| Mathmuse |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The title of this thread comes from a song I am the Very Model of a Modern Major-General sung by Major-General Stanley in Gilbert and Sullivan's operetta The Pirates of Penzance, in which Stanley boasts of his extensive education. The song is comic because his knowledge has a breadth of classic and scientific topics, but nothing on weapons, armies, or warfare.
The thread After Impossible Magic, what other caster options are you yearning for? drifted to the topic of how to improve the Remastered PF2 wizard, which most people agree has become one of the weakest classes in PF2. This lead to the following posts:
Theaitetos wrote:This is a good call, but please note that I cannot do this! If you want to move a conversation to another thread, you just have to make another thread and continue the conversation there. I can't move comments. I can only move whole threads.No, WotC made the Wizard a King Caster.
And I repeat my call to have the perpetual Wizard debate moved to another thread; it's suffocating everything else this thread was originally about.
This is the new thread for continuing the conversation about improving the wizard class.
The PF2 wizard is the design descendant of the original Dungeons & Dragons magic-user. The class claimed the name "wizard" in Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition, but players had been thinking of it as a wizard before that. This means wizard class has a long legacy and any changes have to struggle against the expectations of its previous designs. In addition we have old folklore and new fiction about wizards adding more expectations, yet those wizards are all different from each other.
| PossibleCabbage |
| 8 people marked this as a favorite. |
Class niches need to be smaller than "I am the best at fighting" or "I am the best at doing damage." Since like a fighter is the best at accurately hitting people with weapons, but doesn't have the defense of a Champion or the damage potential of a Barbarian, or the action economy and mobility of a Monk.
So I think "the Wizard is the best at magic and should be King Caster" is wrong-headed and doesn't belong in the game. Obviously there should be something that Wizards are better at than anybody else, and that can't just be "they have access to the Arcane list, which is strong" since Witches and Sorcerers get that too and other stuff.
| Perpdepog |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I'm not sure if this thread is intended to be about what we'd like to see in this edition's wizard via new feats or archetypes, or about our wishes for a hypothetical Unchained/3E wizard, so I'm going to lean on the latter and just talk a bit about what I'd like to see the wizard be.
For one thing, I actually like the wizard's niche of having spells all day, every day, and not frequently running out of gas. I know the sorcerer has that as well, but wizard has feats that give them scrolls, or lets them play a minigame of trying to chain slots down their list to keep getting Drain Bonded Item to trigger feel more wizardly to me. Honestly the idea of wizard feats opening up a few minigames is just something I find cool overall. I also like the idea someone else mentioned, I think it was QuidEst, of wizards getting more feats that don't expressly force you to use a particular flavor of magic, but reward you for doing so.
Actually, that brings me to the one big thing I'd like to see changed in a hypothetical future wizard: I want to see their restrictions become rewards. It's something I've talked about before, most recently with the magus and how Arcane Cascade got reframed to grant extra benefits through feats rather than being a requirement. That kind of design makes classes feel better in play because finding synergies, even if they're obvious ones, feels good. It makes players feel like they've got control over their character rather than being forced in a particular direction because the game said so.
A good example of what I mean are the school spells. I'd really love to see a future wizard offer some kind of benefit for casting those spells, or maybe categories of spell, rather than having special slots that can only cast those spells. Perhaps it could be a connection between their Arcane School and Arcane Thesis which, while both very flavorful and cool, feel rather siloed off from one another. As a spitball, maybe the Spell Substitution thesis provides a faster spell slot conversion time when you are swapping in one of your school's spells, or the familiar thesis allows you to cast your school spells from your familiar's location rather than your own. Features like that, features that give incentives to use the limited spells from your school rather than just appending them to your spell slots are something I'd really like to see.
| WWHsmackdown |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
The best at the intersection of academia and magic would be my preferred wizard.
Feats for bonuses or action compressions when casting curriculum spells. Multiple feats revolving around lores and recall knowledge checks. In chassis reductions to learn a spell costs. 4 slots free and clear with curriculum spells being free spells known. Free lores based on your curriculum. Spell substitution in chassis if swapping to curriculum spells.
That kind of stuff would be dope for wizard.
| exequiel759 |
I'd also talk about what I would want to see with an unchained wizard in PF2e. I think its impossible to know what's going to happen with the wizard in a future edition, more so when I expect vancian to not exist in this hypothetical edition but we don't know the replacement for that yet.
I think most arcane thesis have to become baseline options. Experimental Spellshaping has to become a Combat Flexibility-like feature (You gain a spellshape feat at 1st level. Then a second spellshape at 9th, and finally a third spellshape at 15th. You can change them during your daily preparations). IMO Improved Familiar Attunement is mostly a trap option and kinda redudant with the witch, so I'd remove it or just grant all the familiar improvement feats to the wizard instead. Staff Nexus IMO is kinda of a trap as well. I'd make this just a feat option for all wizards (the class needs better feats anyways).
The only thesis I'm having doubts about is spell blending. I wouldn't make it so you have to choose between spell blending and spell substitution because I find the latter to be really fitting of the wizard's identity, but having both spell blending and spell substitution feels like it bloats the class a bit too much in the early levels.
I'd also want to remove arcane schools and just make the wizard a 4 slot caster, but there's like a bazillion arcane schools and I doubt Paizo is going to willingly throw all of them into the thrash bin (even though I'd argue they should). The class also needs better feats ASAP. This is arguably what the class needs the most.
| Teridax |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Part of the underlying problem I think is that the term "Wizard" can mean very different things to different people, in large part because the Wizard's identity has historically been so focused on spellcasting supremacy that taking that away leaves the class without a strong identity. With that said, though, I don't think that has to always be the case: as others mention, Wizards are studious characters by nature, and that I think could reflect itself in exceptional Lore access and ability to Recall Knowledge. Wizards study the rules of magic, and thus in my opinion should be able to play with the rules of spellcasting in ways other classes cannot: this is something arcane theses do currently, albeit timidly and not always very well. Similarly, the ability to modify magic could apply directly to spells via spellshapes, of which the Wizard could have many more. All of these individually are components to the class that I think could be implemented in 2e via a rework to their features and the addition of feats, though whether we ever get a Wizard Unchained is anyone's guess.
In a future 3e, I feel there would be even more room to differentiate the Wizard from other casters if there is a larger overhaul to spellcasting: spellcasting, in my opinion, shouldn't rely on daily spell slots by default in a future edition, and most casters I think ought to work like spontaneous casters, if only because that model tends to make individual spells feel like a closer and more permanent part of a character. In this environment, a Wizard class that had the unique ability to prepare new spells would shine through their adaptability and versatility.
| Theaitetos |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The Wizard, and frankly all classes, should get a 1st-level feat slot to begin with. Then add some good 1st-level feats like the Oracle, grant a feat with every school/thesis and go to town.
