CaspianM's page

189 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.

Do cannon golem's cannons attack touch AC in the first range band?

So I've finished the written part of the adventure and its a real relief I will tell you that. I need to read adventures in more detail next time to make sure everything makes sense.

So in a Narnia kind of thing the last couple of parts of the game will revolve around the PCs versus Chorral (who's in a Star Warsian twist is one of the PCs' father) I wish I could use the mass combat system but that subsystem turned out really badly.

So yeah, what would you do for a final showdown type event?

So, if I had a big bad monster that could cast shadow projection from the APG what happens?

It keeps its HD and what not, but is the incorporeal touch attack conducted at it's normal attack bonus with it's normal damage and STR damage, or is it at it's normal attack bonus but with only STR damage?

I've been dealing with weapons for large sized creatures a lot lately and I can't find a definitive listing for damage progression for weapons that are large and greater.

Where would I go to find such a list? Should I still be using the old 3.5 chart?

For the fighter archetype there is the 5th level power that allows them to disarm and do damage "without the usual strength modifier" Now this is supposed to suggest that the bonus damage done is just by adders and other riders but what about other stat modifiers (ie dex) to damage? hter-archetypes/aldori-swordlord-brevoy

2 people marked this as a favorite.

I'm running Kingmaker and am currently trying to build a human NPC designed (hopefully) for one on one combat with a PC. What suggestions would you make regarding classes/feats/etc?

So when statting monsters up, how do you deal with this particular confluence of huh regarding con increases during rage? Does it gain bonus charisma when raging instead or does that part of the power not count for anything? Should I just use charisma as the base for the rest of the other keyed stats like how hitpoints switch over?

Just a question. Spell combat seems to be focused on single attack touch attacks. How does it interact with multiple attack touch attacks like Chill Touch?

So, one of my players brought to attention a rather odd situation. The wording for Axiomatic and Anarchic weapons does not suggest that it works on people/native dwellers of the main plane of Chaotic and Lawful alignments but only towards outsiders of said type. Is this the case?

Ok, I'm having a quandary here. I redesigned some monsters for my Kingmaker game to give actual challenges to my PCs. What I'm using is someone's fan-conversion of the Warlock because I really don't feel up to running a high level wizard as a main baddy yet.

( btw)

The problem of stacking Character levels on a monster became kinda evident in what I did. The output CR 9 creature has 162 HP and a 150 range touch attack that does 5D8+6 fire damage and forces Will saves or become shaken (the party is pretty bad at will saves it seems)

The question is, how would you fine tune this so it doesn't just outright kill PCs? The thing that I don't get is that apparently that damage code seems actually about right, but I'm thinking the HP and the control rider on the damage might be the thing that takes the fight to crazytown.

That being said, one of the players is a Cavalier who's damage code is up to 2d12+34 to 42 on a charge and another is an alchemist barbarian who's running a claw/claw/bite/gore attack routine that does a lot of damage when he's full attacking.

I've been doing a lot of digging around with Cavaliers and I was wondering, what is the interaction with the crit multiplier with the multiplier from Spirited Charge? Is it not a crit multiplier so its a case of 3x damage x3 or does a crit only add another 2x damage in the way Pathfinder deals with crits?

3 people marked this as FAQ candidate.

Is there a rules legal way to make the Black Blade the Magus gets an Agile weapon? Or is the character basically leveraging shocking grasp for the extra damage?

So interestingly my players are taking the narrative into their own hands and are interested in hosting a tournament in their lands as an attempt to show how awesome they are. I guess the idea is to introduce their kingdom to the rest of the River Kingdoms.

This is amusing mostly as this was the point where a Song of Ice and Fire game I was playing in previously fizzled out.

I've got some notes on how medieval tournaments go and I think running a ruleset so the joust resembles Full Metal Jousting's format. Also I think I'm going to take ideas from Green Ronin's Song of Ice and Fire RPG as it has some guidelines on that.

What else should I include?

So, there's the whole Aldori sword-fighting culture in Brevoy. Are there any canon details about them other than the origin story?

Sorry, my internet at home has decided to go insane. I'll be posting what I have as I can. They're not really finished so comments would be appreciated to fine tune these rules. Also there are spoilers and what not so yeah.

The problem with running macro social encounters is that you kinda have to expand on the material given for the local kingdoms, which is kinda sketchy. The Guide to the River Kingdoms is a really cool book however and gives good pointers as to what the various kingdoms do.

First things first is to outline stats for the kingdoms. What I have as a guideline is:

Disposition: Does the country like the PC's country. Rate -10 to 10. Depending on your players you can keep this hidden and reveal it through narrative or show the number. The PCs can do some kind of interaction with the other kingdom to improve relations (ie quest or a diplomacy roll plus an expenditure of BP) Of course with Pitax their disposition should always be kinda neutral (barring crazy stuff the PCs do to them) until War of the River Kings.

