Zaister |
Chambers and Bierce should be at least mentioned in the AP's metaplot since they predate Lovecraft.
Considering that the King in Yellow seems to be involved, and it looks like we're even going to Carcosa, I think that's a given.
Misroi |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Fingers crossed on Flumphs.
Sorry, Davia, I already asked Daigle about this one - he confirmed then that there were no plans on including flumphs. Not saying that they're won't be, as plans can change, but I think we're out of luck.
Which is a shame, given their new role in Pathfinder. They would have been ideal for this AP.
Hubaris |
Espagnoll wrote:Chambers and Bierce should be at least mentioned in the AP's metaplot since they predate Lovecraft.Considering that the King in Yellow seems to be involved, and it looks like we're even going to Carcosa, I think that's a given.
Hopefully the Unspeakable One's name actually becomes dangerous to speak.
Davia D |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Davia D wrote:Fingers crossed on Flumphs.Sorry, Davia, I already asked Daigle about this one - he confirmed then that there were no plans on including flumphs. Not saying that they're won't be, as plans can change, but I think we're out of luck.
Which is a shame, given their new role in Pathfinder. They would have been ideal for this AP.
Aw. I guess not horror-y enough, but a bit disappointing.
Maybe in the future. The eventual Dominion of the Black AP?
Or just a whole Flump-centric ap ^^
Soilent |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I'm not sure what to expect, it's quite a conflict of interest.
Seeing as Lovecraft is a heavy inspiration, yet this is a Paizo product.
Lovecraft was very racist, most noteably making a HUGE deal out of interracial marriage.
Meanwhile Paizo has always been deep into the progressive mindset.
I'm curious.
Though really, the lovecraft quote seen above "Never explain anything." explains a great deal about his concerns as a writer. He was considered a hack in his own time, because his primary concern was getting words onto pages, without actually saying anything.
I'm hoping Paizo can do better than him.
thejeff |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I'm not sure what to expect, it's quite a conflict of interest.
Seeing as Lovecraft is a heavy inspiration, yet this is a Paizo product.
Lovecraft was very racist, most noteably making a HUGE deal out of interracial marriage.
Meanwhile Paizo has always been deep into the progressive mindset.
I'm curious.
Though really, the lovecraft quote seen above "Never explain anything." explains a great deal about his concerns as a writer. He was considered a hack in his own time, because his primary concern was getting words onto pages, without actually saying anything.
I'm hoping Paizo can do better than him.
Nearly everyone who's used Lovecraft as inspiration in the modern age has avoided at least the more troublesome racist aspects. Paizo certainly has so far, to the best of my knowledge. I can't imagine that will change.
There may be some things that could be racist by analogy - if you take Deep Ones interbreeding with humans as an allegory for interracial marriage, then it's a problem. Of course, Paizo already has that in both Deep Ones and the Skum.
Adam Daigle Developer |
8 people marked this as a favorite. |
As the developer of this Adventure Path, I'm just gonna chime in here and say that Lovecraft's racism is not something that I intend on having a presence in this AP. Also, considering that much of this AP deals with creations of Robert Chambers and Ambrose Bierce (Hastur, Carcosa), as well as James Jacobs (Xhamen-Dor), I don't see it as a thing coming up during this campaign.
The Raven Black |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I'm not sure what to expect, it's quite a conflict of interest.
Seeing as Lovecraft is a heavy inspiration, yet this is a Paizo product.
Lovecraft was very racist, most noteably making a HUGE deal out of interracial marriage.
Meanwhile Paizo has always been deep into the progressive mindset.
I'm curious.
Though really, the lovecraft quote seen above "Never explain anything." explains a great deal about his concerns as a writer. He was considered a hack in his own time, because his primary concern was getting words onto pages, without actually saying anything.
I'm hoping Paizo can do better than him.
Lovecraft was a great writer and he was a racist
You can enjoy his work while not being racist
Ragusa Cekbar |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Soilent wrote:I'm not sure what to expect, it's quite a conflict of interest.
Seeing as Lovecraft is a heavy inspiration, yet this is a Paizo product.
Lovecraft was very racist, most noteably making a HUGE deal out of interracial marriage.
Meanwhile Paizo has always been deep into the progressive mindset.
I'm curious.
Though really, the lovecraft quote seen above "Never explain anything." explains a great deal about his concerns as a writer. He was considered a hack in his own time, because his primary concern was getting words onto pages, without actually saying anything.
I'm hoping Paizo can do better than him.
Lovecraft was a great writer and he was a racist
You can enjoy his work while not being racist
I'm not a huge fan of his writing and am certainly not a fan of racism. I should point out the other charge against Lovecraft, that his main concern was getting words onto pages, is rather unfair. he was writing during the depression when pulp writers were paid (as writers often are still to this day) by the word, and at a mere pittance. "Being concerned with putting words on the page" was the man trying to feed himself and pay his bills. As a full time writer myself, I well understand his motivations. Now, whether his work is art or groundbreaking or whatnot....that's a fair discussion to have
Wyrd_Wik |
7 people marked this as a favorite. |
Ah the inevitable Lovecraft was a racist therefore anyone who enjoys his writing must be racist. (OK well if you enjoy Horror at Red Hook maybe)
The notion that Paizo has a conflict of interest (i.e. a company with evident progressive direction) mining Lovecraft (and others) for inspiration for a game is spurious. I don't think the good folks over at Chaosium are continually worrying about the yellow peril or miscegenation either.
Looking forward to the AP and all of its Lovecraftian tentacles.
Misroi |
9 people marked this as a favorite. |
Agreed, Wyrd. Lovecraft's views on race are abhorrent, even more so than the alien creatures he imagined. However, the contributions he made to weird fiction cannot be understated. It's like throwing out the contributions Shakespeare made to English literature due to the sexist problems of The Taming of the Shrew, or the uncomfortable parallels between colonialism and The Tempest. Are those subjects present in the text? Absolutely. Does that mean there's nothing there worth reading? Of course not.
Stone Dog |
I am testing the waters for what to do after my group is done with the current game and a concern has come up about the content of Strange Aeons.
Knowing only what was on the main blurb for the campaign as a whole, one of them wondered if there were going to be firearms/an earth visit in any stage of the game since Call of Cthulu is often in an early-modern setting and they seem to want neither thing.
Is there any word on either of those concerns for sure?
Kalindlara Contributor |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
It won't visit Real Earth the way a certain other Path does, if that worries you. However, you might want to take a good look at the background image for the cover of Book 6.
Cohle Slaad |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Many things immediately obvious from the AP premise(Yithian connection) and from reading scenario names(Hastur) and posts on the boards may have become red herrings by now.
The Red Herrings are a sekrit abolethian counterintelligence SEAL team of gillmen.
Muser wrote:A bhole in the first adventure? I'll see what I can do. ;)They're in the cover of the first adventure to boot.
Hoping for a bhole, personally.
Wait. You mean there's actually... a bhole in One? {rolls vs. Will damage for self-inflicted pun}
Cthulhu Fhtagn. CTHULHU FHTAGN. CTHULHU FHTAGN.
What's this, then? "Cthulhu Fhtagn"? People called Cthulhu they go the dreaming?!?!
John Ryan 783 |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
So, now that the sanity system has been fleshed out and released have thoughts changed and it has been added into the path? If not, how hard do you think it would be to incorporate into it? Because honestly if it's Lovecraftian in nature, and we have a Paizo designed sanity system then I(and most of my players) feel it should be included.