@Skystarlit1, Oh mind, you said it Skystarlit1. Those are the points that have us all unhappy.
On point 2. I'm playing in 5ed right now. The limit on the difference between someone trained in a skill and someone who is not, feels very unrealistic.
On point 6. I want to compare Skyrim and Dragon Age. Both are great RPGs, but you know why people still play Skyrim years later? (Other then mods)
It makes the story and your character come alive! Cos whatever you do, you earn it in someway. It becomes a living game, not just a number cruncher. Should a game give some reward for a character's backstory? Yes
Once something is a game mechanic, people will compare them. Guides and players would start picking 1 over another for their game benefits.
Br11741 wrote: I’m not talking about a GM rolling behind a screen, I’m talking about a GM rolling for the player. Skill check that have the Secret Trait are rolled by the GM not the player. Solution: Have the player roll for it, then before the dice stop rolling, cover it with the GM screen and only the GM gets to see the results.So now, the player gets to roll and the GM gets to play out the results.
@Kondenado, as a metric system user, I have to agree with John Lynch 106.
Metric is really good in real life, but remember its origin. It came about after a large number of countries decided to standardise units of measurement. To help improve trade, makes life easier for everyone and basically be less confusing. Since Golarion only uses 1 common system (as far as we know). There isn't a need to have metrics, as everyone is using that one system.
The more science-based Starfinder on the other hand... lol...
Iomedae protects! Just finished playing a great 10-11 tier Core game with my Cleric of Iomedae and it was... great! In the last fights, I was using Glory Domain's Divine Presence (Su) every turn to rob the enemies of the chance to hurt my party. In classic PFS, the Glory domain is hardly pick by anyone. And if they do, they would often pick the heroic subdomain instead, thanks to the heroism aura. There are just so many other better options for most clerics to pick from. But here in Core games, the Glory domain really shines! And its helped by the whole party winning initiative. (Improve Initiative is also very popular here in Core games. Feats that people usually couldn't be bother with in Classic.) I just had to delay till after my party had made their attacks, before throwing up Divine Presence and seeing the enemies struggle to even land hits on my party. I'm not even a caster cleric with a way high wis to boot! But a melee combat cleric with 20 str. Love the fact that in Core the party actually works better together. We have to rely more on each other to succeed!
Varun Creed wrote:
I really like this proposal. It reminds me of how the over use of magic is handled in some fantasy settings. For example, in the circle of magic books, magical healing gets harder on a person who have received too much magical healing. The mage describes it in-world as the lingering older healing spells are fighting the fresher newer healing spells. Pathfinder 2 needs to stop looking at the system purely from a mechanical or math only view and focus too on the flavor and in-world setting.
Otherwise PF2 would be no different from 4ed D&D, where the math and need to balance everything was made to the point that the game resembles a very stale CRPG instead. Turn away the very people that come to Pathfinder. Really hope that the designers are taking our words to heart. We are not posting to spite Pathfinder 2.0. A new system is great! Especially after so many years of material build up in PF1.0. We are posting, cos we really care about Pathfinder and want PF2.0 to be great and fun to play in.
Corrik wrote:
This is a good example of why Resonance(RP) just seems odd. Its purely mechanical and don't make sense from a roleplay point of view. How is Resonance even explained in-world? That's something that really needs to be thought out first.
@wraithstrike, Your break down of FoM is correct. Once you have FoM on, the vast majority of movement restricting effects would just fail on you. Even something like Tanglefoot bag would fail. Its kinda covered in by FoM spell description. @DeathlessOne,
A clever Spellcaster can dispel or better yet switch to using the environment against a target under the effects of FoM.
For martial characters, stop trying to grapple or restrict someone under FoM, just beat the target up! FoM don't protect a target from damage or attack of opportunities.
Groin Greenleaf, The Fire Opal Sage: Alignment: Neutral Good Race: Elf Class: Gunslinger 1 / Alchemist 7 Description: Groin, also known as Groin the Beardy Elf is the adopted son of a loving Elf-Dwarf couple. He and his brother Gloin were named after two famous dwarf heroes on the dwarven side of the family. Groin grow up knowing he wanted to be a WIZARD! when he saw the fireworks the local sage threw up for the town. When he was found lacking the magical skills for wizardry, he decided he will find a way to make things go boom, with or without magic. Joining the Pathfinder society with his adopted dwarf brother, he soon found that he has an aptitude for explosives and making things go boom! or choke or snared in goo, it was all good fun. When the Scarab Sages was formed, Groin decided to take part. Knowing his skills will be of much use when breaking into long forgotten tombs and he maybe a thing or two about magic. Groin confess he never did thought of becoming a sage, but now that he has reach this milestone in life, he believe its time to start looking for a nice Dwarf to settle down with. *Groin Greenleaf is my very first PFS character and first started play in August 2012. Groin's and his dwarf brother Gloin where named after 2 of the dwarfs in the Hobbit. I'm very happy to play him on and off throughout the years and reaching this capstone.