The Wizard also needs more in the class chassis itself, not just feats to choose from. Stuff like Recall Knowledge abilities, especially around a "lore thesis" or something like that.
Maybe an ability like the Investigator's Devise a Stratagem but for spells or the ability to add a "spell catalyst"/something anathema to the creature (as in the Banishment spell) to make better use of a spell depending upon the degree of success of the RK check. This allows better preparation even before encounters, instead of just spell preparations.
There are also a lot of magic items/consumables that could fit into some theses, that Wizards might be able to use easier or more often.
In general, why not just steal good ideas from other classes and adapt them to Wizard magic?
| gesalt |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
What would I need to care about the pf2e wizard...
Remove the idiotic school restriction on their 4th slot.
Some very powerful arcane silver bullets that reward prep time and learning a lot of spells. Similar to how divine can punish undead and such, give arcane the tools to break normal scaling on targets with the right traits.
Similar to the above, bonuses that scale directly with spells known. Everything from discounting the cost on the learn a spell table to empowering your spells with things learned from other spell formulae.
All the theses. If not for free, then offered as feats or for free as options at certain levels. Not like anyone's picking anything other than blend or sub anyway.
I would love an option to increase DC in exchange for giving up any chance of an enemy crit fail. Call it regulated magic or something and give +1 DC and then +2 DC to first remove crit failure and then crit success. Never liked the 4 degree of success system in the first place.
| Unicore |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
So I am often one of the biggest defenders of the wizard, and I really like the class where it is currently at. I feel like it plays plenty powerful in my games and games I run with wizards in them. I want to thus put into this conversation what I like about the wizard class, because I think it would be tragic for the game to lose these elements of the class, even if I want others to get the features that will help them be satisfied with the casters they want to play. I will do that in the next post I make.
Before I go into the good stuff, though, I want to move a point I made in the other thread here, and acknowledge that I think that this point creates a lot of tension for what players want out of a wizard:
Intelligence is a terrible attribute to try to "give power" to in a TTRPG. It is really difficult to give characters boosts from intelligence as an attribute, or build class features really centered around that attribute that represent what makes intelligence such a powerful element of games like these. The key feature of "Intelligence" in fantasy storytelling and game play is cunning strategy, planning and the clever matching of resources to circumstance. It is very difficult to give players full agency over their characters and how they approach RPG problems, and not have player "Intelligence" (cleverness, problem solving, planning, etc.) being the dominant intelligence being applied. "My character has a +4 modifier to INT, they should be able to come up with a better plan than I can, especially in 5 minutes while I am distracted having fun with my friends" is probably a true statement in most cases, but nearly an impossible one to arbitrate as a GM, especially as a lot of the things that are necessary to develop a good plan fall on skills that are not intelligence-based. A good plan requires knowledge of the situation which is usually created first through perception, then a base of knowledge much, much bigger than is represented through the recall knowledge system, which is about getting very small tidbits of information much to late for a prepared caster to be able to do much with them. In encounter recalling knowledge actually helps out spontaneous casters much more than prepared ones, as being prepared to face every possible contingency of enemies and saving throw combos usually means being able to do the right thing one time, maybe twice with a bonded item in a day. That is not how an intelligent, studious caster would approach a dungeon. They would approach the dungeon with knowledge of what creatures are going to be faced in advance, and have the spells prepared to deal with those creatures. If they don't know what is in the dungeon, than figuring that out is the thing the smart caster is going to do before going into the dungeon, and if that kind of research is not possible, then not triggering encounters, finding the key objective, and getting out of the dungeon without having to fight everything is the next best option. Many tables do not play to the strengths of a studious spell caster and I think that colors the perception of how good the studious caster can be.
In past versions of the game, the solution was to give the smart studious caster so many spell slots with so much power, that they could just pretty much make up a plan in advance of facing any situation that would override the strengths and weaknesses of those enemies and just win. This wasn't from cleverness or studious preparation, it was just exploiting the base math of the game that had to be tuned down from that level from the GM side as a baseline or parties would just be swallowed alive by every antagonistic wizard they ever faced who got to learn all about them as they made their way through the dungeon before facing them.
So, from the outset, the studious caster class faces a very big problem in a game with tight math and a tendency to encourage less intelligent and more cinematic approaches to adventuring and exploring than any real adventurers would ever go for: Groups of people don't play TTRPGS to intelligently and safely explore dangerous situations. Even really smart players can't really keep up with really smart characters who get to spend a week of downtime doing nothing but preparing for their next expedition in the 10 minutes that pass in the real world for that to happen. Intelligence takes analysis, which takes time and information, and doing that the right way for intelligent and safe exploration tends not be very dramatic or fun for a lot of players. Game mechanics that replace that, or serve as stand-ins for that careful planning are very difficult to get right without either removing agency from the player in being able to make decisions for themselves (decisions which are almost certainly ill informed, and hastily made), or make the character better at accomplishing plans which are probably not the best.
BotBrain
|
| 9 people marked this as a favorite. |
This is starting to remind me about what Paizo said about Inquistor. Ask three people what they want wizard to be and you get four answers, and a lot of the time you're given a mechanical prescription.
So, in that spirt, what do I want out of a Wizard, thematically?
I want a class who understands magic, and can therefore tweak around its edges. Wizards know the rules, and they know those rules are suggestions. Everyone else can cast spells yes, but it's like driving a car, you don't need to know how it works. If you want to make your car do something unique, you need to learn how it works.
Translating that to mechanics, I'm thinking something that approaches technomancer, without the overclocking. Spellshapes galore, perhaps even some innate free action spellshapes, like changing cones to lines, changing damage types, maybe even changing saves down the line.
What I don't want, and I mentioned this in the other thread, is a Wizard who's identity is being "the best". I appreciate this is how Wizard has been before, and it's a fantasy people enjoy and are attached to, but if we assume pf3e, pf2e unchained, whatever holds the same goals as PF2e, it's just not something that can be facilitated.
At the worst case, it could constrain design space where every new caster feature has to be evaluated against "does this make them better than wizard?" and once that dam breaks, that's it. Wizard's identity is gone.
I don't think it would go that far, but it's a very real possibility.
| Dubious Scholar |
This is starting to remind me about what Paizo said about Inquistor. Ask three people what they want wizard to be and you get four answers, and a lot of the time you're given a mechanical prescription.
So, in that spirt, what do I want out of a Wizard, thematically?
I want a class who understands magic, and can therefore tweak around its edges. Wizards know the rules, and they know those rules are suggestions. Everyone else can cast spells yes, but it's like driving a car, you don't need to know how it works. If you want to make your car do something unique, you need to learn how it works.
