Times you aren't sure if the GM is losing it or not


Gamer Life General Discussion

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

I'm sure we've all had that moment where the DM does something so off the wall, you weren't sure if they were being serious or not. I have some crazy friends and at one point, I never even considered their GMing to be odd (I just kinda got used to it because I know what their preferences/hobbies are) but damn, looking back, I wasn't sure they weren't on crack. Here's a few top ones.

1. I have a friend (Let's call him..um..Dude 1) who was a big fan of anime and pop culture in general. Often times, he'd watch or read something, then feel the need to shoehorn it into the setting regardless of logic. We were once playing in a feudal japan fantasy setting, he read a manga called 'Love Hina' which is about a guy running a girl's dorm while trying to enroll into university...Lo and behold..Our party ran into an inn with literally the same characters from the manga, and we had to try and get them to enroll into Tokyo University..uh

2.Still Dude 1! After watching transformers: Dark side of the moon, he decided to bring optimus prime (not even a name change) into our steampunk setting, claiming it to be 'ancient technology'. Then, we uh, had to go to the moon on a rocket to fight the BBEG.

3. This is a different dude named dude 2. Dude 2 is big on Korean culture and at one point, in a high fantasy setting (which did involve dimensional hopping), he had us wander into the set of a korean gameshow called 'the running man' where they pit celebrities against each other in silly games. He then had about 10 npcs (actual korean actors) show up and acted out the gameshow by himself as everyone watched in confusion

4.This one is about a guy named dude 3. Dude 3 likes to include uh..sexual situations in his game, which wouldn't really be odd to me..If only it didn't involve human wastes


I very, very rarely get to be on the player's side of the screen, but the guy that does occasionally run Pathfinder in my group doesn't read well, and mispronounces the same words over and over in different ways. We had a fight with a chimera once and I know he pronounced it three different ways, NONE of which was in a configuration that allowed us to know what he was talking about.


6.At a convention the DM insisted on not using miniatures. The battle mage killed most of the town because he couldn't hear the descriptions of NPCs.


I think the title should probably be changed.


What's wrong with it? Any suggestions?

@Goth Guru: The dm insisted on 'no backsies' despite it clearly being an error?


godfang wrote:

What's wrong with it? Any suggestions?

@Goth Guru: The dm insisted on 'no backsies' despite it clearly being an error?

Drug reference bro. Probably against the community guidelines or somesuch.

Maybe rename thread title to "Times you aren't sure if the GM has lost his mind or not..." or something like that.

Grand Lodge

I become very gleeful when I'm 'killing' PCs in dream realms, as I know they will not be out of the game.

The players just see me gleefully murdering their characters, having no idea that it is not for real.


Newbie question, how do I rename the thread? .__.

Silver Crusade Contributor

Unfortunately, it's too late to edit. I'm sure a moderator can help you, though. A post in this forum might direct their attention here. ^_^


Thank you :D

Silver Crusade Contributor

No problem! ^_^


2 people marked this as a favorite.
DungeonmasterCal wrote:
I very, very rarely get to be on the player's side of the screen, but the guy that does occasionally run Pathfinder in my group doesn't read well, and mispronounces the same words over and over in different ways. We had a fight with a chimera once and I know he pronounced it three different ways, NONE of which was in a configuration that allowed us to know what he was talking about.

Wait, isn't English language supposed to work like that?


I have no problem with the current title of the thread. There are many players and GMs that combine recreational activities. I have DMed drunk.... Have had a lot of stoned and drunk players. Generally no problems because the guys I play with are able to tell the difference between serious RP, casual game, beer & pretzels and a lets get hammered and wake up next day face down at the table with no idea what frak we did game.

As for weird stuff from other DMs it's has been the usual wish/fantasy fulfilment.

Scarab Sages

Alexander S. Modeus wrote:
I think the title should probably be changed.

I thought it was funny - certainly got my attention.


Gotta agree with Closet on this one. Seems fine to me.

I'm kinda sad that all my friends are sane, because I don't get to tell stories like this.

Shadow Lodge

godfang wrote:

4.This one is about a guy named dude 3. Dude 3 likes to include uh..sexual situations in his game, which wouldn't really be odd to me..If only it didn't involve human wastes

At that point you just leave the table

I was going to tell my story of "I sense motive on the cake"
Or the one about the gazebo, but that's when the players got drunk

Sovereign Court

I've had crap like that.

I also once played with a bunch of players who were stoned out of their mind.


I had a player went 'I sense motive on the bridge to see if it's safe or not', but that might be the language barrier at work (since english isn't our native tongue)


Roan wrote:
godfang wrote:

What's wrong with it? Any suggestions?