Let's guestimate some possible interactions

Trade agreement: The PCs arrange some sort of trading setup that's beneficial to both sides. This acts like a revenue stream per month of the Power + Disposition of the other country. In addition the other country might have extra bonuses to this trade agreement in the form of more BP or some kind of other narrative discount.

It takes a minimum of two months of game time to setup which sees the councilor in charge of it, usually the Ambassador, not providing his bonuses to your country. Furthermore it requires an extended Diplomacy test pegged at lets say the character's diplomacy + 10 to 15 (depending on how difficult you want to make it), with each check taking up 1 month's time, minimum 2 successes, more for people who want to provide hassle to the PC's country, like say Pitax. Your PCs might also want to quest to finish this somehow. Easiest solution is a "remove bandits" quest with several high CR encounters.

War: This subsystem hasn't been explored well. That being said there should be ways for the PCs to engage in lower level skirmishes. If the PC's declare war on a country they suffer an unrest penalty of 3+disposition, minimum 1 unrest unless disposition is at -10.

Research: Man I wish there was a research option. Sadly I can't think of one other than somehow providing the PC's prerequisites for building armies.

Power: This is another soft rating. This is just to suggest the general level of NPC they'll be dealing with when they interact with the town. Peg the rating above the PC level to suggest they might want to hang back a bit from a place or lower if you want the PCs to try to invade/co-opt a place.

Make revealing information about the kingdoms cost BP and/or face time. My guess is travel to adjacent kingdoms is something along the lines of 2 months (assuming travel, staying and hassles) with the countries farther out taking 3-4 months?

Also with all of this don't forget Brevoy. It's likely they'll want some taxes and to check if there are any Rogarvian holdouts in your PC's country. For now we'll say the Greater Powers (Brevoy, Galt, Numeria, Kyonin, Razmiran) also fall within the purview of these rules, with greater bonuses and greater penalties and so forth.

1 person marked this as a favorite.

After going through all the background material for Brevoy its pretty easy to draw a comparison with the state of Brevoy and the Song of Ice and Fire series. Has anyone diverted the course of the adventure path into something that has interactions with Brevoy and the whole Rogarvia/Surtova issue?

So, I have a couple of super high AC people in my game at the moment,

1)Cavalier Alchemist, 2) Armored Hulk Alchemist and 3) Vivisector/Armored Hulk. With mutagens up they're running around AC 20-22 and have the option to use Shield extracts which push their AC up another 4 points.

The thing is, they've just hit level 4. Apparently people are willing to club together to get the combat monsters full plate really early in the game and not a lot of monsters I was using previously, even Trolls were requiring 17s and up to hit them.

I've run into some luck dealing with the party using Gunslingers with Muskets, but that seems to be only one part of a panapoly of things I should be doing. What else could I use to challenge these 3 rather crazy characters while letting the other PCs not instantly die? What other sources of touch attacks are there? Are there any good Will save spells to use?

(Other PCs are, Conjuration specialized Wizard, Bear Druid, Oracle, and a Cavalier Bard specced for social)

How are summoners at mid level? I was under the impression they were still quite formidable at levels 6-10, however a friend of mine has a different opinion.

I ran my Kingmaker game again on Sunday and several amusing things popped up which is annoying but I know how to fix.

1) Be worried when all the fighty types decide for that lvl 1 dip into Alchemist for mutagen.
2) Having the party club together to sell basically all the loot and buy the fighter types masterwork platemail is annoying when combined with 1.
3) 20 lvl 1 fighters with shortbows and an attack of +2 don't mean quite so much versus a mounted character who has an AC of 25. (They're incidentally not worth the XP listed)
4) Kingmaker makes heavy use of big bads who are melee bruisers. This will not end well with the composition of my group.
5) I don't really like the 4 encounters per day thing. I'm gonna need to do something like two back to back boss fights to manage the same level of tension you're supposed to have in low level D&D.

Kingmaker is otherwise quite cool. I don't like running with minimal prep but I did this time around because of other obligations.

So, there's something great about the versatility between classes and the ability to dip into other classes to change what your character does. Unfortunately I am currently running into an issue with people in the game I am running where the Alchemist kinda proved the point that he is the greatest of fighters by slaying a troll more or less single handedly.

Now the Cavalier and Barbarian are dipping into Alchemist (for Mutagen).

This is annoying but not bad perse. I'm mostly annoyed as it shows that the 1 level dip into Alchemist really is the way to go for most melee characters. And mutagen stacking on top of Rage is quite awesome.

How would you deal with this situation?

So I ran my first session of Kingmaker and came up against some odd mechanical issues. One is apparently Alchemists are so front loaded its not funny. In short:

1) It is perfectly possible for a party of 5 first level characters to kill 2 trolls, so long as the overpowered alchemist rolls 2 crits in 3 rounds.