Translating that to mechanics, I'm thinking something that approaches technomancer, without the overclocking. Spellshapes galore, perhaps even some innate free action spellshapes, like changing cones to lines, changing damage types, maybe even changing saves down the line.
What I don't want, and I mentioned this in the other thread, is a Wizard who's identity is being "the best". I appreciate this is how Wizard has been before, and it's a fantasy people enjoy and are attached to, but if we assume pf3e, pf2e unchained, whatever holds the same goals as PF2e, it's just not something that can be facilitated.
At the worst case, it could constrain design space where every new caster feature has to be evaluated against "does this make them better than wizard?" and once that dam breaks, that's it. Wizard's identity is gone.
I don't think it would go that far, but it's a very real possibility.
A metamagic specialist definitely captures a lot of the fantasy, and I love the idea of just having "Linear Spell" as a metamagic and such. You could even do things like "Selective Spell" that lets you exclude INT targets from an AoE so you can drop a fireball in a tiny room and not hit your allies (probably want some frequency limit but even so).
I've also thought about breadth of spells and I think you should be able to over-prepare or something. Like what if you could prepare 6 spells of each rank but only cast 4 of those each day, which would mitigate the weaknesses of prepared casting by letting you have both silver bullets and generically useful stuff loaded each day.
Given how Halcyon magic works, I'd also probably allow them a feat to cheat at spell lists somehow. Let them add spells of other traditions to their spellbook but at a drawback or something (takes two slots, or lower max rank when preparing, etc). The truth of magic is magic is already there as one of the big Arcana feats at 15, and as Wizard in particular is the class about study then they're the ones who make sense to get that. Yes, there's already the archetype for it, but still.
| Angwa |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
If we're tweaking the current PF2e class I would give spell substitution as a baseline ability.
In addition, also baseline, a free action Focus Spell that lets you select a spellshape (selection widens with heightening) and does not lock you out of applying a second spellshape.
And either generally for the INT attribute I would consider trained in a regular skill or Addition Lore if you pick a lore skill, or alternatively specifically for the wizard a feat that upgrades all your lore skill picks like additional lore does.
| moosher12 |
As a 3E possibility, I'm with going the way of the Technomancer with more metamagic and spell customization. I also think there is in-world precedent for it. Rune magic is simply more well-known in the Pathfinder world, and wizards have more access to loosely knowing its exploits in time for 3E.
Though across the board, I think Wizard, and all prepared casters, would get less flak if they had a more friendly preparation system. I don't like many of D&D 5E's rules, but frankly, its spellcasting preparation engine is the one thing that's better than Pathfinder/Starfinder.
| Claxon |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The best at the intersection of academia and magic would be my preferred wizard.
Feats for bonuses or action compressions when casting curriculum spells. Multiple feats revolving around lores and recall knowledge checks. In chassis reductions to learn a spell costs. 4 slots free and clear with curriculum spells being free spells known. Free lores based on your curriculum. Spell substitution in chassis if swapping to curriculum spells.
That kind of stuff would be dope for wizard.
I never thought about it before, but a feat that let a wizard (once per round) reduce the action cost of a spell by 1 action (minimum 1) would be an amazing feat.
| ScooterScoots |
I want spell combination as an early level class feature instead of a level 20 feat. Add a few feats that loosen the restrictions on spell combo in different directions, like letting you combine different saves or take the range of the spell with the longer range.
Pair that with revamping the schools so they’re all on the same level as gates. This might require loosening the curriculum slot restrictions, as a major reason gates is a good subclass is that you’ll never be sad to have a warping pull prepared at any level (and they also get other good spells!), but having actually good focus spells would help too.
Do that and the class would have a strong identity (make your own spells!) and be in a good place mechanically.
| exequiel759 |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I also feel spellshapes as a free action should be a baseline option for all casters. With very few exceptions, most spellshapes aren't worth the action cost and every caster that isn't a wizard has much better use for that third action than what most spellshapes provide.
The 1 per spell limit would still be a thing, but the wizard would be able to bump that to 2 through a feat or class feature.
I think that kind of mix-and-match fits perfectly to wizards.
| Tridus |
| 5 people marked this as a favorite. |
Intelligence is a terrible attribute to try to "give power" to in a TTRPG. It is really difficult to give characters boosts from intelligence as an attribute, or build class features really centered around that attribute that represent what makes intelligence such a powerful element of games like these. The key feature of "Intelligence" in fantasy storytelling and game play is cunning strategy, planning and the clever matching of resources to circumstance. It is very difficult to give players full agency over their characters and how they approach RPG problems, and not have player "Intelligence" (cleverness, problem solving, planning, etc.) being the dominant intelligence being applied. "My character has a +4 modifier to INT, they should be able to come up with a better plan than I can, especially in 5 minutes while I am distracted having fun with my friends" is probably a true statement in most cases, but nearly an impossible one to arbitrate as a GM, especially as a lot of the things that are necessary to develop a good plan fall on skills that are not intelligence-based.
I'd be up for combining INT and WIS into something else like "Knowledge" and not having the two of them anymore. It doesn't make a ton of sense why some skills are on INT and some are on WIS except "D&D had 6 ability scores so we also have that and this have to split these up in some way."
you're describing one of the reasons why, but I also don't think the split really works that well anymore (if it ever really did).
A good plan requires knowledge of the situation which is usually created first through perception, then a base of knowledge much, much bigger than is represented through the recall knowledge system, which is about getting very small tidbits of information much to late for a prepared caster to be able to do much with them. In encounter recalling knowledge actually helps out spontaneous casters much more than prepared ones, as being prepared to face every possible contingency of enemies and saving throw combos usually means being able to do the right thing one time, maybe twice with a bonded item in a day. That is not how an intelligent, studious caster would approach a dungeon. They would approach the dungeon with knowledge of what creatures are going to be faced in advance, and have the spells prepared to deal with those creatures. If they don't know what is in the dungeon, than figuring that out is the thing the smart caster is going to do before going into the dungeon, and if that kind of research is not possible, then not triggering encounters, finding the key objective, and getting out of the dungeon without having to fight everything is the next best option. Many tables do not play to the strengths of a studious spell caster and I think that colors the perception of how good the studious caster can be.
Prepared casters just aren't that good in PF2 because the difference in power between "I picked the right spells for this specific set of encounters" and "I picked a set of spells that are generically good against a wide range of enemies" isn't that big in most cases. There's a set of spells that work on almost everything and if you have those, you're going to be effective no matter what happens.
Whereas you might be a bit more effective with another, niche spell, but only in that specific case. And if you don't use it or that doesn't come up, you left power on the table in some other encounter that you ran into instead because "stuff happens" and you didn't wind up where you planned to be. Plans go awry, after all.
This worked in PF1 because PF1 has a lot of silver bullet spells that can just hard counter certain things and so knowing you can use those today makes a huge difference. PF2 largely doesn't do that.