AoN for information on a source, feat, spell etc. Also for making any PFS character d20pfsrd for game rules and quicker GMing (since creature abilities are usually linked to their rules.) To be very honest, if it wasn't for both of these sites, I and likely many in my local PF community would have quit PF a long time ago. NO ONE wants to have to dig through 3 dozen+ books to make a character. AoN and d20pfsrd, keep it up!
Advanced Player's Guide pg. 213 wrote:
The hole/pit is 10 feet by 10 feet, aka 2x2 squares. If a creature ends its turn on a square adjacent to the pit, they risk falling in. You are confusing the adjacent squares (aka the squares around the 2x2 pit) with the size of the pit.Pit = 10 feet x 10 feet, aka 2x2 sqaures Square adjacent to the pit = any square adjacent to the 2x2 pit
Gisher wrote:
Thanks for pointing that out. I will pick up the fox shape feat, later down the line. And maybe select a Cha based discipline instead. So any advice on feats and discipline?
In many recent PFS games, it is becoming overwhelmingly clear that Str is effectively useless as an ability score. As Dex builds are simply equal to or way better then any Str build. There are now many ways to use Dex for attacking and melee damage. Not to mention that many of these Dex builds benefit from an increase in the attacks of opportunity they have via Combat Reflexes.
With so many options leaning heavily towards Dex, why even brother with making any Str-based character at all? Is the Pathfinder system even doing anything to balance this? Strength
Dexterity
Just looking at the pros of each ability score and its clear Dex clearly leads in almost every way.
Just a quick re-post of a previous reply of mine to this same topic.
ALL archers (fighters, rangers, slayers, zen archers, etc) are POWERFUL damage dealers. It really is more about what you want out of your archer. Fighters - More consistent damage output, just pure damage
Ranger - More than just damage
Slayer - Ranger with no spells, but more damage output
Zen Archer (Monk) - A LOT of arrows in the air!
As you can see archery comes in every flavor. There are very few cons, it REALLY is just what YOU want!
I just realize that selling back stuff in SF is only 10% of the purchase price. Instead of 50% in PFS. With no way to upgrade equipment in SFS, is the 10% sell back for equipment really viable in SFS? I'm asking this, as this whole buy at 100%, sell at 10% system, just seems to encourage players to save on money, by holding back on buying anything till later, when better equipment is available. Riding on the efforts (and purchases) of other players to complete missions instead. Whats the point of getting a lv 4 armor, when you know you could save money by holding out and get the much better lv 7 armor version instead? Anyone who actively upgrade their weapon and armor as they level, will have a lot less wealth per level, over someone that don't buy till later levels. It just seems like the weirdest way to discourage people from being actively useful to a party. *One item that can be upgraded is the personal implant. Why can't that be the same for the other equipment?
Joshua Sutton wrote: I'm looking for advice on my build. I would like to optimize my hit and then damage as much as possible, even though the Archer archetype was used for roleplaying purposes. If you wish to optimize attack and damage, don't use the Archer archetype. Go straight up fighter. Why? Cos the Archer archetype losses access to the Gloves of Dueling These wonderful gloves -
2) Prevents you from losing or dropping your bow, which is death sentence in combat for an archer. 3) Give you A LOT more out of the Advanced Weapon Training options. Archer's Expert Archer (Ex) does not work with Gloves of Dueling (as per the faq) Also the normal fighter can wear up to heavy armor and still be an archer. If you are playing a homebrew and your GM allows Gloves of Dueling to work with the Archer Archetype, then go with the Archer. Otherwise a normal fighter would make you a more damaging and tanker character.
I'm asking this cos firstly, the Harrow Deck(all versions) is out of print on Paizo's store (as far as googling goes).
Not only must you own the Inner Sea World Guide book/pdf, you must own an out-of-print product to make use of archetype. Secondly, while there seems to be a couple of copies available else where online, the shipping (to my county) + product cost is way too expensive for a single archetype's ability. It feels like a uncalled for tax to players who already own the Inner Sea World Guide to hunt down an out of print product like the harrow deck. The AA after all keeps pointing out that "The Harrow deck may be used if it is an actual Harrow deck. Any alternative means to simulate the Harrow deck usage, such as a normal deck of cards or dice, is not legal" More worryingly! I want to point out that some of these 3rd party sources of the Harrow Deck has forced the prices way high for a copy.
That's $45.00 vs $15.99 for the original.
