I downvoted you before. Like, three or sixteen times. But now we've got acquainted, I look around and see that you really can shine, under the right light...
I found an item that, up until now, was believed to have been culled! I updated the list! one of you lucky ducks now know that you live to fight another day!!!
I found an item that, up until now, was believed to have been culled! I updated the list! one of you lucky ducks now know that you live to fight another day!!!
And I voted for it!!!
PS - I hope I made your day. Because that would make mine.
I think that there are three coins around. Maybe some that I'm selectively forgetting like some of those shields. But the three I remember are really cool. There's one in particular that I really like, though.
An anti-undead item that I not only enjoyed, but made it into my top picks for Round 1 (this one included, three total)
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I am in the military (Army) specifically. My current favorite item is one that no Soldier would go without, and one that all Soldiers universally love. Praise praise praise for this item.
Hopefully this is vague enough. Those who are in the Army will probably zero right in, and if required, please delete. :-D
Whoever made the bakery item is my new favorite person.
Dang it, I cannot click the little + button enough on this!
Star Voter Season 7, Star Voter Season 8, Marathon Voter Season 9
|
There was a pairing earlier that was heartrendingly difficult for me.
Both used mechanics that I don't get to see often.
Both had solid writing and templates.
Both had innovative themes that were executed brilliantly.
I chose one, but I will be immensely saddened if you one of you doesn't make it.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Y'know for an item I'm 99% sure is a joke, I think I've voted for you every time you've come up for me. You're just so... really well written. I'm sorry to the community if that's a no-no, but honestly props to the writer.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Ooo, hello again, one of my two favorite arthopod-themed items. Yes, u can haz upvote!
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Y'know for an item I'm 99% sure is a joke, I think I've voted for you every time you've come up for me. You're just so... really well written. I'm sorry to the community if that's a no-no, but honestly props to the writer.
There's nothing wrong with joke items at all - they're just not for every group, and thus prove less popular than non-joke items. If you found an awesome item that's silly or even gonzo, by all means vote for it!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Nice. Almost a spell in a can, but different enough. I like it. Well thought out and useful. Kind of a plot item, but it is a plot I would use. Your competition is kinda creepy, has charges that are not "charges," and has a terrible recharge mechanic.
Oh darn, the rest of this item is pretty generic, but that one ability is so cool I want to steal it for something.
One of my favorite armours keeps showing up.
That's disgusting- why would anyone think to do that?
*thinks about it for a minute*
... Oh that's really clever actually
So far, I have seven items that I would consider to be superstar, including one weapon and one armor. As far as I can tell, none of these has a perfect template.
There are a handful of other items that I really like for their concept, but unfortunately found their execution to be lacking.
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Oh! I just saw my first item that I literally sat up and went "YES" to. I've liked quite a few so far, and thought they were all decent competitors, but if this one doesn't end up in the top 32 I'll eat my shirt. It's beautifully thematic, useful in and out of combat, simple, cheap, and it would just be so much fun to use, both as a GM and a player! Good job, Designer!
overall since cull 2, the quality has been really good.
There are some really cool suits of armor this year.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Thank you oh evil pastry person. I now have to clean coffee off of my monitor. :-)
There's one little item that hits on all cylinders for me. Name, inspiration, and execution. I expect to see it in the Top 32.
Are you maybe trying to replicate this? Clever. I should have spotted that immediately.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Two simple and elegant items of low word count paired against each other. I gotta go with the slightly more interesting effect, but bravo to the two designers.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I'm kinda bummed out because one of my favorite items seems to have been culled for no good reason. It was a clever, pretty item with great style and mechanics.
Hamelin called.
I hung up, cause I'm keeping this. :)
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
It's funny comparing the level of detail given in this thread and the snark one. Over there it's (and yes I am intentionally using a description here that does not apply to anything I have actually seen):
"Really? Pink elephants?" "No glaive-guisarme should cost that much." Etc.
Here, it's:
"Ooh! I really like you!"
Seems like the two should really work on the same standard, one way or the other.