A game that rewards this style of Vancian prepared casting needs those special spells that aren't usually useful but having them at the right time makes a huge difference. But that also can make spellcasters feel swingy and overpowered, because if you can prepare and get the right tools, you've won the fight at the planning stage.
We used to do that in 3.5: spend an hour preparing for a fight before having it, drawing up big lists of spells and items to bring for that specific fight, what to prebuff, and such. We'd literally win fights before the fight started, and the actual fight itself was anticlimatic unless our foreknowledge of the encounter was wrong, or the GM had the creature somehow learn what we were planning and actively counter it (which tends to feel adversarial to the players even if its legit).
In one case I remember half the session was planning the fight. We had a list of spells going all the way down a 3x2' whiteboard. The plan worked perfectly. For the players that planned it, it was pretty cool. For the players that didn't plan it? They were bored out of their minds because they wanted to actually play the game rather than spending more time planning than actually playing.
It was very studious, very methodical, very well planned, and very effective. It was what you're describing. And it sucked if you weren't very heavily into planning. (It also sucked for the GM who had nothing to do for half the session and then had a fight that was over before it started but have to run it anyway already knowing the outcome was in no doubt.)
| Unicore |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Things I like about the PF2 wizard:
1. Spell slot spells are the most powerful limited but common resource in the game. Their effects are stronger than focus spells, Impulses, or any repeatable actions. As such, I want a class that gets as many of them as possible, especially top rank ones. I want this class to have the arcane list, because any list with heal on it ends up getting expected to provide a decent chunk of the party healing and condition removal, and that eats into what I can do with my spell slots. I want true strike, I want fireball, I want haste and slow, I want illusory disguise (at multiple different ranks), I want ventriloquism, Banishment, I want Water Breathing and Water Walk, and I don't want having access to any of these spells at the levels I can first get them or at the rank I want to cast them to prevent me from being able to cast any of a hundred or more other spells I also want to be able to cast, even if I only cast them once or twice in the whole campaign. I am greedy for casting spells and the wizard is very good at giving me a lot of great spells that I will figure out how to cast at various times in a campaign without having to wait until scrolls of it are dirt cheap. Some people will argue that druids get access to a lot of spells and don't have to pay to learn most of them (the common ones at least). Sure, but 3 slots per level hurts. As does having heal on your spell list and your party expecting you to be able to fill the role of healer with your spell slots. Suddenly half your best slots are filled with heal and you get 1 or maybe 2 fun spells to cast per rank. The wizard is casting 4 to 6 top slots on whatever they want and at least another 4 top rank -1 slots the same way. That is a lot of spell slots that I can use to cast different spells for downtime days, social encounter days, overland exploration days or dungeon crawling days. Every class feature that takes away from giving me as many spell slots as possible is a wasted feature. Drain Bonded Item gives me a free slot. My thesis either gives me more slots, or more ability to cast different spells in the same day ( I have played spell blending wizards, spell subsitution wizards and spellshape mastery wizards, but probably wouldn't play spellshape mastery again). I will talk about spell school later, but the PF2 remastered wizard doesn't get basic class features that don't help me cast more spell slot spells that I want to cast. That is the number 1 thing I like about the class' design. When people talk about more focus spells or HP or saves, I don't hate the idea of the class getting more of that stuff, but I would much rather just get more spell slots if I possibly can than anything else the class could get.
2. I like the remastered schools. For my Ars Grammtica wizard, who was captured by a false king of Old Korvosa and the campaign ended before she could be rescued, we were 8th level. My rank 4 school slot had 10 spells I could put in it. A sorcerer's rank 4 slots have 7 different spells that can be cast from it as a rank 4 spell. Sorcerers gain 1 spell every rank that can go in spells of that rank. The wizard's school spell usually gains 2. If you like your wizard school, you are a 4 slot caster for the vast majority of your spell ranks. At high level, you maybe end up with a couple of low rank slots with spell choices that you will almost never cast. Well, you will rarely cast all of your low rank spell slots in a day anyway, but if your are a spell substitution wizard, you can end up casting just about all of your spell slots every day, so one or two lower rank spells you just have nothing to switch into isn't that big a deal, or you can spell blend those slots away. Ars Grammatica gets command as a rank 1 spell so you already have a versatile good low rank one and then I pick the school because I want spells like translate veil of privacy and dispelling globe, but if there is a day where I don't want one of those, I don't usually cry over having to have command in its place (or subbing that in later in the day if I am running low on slots and we have combats coming up and I often want a rank 5 command. The "no good school spells" myth just doesn't hold water for me, and the schools give a lot of color to a wizard. I think there could be a level 1 feat that lets you swap one of your rank one school spells for a spell of your choice and that would help the players struggling to figure out how to use their school slots effectively.
3. Spell substitution and Spell blending are both exceptional theses to the class. For any newer player wanting to play a wizard, I strongly push them to consider Substitution. That way you only ever need as many encounter spells memorized as you will need in the next set of encounters before your next short rest and you can take a shot on weird niche spells that you think might come up, but not be stuck with them all day if there are more pressing needs that come up in the day. But I am glad that not every wizard is stuck with spell substitution because if you want to cast a ton of top rank chain lightning spells on most heavy combat days, Spell blending really is the thesis that just flat out adds 25% more casting power to the wizard and a lot of players just want that. More spells is moar spells, afterall.
4. Counter to popular opinion, I think the wizard has a great set of non-flashy useful feats, enough to make wizards feel very different from each other. I think there is still always room for additional feats focused on specific themes and ideas that are not currently supported as well as they could be, but there are already really great feats set baseline. Do people hate Reach spellshape? Conceal spell? Familiar? Nonlethal spell? (the only caster in the game who can AOE Nonlethal damage in mass). Linked Focus, Irresistible magic, bond conservation, overwhelming energy, Forcible Energy, Knowledge is power, convincing illusion, spell protection array, and then the feats start getting down right OP at higher ranks. And none of these include the really great options added by Impossible Magic. I think some of the "wizards have bad feats" talk is lingering core rulebook, pre-remaster rhetoric that just will not go away.
So if the wizard is not good enough as a class and needs a boost beyond just more new spells and feats and schools in future books, which is mostly true of every casting class, the only thing I would want added is either more spell slots, a free level 1 feat, or improved saves (as a "nothing else is getting added so this is all you can get boost). We have archetypes that do almost everything else I see folks asking for in the wizard.
| Mathmuse |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
My own opinion is that the Pathfinder wizard is the studious spellcaster. Alchemists mix elixirs, Animists have spirit friends, Champions have a few divine gifts, Clerics have a full divine spell list from their gods, Druids pull magic out of nature, Kineticists have direct connections to the elements, Necromancers call upon the dead, Oracles are cursed with an unintentional connection to the domains, Psychics have telepathic mind magic, Summoners have a magic buddy, and Witches are given a magic-rich familiar by their eldritch patron. None of this requires paging through ancient tomes. Magi are a fighter/wizard hybrid and Runesmiths study runes instead of spells, so they have study skills in common with Wizards.
