Elven Witch: How do I escape the Witch Stereotype?


Advice

1 to 50 of 59 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?


Which stereotypical witch from pop culture?

Hot witch?

Wicked witch?

Magical girl witch?

Scarab Sages

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Based on what you've got so far, a few ideas:

- A street performer who plays an instrument while his familiar performs; said familiar may be in the habit of pretending to just be a normal animal of its type

- a mesmerizing, Jaffar-and-Iago royal vizier type (need not be Evil)

- an "alternative medicine" practitioner (NOT a quack) who offers his familiar for use in animal therapy; explains his aggressive/manipulative uses of his powers by smiling sadly and saying "the butcher and the surgeon use the same tools"

- a lonely and somewhat frustrated soul who was never good at making friends, and originally learned magic from his patron in order to rectify that

- a Puckish trickster ("Lord, what fools these mortals be!" - great for an Elf)


Witch was pretty firmly built around the stereotypical witch theme. They go and give people the evil eye, they can have a black cat, and can cook people in their cauldron, should they select the appropriate hexes.

However, you could play the character so that it looks like an oracle with mystic powers, a tribal shaman, or even a learned wizard who dabbles in different arcane magic than normal wizards. There's a lot of ways you could go about it without being obviously a witch. So long as you don't try to look like a tough fighter (with a CON penalty and a d6 HD class), you'll be fine.

Scarab Sages

1 person marked this as a favorite.
My Self wrote:

Witch was pretty firmly built around the stereotypical witch theme. They go and give people the evil eye, they can have a black cat, and can cook people in their cauldron, should they select the appropriate hexes.

I don't entirely agree - if you want to see a Witch class consciously based on the traditional fairy tale witch, I recommend Green Ronin's 3.0/3.5 Witch class (itself based on a great passage from the 3.0 Dungeon Master's Guide that used the fairy tale witch as an example of how one would go through the process of designing new spellcasting classes).


You could be Glenda the good witch! :D
The Feral speech and Heal hex would go well.
Bruising intellect perhaps...for those furious moments.
Fortune and Ward are "Good" hexes.
The patron theme of stars from UM is really cool. It gives wandering star motes at 8th among other things.

Scarab Sages

Larkspire wrote:

You could be Glenda the good witch! :D

Or Elphaba the musically misunderstood and maligned witch! :P


Play a stoner who laughs at everybody (evil eye or misfortune? "It's just karma, man" cackle? *laughs*)


Typelouder wrote:

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?

Lord of the rings:

Gandalf and Sauruman are wizards.... Lady Galadriel is a witch.


My Self wrote:

Witch was pretty firmly built around the stereotypical witch theme. They go and give people the evil eye, they can have a black cat, and can cook people in their cauldron, should they select the appropriate hexes.

However, you could play the character so that it looks like an oracle with mystic powers, a tribal shaman, or even a learned wizard who dabbles in different arcane magic than normal wizards. There's a lot of ways you could go about it without being obviously a witch. So long as you don't try to look like a tough fighter (with a CON penalty and a d6 HD class), you'll be fine.

meh.... my wifes first witch she ever made (back when they were new) never had evil eye or cackle, she took hexes like tounges n stuff like that.

Shadow Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I would recommend not calling yourself a witch. My group's first pathfinder witch styled himself "Dr. So-and-So, Apothecary." He had the Cauldron and Healing hexes. "Enchantress" works very nicely, if you want to advertise. Otherwise you could use a mundane profession (scribe, herbalist, poet) or evocative "elven" title like "Dreamspeaker."

My Self wrote:
Witch was pretty firmly built around the stereotypical witch theme. They go and give people the evil eye, they can have a black cat, and can cook people in their cauldron, should they select the appropriate hexes.

The Witch class is built to allow the stereotypical wicked witch theme, not to require it.

Pendagast wrote:
Gandalf and Sauruman are wizards.... Lady Galadriel is a witch.

In the sense of "female magic-user," yes. Though I think the term was mostly used by those fearful of her magic rather than a title that she would have given herself. (Correct me if I'm wrong - haven't read the books in years.)