I hope that the Varisian Pilgrim archetype and the Harrow Deck as a requirement for play, can be looked into, so as to give players a fair use of Harrow Deck affected archetypes, abilities etc. Finally, for the Inner Sea World Guide's cleric archetype - Varisian Pilgrim, it says in the additional resources... Additional Resources wrote: Upon gaining 8th level, the Varisian Pilgrim may gain the 8th-level ability Blessing of the Harrow as long as the player possesses a Harrow deck. Since this ability is a MAY gain. Does this means that if I got the PDF for inner sea world guide, but can't afford to get an actual real life harrow deck, my character can ignore the Varisian Pilgrim's lv 8 Blessing of the Harrow and have 2 normal domains instead? (Blessing of the Harrow usually replaces one lv 8 domain power.)Varisian Pilgrim wrote: Blessing of the Harrow (Su): At 8th level, once per day the pilgrim may perform a harrowing for herself or another creature. This is otherwise identical to the blessing of the harrow from the harrower prestige class (Inner Sea World Guide 276). This replaces an 8th-level domain power of the Varisian pilgrim’s choice.
ALL archers (fighters, rangers, slayers, zen archers, etc) are POWERFUL damage dealers. It really is more about what you want out of your archer. Fighters - More consistent damage output, just pure damage
Ranger - More than just damage
Slayer - Ranger with no spells, but more damage output
Zen Archer (Monk) - A LOT of arrows in the air!
As you can see archery comes in every flavor. There are very few cons, it REALLY is just what YOU want!
Dave Justus wrote:
I'm playing an Eagle Shaman in PFS, and this FAQ is pretty significant. Since most of my wildshaping would be a flying eagle or Roc, I needed a good dex score to make the most of the fly skill.I was working under the understanding that Wild armor being an expensive +3 armor special property would not have a penalty to my Max dex and armor check penalty. Now this FAQ just grounded my character... The irony is I would be expecting to cast Fly on my eagle or Roc wildshape just to have a good fly skill.
I have to note that in a homebrew, where spells like ironwood can be make perm, it won't be that big of a deal to druids, as they don't have to pick up Wild armor to have a good AC score.
With the new errata, the Occultist archetype is really too weak to work properly. I feel thew new errata is overkill on the Cha requirements. It seems a heavy handed approach to making the Arcanist more "sorcerer", whereas pre-errata, the arcanist was decidedly more wizard in feel.
The sad thing is that it really affects the Occultist archetype badly, whereas in the past, you need to give up your spells to fuel the summon monster ability, now you can't even do that without giving up your strongest spells, which scales badly. I may just take a plunge into the cheese pool that is Occult Adventures and make a psychic character instead for this character.
Is the Occultist archetype for the arcanist worth getting? It looks really cool to be able to summon 1 monster as a standard action, but the cost to actually use it seems to increase exponentially, when compared to the amount of arcane reservoir points the arcanist gets per day. The archetype also lacks any feat support. Lastly, does feats like summon good monsters or summon neutral monsters work with the occultist or summoner's summon monster (sp)?
ranmyaku262 wrote:
Your build assumes you are not locked down by spells or otherwise unable to act. If so, why not try the hp tanking Paladin? Race - Tiefling Feats:
Favored class - Paladin Tiefling - +1 hp healed when lay on hand on self. Items - Inheritor's Light - Any cure spells or lay on hands effects used to heal the wielder of this blade heal an additional 1 point of damage per die, up to the effect’s normal maximum healing amount. Bracers of the Merciful Knight - When worn by a paladin, he is considered four levels higher for the purposes of determining the uses per day and healing provided by his lay on hands class feature. With this setup at lv 6 you can heal 6d6 + 24hp each turn.
Really like this character. It is very refreshing to have an iconic adventurer whose family and life is not all dead or tragic. That she becomes an adventurer because she wants to, with fate only aiding her on that path. With no dark secrets, traumatizing monsters or deaths. For the record, my indian colleague saw Rivani's artwork and said that her outfit make sense from an indian inspired view and that's a big plus!
Bioboygamer wrote:
A Portable Hole is clearly meant to be used in combination with a Bag of Holding as a tactical weapon. Combined they are effectively a "BABY NUKE" By placing a Portable Hole inside a Bag of Holding, you get the equivalent of a 10-foot radius portable nuke that can remove most creatures from play by throwing them into the Astral Plane (hopefully permanently) Together they are greater than the sum of their parts. While there are more powerful (and expensive) options to remove creatures from play. A Portable Hole + Bag of Holding is one of the cheapest known permanent removal weapons available for adventurers.
So, what happens if you gain immunity to an ongoing condition? And lose the immunity later? What happens then? Basic Question: How does immunity interact with ongoing conditions? Does it cure or suppress these conditions? Example, you gain Poison or Disease Immunity -
And if you lose the immunity to Poison or Disease -
Example 2, you are paralysed, then gain immunity to being paralyze -
And if you lose the immunity to being paralyze -
Any clarification would be welcome.