For example, the anadi wizard Idris in my Strength of Thousands campaign began as an extremely studious student at the Magaambya Academy. All the PCs were students, but Idris was roleplayed as spending all his non-adventuring time in the Archhorn Library, learning new spells. When the characters graduated from students to teachers. I told them that they had to move out of Spire Dormitory and find other residences. Amusingly, Wilfred, champion of Cayden Cailean, teamed up with NPC brewer studnet Chizire to open a pub, and they stay in the apartment above the pub. Idris moved into the basement of the Archhorn Library.
Idris's player messaged me that she could not participate in this week's game session, "Skipping today. Idris can ooh and aah over the engineering room in the [flying] ship and then get sent to do legal research by the diplomats." In other words, Idris going off to look something up was his default behavior.
The mechanical support for a wizard acting studious is that Intelligence is their key ability and they have a spellbook instead of a spell repertoire or the ability to pull from their entire spell list. They can freely add spells to their spellbook through the Learn a Spell activity. Their spells are prepared rather than spontaneous, implying that they must think ahead. Two of their class features are named Arcane School and Arcane Thesis.
Ironically, when the Remaster changed the meaning of Arcane Schools from the seven categories of arcane spells to the curriculum of Golarion's different academies of magic, they emphasized more that the wizards had studied their spells. Unfortunately, the new system left the wizard functionally weaker.
Contrarily, the wizard's Initial Skill Proficiencies are, "Trained in Arcana. Trained in a number of additional skills equal to 2 plus your Intelligence modifier." They would have fewer trained skills at 1st level than most of the other classes, except for the bonus training from high Intelligence. Compared to the other Intelligence-based classes, Alchemist and Inventor get Crafting and 3+INT skills, Commander gets Society, Warfare Lore, and 2+INT skills, Investigator gets Society, a methodoloy skill, and 4+INT skills, Magus gets Arcana and 2+INT skills, Necromancer gets Occultism and 2+INT skills, Psychic gets Occultism and 3+INT skills, Runesmith gets Crafting, a knowledge skill, and 2+INT skills, and Witch gets a patron skill and 3+INT skills. The non-Intelligence classes start with at least 4 trained skills in addition to the bonus training from Intelligence. This is to compensate that they are unlikely to invest in Intelligence and gain bonus skills, but such compensation lessens the skill impact of playing an Intelligence class, such as Wizard.
I heard the lore justification in Dungeons & Dragons that the wizard had few skill proficiencies because they spent their study time studying spells instead. But since the other classes gained their spells without studying, that suggests that studying spells is a penalty on the education of a wizard rather than a benefit.
However, initial skill proficiency fades in importance as the characters level up. Skill increases become more important. In Pathfinder 1st Edition, the intelligence bonus granted skill points at each level for advancing skill ranks; therefore, the wizard with INT +4 could keep four knowledge skills easily at maximum rank. In Pathfinder 2nd Edition, they gain Skill Increases at the same rate, at 3rd level and every odd level afterwards, as the other classes except for Investigator and Rogue, who gain additional skill increases. This further undermined the reputation of the wizard as well-educated. Deriven Firelion has a nice post at After Impossible Magic, what other caster options are you yearning for? comment #117 about that change and other PF2 changes that subtly weakened the wizard.
I'm not sure if this thread is intended to be about what we'd like to see in this edition's wizard via new feats or archetypes, or about our wishes for a hypothetical Unchained/3E wizard, so I'm going to lean on the latter and just talk a bit about what I'd like to see the wizard be.
This thread is mostly analysis and daydreaming. We can imagine that Paizo will Remaster the Remastering of the wizard or publish Pathfinder 2nd Edition Unchained. Pathfinder 3rd Edition would have such major changes that our current analyses will be obsolete.
My turn to imagine. I favor changes that make the wizard seem more studious and better reward studious activity.
1) Give a trained skill to each school so that the wizard begins with training in Arcane, a school skill, and 2+INT other skills.
Red Mantis Magic School: Stealth
School of Ars Grammatica: Diplomacy
School of Battle Magic: Intimidation
School of Breathtaking Influence: Society
School of Civic Wizardry: Crafting
School of Gates: Survival
School of Kalistrade: Society
School of Keen Inquiry: Deception
School of Magical Technologies: Crafting
School of Mentalism: Occultism
School of Nexian Spaces: Religion
School of Protean Form: Nature
School of Quantic Control: Nature
School of Rooted Wisdom: Nature
School of Thassilonian Rune Magic: Crafting
School of the Boundary: Occultism
School of the Reclamation: Relgion
School of Unified Magical Theory: Occultism
2) Give the wizard an additional Skill Increase in Arcana or their school skill at 2nd, 3rd, 7th, and 15th levels.
3) Convert wizard's school focus spells to uncommon arcane spells with access limited to the school and add them to the school's curriculum. The wizard no longer receives focus spells nor a focus pool. Instead, in a 10-minute Restudy activity with their spellbook open they can prepare a curriculum spell in a curriculum spell slot, either refilling an empty slot or overwriting a prepared spell. The Linked Focus, Shared Focus, and Bonded Focus feats will be replaced by:
Extended Arcane Schooling, feat 2: add the curriculum spells of another school to your curriculum spell list. This does not grant the school skill nor additional curriculum slots.
Linked Arcane Bond Focus, feat 4: Once a day when you use Drain Arcane Bond, you may grant a focus point to a willing creature within 30 feet who has a focus pool. If their focus pool is full, then they gain a one-round temporary focus point instead.
Quick Restudy, feat 14: The Restudy activity takes only 1 minute.
Or just give the wizard more spellshape feats to replace the focus feats.
| PossibleCabbage |
My conceptual pitch for a class niche for the Wizard is that the class's understanding of magic on a theoretical level allows them to do metamagic type stuff much better than anybody else, in the same way that a chef who understands culinary theory can substitute ingredients.
So you could do things like the PF1 Arcanist Exploits where you can change the damage type, area, etc. better than anybody else.
| Deriven Firelion |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
The wizard took the most advantage of the system in PF1. These inherent advantages along with the strength of the arcane list made the wizard the strongest caster in PF1/3E with intelligence being an incredibly strong stat in PF1/3E. All of that is gone.
With all the changes, I want a wizard that is well-designed for PF2 to stand out in the same way a fighter, rogue, and cleric standout in PF2. Intelligence should be a stronger stat. Wizards should be able to do interesting things with spells before level 20.