7 people marked this as a favorite.

for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.


Pendagast wrote:
for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.

That is a pretty good idea. I have also been looking at pulling some ideas from the Warlock pact ideas via 5th Ed (is that a no no to mention?).


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Pendagast wrote:
for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.

*Because David Bowie is an arcane fullcaster.*


5 people marked this as a favorite.
My Self wrote:
Pendagast wrote:
for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.
*Because David Bowie is an arcane fullcaster.*

He did figure out how to make permanency work with glitterdust on himself. That's some serious arcane chops. :p


2 people marked this as a favorite.

To my knowledge there is nothing whatsoever in the rules that says you actually have to state your class to your party. You could easily design codes "I use the one with paralysis on him." That your DM understands, and work around that, at least for a while. If the party doesn't know what you're capable of, doesn't have the name witch to assign to you at all, but sees you doing things and enemies flailing helplessly before you, while your allies heal?

It's a more realistic version of a witch in my opinion, because a real witch likely would never say so. When the players have to only guess at your powers it makes you an unknown, potentially more powerful than themselves (even though witches I've seen aren't exactly powerhouse material), friend/foe. You could well be the most feared player at the table, since even after they nailed you down to "witch" you still don't have to tell them what feats and hexes you're taking. Every level they have to wonder, "did she take x to stab us in the back with this level?".

Edit:
Mysterious characters are a great way to achieve the mysterious character theme. Mysterious players are a great way to actually make everyone wonder what's going on with your character.

Silver Crusade Contributor

I made a weird GMPC for my Emerald Spire group.

She was a lonely, thin girl who claimed talents such as "fortune-telling" and "faith healing". She's always afraid of something, and very quiet. When spied on alone, she seemed to argue with a terrifying presence she called "Mother". She carried only a sap for weaponry and wore no armor.

What was she? See if you can guess...


Look to some of the urban fantasy characters, as well. Many of them have arcanely talented women/men. Just readjust the time period.

Scarab Sages

My Self wrote:
Pendagast wrote:
for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.
*Because David Bowie is an arcane fullcaster.*

Whith the Magic Dance song, I'd see him as more of a Bard.

Liberty's Edge

3 people marked this as a favorite.
Kalindlara wrote:

I made a weird GMPC for my Emerald Spire group.

She was a lonely, thin girl who claimed talents such as "fortune-telling" and "faith healing". She's always afraid of something, and very quiet. When spied on alone, she seemed to argue with a terrifying presence she called "Mother". She carried only a sap for weaponry and wore no armor.

What was she? See if you can guess...

Emo?


Have you considered the VMC out of Pathfinder Unchained? The bard or cleric VMC could work well with a witch. With the bard you get bardic knowledge and some performances which could work well for a knowledge focused witch. Cleric works well for a healing focused witch. A witch who can spontaneously cast healing spells and channels energy is going to confuse the hell out of people.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder PF Special Edition, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Typelouder wrote:

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?

Don't act like a stereotype witch from pop culture. Nor the caricature the Catholic Church created when dealing with their favorite targets, women who could not defend themselves.

There is a wide spectrum of character possibilities ranging from being almost Druidic, to an urbane type much like a Rosicrucian, your grandfather's Elk Lodge, or scholastic Order of the Rising Dawn.


The late Terry Pratchett differentiated his witches well and might have some examples to look at. From the typical "Maiden, Mother and Crone" witch trio it extended to all sorts - fortune tellers, midwives, village elders, shepherdesses, carnies and so on.

Not telling your party exactly what class you are sounds fun, especially if you play it well.


Corvino wrote:

The late Terry Pratchett differentiated his witches well and might have some examples to look at. From the typical "Maiden, Mother and Crone" witch trio it extended to all sorts - fortune tellers, midwives, village elders, shepherdesses, carnies and so on.

Not telling your party exactly what class you are sounds fun, especially if you play it well.

Well, it is no surprise that carnies all have the misforune hex.

