| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Finally, a list with my item on it (without asterisk too!) - whoo hoo.
Thanks for posting this list.
Having some experience of bb tags (see the archetype list), I know big posts like this can be painful.
So I do very much appreciate this indeed.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Nice one Eric. Epic indeed. I see a bunch I had forgotten about but enjoyed, and a few that I saw that may have been culled. Very interesting list. Well done all who took part in RPGSS 2013 by submitting an item, and well done to the voters and judges!
Eric, how many are on your list?
And Wow, you found a way to spend your 1 minute waiting period between each vote.
The only time I saw my item was post cull. Interesting that you never saw it post-cull (if I am reading the thread right).
Many props to Meepo!
Well done sir.
Fantastic and thank you so much for taking the time to post this! Since I didn't take great notes, this is helping jog my memory on items I know I liked.
Haha I made it past the cull. Well at least that's something. First time I've even seen my item mentioned too.
Thanks, Eric!!! I've been wondering if my item was in there. I'm relieved to know that it was (and that it didn't get culled).
I never saw it, and an extremely similar item made it into the top 32, so I kept thinking maybe I forgot to fill out the subject line of my submission.
I didn't even make the top 89, but I'm glad my item at least had the chance to compete.
Sincere thanks for compiling this list. That's a lot of work. Much appreciated! :)
Dedicated Voter Season 6, Marathon Voter Season 7, Dedicated Voter Season 8
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Thanks Eric! Your dedication was never in doubt, but this is pretty spectacular.
I count 810 on this list. I've copy/pasted it to a googledoc document. If anyone knows of any that aren't on this list, I'd love to add them to see just how complete a list we can get.
Thanks Eric! This is absolutely marvelous. I also kept an alphabetical list. Most of the ones I found in mine but not yours are pre-cull, which makes a certain amount of sense.
Anyways: the following items can be added. (no * means it was seen post-cull)
Amulet of the Whispering Woods*
Anonymous Cloak
Bloody Bestiary
Book of Infinite Smells*
Bracelet of Absorption*
Chatter Rocks*
Circlet of Precognition*
Cloak of Necromancy*
Conrad's Dancing Teeth*
Crown of the Soulbound Usurper*
Cygwin's Clever Cincture*
Deathwatcher's Blessing*
Favor of the Goddess Charm*
Fleshmask of Hemotheurgy*
Instant Pit*
Jar of Thoughts*
Mask of Machismo*
Mask of Wraith's Deceit*
Mosquito Swarm*
Nimble Finger's Needle*
Nimel's Elemental Exchanger*
Pom's Periapt of Pan-Planar Pilotage*
Portable Window*
Relic of Mortus Dissimulo*
Replenishing Quiver*
Ritual Blade and Bowl of Zon-Kuthon's Transformation*
Robe of Robing*
Room-Ex Cube of Wonder*
Spellbook of the Arcane Apprentice*
Sphere of Capture*
Storm-bound Pouch of Cutting Winds*
The Gambler's Card*
The Pillars Dexter*
Timepiece of Stolen Moments*
Tome of Heritage*
Whisper Pebble*
Wey Stone*
The following items can have their * removed
The Bully Pulpit of the Reluctant Martyr
Elixir of Last Will
Saddle of the Chevalier
Shadow Sentry
The following items are misspelled in some way. (This is a ridiculously nitpicky thing; heck, I had several items misspelled or unalphabetized in my own list, so I'm not trying to claim King of Grammar Superiority by any means.)
Arc Light of Spectral Reclusion
Chrono Baton
Hunter's Geas
Rat-Tread Boots
Siegebreaker Cymbals
Vrolikai Hide Belt Sheath
Lastly, there was one item with two iterations of the same name that people were talking about on the boards. I never saw such a case; anyone remember what was being referred to?
Wow. What a list. Glad to see my item wasn't culled, but didn't make the top 89 (from another thread). I wrote the fleshwarping unguent.
Thanks Eric! Your dedication was never in doubt, but this is pretty spectacular.
I count 810 on this list. I've copy/pasted it to a googledoc document. If anyone knows of any that aren't on this list, I'd love to add them to see just how complete a list we can get.
A couple of missing items:
Jeopardy Sensing Goggles
Rose of Midnight
(Also, "rat-treat boots" should be rat-tread, unless there's an item I don't know about.)
Woohoo my item was actually seen. I was worried since I never saw it...and it wasn't culled....but still a failure Que Sera Sera.
|
Dedicated Voter Season 6, Marathon Voter Season 7, Dedicated Voter Season 8
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Woohoo my item was actually seen. I was worried since I never saw it...and it wasn't culled....but still a failure Que Sera Sera.
havoc xiii, your item was NOT a failure. By submitting, you most likely battled and triumped over demons of self doubt, time thieves, and holiday madness. Just by submitting your item, you pushed it past the failure mark. Further, if it wasn't culled, that means you were in the TOP 75% of the entrants. That isn't failure; that is progress. Next year awaits.
Hm, so I made it past the cull but not as far as the top 89. I guess that makes my score 6 out of 6 for not getting through. Ah well, thanks - I'm glad someone saw it.
RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32
,
Champion Voter Season 6, Champion Voter Season 7, Champion Voter Season 8, Champion Voter Season 9
|
Thanks Eric! This is absolutely marvelous. I also kept an alphabetical list. Most of the ones I found in mine but not yours are pre-cull, which makes a certain amount of sense.
1 item on your list was over word count and disappeared after being reported.
Thanks Eric!
Yep it's good to see my item in a list...even if it is just an alphabetical list of items seen! :)
Friday, ya'll get to critique my boring as dirt intellectual's clay pipe
Impressive organization and dedication to the Superstar process!
I knew my item - the mantle of terror - made the cull but not the Top 89. I'm pretty sure it was too niche and not very attention-getting in what it did. Ah well, that's what the Critique My Item thread is for.
Looks like it's time to start on my next Wayfinder submission!
Finally, a list with my item on it (without asterisk too!) - whoo hoo.
Thanks for posting this list.
Having some experience of bb tags (see the archetype list), I know big posts like this can be painful.
So I do very much appreciate this indeed.
My thoughts exactly.
Dude, you are a rock star for making this list.
Glad to see that my tesseract dust was seen by at least a few people.
Nice work.
Here are the additions from my list that I haven't seen mentioned on this thread yet. (If I'm doubling any through sloppy reading, sorry. Also, I don't have more than a vague idea of what pre-and-post cull items are; I'd pretty much need to check for each individual one, so will pass on that for the moment.)
amulet of recovered time
appendage of autonomy
assassin's bandoleer
assassin's cloak
book of weapon holding
boots of prodigious leaping
bracers of rotation
brain bowl
chalice of divine resilience
crossroads talisman
crystal of wondrous power
deslina's dreaming tree
drinking horn of true alignment
earrings of whispers
Farouq's lamp
headband of fearlessness
hemotheurgic attuner
mantle of solitude
mantle of the berserker
master's tool kit
metamagic splitter
moebius strip
necklace of knock
nethian scroll tube
pillow of restfulness
radioactive sludge
ribbon of meritorious conduct
sash of competency
scales of life and death
scroll case of inscribing
slippers of dancing
stone of penumbral corruption
tabard of the watchmen
THE onesie
torc of shadow
torc of Trollheim
weirdavian
whispers of Cassandra
handy handkerchief *
Ouch!
*palm slaps face*
I guess that's my fault for putting my item submission together at the last moment. I had been thinging about it since early December...but forgot about the contest until that day around noon central time.
Oh well...
=/
Star Voter Season 6, Dedicated Voter Season 7
|
Okay, now I wish I had made a spread sheet list, because I feel utterly, and completely, out classed and out geeked here.
;)
But I am impressed! And it's good to know my item made it past the culling! (I don't think my item did last year, so YAY! I'm improving!)
|
RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32
,
Champion Voter Season 6, Champion Voter Season 7, Champion Voter Season 8, Champion Voter Season 9
|
Well glad to see it mentioned at least. I made the bracers of tempered wrath. I think I should avoid messing with immediate actions, and I guess add more description or something.
I voted for these pretty often. The immediate action wasn't the problem. Critque thread opens tomorrow.
|
Well glad to see it mentioned at least. I made the bracers of tempered wrath. I think I should avoid messing with immediate actions, and I guess add more description or something.I voted for these pretty often. The immediate action wasn't the problem. Critque thread opens tomorrow.
Sorry bout that didn't mean to do that. Just first time I have posted on my item, and first time I saw it mentioned.
Yay. A list with my item on it (Cloak of Rest). Sadly while it made the cull, I don't think it was pop-out good enough and too ordinary perhaps. Oh well. Thanx for the list!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
My favorite pairing:
abadar’s change purse vs abadar’s portable moneychanger
same idea voted for the slightly better execution.
I recognize one in Sean's list that was DQ'd. It was over word count but man, was it ever memorable. I wish I'd made a copy.
|
RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32
,
Champion Voter Season 6, Champion Voter Season 7, Champion Voter Season 8, Champion Voter Season 9
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
My favorite pairing:
abadar’s change purse vs abadar’s portable moneychanger
same idea voted for the slightly better execution.
I had that pairing once, was an easy choice. I liked one and disliked the other.
Eric, Verdigris, and Sean,
You folks are the absolute best. I really can't say that enough. It's awesome to know I wasn't DQ'd and made it past the cull, since I never saw my Sash of Singularity. A load off of my mind.
Thank you so much.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Eric, Verdigris, and Sean,
You folks are the absolute best. I really can't say that enough. It's awesome to know I wasn't DQ'd and made it past the cull, since I never saw my Sash of Singularity. A load off of my mind.
Thank you so much.
Hey, don't forget to include Thunderbuckets in your list of "Anal-retentive RPGSS '13 chroniclers deserving of praise".
And, for what it's worth, I personally liked your sash a good deal. I'll save further commentary for the critique thread, should I see it among the madness...
RPG Superstar 2012 Top 16
,
Marathon Voter Season 6, Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8, Star Voter Season 9
aka Locke1520
|
I thought of another one that I saw Before the cull and never after:
The Onesie (sp?)
**edit** if you wrote this one or happened to save a copy of it please PM me...nobody I know has seen it and I want to make sure I wasn't delirious from too much voting. ;D