Get rid of the curriculum slots and give them four slots to play with and find some other way to differentiate curriculums. Improve the focus spells. Give them some unique school ability for each one to start with or at some higher level.
I think given what they did with Spontaneous Casting that all casters should be spontaneous at this point. Paizo made spontaneous so good that prepared casters can't keep up with them.
The arcane or occult sorcerer has up to 45 spells known with 1 flexible spell and possible access to other lists. Then they have up to 8 signature spells so up to 13 ways to use their top slots.
There is no way for a prepared caster to compete with this type of on demand versatility with heightening. Slots 6 to 10 being this flexible make the sorcerer far superior for both versatile and power casting leaving the wizard in this weird place of being the "occasionally useful if you find a situation where you need to change out spells and use a specific spell if the rest of the party can't just kill them without the spells being changed" caster.
Is that really where the wizard should be in the list of casters? The maybe he can figure something better out guy on occasion? If that occasion doesn't come up, he's having his lunch eaten in damage and capability by the sorcerer? Sorc does more blasting damage due to Sorcerous potency. Has more on demand versatility with 4 slots and 4 to 5 different choices for each slot on top of signature spells providing even more versatility for their slots.
The pro-wizard crowd relies on this "They have the most top slots" argument. Who cares. Slots 6 to 10 are all useful, even at high level. Sorc uses slots 6 to 10 just fine and matches the wizard just fine, especially if they blend their slots away to get the most top slots.
Then you couple that with highly useful focus spells like Ancestral Memories or Elemental Toss and several others like constant fly usable all day.
Then toss in great feats like Explosion of Power with Anoint Ally.
You have this really subpar, middling wizard class looking like the sorc just replaced the wizard as part of the main four. No longer fighter, cleric, rogue, wizard. Now it's fighter, cleric, rogue, sorcerer as the core four. Wizard is like the leftover caster from PF1 that doesn't even feel necessary. It's a non-competitive leftover kept in the game for tradition.
Maybe that was the intent long-term. I don't know. Maybe the sorc was supposed to be the newly crowned member of the core four because the sorc is a well-designed versatile caster able to fill a lot of rolls with Charisma as an amazing stat with strong skill support. The sorc has tons of feats worth taking that make it stand out as unique and highly capable.
I know right now if the wizard class was removed from the game, it wouldn't have a noticeable effect as the sorc would fill its role and feel much better.
I guess I'm a traditionalist having played D&D/PF for so long that I feel like the wizard should feel much better as a class. It should feel consequential and be extremely good at using arcane spells, noticeably good like the fighter is noticeably good at using weapons and the rogue is a master of skills and stealthy combat and the cleric is the master of healing. The wizard doesn't feel like that right now. It feels like the master of nothing.
| BishopMcQ |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
One way to lean into the "my character is a genius who should have a plan for this" aspect of high intelligence would be to give them options that do that. Blend Prescient Planner with Scroll Adept, to allow them to have a scroll that they didn't declare as prepared at the start of the day, but make it on the fly because they "knew."
Creating Mastery schools, subsets of crafted spell lists that the Wizard has developed such mastery over that they can cast them without spell slots - have them be arcane utility spells at (Max rank - 4). At 9th level, being able to cast Alarm, Pet Cache, or similar utility spells without a spell slot demonstrates arcane mastery and since it's a preset list, the amount of abuse can be mediated.
| WHW |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
So, for me, the core of Wizard fantasy that differenetiates it from other magic users is as follows:
1. Magic that is obtained through study and is intellectual in nature, not instinctual, emotional, or religious
2. Focus on knowing things and intellectual approach to problems
3. Affinity for using traditional trappings of a wizard: magical tomes, staves, wands, scrolls, rings, hats
4. Understanding magic as a rules-driven system that allows for exploiting or changing some of the rules some of the time.
This leads to specific pain points for me in the current iteration of the Wizard. One is that unless you go Loremaster or have a GM with lore-friendly ruling for Untrained Improvisation, Wizard is not in a position to be very good about knowing things. They can be *passable*, but their need to focus on Arcane and the fact they get to max out the standard number of skills means that you are just not going to be that knowledgable about stuff, especially compared to rogues or investigators or the wost offenders – thaumaturges (I absolutely hate that Thaumaturge is a Charisma class – were it an Intelligence class, it would be actually very close to my fantasy of a wizard). My current solution is to keep grabbing Additional Lore with skill feats, and use initial skill trainings to pick Lores rather than real skills, because Lores tend to be much more useful at Trained compared to other Knowledge skills.
I understand that the game tried to make wizard the best knowledge user by the virtue of being able to strongly capitalize on information via exploiting weakest saves and weaknesses, but as mentioned earlier in this thread, spontaneous non intelligence casters can do that too, and often better. Other than Knowledge is Power, it makes me just sad that ther is little mechanical satisfaction driven from your class for actually engaging with the recall knowledge system. At very worst, give me Arcane Education feature that allows me to Recall Knowledge about potential *uses of my spells* rolling Arcana instead of whatever. So instead of using Religion to check which save of the Devilsaurus Rex is the weakest, let me ask *which kind of a spell is most likely to land against them*.
Personally, I would love if Wizard got auto-scaling on Arcana and a Skill Training variant that can be only used on Lores or a Quick Study feat. Let me be a nerd! If Sorcerer is Rogue, then let Wizard be the Investigator, to use a comparison.
The magical trappings part of wizard is, again, better represented by thaumaturge than a wizard for me. Giving wizard access to feats or class features that encourage using magical items, especially consumables, would be a good way in my book for encouraging the prepared caster fantasy. Let me quickdraw my wands and scrolls, even if only once per minute. Being able to get extra uses of wands and grimoires would also help reinforce wizard as the intelligence-driven tool-user. What thaumaturges esoterica is condensing into flavor that is hand-waved mechanically would be great for a wizard as an actual mechanical expression of interactions with magical items in the game.
I feel that a lot of work could be done by giving extra action compression to Recall Knowledge by giving options that combine it with a follow-up action. For example, you could let me draw a scroll/wand, sustain a spell or apply a Spellshape as a part of the succesful check for Recall Knowledge. This would reinforce the basic idea of 'ask a question, and immediately use the answer for something clever'. The recent Spellshifter archetype hits close to what I wish spellshapes were for a wizard: less an ability to objectively enhance a spell by adding some fraction of power to it, but an ability to make technically equal adjustments that leverage specific situations to make the change asymmetrically powerful. You know, stuff like swapping one type of damage for another or forcing the target to use save either of the saves that is not the original one.