Actually, that could be an interesting angle- a smooth talking social butterfly and professional gambler. Give herself fortune, give her opponent misforune. Doesn't see too hard.


Kalindlara wrote:

I made a weird GMPC for my Emerald Spire group.

She was a lonely, thin girl who claimed talents such as "fortune-telling" and "faith healing". She's always afraid of something, and very quiet. When spied on alone, she seemed to argue with a terrifying presence she called "Mother". She carried only a sap for weaponry and wore no armor.

What was she? See if you can guess...

druid or maybe a rogue


another "witch" would be the witch king of Angmar.

Id make something like that a Magus Hexcrafter.

there's also white haired witch that isnt a stereotypical witch.

I could easily make a witch that wasnt anything like a "witch".
although, I dont prefer full casters for my own PCs.


Rennaivx wrote:
My Self wrote:
Pendagast wrote:
for a male, "the goblin king" (David Bowie) from labyrinth seems like an "elven witch" to me.
*Because David Bowie is an arcane fullcaster.*
He did figure out how to make permanency work with glitterdust on himself. That's some serious arcane chops. :p

Except that that movie starred the other guy. Everybody knows that the real David Bowie was murdered in 1980 and then began his unlife of crime.

On the actual thread topic, witchery can be used as hedge magic. You can play them like a self-taught wizard. They don't realize that their arts are different than true wizardry.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2011 Top 32

Fundamentally, a Pathfinder witch is a caster who derives her power from a "patron." You end up with a familiar as a go between for you and your patron. That's it - you can play around with those themes pretty much however you want.

I'm currently playing a witch in a Skull&shackles game who is terrible at sailing (Wis penalty), but he always wanted to be a pirate - so he made a deal with the sea itself to have power over the waves. A little snapping turtle came out of the ocean and whispers dark secrets of magic to him. Mechanically, he's a water patron witch, but most of his in-game flavor is of a guy who made a bargain for power.


Has anyone watched Vin Diesel's "The Last Witch Hunter"? Some ideas for witches there - though they're also stereotypical


Typelouder wrote:

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?

You could just pass yourself off as an enchanter and go for a more traditional wizard or sorcerer feel. Give yourself more of a courtly / aristocratic wizard vibe. Hell, you could even carry a book around. Mechanically you wouldn't look much different aside from having a little more natural magic at your disposal.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Given how dreadfully boring I find the pf cleric, I would be inclined to try the witch as cleric idea. Replace "patron" with "deity" and it falls right into place.


I can do no better than to recommend that you check out this Witch. Not an Elf, but not a stereotype of Witch often spoken of over here (although Eastern Europe might be another story).

Liberty's Edge

"Pop culture" made me think of a hippy-style witch, trying to make people feeling happy and cool and at one with Nature, Life and the Universe.


The Raven Black wrote:
"Pop culture" made me think of a hippy-style witch, trying to make people feeling happy and cool and at one with Nature, Life and the Universe.

That one so needs a toad familiar that he/she gives to the party to lick...

Shadow Lodge

Ideas--

Fangirl-- the patron manifests as whatever they are fans of even though it might be something else in truth. Good ones for Golarion, Varian Jeggre, Baba Yaga, Minkai culture, the Pathfinder Society, whatever. Good movie for this concept is Julie and Julia.

Librarian-- I'm doing one as an half orc Aranist. Think Rachel Weiss in The Mummy or Yomiko Readman.

Cheerleader--Hexes as cheers.

Odin or a Valkyrie, preferably the less armored version i.e. lets give an eye for foreknowledge.


A patron and an archetype can be recommended for a witch at work Inquisition iomedae?


PhD. Okkam wrote:
A patron and an archetype can be recommended for a witch at work Inquisition iomedae?

What he said.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
I'm Hiding In Your Closet wrote:
Larkspire wrote:
You could be Glenda the good witch! :D
Or Elphaba the musically misunderstood and maligned witch! :P

I hear she has an extra eye that always remains awake!

I hear that she can shed her skin as easily as a snake!

I hear some rebel animals are giving her food and shelter!