1) Take a lv of Gunslinger. *Edit: Grow a beard, you will look more serious. 2) Have 3 daughters (Adopt if necessary) 3) Marry each daughter to the ruler of A, B and C respectively. 4) Invite all 3 of your now son-in-laws back home for a family dinner. 5) Sit at the dinner table with your Double-barreled musket on your lap. 6) Get them to start talking to each other. 7) Peace Edit: Oh and remember to get them grant you a suitable title like "Grandfather of the New Nation" or something similar. EDIT 2: On 2nd thought, it may be better to pull this off as the MOTHER-IN-LAW. It can generate more fear/respect from your son-in-laws. Remember! If you do go with MOTHER-IN-LAW, you could always threaten to "MOVE IN" with any of them... ...to help them keep the peace... with a musket... *Oh! And remember to start talking about grand kids. Nothing sinks the warmongering ways of a warlord faster then his MOTHER-IN-LAW breathing down his neck over having grandkids.
The Tetori Monk archetype is what you are looking for. You will be able to grapple targets that are usually unable to grapple at higher levels. With access to most of the required feats.
felinoel wrote:
@felinoel, did you cast the fly spell on yourself? Or did the GM forced it upon you? If you prepared and choose to cast fly on yourself, shouldn't you have the responsibility to read up on the spell and how flying works? And yes the GM could have reminded you, but you should not expect it from every GM. Even more so if your in PFS and playing a lv 5+ character.
Jeremy Coppersmith wrote: Also what hard copy/PDFs will I need to get in order to play a Tengu monk with archetypes and exotic weapons. (Include anything I will need to play in general) I would suggest looking up a site like www.archivesofnethys.com The archives lists the source book (and page) for all the resources/spells/feat/class etc. By cross referencing your character's feats/class/etc, you can have a good ideal which books/pfs you need for your character. This would save you a money, as you can just buy what you need for your character. In addition, the archives kindly labelled what is PFS legal with a PFS logo. (You would still want to double check the additional resources page, as the Archives does not differential between races/class/etc that require a boon to unlock and those that always accessible. *I'm suggesting www.archivesofnethys.com instead of www.d20pfsrd.com, as the d20pfsrd often renames materials, which can be very confusing for players and GMs.
Breakdown of grappling a Target - Round 1) You: You grapple Target successfully Target: Tries to break free and fails or does not try to break free and decides to hit you instead OR enjoys being grappled by you and ask you to continue doing so. Round 2) You: Maintain your grapple with a +5 circumstance bonus on the grapple check. If you succeed you can perform one of the actions listed under the grapple rules. Target: 1.- Tries to break free again and fails or does not try to break free at all = you continue to enjoy the +5 circumstance bonus on following checks
---------- Alternative flow of events: Round 1) Target: Goes first You: You grapple Target successfully Round 2) Target: Tries to break free and fails or does not try to break free and decides to hit you instead OR enjoys being grappled by you and ask you to continue doing so. You: Maintain your grapple with a +5 circumstance bonus on the grapple check. If you succeed you can perform one of the actions listed under the grapple rules. ------- Hope this clears it up!
Remember that while under the effect of "Panicked" you must flee from the source of fear. Logically this means once you have actually fled from the source of your fear and are effectively out of sight, some distance away and no longer able to determine where the source of fear is, you could stop and cast remove fear on yourself. So while "fleeing" you cannot do anything else other then flee or use any means to flee including magical/item bases options, but once you have "fled", you can stop and cast spells to remove the condition on yourself.
Ravingdork wrote: I have an imp familiar who disguises himself as a cat. How do I protect him from divinations that might reveal his true nature... There is ANOTHER way other then disguise to get your party to accept an imp familiar. (!)Note(!) - This is pretty intense way to RP, Please do not do the following if you or your party are in anyway uncomfortable with such RP.
Method: Redirect any hatred of your imp to yourself. Make the party sympathize with your pet instead. How?
2) RP your Imp
3) Offer to kill off your Imp, is any party member is upset with an Imp in party.
4) Make the Imp the party's pet. Imp helps party.
Conclusion: Tuck at the hearts of your party mates to have them sympathize, care and love the Imp. WARNING: Again don't do this if your party or you are uncomfortable with such evil RP. It is really more for a BBEG type PC. WARNING2 (evil parties): If your party are murderous kill-them-alls, the method above will not work. The party needs to have hearts and feelings.
Chess Pwn wrote:
2nd this. One very important thing to remember is that at mid to high levels, the party will start facing enemies that can do ability score damage and drain. The above classes are the ones that can repair such damage. With the inclusion of domain spells and abilities, clerics can fulfill any number of roles in a party.
Kadasbrass Loreweaver wrote:
I think this is a brilliant ideal on his part. I makes lots of sense and I'm kinda surprise that other parties did not think of doing so. Should you encounter this again, I would suggest letting the 2 HA help out the npcs, aka giving the party a couple more rounds to solve the encounter. |