@Goth Guru: The dm insisted on 'no backsies' despite it clearly being an error?

Drug reference bro. Probably against the community guidelines or somesuch.

Maybe rename thread title to "Times you aren't sure if the GM has lost his mind or not..." or something like that.

How dare we sully the reputation of crack users by implying they act in odd and unusual ways. For shame!


We had an odd dm and a player that had read the adventure path and was determined to use his out of game knowledge to his advantage.

So our first enemy was an animated very large pie. With extra hot filling.

Many games later when we persuaded the soldiers of evil to lay down their weapons, they realised the extent of their crimes and betrayal to Korvosa and impaled themselves on the spot. Both were very odd events.


Burrowing? My Special Skill is Burrowing!?


7. When your GM is Lindsay Lohan.

Community & Digital Content Director

Changed thread title by request.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

GMs do stupid things sometimes. I certainly stand accused.

1. As a child of the late 70's/early 80's I routinely steal from old action films. I once ran an entire campaign loosely based on Big Trouble in Little China.

2. I also love adding movie lines into NPC dialogue. I used to give out Exp to folks who caught it and could name the movie/character.

3. I usually enjoy a beer or three with the game.

4. Action scenes are a big deal at my table as I like to act out some of the motions, add sound effects, etc. As such I've broken a lamp, knocked over the entire gaming table and once even toppled an entire full, just-opened 2 litre of Mountain Dew on a player among other mishaps.

Still eccentricity is like the glue that holds all of us together as a community. At a game session last year I had a table with:

- a stoner in a homemade cloak
- an uber-professional executive who programs code
- a grown man with a bigger collection of toys than my daughters
- a heavy metal producer/critic

Bear in mind: we were in public at a local game store. I loved it and am very proud of the diversity. I only wish there'd been some girls there.

Needless to say: I hope GMs continue being nuts. I hope players stay silly and weird. If ever my games get tame and predictable I'll probably start looking for someone to pawn all this stuff to.

Grand Lodge

See, I've never actually watched Big Trouble in Little China, so that would be pretty awesome and I'd have no idea.

Sovereign Court

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Running games based on stuff is awesome. Running games that ARE stuff is stupid.

Sovereign Court

If you have not watched Big Trouble in Little China, you should remedy that at the soonest availability.

I would also like to add that the gaming community in which I reside is full of "colorful" personalities that I keep at a respectable distance. I am very happy with my current group, and pray nightly that they do not move away.


Terquem wrote:
Burrowing? My Special Skill is Burrowing!?

Dammit, I know that quote, and cannot place it.

Sovereign Court

Dexter's Lab perhaps?

Sovereign Court

Yep, dexter.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Ah, right. Same episode as the pinata dragon.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
DungeonmasterCal wrote:
I very, very rarely get to be on the player's side of the screen, but the guy that does occasionally run Pathfinder in my group doesn't read well, and mispronounces the same words over and over in different ways. We had a fight with a chimera once and I know he pronounced it three different ways, NONE of which was in a configuration that allowed us to know what he was talking about.

Is his name Ed? I think he's in my group. :-D


DeeDee - greatest DM the world will ever know!


Based on can be good fun, but you don't want to get too restrictive in what the players can do (muh railroad) and it has to fit. For example, for my Friday game I'm using characters from the game Recettear, which focuses on a poor girl in a fantasy setting that is thrust into being a merchant as her adventurer father has disappeared (probably died) and left her with a massive debt, which a loan shark rocks up to collect. This works with a party of bandits lying low in a city, quest options will be there, but there are other threads they can take. If they want to indulge in a bit of jrpg influence, they can. If they want to rob her and further prove they are awful evil, they can, but her on call adventurer is quite the high stat-machine. Now I've had the idea of bringing this in for a while, and its characters are pretty fun and could give something to the game. The players will get the reference and characters as some have played Recettear (also play Recettear, it makes being a merchant-adventurer very fun).


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Capitalism Ho!

I wonder though, how many DMs here have anime/japanese influence in their games, that seems to be a pretty reliable source of 'off the wall moments' (I have a DM who constantly makes the BBEG 8 year old girls carrying giant weapons)


"You know, you seem to have a basic understanding of how to sell things to people and not drive them to burn down the shop in anger."

I was a little surprised to see so much hostility to anime and anime influence upon pathfinder/games within paizo threads, but not everyone likes Durians.

Yayifications to you Godfang.


I can honestly say there has never been a single anime influence in my games. I don't hate anime; I'm totally disinterested in it.

Scarab Sages

DM Under The Bridge wrote:

"You know, you seem to have a basic understanding of how to sell things to people and not drive them to burn down the shop in anger."