I hear her soul is so unclean pure water can melt her!


Tarot, Witch of the Black Rose.


Anarchy_Kanya wrote:
Tarot, Witch of the Black Rose.

I've read that. You ought to put an NSFW with it.

RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I played a half-orc witch that acted like Conan the Barbarian, but played like your typical witch. He did the whole Sacred Tattoo + Fates Favored thing, too, of course. He was fun! Baelock Curse!!!!


4 people marked this as a favorite.

You know, I never really got why Witches were INT-based in the first place. They don't study magic out of a book, they cut deals with powerful forces via talking animal lawyers.

Sounds like it'd be Charisma all the way to me. Would also make Changelings better Witches.


DominusMegadeus wrote:

You know, I never really got why Witches were INT-based in the first place. They don't study magic out of a book, they cut deals with powerful forces via talking animal lawyers.

Sounds like it'd be Charisma all the way to me. Would also make Changelings better Witches.

I recommend picking up Wayfinder #14 when it comes out. There might just be something of interest there for you. ^_^


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Typelouder wrote:

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?

Whatever you perceive that stereotype to be ... don't be that.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder PF Special Edition, Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Typelouder wrote:

I am playing around with a Dreamspeaker (racial ability) Elven Witch with a focus on enchantment/charm spells. Mechanic wise I am pretty happy with the build.

What I am having an issue with is really separating myself from stereotypical witch from pop culture. I planned on having a decent CHA and focusing on face type (Diplomacy, Bluff, Sense motive) to fit that Enchanter theme.

Does any one have any ideas on ways to further flesh the character out to separate himself?

It's actually very easy. First purge your mind of modern goth and Elvira.

Second, put background as well as class into your concept.

My half-elven hedge witch for example is more of a rustic and reclusive healer personality. while have a slight arcane flavor over a healer focused cleric, shaman, or druid.


Kalindlara wrote:

I made a weird GMPC for my Emerald Spire group.

She was a lonely, thin girl who claimed talents such as "fortune-telling" and "faith healing". She's always afraid of something, and very quiet. When spied on alone, she seemed to argue with a terrifying presence she called "Mother". She carried only a sap for weaponry and wore no armor.

What was she? See if you can guess...

I give up.

Silver Crusade Contributor

Gisher wrote:
Kalindlara wrote:

I made a weird GMPC for my Emerald Spire group.

She was a lonely, thin girl who claimed talents such as "fortune-telling" and "faith healing". She's always afraid of something, and very quiet. When spied on alone, she seemed to argue with a terrifying presence she called "Mother". She carried only a sap for weaponry and wore no armor.

What was she? See if you can guess...

I give up.

I forgot I posted this here!

Spoiler:

"Misty" (short for Madame Mystique, her fortune-telling stage name) is a changeling spiritualist with the haunted archetype. "Mother" is her phantom, who has the hatred emotional focus (and was her hag mother in life).

The party has seen Mother come out to fight. As the party is now 4th level, they've also seen her use usurp manifestation - draining Misty and growing to Large size.

Lately, the party's android kineticist has been trying to brighten Misty up as part of her own evolution and emotional growth.

Now that I think about it, maybe I should do a write-up of this character for Wayfinder #15...


LazarX wrote:

It's actually very easy. First purge your mind of modern goth and Elvira.

{. . .}

Wait, you can't purge Elvira!

Actually, Elvira is pretty offbeat relative to the Witch stereotype. Seems (at least from my very limited watching) more of a prototype for an atypical Chaotic Neutral/Good Succubus. Although I haven't heard of anyone actually following after this prototype.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

I have two character concepts waiting in the wings involving Strength Patron "battle Witch" characters (arcane Divine Favor...).

One is a strength-based wild 'pagan' warrior Synergist bonded with a goat familiar, wielding longsword/unarmed/claw/gore. The other is a bow/shield/rapier combatant that comes across more like a Ranger, but with a 'nature magic' on a whole other level.

1 to 50 of 59 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Advice / Elven Witch: How do I escape the Witch Stereotype? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.