2) Random encounters are weird deals (1d4 trolls is a possible encounter at any level)

3) I am going to have to overbuild my encounters from now on.

4) People do not like fetch quests.

So, standardly guns are rather expensive running more than a starting PC that's not a gunslinger can get.

The question is, even with the touch AC to hit thing within the first range band, is it worth that much more standardly?

So I'm starting a Kingmaker Campaign sometime in December and I was wondering if anyone had any experience with the adventure path and the kingdom generation mini-game? It seems kind of odd regarding times to build things.

Also are there any pitfalls I should be looking out for?

Any ideas as to how to make the kingdom game more interactive?

So I'm playing in a Planescape styled game and am thinking of creating an elven alchemist. The thing though is, what are alchemists for? They seem like sort of a hybrid fighter/caster/skill guy to me, but how does that work in application?

"A rage prophet’s class level stacks with barbarian levels for determining the effect of his rage powers, oracle revelations, and his oracle’s curse. This does not grant additional abilities."

Does this mean that Rage Prophet levels stack with Barbarian levels for Rage stuff, and with Oracle for Oracle stuff.


This keys both Rage Prophet and Barbarian to stack with Oracle for stuff?

So in the troll thread that was about how rogues sucked someone made the statement that the falchion was a good two handed weapon to use. Why is that? Rolling D4s kinda suck? Or does the expanded crit range make that big of a difference?

1 person marked this as FAQ candidate.

Just to confirm, with Come and Get me from the APG, Opponents get a +4 to hit and damage versus me, but I get to counter attack them each time they attack. The counter attacks use up attacks of opportunity, so this feat really needs combat reflexes to shine.

That is correct right?

I know this is an often discussed topic, but I was curious as to why the Monk was built the way it is? I guess it mimics the 1st ed design except without the murderous leveling up, but was there anything else? I guess it's kind of special effects, mobility and defense focused?

1 person marked this as FAQ candidate.

How's this supposed to be adjudicated?

A level 4 Invulnerable Rager has 4 HP left and is hit for 8 HP of damage. He has guarded life as one of his powers.

Does he suffer:
1) 8 HP, 4 of which is converted into Nonlethal, which he soaks completely with his DR and is reduced to 0

2)6 HP, his DR soaking 2 points, and the remaining 4 is converted to non-lethal, which he soaks leaving him at 2 HP.

I'm guessing its the first, but I was just curious about confirmation of this particular weird one.

Is the stat bonus when you gain levels +1 or +2? I seem to remember +2 for some reason.

I remember stirrings that there were several core classes that were notably not as good as other classes, one of which being the barbarian. What was the deal and how would you go about fixing said deal?

Hey, are the spells from Complete Divine as spells go fairly reasonable or non-reasonable. Had a guy pull a fast one on me and add some to his spell list, and am generally curious. The spell in question is Wave of Grief, but a general thought on the other cleric spells is appreciated.

Will feedback on the classes be useful still post end of Jan out of curiousity? I'm running a game this weekend in which I intend to stuff several villain APG characters and remembered it was the end of the month already.

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I get the impression despite the volume of special abilities the PF Monk gets it still somehow lags behind the other classes in use, up until high treasure levels where you can get a pretty crazy AC. What would need to change to get them to contribute better to a party?

Being a fan of Wuxia movies I had an idea to bring the monk more in line with those genre ideals. However I am struggling with the balance part of the mechanics so ideas are welcomed.

Youxia translated means Knight-Errant. Its the term for the various characters in wuxia novels who participate in the wuxia ideal. Generally they wander around dispensing justice, much like some PCs. However the idea of justice is subjective, much like for some PCs.

* Simple and Martial Weapon Proficiency
(Maybe just for Melee and Thrown)
* Flurry of Blows works with any weapon they are proficient with
* Abilities like Stunning Fist and Quivering Palm work with weapons
(again for just melee and thrown weapons)

* Bonus Unarmed Damage
* Ki Pool

One thing I've felt ever since 3.0 is that ranged damage is far worse than melee damage. This is probably slid around due to a risk/reward theory on game stuff but it has gotten me thinking.

I am thinking intently on is increasing the die size of all ranged weapons to go up 1 step. Also I am thinking about but pretty sure it would be to crazy is a way to add a feat that let you add your DEX mod to damage.

I've got a friend who's not played D&D in a while, but seems interested in joining my Pathfinder game. He's thinking of playing a Paladin, but doesn't really want to cast spells. Going along the lines of the substitutions that they did in the Pathfinder campaign setting, what else could I reasonably sub out for the spell powers? Would it be reasonable to say that he could get the weapon bond and a slightly less good mount bond?

Having run some Pathfinder sessions and listened to some frankly crazy musings from one of the players, I'm wondering how is the Pathfinder Fighter better than in 3.5. Armor training is a big one and so are the vital strikes but is the sum of those two things really that big?