I was a little surprised to see so much hostility to anime and anime influence upon pathfinder/games within paizo threads, but not everyone likes Durians.

Yayifications to you Godfang.

I might be capable of understanding. I'm sure it depends on specifics, but anime doesn't always combine well with Western fantasy (See also: The Book of 9 Swords).

I do like all the androgynous males with spectacular powers, though!

@DungeonmasterCal: If you're so disinterested in anime, where'd you learn to be a ninja like that?


I'm always the GM/DM side of the screen, so I rarely get to be a witness to how really messed up my friends are, but one buddy of mine ran a game, where he spent HOURS, coming up with his own monsters.

When he unveiled his weeks-worth of creativity, big boss, aberration masterpiece- and it had private parts included in it's natural attacks, I don't think stunned silence, was the response he was hoping for.

PS: I hope sharing that particular GM story was not too inappropriate for these forums. It was literally the first thing I thought of when reading the thread title. :/


1 person marked this as a favorite.
I'm Hiding In Your Closet wrote:
@DungeonmasterCal: If you're so disinterested in anime, where'd you learn to be a ninja like that?

I was a ninja in the 80s before anime became a thing! Ok, this next statement is true; I went to college with a guy who graduated high school at 15. Because he was so young his dad lived in the dorm with him. And his dad wore costumes when he accompanied him to class. One of them was a ninja costume. I wish I was making that up. But our joke for years after was he was our ninja sensei whenever we played 1e's Oriental Adventures.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
DungeonmasterCal wrote:
I'm Hiding In Your Closet wrote:
@DungeonmasterCal: If you're so disinterested in anime, where'd you learn to be a ninja like that?
I was a ninja in the 80s before anime became a thing! Ok, this next statement is true; I went to college with a guy who graduated high school at 15. Because he was so young his dad lived in the dorm with him. And his dad wore costumes when he accompanied him to class. One of them was a ninja costume. I wish I was making that up. But our joke for years after was he was our ninja sensei whenever we played 1e's Oriental Adventures.

Ninjas really were a big thing in the 80's weren't they? I remember being 8-years-old, and my dad let me have throwing stars. Man times have changed- you can't even buy lawn-darts anymore!


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Joe Hex wrote:
Ninjas really were a big thing in the 80's weren't they? I remember being 8-years-old, and my dad let me have throwing stars. Man times have changed- you can't even buy lawn-darts anymore!

I have a set of authentic steel lawn darts! They were given to me by a friend. Great fun with beer.

Japanese influence was actually all over the place with the 80s pop metal scene. Japanese writing on headbands, tshirts, guitar straps, etc. There were some Japanese animated shows on tv, but it wasn't a culture like it is today.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

The late 70's - 80's Ninja craze - good times. Ran around a mates backyard with rubber shuriken, nunchucks, and bokken smashing the crap out of each other. Star Blazers, Astro boy, MONKEY!!!, then Robotech.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Speaking of ninjas, I had a GM once that had a whole village ignore a pc when he tried to talk to them. The player asked 'why?' and he said 'your passive stealth is too high, and you have hide in plain sight'


Kiss a wall, open a door.
Switchblade dildo.
Hat of many animals.
Hopscotch.
Potato Room.
Glory Hole Lock.
Revenge of Hopscotch.

That's all coming to my head right now. Inquire further if you want details.


...Glory hole lock? So like..you have to find a party member willing to stick their reproductive organ through a keyhole?


godfang wrote:
...Glory hole lock? So like..you have to find a party member willing to stick their reproductive organ through a keyhole?

More like it is a lock shaped like a glory hole and we have to find a dildo key to move on unless one of the male PCs wants to take a risk. And we kind of lack a Kuthite.

Silver Crusade Contributor

HyperMissingno wrote:

Kiss a wall, open a door.

Switchblade dildo.
Hat of many animals.
Hopscotch.
Potato Room.
Glory Hole Lock.
Revenge of Hopscotch.

That's all coming to my head right now. Inquire further if you want details.

Go on, please...

^_^


1 person marked this as a favorite.
HyperMissingno wrote:

Kiss a wall, open a door.

Switchblade dildo.
Hat of many animals.
Hopscotch.
Potato Room.
Glory Hole Lock.
Revenge of Hopscotch.

That's all coming to my head right now. Inquire further if you want details.

... what?

Umm, you have just set a bar that I don't know can be topped on a private forum. I thought my buddy was weird when we encountered mushroom-folk called the Dildonians. The thread is yours.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

If I'm not sure if the GM is losing it or not, and I see the lines of sanity starting to crack, I start playing Slim Whitman's Yodeling albums.

1 to 50 of 52 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Gamer Life / General Discussion / Times you aren't sure if the GM is losing it or not All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.