunch is all set at level 9.
No appreciable amount of money to make purchases with, and few nonfixed upgrades/choices.

![]() |

To use a scroll I need to be able to cast the spell, right? So if Isaku can't cast Lightning bolt, he can't use the scroll?
You need it in your list. So if you are an Arcane or Primal caster you can use a Scroll of Lightning Bolt, whatever your actual ability to cast it in your spell slots (mostly because you are not level 5).
On top of that, for Pathfinder Society, I think I've literally only seen 2 PCs ever die. One died specifically because none of us were in range to heal them, so I don't even know if Breath of Life would have saved them. The other died to the "massive damage" rule, before scenario writers stopped putting Level+3 monsters as bosses. (Both were Level 1-4 scenarios, so BoL wouldn't have been available.)
I got one character killed, I killed 2 and I've saved one character with BoL (twice in the same adventure, Doomed 3 is a killer).
So I feel experience differs on this question :DBoL has a 60ft. range, so it covers most of the map in general.

GM Watery Soup |

signaled that Isaku is ready here. Is there something I need to do?
Nope - sorry, I missed it!
I think Crunch is all set at level 9.
Cool cool cool.

Watery Soup |

I got one character killed, I killed 2 and I've saved one character with BoL (twice in the same adventure, Doomed 3 is a killer).
So I feel experience differs on this question :D
Our experience does differ! I've never even seen Doomed in a PFS scenario, but then again, I've mostly been GMing Levels 1-6 from Seasons 1-2.
---
Also, to be clear to everyone, all of this is discussion in general, so don't think I misled you if some creature in 2-22 or 2-24 ends up Dooming you all. I neither make claims that Breath of Life would be specifically useful nor that it would not be useful.
:)

GM Watery Soup |

This scenario will reference multiple other scenarios from Season 2.
Can you please indicate which of these scenarios you have Chronicles for, as a PC or GM, even if not with this PC specifically?
[ ] #2-01 (Citadel of Corruption)
[ ] #2-03 (Catastrophe's Spark)
[ ] #2-05 (Balancing the Scales)
[ ] #2-14 (Lost in Flames)
[ ] #2-18 (The Fanciful March of Urwal)

![]() |

I've collected the set.
1, 14, and 18 with Crunch.
3 and 5 with other characters.

GM Watery Soup |

Oh, sweet, one is sufficient. You'll all be getting certain bonuses later in the scenario.

![]() |

Appreciate all the input re: the scrolls. Cal has actually died once, although he's my only character to do so. I'll stick with the heal scroll.
@GM looks like both our #1-24 Outpost tables filled! No worries on that now.
But we could use some help over at Isaku's / GM Tiger's table of #3-6 Struck by Shadows. It's an eval table for him, and so far we've only got a level 6, a level 3, and the mystery evaluator. I'm not shilling for Isaku, this is totally a self-interested request. I just don't want to have to run a pregen along with running my own character; and, it'll be more fun with some good roleplayers like you all.

Watery Soup |

Eval as in he's going for his nth glyph and someone's going to be watching the table? If so, I'll join if it doesn't fill by, say, a few days prior.
(I'd be a little more commital but I'm stretched thin and I'd have to spend a Replay, but obviously it's a big deal for Tiger.)
---
And yeah, I was super surprised that both games filled pretty quickly. I figured it was Season 1 so a lot of people had played it already.

![]() |

02-03, 02-05, 02-18.
Isaku specifically has a GM Chronicle for Urwal.

![]() |

03-06 is my second eval. Xyntryx (VC for the Philippines) will be playing (he's the reserved player in the spreadsheet).
02-18 was my first eval. Hmm (VC for MN, and the author of said scenario) was my evaluator.

![]() |

I have played all the adventures of the series, but none with Herr Doktor.
If needed, I can come to help Tiger, it'll be a replay for me, too. But considering my characters, I'm not sure it's a blessing :D

![]() |

Tiger, if you need the seat filled, I can burn a replay. Rhaegal would do as much for Jinlong. Good Luck!

![]() |

Last I checked there are 3 open seats :)

![]() |

Tiger, if you need the seat filled, I can burn a replay. Rhaegal would do as much for Jinlong. Good Luck!
It's a 3-6 so Rhaegal would be out of range...

![]() |

Can you please indicate which of these scenarios you have Chronicles for, as a PC or GM, even if not with this PC specifically?
Late to the party, but I have played 2-01 and GMed 2-03 but not on Eliadyr.
But we could use some help over at Isaku's / GM Tiger's table of #3-6 Struck by Shadows. It's an eval table for him, and so far we've only got a level 6, a level 3, and the mystery evaluator. I'm not shilling for Isaku, this is totally a self-interested request. I just don't want to have to run a pregen along with running my own character; and, it'll be more fun with some good roleplayers like you all.
I haven't played that one before so I have signed up. That gets us to 4 players.

