
CariMac |

@Nohwear: The regular campaign is looking rather short on healers, so anybody who can activate a wand of cure light wounds ends up in the role.
I'm happy to switch to a healer of some type if that helps the tables work better. I don't have one ready to go, but can get it up by Saturday.

![]() |

It looks like we might actually get more players than seats at the tables, so here's some advice for making the cut:
- Choose core campaign.
- Play a simpler class/archetype (CRB & APG are best, OA is worst).
- Clerics and rogues seem to be in demand.
- If something is TBD, make a decision by Friday night.
Assume that there will be 9 tables of 5 players each, so 45 spots available.

Bigguyinblack |

It looks like we might actually get more players than seats at the tables, so here's some advice for making the cut:
- Choose core campaign.
- Play a simpler class/archetype (CRB & APG are best, OA is worst).
- Clerics and rogues seem to be in demand.
- If something is TBD, make a decision by Friday night.
Assume that there will be 9 tables of 5 players each, so 45 spots available.
A reminder. You can make any changes you want to your character and sell your gear back for full value before you play your first game at level 2. The exception being consumables.
So if you so decide to try out an Alchemist/Rogue or Cleric/Oracle/Shaman and decide you don't like it just switch at second level to something you like more.
![]() |

I'm also wondering when you're going to start. I have three PCs at level 1 on paper character sheets that I need to enter into the computer, and I don't have a ton of spare time right now. If we're not starting until Monday or later, I'm fine, as I should have time over the weekend to type at least one of them in.

![]() |

Those heading to Isger seeking permission to start construction of a new venture lodge (Gallows of Madness), please go here to figure out final party composition and meet your team. We'll also discuss best start time.
PLAYER
Otha
Zin Z'arin
Nohwear
PatheticWretch
Upaynao
Wrong John Silver

GM Deekan |

gstor, aerondor and Z..D.. you are currently signed up for my Glass River Rescue. You have characters signed up at multiple tables and you can only play 1. Pick what character you want to stay and remove the other. In 24 hours if you still have 2 characters signed up I will randomly remove one and keep the other seated at a table. The link is below.

Kate Baker Contributor |

It looks like we might actually get more players than seats at the tables, so here's some advice for making the cut:
- Choose core campaign.
- Play a simpler class/archetype (CRB & APG are best, OA is worst).
- Clerics and rogues seem to be in demand.
- If something is TBD, make a decision by Friday night.
Assume that there will be 9 tables of 5 players each, so 45 spots available.
I switched from kineticist to oracle. Also, Dennis and I would prefer to play together, but if it makes more sense to assign us to different tables, we're certainly fine playing separately.

![]() |

Please report to Table 1 (core)
- GM Andrew
- Bigguyinblack
- Wrong John Silver
- RePete
- Dystopiandream
Please report to Table 2 (core)
- Eben the Quiet
- Otha
- Melda
- Luke_Parry
- Ed Birnbryer
Please report to Table 3
- Dennis Muldoon
- Kate Baker
- SkipperD
- Fromper
- JAF0
Please report to Table 4
- hiyami
- supervillan
- Middleman
- GM Deekan
- Enchanter Tim
Please report to Table 5
- Cari Mac
- GlennH
- KeegH
- Banesama
- Luthor Volandis
Please report to Table 6
- Blue Moose
- PatheticWretch
- graywulfe
- The Chess
- kuey
Please report to Table 7
- Cwethan
- DebugAMP
- OlSmokey
- Michael Hopkins
- Wydroe
Please report to Table 8
- Mister Slanky
- Lady Ladile
- Blake's Tiger
- Jason Rodarte
- PJP
Please report to Table 9
- Nohwear
- KingOfAnything
- Thrawn007
- Big Joe
- Zin Z'arin

Pirate Rob |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

As a warning having run several confirmation pbps, I've found the reused posts to be much closer to 25% instead of 75% although some of that may just be customizing the same information for the approach of different parties.
While this is less applicable to replaying evergreens, please remember that each PFS scenario is a beautiful snowflake and should be treated as such. It's your job as GM to help make sure everybody has the best experience possible.
On a related note I've had a couple of bad experiences with previous pbp game days where GMs were clearly running far more games than they could handle, and were just copy/pasting responses rather than actually listening and interacting with their players. It was extremely frustrating and caused me to drop from the middle of a couple of games.
While there's no way I could handle running even half that many pbp games at once, I'm hoping/looking forward to seeing 45 happy and smiling players finishing up there Confirmations.
All that said I love crazy and ambitious plans so here's to wishing you the best. Let us know how it goes and don't be afraid to help for help if you see yourself faltering. I think we all want to see this go well.

![]() |

I just finished running 3 tables of #7-27 and 4 of #6-18 simultaneously, and actually expect this to be easier. The number of scenarios seems to take more out of me than the quantity of tables.
I am going to hold off on starting more scenarios as a player though, until I see how this increased load goes. So basically, we're all a bunch of guinea pigs together :-)

GM NotEspi |

I'll be running a Confirmation game. This is an evergreen, so you can replay it unless the character in question reached level 3. There is a possiblity of me running more than one table, depending on the number of applicants. I'd rather not do 3 tables at the same time, however ( me being already busy as it is, etc ), so I'll run a lottery if there's too many of you.