I actually don't need to have the most slots of all casters, and I wouldn't cry if Schools and curriculum slots were removed entirely. Honestly? I would gladly swap the 4th spell slot in exchange for giving Wizard unique spin on practical magic by adding class skill feats to their list of options that represent various ways of cleverly applying magic. Things like using Telekinetic Hand for Thievery or Athletics, you know, stuff that Spell Trickster tried to do. I would kill for a Wizard that ditches School system, gets extra skill upgrades for Lores, and gets Skillful Magic skill feats at the same rate the Investigator gets their bonus skill feats. For me, wizard is the *scholar* type of magic user.
| Theaitetos |
The "no good school spells" myth just doesn't hold water for me, and the schools give a lot of color to a wizard.
I absolutely agree. Every single school (with the sole exception of Reclamation) has top school spells available for every spell rank, especially if you include heightened options (e.g. See the Unseen 5th, Slow 6th, Paralyze 7+, …).
3. Spell substitution and Spell blending are both exceptional theses to the class.
Agreed, they do what they say. Spell substitution is mostly useful for non-combat encounters and new (spellcaster) players though; it should have some in-combat application imho.
4. Counter to popular opinion, I think the wizard has a great set of non-flashy useful feats, enough to make wizards feel very different from each other. I think there is still always room for additional feats focused on specific themes and ideas that are not currently supported as well as they could be, but there are already really great feats set baseline.
I also think the Wizard has already a lot of good feats, though I think more options as well as bonus feats (1e Wizards got bonus "magic" feats every 5 levels) e.g. for spellshapes would be fine too. Reintroducing Arcane Discovery feats (tied to a school and/or thesis?) would also be cool.
None of this requires paging through ancient tomes.
True. I think the spellbook should be more important for Wizards – maybe Legacy of the Forge will have something in this regard? But the ability to slowly turn that mundane spellbook into a powerful tome as the Wizard achieves higher levels would be cool.
Oh, and remove the cost from Learn a Spell for common spells. It sucks and serves no balance purpose whatsoever. You still need to find the spell and spend some time, but not gold. Only uncommon and rare spells should cost something – a bit like Frieren doing quests to collect those, while basic magic is taught without paying/questing.
2) Give the wizard an additional Skill Increase in Arcana or their school skill at 2nd, 3rd, 7th, and 15th levels.
I'd say have the Wizard start with Expert proficiency in Arcana – it's what they studied all their life, right?
I'm also a friend of auto-scaling a class' primary skill for free, not just the Wizard, so instead how about each school also has a few Lores that you start trained in – e.g. Civic Wizardry gets Engineering Lore, Warfare Lore, and a local lore – and you get free skill increases for only those school lores every 4 levels (4, 8, 12, 16, 20)?
Whatever it is, the Wizard deserves some skill increases, though I'd still tie them to INT-skills at least. Increasing Survival or Intimidation doesn't fit imho.
3) Convert wizard's school focus spells to uncommon arcane spells with access limited to the school and add them to the school's curriculum. The wizard no longer receives focus spells nor a focus pool. Instead, in a 10-minute Restudy activity with their spellbook open they can prepare a curriculum spell in a curriculum spell slot, either refilling an empty slot or overwriting a prepared spell.
I don't think that'd work out well. Though I like the idea of a "general focus spell" for Wizards tied to studying, e.g. a once per 10min focus spell that lets them cast one of their school spells without a spell-slot and without having it prepared. Such a focus spell would get some Heightened entries to make sure you can't just spam top-tier spells every encounter, e.g. Heightened 6 allows a school spell up to rank 4. It would solve the missing 3rd focus spell issue for the Wizard and give them a bit of spontaneous casting.
| Loreguard |
I like the idea of allowing the wizard the option to ask a question about an opponent and being able to make a RK to get an answer as long as it is relevant to a spell they can cast.
Things like what is the lowest save (of spell targeting you have); what spell would trigger biggest weakness? What spell might bypass an apparent resistance.
If your result is a success it will give you the answer based on your current prepared spells and arcane spell casting items. If none of these are relevant it could reference an arcane spell which is known but not prepared/available.
This would absolutely help them feel Ike they know more. Even if it doesn’t answer, oh it’s aberration, or divine, or such. If you happened to know a spell that does vital damage and it would trigger weakness it gives you and your party some hints about what it might be.
Both a win for favor, plus a useful mechanical ability that I don’t feel is overpowered.
Edit:
Honestly, wizards starting with arcana as expert, or starting and immediately advancing to expert at second would seem to have merit. I’m not sure the entire ramifications of that with respect to skill feats, but it would help give a little bit of the feel of the wizard being the fighter (specialist) of arcane casting/knowledge.
At first the idea of making common spells free was no way, because they should have value, but in retrospect, I can’t help but wonder if that reaction is wrong, or too strong. I think I’d have to think it over more, but I think someone might be able to change my opinion.
| AestheticDialectic |
I also feel spellshapes as a free action should be a baseline option for all casters. With very few exceptions, most spellshapes aren't worth the action cost and every caster that isn't a wizard has much better use for that third action than what most spellshapes provide.
The 1 per spell limit would still be a thing, but the wizard would be able to bump that to 2 through a feat or class feature.
I think that kind of mix-and-match fits perfectly to wizards.
Well, I would argue that a wizard maybe should be the only one with spellshapes as a niche. Since everyone else had other features they'd rather use instead. Then juice them into a real class feature
| Theaitetos |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
If your result is a success it will give you the answer based on your current prepared spells and arcane spell casting items. If none of these are relevant it could reference an arcane spell which is known but not prepared/available.
While it sounds cool, I think this is completely impractical at higher levels: Your GM would have to know every spell you have prepared & all magic items you have on you, as well as know what each of those spells does. With nearly 1,000 arcane spells (and possibly more if you have other spellcasting archetypes), that is not something a GM can do; the GM might recommend a spell they think works fine, only for you to find out later there was an even better one and get angry the GM didn't tell you.
| Ryangwy |
Honestly the thesis already covers a lot of what people want wizards to do, the problem is you can only pick one of them (and one school, another weird leftover D&Dism that makes no sense with how narrow they are now compared to old spell schools). Just like... find some way to get all of them at cost, the Druid has it, the Witch has their variant with Lessons, why is the wizard incapable of it when their themeing is academia?
I'm somewhat surprised how much desire for RK support there is here when the wizard had their skill points kneecapped in 3.PF. They've never been reliant on skills for their knowledge before; that's always been more of the role of other Int classes.
| Mathmuse |
Get rid of the curriculum slots and give them four slots to play with and find some other way to differentiate curriculums. Improve the focus spells. Give them some unique school ability for each one to start with or at some higher level.
Hm, in my revision the significance of the curriculum spells is that they can refill spell slots. That revised wizard won't need curriculum slots to keep the curriculum spells significant. Four regular spell slots would be simpler.
I think given what they did with Spontaneous Casting that all casters should be spontaneous at this point. Paizo made spontaneous so good that prepared casters can't keep up with them.
What about the Signature Spell ability for heightening spells in the repertoire? Will that kludge be necessary? Without it, spells with better effects when heightened will be more valuable.