![]() |

Whoops, I thought you only needed one person to answer that. I have player credits on other characters for 2-03 and 2-14. None for Cal.
"Arcana, Athletics, Nature, Occultism, Performance, Religion, or Society."
Arcana, Nature, Occultism = Nope (U)
Athletics = Meh (T) but low STR
Religion = Meh (T) but does Cal strike you as "wise"?
Society = Meh (T) and he's not too smart, either.
Performance = The only thing he could contribute in. +15, (T) and high CHA.
Cal probably should not be one of the 3 secondary casters with only the one decently useful skill and it being only at the Trained level.

![]() |

Rhaegal has a +14 Nature, but that's the only skill that probably is worth him trying.

![]() |

Soup -- 05-18, Seriously?! LOL!! :)

![]() |

Crunch can take point on the physical aspects -> +20 Athletics (master)

![]() |

So, it looks like it's Crunch, Eliadyr and either Cal' or Isaku (you haven't answered the question, Isaku).
Roll your dice guys, Herr Doktor is watching you.

![]() |

+16 Society is my highest.

![]() |

Well, then it's Crunch, Eliadyr and Isaku, which are the only ones to be expert or better in the aforementioned skills so it makes sense from an ooc point of view and from a ic point of view.

![]() |

So, it looks like it's Crunch, Eliadyr and either Cal' or Isaku (you haven't answered the question, Isaku).
Roll your dice guys, Herr Doktor is watching you.
Don't threaten me! Threaten the dice bot! My rolls have been pretty lousy :)

![]() |

Herr Doktor Krankenweg wrote:Don't threaten me! Threaten the dice bot! My rolls have been pretty lousy :)So, it looks like it's Crunch, Eliadyr and either Cal' or Isaku (you haven't answered the question, Isaku).
Roll your dice guys, Herr Doktor is watching you.
"Ich don't beliefe in luck!"

Watery Soup |

Last I checked there are 3 open seats :)
I just checked, there are 5 spots filled. Since that's a pretty good game, I'm not going to use a Replay unless you really want me to (I'm saving them because I frequently use Replays when I play with my kids), or unless a bunch of people drop.

![]() |

I've been holding off to allow others the opportunity, but I'll be happy to fill the last seat and burn a replay for Tiger. I have a level 4 medic that can play.

![]() |

before I forget -- are people ok with friendly fire (splash damage)? Isaku bought a bunch of alchemical bombs... since he's set up for fire and this trilogy is essentially a bunch of fire resistant creatures, I had to get other resources to actually be able to contribute! :)

![]() |

Eliadyr fires an arrow, but it wobbles in the wind, and falls just short. Miss, not a Critical Miss.
Spellstrike with a save spell complicates this sorry
If the spell required a spell attack roll, use your Strike’s results to determine the effects of both the Strike and the spell. If it required a save, the target of the Strike rolls its saving throw normally, though if your Strike was a critical failure, the target is unaffected.
(fortunately AoN now has the Fall FAQ updates)
So I think the four undead should have been damaged (with the basic save) and the terrain around them should be difficult for 1 minute.

![]() |

before I forget -- are people ok with friendly fire (splash damage)?
Splash damage is fine for Eliadyr (he'd normally be trying to be out of the way but not right now)

![]() |

before I forget -- are people ok with friendly fire (splash damage)? Isaku bought a bunch of alchemical bombs... since he's set up for fire and this trilogy is essentially a bunch of fire resistant creatures, I had to get other resources to actually be able to contribute! :)
You are speaking of 2 points of damage? It should be fine (unless I'm dying on the ground ;) ). And anyway, the Doktor has long reach so he's rarely at melee range from enemies. As a side note, I have resistance against fire (when the enemies are not fire resistant).

![]() |

Cal's fine with a little splash damage. Just so long as it's not in the face.
Note for GM: Following Cal's rebuild, he is now Trained in Religion (+12 only) and has a Pilgrim's Token.

![]() |

Friendly fire is fine.

![]() |

Friendly fire is ok. Rhaegal has resist acid 5 and the Eat Fire cantrip if that helps the decision.

GM Watery Soup |

Spellstrike with a save spell complicates this sorry
Spellstrike wrote:If the spell required a spell attack roll, use your Strike’s results to determine the effects of both the Strike and the spell. If it required a save, the target of the Strike rolls its saving throw normally, though if your Strike was a critical failure, the target is unaffected.(fortunately AoN now has the Fall FAQ updates)
So I think the four undead should have been damaged (with the basic save) and the terrain around them should be difficult for 1 minute.
Oh, nice! I'll retcon.

![]() |

As a player, I thought these are zombos... until I noticed that they have 3 actions... :)

![]() |

Well that changes everything, and not in a good way. DELAY. Expecting to come out of delay once some others move around a bit more.
Cal might be dubious of Isaku's claim and would like to see what he knows himself. Trained +12
In the original configuration, I thought Cal had flanking by virtue of Herr Doktor's reach. I could have been wrong though. Just wish I could keep that sweet 18 I rolled.