
Turin the Mad |

While I can appreciate Cthulhu mythology, I just find Lovecraft's stories to be OK at best and racist at times.
Well, keeping in mind when they were written (Great Depression) and by whom, your findings are to be expected.
What I would probably be shunned for: I do not care one whit for gaming in various movies/TV shows/comic book settings. Be it Star Trek, Star Wars, Dragonlance, Firefly, Buffy the Vampire Werehamster, Alien vs. Predator vs. Pokemon or the combined worlds of DC, Marvel and Dark Horse comics.

Laurefindel |

What I would probably be shunned for: I do not care one whit for gaming in various movies/TV shows/comic book settings. Be it Star Trek, Star Wars, Dragonlance, Firefly, Buffy the Vampire Werehamster, Alien vs. Predator vs. Pokemon or the combined worlds of DC, Marvel and Dark Horse comics.
But what about My Little Pony?
...although the werehamster thing sounds intriguing.

Craig Bonham 141 |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I had my players saved by Santa Claus.
I had my players run into the kids from the 80s Dungeons and Dragons cartoon show. The characters had become vile, corrupt and heinously evil after having been yanked into a series of dangerous situations by the sadistic and manipulative "Dungeon Master". Presto's spellbook was covered in cloth from Dungeon Master's cloak and the place-holder was made from his scalp. Bobby the Barbarian's loincloth was made from Uni's hide.

MagusJanus |

I had my players saved by Santa Claus.
I had my players kill Santa Claus. On Christmas Eve.
It was a Santa based on this song, but made using 3.5 rules. Including firearms.
Now that I have Pathfinder, guess who is going to get a weapon proficiency in firearms when I remake.

Tequila Sunrise |

What I would probably be shunned for: I do not care one whit for gaming in various movies/TV shows/comic book settings. Be it Star Trek, Star Wars, Dragonlance, Firefly, Buffy the Vampire Werehamster, Alien vs. Predator vs. Pokemon or the combined worlds of DC, Marvel and Dark Horse comics.
No shunning here! I love the Wheel of Time, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where casters are even more gonzo than they are in 3.x D&D. I love A Song of Ice and Fire, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where magic and monsters are so rare.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.

Adjule |

Turin the Mad wrote:What I would probably be shunned for: I do not care one whit for gaming in various movies/TV shows/comic book settings. Be it Star Trek, Star Wars, Dragonlance, Firefly, Buffy the Vampire Werehamster, Alien vs. Predator vs. Pokemon or the combined worlds of DC, Marvel and Dark Horse comics.No shunning here! I love the Wheel of Time, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where casters are even more gonzo than they are in 3.x D&D. I love A Song of Ice and Fire, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where magic and monsters are so rare.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.
I had once thought of making a d20 modern game loosely based off Special Unit 7 tv show. It never progressed further than just a thought.

Fabius Maximus |

Turin the Mad wrote:What I would probably be shunned for: I do not care one whit for gaming in various movies/TV shows/comic book settings. Be it Star Trek, Star Wars, Dragonlance, Firefly, Buffy the Vampire Werehamster, Alien vs. Predator vs. Pokemon or the combined worlds of DC, Marvel and Dark Horse comics.No shunning here! I love the Wheel of Time, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where casters are even more gonzo than they are in 3.x D&D. I love A Song of Ice and Fire, but I wouldn't want to role play in a universe where magic and monsters are so rare.
In Martin's universe, human beings are the monsters.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.
Supernatural is the TV version of WoD's Hunter.

MrSin |

MrSin wrote:According to what some say about fighters, he's only 1/4 right ;)MagusJanus wrote:He's only 1/4 wrong?Kthulhu wrote:However, according to at least 2/3 of the posts I read on these boards, that's BADWRONGFUN!My fighter 3/commoner 1 would like to argue with them on that... ;)
Zero plus half of zero is zero still. Next thing you know you'll play rogues with the rumormonger talent!

Tequila Sunrise |

Tequila Sunrise wrote:Supernatural is the TV version of WoD's Hunter.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.
Does Hunter explain why everyone on the planet doesn't know about demons and monsters being real and hungry?