GM Hmm |

For most GMs, I honestly don't recommend doing multiple tables at the same time of the same scenario. There are some great GMs on here who can handle it and enjoy the prep synergy, but your brain has to be wired that way to make it work.
For me, it really does not. You know what you can do best. I'd rather you had a great time with one scenario than burn out on us.
Hugs,
Hmm

NotEspi |
For most GMs, I honestly don't recommend doing multiple tables at the same time of the same scenario. There are some great GMs on here who can handle it and enjoy the prep synergy, but your brain has to be wired that way to make it work.
For me, it really does not. You know what you can do best. I'd rather you had a great time with one scenario than burn out on us.
Hugs,
Hmm
Won't be for the first time, but I can appreciate the advice.

GM Fuzzfoot |

I used to run a Core and Standard at the same time, but while the synergy of the prep work is great, I found that I was too often thinking group A completed a task that group B did, etc. Not a big problem, but enough to convince me to skip it.
On the other hand, I did start 3 full groups simultaneously on the same AP, and am having better luck with that - although I am having to take much more extensive notes to keep it straight.

![]() |

One of these days, I need to get back to GMing PBP. I did it once in the game day last year, and found it tough for me to keep up with. But I was also playing a few PBP games at the same time. I'll probably start another table of the same adventure (since it's an evergreen, and I already did the prep work) in the next week or two.

Dungeon Master S |

We should move this conversation to "Discussion."
That being said, I also supplement my multiple tables by having a spreadsheet check list of checkpoints. IT helps me track who has done what. I also recognize that I'm unreasonable in how many games I'm in at any given moment, and it's not advisable to try it...

NotEspi |
I'll be running a Confirmation game. This is an evergreen, so you can replay it unless the character in question reached level 3. There is a possiblity of me running more than one table, depending on the number of applicants. I'd rather not do 3 tables at the same time, however ( me being already busy as it is, etc ), so I'll run a lottery if there's too many of you.
Okay this was up for 24+ hours, so I'll likely set up the form to not accept entries anymore after I get back from work. I am in CET+1, by the way, so that's a few hours from now. Like 3-5 hours.
So far there are 8 people, so 2 tables of 4. This is fine, but there is space for 4 more if anyone wants to join in last minute.

![]() |
Please report to Table 1 (core)
- GM Andrew
- Bigguyinblack
- Wrong John Silver
- RePete
- Dystopiandream
Please report to Table 2 (core)
- Eben the Quiet
- Otha
- Melda
- Luke_Parry
- Ed Birnbryer
Please report to Table 3
- Dennis Muldoon
- Kate Baker
- SkipperD
- Fromper
- JAF0
Please report to Table 4
- hiyami
- supervillan
- Middleman
- GM Deekan
- Enchanter Tim
Please report to Table 5
- Cari Mac
- GlennH
- KeegH
- Banesama
- Luthor Volandis
Please report to Table 6
- Blue Moose
- PatheticWretch
- graywulfe
- The Chess
- kuey
Please report to Table 7
- Cwethan
- DebugAMP
- OlSmokey
- Michael Hopkins
- Wydroe
Please report to Table 8
- Mister Slanky
- Lady Ladile
- Blake's Tiger
- Jason Rodarte
- PJP
Please report to Table 9
- Nohwear
- KingOfAnything
- Thrawn007
- Big Joe
- Zin Z'arin
This gets my respect and damm I sure as heck can't handle that many even if it's the same scenario.

NotEspi |
hey Espi...i can bring in a fresh toon to round out a table...havent made it yet will make something table needs....healer etc....
Unfortunately, we're filled up with 12 at the moment. If someone drops, I'll keep you in mind.
We have 12 applicants. I tried to set up a balanced party on each table. If anyone of you wish to play with someone not at your table, let me know. We can always swap it around.
- Escharid Blackrose - Nattia Radmij
- Luthor Volandis - Taleck
- RePete - Utara Yuu
- JamesMartin - Minmaximus
- Michael Hallet - Aurora Rose
- Thrawn007 - Brynjar Colburn
- Middleman - Vorden Salvus
- Fromper - Utu Noranti Pralatong
- Psyblade - Cleric assumed here, name not specified
- Blake's Tiger - Zaratina
- Jayson MF Kip - Carlotta Valdez
- SodiumTelluride - Evariel

![]() |

grimdog73 wrote:hey Espi...i can bring in a fresh toon to round out a table...havent made it yet will make something table needs....healer etc....Unfortunately, we're filled up with 12 at the moment. If someone drops, I'll keep you in mind.
We have 12 applicants. I tried to set up a balanced party on each table. If anyone of you wish to play with someone not at your table, let me know. We can always swap it around.
- Escharid Blackrose - Nattia Radmij
- Luthor Volandis - Taleck
- RePete - Utara Yuu
- JamesMartin - Minmaximus
- Michael Hallet - Aurora Rose
- Thrawn007 - Brynjar Colburn
- Middleman - Vorden Salvus
- Fromper - Utu Noranti Pralatong
- Psyblade - Cleric assumed here, name not specified
- Blake's Tiger - Zaratina
- Jayson MF Kip - Carlotta Valdez
- SodiumTelluride - Evariel
Cheers, let me know where to report, my cleric is ready to go