| Quandary |
Uhh...
From the best-known mixed-blood races, like half-elves and half-orcs, to beings with just a touch of another race’s blood in their veins
Enough with the "bastard" fixation, already... ;-)
I would say all the elemental-touched races, including suli, would be the prime candidates here.
And the Orc Bloodline Gnomish Sorcerors ;-)
| Odraude |
| 5 people marked this as a favorite. |
You guys might want to change that title. Over here, the word "bastard" is usually understood as "son of a beach" first and "half-blood" second. Also, regardless it implies some sort of pejorative tingle.
I hope they keep the title. It'll make up for changing Brothels to Dance Halls in UCamp ;)
brock, no the other one...
|
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
You guys might want to change that title. Over here, the word "bastard" is usually understood as "son of a beach" first and "half-blood" second. Also, regardless it implies some sort of pejorative tingle.
Agreed - it seems odd to imply that all people of mixed race are bastards, given the pejorative use of that term (in either meaning). It doesn't even correctly define one of mixed blood, simply of blood that was 'mixed' outside of wedlock.
Now, the Bastards of Erebus were proper bastards, but I don't think that their parentage was ever actually specified.
So, is the intention with the title to say that all mixed race characters are disreputable and verging on evil, or that the only way that a mixed-race character would arise is if someone couldn't keep it in their pants - not from a monogamous relationship?
| Grey Lensman |
I don't want the orc sorcerer bloodline explained I just want bloodlines for the other races like elf, dwarf, gnome, catfolk, lashunta, etc.Well at least this book as some interest but I hope that it covers all the half human races.
I suspect that it is largely due to many of the other Core Rules (and even several from the ARG) races already have a bloodline that captures the 'feel' of the race in question, both the stereotyped Tolkienesque version and the Golarion version. Orcs didn't seem to, at least to me. Catfolk and Dwarves still are left out IMO.
Of course, I'd also like weapon feats as awesome as Dervish Dance for the 'not-a-scimitar', but that is for a different book.
| Odraude |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I'll admit, I agree with a name change. Not because it's offensive, but because when I think of Bastards of Golarion, I think of a book of villains, con-men, bounders, and ne'er-do-wells. I don't think of a book of half-breeds.
Also still wondering how Brothel got changed, but this title somehow made it through.
brock, no the other one...
|
If this was a UK forum then 'bastard' would be censored in the same way that 't+$!', 's!$&' and 'wanker' would be.
I've been turning it over in my head all evening, and the only place where I've heard the word used to represent a 'mixture' would be in 'bastardise', and even then it implies corruption and pollution.
| theneofish |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
GeraintElberion wrote:If this was a UK forum then 'bastard' would be censored in the same way that 't+$!', 's!$&' and 'wanker' would be.I've been turning it over in my head all evening, and the only place where I've heard the word used to represent a 'mixture' would be in 'bastardise', and even then it implies corruption and pollution.
To be fair, it's used often in faux mediaeval literature to denote illegitimate - I'd be astonished if it hasn't appeared in Game of Thrones, for instance. Of course it still carries a pejorative tone, hence the corruption of the original word into one of abuse.
"Devil's Advocate"
|
| 4 people marked this as a favorite. |
Yes, a name change would probably be in better tastes as well as actually convey what the book is intended to be. Bastards of Golarion implies either 1.) a book that will focus on NPC's born out of wedlock or B.) a book about truly vile NPC's. I fail to see the connection between "bastards" and either Half-Orcs or Half-Elves, nor any of the other half-blooded races that may also be included.
| Cthulhusquatch |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Mead Gregorisson wrote:I say leave the name. I like it.Why?
Because I am not one of the people that complains just to complain. I know what the word 'bastard' means, and it fits.
Seriously, would 'Halfbreeds of Golarion' be better? To me... no.
The name is fine. Spot on. People just need to get over what they think is being said or implied and focus on what the word means.
| Heine Stick |
The word "bastard" is used in the Core Rulebook to describe how humans and elves generally view half-elves. Being labeled "bastard" is likely a part of life for many, if not most, half-elves and half-orcs in Golarion and as such, the title seems fitting enough to me. It's not a terribly flattering word, perhaps, but it's something both half-breeds have to deal with, I reckon. It's a large part of what the two races have to offer roleplayingwise.
Also, I'd really hate to see a repeat of the Dance Hall incident.
| Odraude |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The word "bastard" is used in the Core Rulebook to describe how humans and elves generally view half-elves. Being labeled "bastard" is likely a part of life for many, if not most, half-elves and half-orcs in Golarion and as such, the title seems fitting enough to me. It's not a terribly flattering word, perhaps, but it's something both half-breeds have to deal with, I reckon. It's a large part of what the two races have to offer roleplayingwise.
Also, I'd really hate to see a repeat of the Dance Hall incident.
I agree about not changing it for censor reasons (don't get me started on censorship). But, I'd want to see a title change because I'd actually rather see the title for a book about villains. I don't really think of half-bloods when I think bastards and I think Bastards of Golarion just fits better with a book about ne'er-do'wells and cads.
"Devil's Advocate"
|
In reference to Half-Elves, only Tanis comes to mind, and it's a lot less that he was a Half-Elf than it was that he was an actual bastard. He mother was raped and he was not raised with the father. I can honestly see it much more as a Tiefling thing, where most Tieflings are disowned.
Now, on there other hand, I would guess that most Half-Elves and many Half-Orcs these days are probably the products of two Half-Elf (or half-Orc) parents rather than the alternatives.
Half-Breeds of Golarion?
| Heine Stick |
Now, on there other hand, I would guess that most Half-Elves and many Half-Orcs these days are probably the products of two Half-Elf (or half-Orc) parents rather than the alternatives.
Do the specifics of a half-elf/orc's parentage (elf/human or half-elf/half-elf) really matter in social situations where merely being a half-elf means that person is somehow inferior socially? Something that, according to the Core Rulebook at least, seems to be relatively widespread among human and elven societies. It's still a half-breed or, in the eyes of those for whom its mixed blood is an issue, a bastard.
This, of course, is largely a matter of how we perceive the role and social status of half-breeds in our campaigns. For me, the word "bastard" makes sense because being a half-breed in Golarion does come with a lot of social baggage.
| Jim Groves Contributor, RPG Superstar 2010 Top 4 |
| 6 people marked this as a favorite. |
NOT AS A PAIZO REPRESENTATIVE
I like the existing title because:
1.) It sounds like a cool title to me.
2.) Half-breeds and half-bloods of Golarion sounds awkward in my opinion.
3.) Now that I know it is not about about evil-doers, con men, or other ne'er-do-wells. I will not ever be confused about it again.
| John Kretzer |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Swirlies of Golarion?
Anyway, I think people are taking the term bastard far more negatively than this particular usage is. Using bastard for irregular origin is not nearly as negative as using it for other reasons.
Especially considering the description of the book is positively positive.
Aggreed especialy considering that what people want Bastards of Golarion to be book of evil kinda haves the negative meaning that people borned out of wedlock are evil....my two sweet and kind nieces would disagree with that.