Drock11 |
While I'm immensely grateful for the modern fantasy genre he created and he hast to be given an immense amount of credit for it and the fictional setting he made I found Tolkien's actual writing to be not very good at all.
A similar statement can be said about George Lucas although I'm sure enough people probably agree with me about him that I wouldn't nearly get shunned by everybody in gaming. Lucas created one of the greatest fictional setting humanity has come up with with awesome aspects to it, but when it comes to things like dialog, characterization, or the minute things in writing that make artist great he leaves a lot to be desired. That is especially true after the prequels came out.
They both strike me as people that at their height would be fantastic in the creation of the broad strokes aspects when it comes to fiction and setting building, maybe the best, but shouldn't touch the actual important writing for it with a ten foot pole and leave that aspect to people much better than them.

Fabius Maximus |

Fabius Maximus wrote:Does Hunter explain why everyone on the planet doesn't know about demons and monsters being real and hungry?Tequila Sunrise wrote:Supernatural is the TV version of WoD's Hunter.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.
I'm certainly not an expert, but Hunter: The Vigil ties in with the rest of WoD's "settings". A lot of the monsters tend to have a high degree of organisation, like in Underworld (which basically is the movie adaption of WoD's Werewolf and Vampire settings). They also know that humans outnumber them and generally have access to superior firepower.

Lazurin Arborlon |

While I'm immensely grateful for the modern fantasy genre he created and he hast to be given an immense amount of credit for it and the fictional setting he made I found Tolkien's actual writing to be not very good at all.
A similar statement can be said about George Lucas although I'm sure enough people probably agree with me about him that I wouldn't nearly get shunned by everybody in gaming. Lucas created one of the greatest fictional setting humanity has come up with with awesome aspects to it, but when it comes to things like dialog, characterization, or the minute things in writing that make artist great he leaves a lot to be desired. That is especially true after the prequels came out.
They both strike me as people that at their height would be fantastic in the creation of the broad strokes aspects when it comes to fiction and setting building, maybe the best, but shouldn't touch the actual important writing for it with a ten foot pole and leave that aspect to people much better than them.
Just like Lovecraft above, this phenomena has a lot to do with the age and primacy of the work. For their time they were so immensely creative and ground breaking they transcended any technical and literary flaws allowing them to become classics on the weight of the concepts alone. They are all so brilliant and revolutionary to their genres in their broad strokes that the many, many weak details are by and large forgiven.

Cronatos |
Hmm... I like dubstep. How's that work? Not Skrillex-type stuff though. More Vexare.
Don't like dealing with animals IRL. Flat out, no exceptions, don't like. So long as I don't have to deal with them, though, all's good. Brazilian Harvestmen are cool.
I like building characters and make a lot that I never use (yeah, I doubt that counts)
I like building and playing tanky gishes.
I don't care for superhero stories. DC, Marvel or whatever. If there's an exception, I don't know it.
I'll throw my chip in with not liking alcohol.
I want a shapeshifting-focused class that is balanced with the 2/3rds casting classes and isn't a treehugger.
I mostly don't like the characters, stories, settings or humor of most anime, yet find most anime to be entertaining. I dunno.
I have a low tolerance for sausage. Continued exposure in small amounts seems to be helping, albeit slowly.
I've never played Risk and have no interest in doing so.
My favorite emoticon is :|
I don't like zombie-focused media.
I like stealth. I don't like sneak attack in both concept and mechanic.

Tequila Sunrise |

Don't like dealing with animals IRL. Flat out, no exceptions, don't like. So long as I don't have to deal with them, though, all's good. Brazilian Harvestmen are cool.
This would get you shunned where I grew up, but not so much in an urban environment, I think.
I don't care for superhero stories. DC, Marvel or whatever. If there's an exception, I don't know it.
Now this is pretty unusual. Is it just the stories, or the whole superhero thing? (For example, have you ever had a "Which superpower would you choose?" conversation?)
I'll throw my chip in with not liking alcohol.
Ditto. I've tried all the major drink groups, and they're all gross.
I've never played Risk and have no interest in doing so.
What, you don't want to roll [1-3]d6 over and over again for hours, even after everybody knows who's going to win? C'mon, there are exactly two winning strategies to learn!
(Only kind of serious here; I had lots of fun with Risk as a kid!)

Jaelithe |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I got a few:
- I can't effin' stand Doctor Who
- I prefer the old anthropomorphic super-hero Godzilla of the late 60's and early 70's to every other version
- I think "In the Pale Moonlight," an almost universally lauded episode of Deep Space Nine, was passable drama but absolutely terrible Star Trek
- I think Kathryn Janeway should have been court-martialed and cashiered from the service on her return to the Alpha Quadrant
- The modern version of Battlestar Galactica is wildly overrated
- JJ Abrams is a hack
- Firefly blew both Buffy and Angel away
And all that's just for starters.

DungeonmasterCal |

I hated The Belgariad series and by the time I got to the Serpent War series by Raymond E. Feist I had given up in disgust. "Rise of a Merchant Prince" was a lesson in economics and international trade, not a fantasy fiction book. I practically threw it at the drop off box of my local library in a drive by fashion just to get rid of it.

Ellis Mirari |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Tequila Sunrise wrote:I'm certainly not an expert, but Hunter: The Vigil ties in with the rest of WoD's "settings". A lot of the monsters tend to have a high degree of organisation, like in Underworld (which basically is the movie adaption of WoD's Werewolf and Vampire settings). They also know that humans outnumber them and generally have access to superior firepower.Fabius Maximus wrote:Does Hunter explain why everyone on the planet doesn't know about demons and monsters being real and hungry?Tequila Sunrise wrote:Supernatural is the TV version of WoD's Hunter.
I do occasionally fantasize about playing a game loosely based on a movie or show. Like watching Supernatural sometimes makes me wonder what it'd be like to role play a monster-hunter in the real world, with some kind of explanation for how the existence of all those monsters and demons isn't common knowledge.
Werewolves also aren't inherently evil in WoD *pushes thick glasses back up his nose*, they're written as a completely separate species that, mostly, is devoted to fighting evil spirits and creatures that they see as the "enemies of Gaia", which, of course, includes Vampires.
There are bad werewolves, not proportionally more so than there are bad humans.
I just recently got into WoD and let me tell you, it's a breath of fresh air after a life of playing just DnD.

MMCJawa |

I hated The Belgariad series and by the time I got to the Serpent War series by Raymond E. Feist I had given up in disgust. "Rise of a Merchant Prince" was a lesson in economics and international trade, not a fantasy fiction book. I practically threw it at the drop off box of my local library in a drive by fashion just to get rid of it.
Here here...although I think I only really disliked the Belgariad after reading it's sequel and the other two part series the author did.

Tequila Sunrise |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Tequila Sunrise wrote:This mad me laugh. Although I think you are more likely to be shunned for liking alcohol.Cronatos wrote:I'll throw my chip in with not liking alcohol.Ditto. I've tried all the major drink groups, and they're all gross.
A guy named Tequila doesn't like alcohol?
I know, weird, right? For a long time, I thought that Tequila Sunrise was just an Eagles song. Hence my internet handle. ;)

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Pan wrote:Tequila Sunrise wrote:This mad me laugh. Although I think you are more likely to be shunned for liking alcohol.Cronatos wrote:I'll throw my chip in with not liking alcohol.Ditto. I've tried all the major drink groups, and they're all gross.
Detect Magic wrote:A guy named Tequila doesn't like alcohol?I know, weird, right? For a long time, I thought that Tequila Sunrise was just an Eagles song. Hence my internet handle. ;)
"Hey man can you turn that down? Its been a long day and I hate the ..... Eagles!!"

![]() |
Werewolves also aren't inherently evil in WoD *pushes thick glasses back up his nose*, they're written as a completely separate species that, mostly, is devoted to fighting evil spirits and creatures that they see as the "enemies of Gaia", which, of course, includes Vampires.
It's not so much "Good" or "Evil" that is the main focus in Storyteller. Nor are the heroes and villains that clear cut. The Garou are Gaia's champions, but on the other hand they've made some very bad mistakes such as trying to exterminate all of the other shapeshifting breeds for no particular reason I can fathom. While others such as the Silver Fang have let the prejudices of their native lands influence their ethics.