I view having to prepare spells a reasonable counterbalance for Clerics and Druids, who can prepare any common spell on their spell list. Making them spontaneous would also require limiting them to a spell repertoire. I played a few D&D clerics who had to say, "I can cure that condition tomorrow, when I pray for the exact spell designed for this." I also played a PF1 oracle who had to keep a teammate alive with Lesser Restoration every day until the oracle leveled up and learned the spells to cure mummy rot (Amaya of Westcrown, comment #6).
The wizard, on the other hand, has a spellbook, which is more than a repertoire and less than the entire common list.
Prepared casters just aren't that good in PF2 because the difference in power between "I picked the right spells for this specific set of encounters" and "I picked a set of spells that are generically good against a wide range of enemies" isn't that big in most cases. There's a set of spells that work on almost everything and if you have those, you're going to be effective no matter what happens.
Whereas you might be a bit more effective with another, niche spell, but only in that specific case. And if you don't use it or that doesn't come up, you left power on the table in some other encounter that you ran into instead because "stuff happens" and you didn't wind up where you planned to be. Plans go awry, after all.
This worked in PF1 because PF1 has a lot of silver bullet spells that can just hard counter certain things and so knowing you can use those today makes a huge difference. PF2 largely doesn't do that.
A game that rewards this style of Vancian prepared casting needs those special spells that aren't usually useful but having them at the right time makes a huge difference. But that also can make spellcasters feel swingy and overpowered, because if you can prepare and get the right tools, you've won the fight at the planning stage.
And in dividing the PF1 arcane spells among the PF2 arcane, occult, and primal traditions pulls many specialized spells that were critical in special cases away from the wizard. For example, Stone to Flesh is on the wizard's spell list in PF1 but is in only the divine and primal traditions in PF2.
I remember a trick I used in Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition. Clerics in that edition had spontaneous conversion of prepared spells into the same level of Cure Wounds spell. Thus, they could have Neutralize Poison prepared as a speculation spell but then sacrifice the unused spell to cast Cure Serious Wounds instead. Thus, I was willing to prepare a few specialized spells because I figured I would need that many Cure Wounds spells. Imagine the PF2 wizard being able to do similar conversions. Let me add a 4th change to my revised wizard.
4) The wizard has four spell slots without a special curriculum slot. They gain Curriculum Casting.
Curriculum Casting 1st level wizard ability
The spells you studied in your Arcane School are at your fingertips. You may cast your curriculum spells even if you have not prepared them. To do so, you must sacrifice a prepared spell of the same rank as an additional cost for Cast a Spell.
Thus, a wizard with four spell slots at a particular rank has access to the four spells and to two to five curriculum spells of that rank. For example, a wizard of the School of Civic Wizardry could prepare Charm, Fear, Force Barrage, and Grease yet still have Hydraulic Push, Pummeling Rubble, Summon Construct, and Earthworks available, eight spells to chose from.
Okay, that is one possible trick and is probably not properly balanced. My main point is that spellcasting classes have different ways of restricting their spells available at any instant. Spontaneous casters are limited to their spell repertoire. Prepared casters pulling from an entire tradition of spells are limited by their choices during preparation. Wizards are prepared casters limited by their choices during preparation but also limited to the spells in their spellbook. That is more limitations than usual.
I want to keep the spellbook, but for fairness the wizard needs more flexibility than choices made during daily preparation. Another possible trick would be giving every wizard Spell Substitution arcane thesis, as others have suggested. A third possible trick would be letting the wizard also write occult and primal spells to their spellbook to prepare them as arcane. A fourth possibility would be some free-action spellshaping for wizards, so that their prepared spells can be changed on the fly though not made more powerful.
Mathmuse wrote:None of this requires paging through ancient tomes.True. I think the spellbook should be more important for Wizards – maybe Legacy of the Forge will have something in this regard? But the ability to slowly turn that mundane spellbook into a powerful tome as the Wizard achieves higher levels would be cool.
Oh, and remove the cost from Learn a Spell for common spells. It sucks and serves no balance purpose whatsoever. You still need to find the spell and spend some time, but not gold. Only uncommon and rare spells should cost something – a bit like Frieren doing quests to collect those, while basic magic is taught without paying/questing.
In my Strength of Thousands campaign the player of the wizard Idris asked how much Learn a Spell cost at the Magaambya Academy. I said that the Magaambya Academy does not charge its students for Learning a Spell. It's part of their tuition, and other people are paying the tuition: Strength of Thousands backgrounds. Then we had to work out how many new spells Idris could add to his spellbook during a single semester.
Mathmuse wrote:2) Give the wizard an additional Skill Increase in Arcana or their school skill at 2nd, 3rd, 7th, and 15th levels.I'd say have the Wizard start with Expert proficiency in Arcana – it's what they studied all their life, right?
That is where I expected the 2nd-level skill increase to go.
Mathmuse wrote:3) Convert wizard's school focus spells to uncommon arcane spells with access limited to the school and add them to the school's curriculum. The wizard no longer receives focus spells nor a focus pool. Instead, in a 10-minute Restudy activity with their spellbook open they can prepare a curriculum spell in a curriculum spell slot, either refilling an empty slot or overwriting a prepared spell.I don't think that'd work out well. Though I like the idea of a "general focus spell" for Wizards tied to studying, e.g. a once per 10min focus spell that lets them cast one of their school spells without a spell-slot and without having it prepared. Such a focus spell would get some Heightened entries to make sure you can't just spam top-tier spells every encounter, e.g. Heightened 6 allows a school spell up to rank 4. It would solve the missing 3rd focus spell issue for the Wizard and give them a bit of spontaneous casting.
I think you mean "curriculum spells" rather than "school spells." The school spells are the wizard focus spells.
My objection to wizard focus spells, AKA school spells, is that they do not involve the spellbook. My bias wants to alter the curriculum requirement on Theaitetos's idea into a spellbook requirement. The following Spellbook Focus can replace my change (3) from my revised wizard.
Spellbook Focus Wizard feat 5
During your daily preparations, select a 1st-rank spell from your spellbook. You can cast it as a 1st-rank focus spell without preparing it. This ability increases the size of your focus pool by 1, up to a maximum of 3 focus points. You can change your choice of spell while studying your spellbook in a 10-minute Refocus activity.
At 7th level, the spell could be 2nd rank and a selected 1st-rank spell would heighten to 2nd rank, and at every odd level thereafter the rank and heightening for this focus spell would increase by 1.
Such a feature would be unmanageable for a cleric or a wizard, because their list of spells they can cast is too large. But for a wizard, it is no harder than Spell Substitution.
| PossibleCabbage |
I also don't think "the Wizard is the weakest casting class" if it were true would even be a problem. That identity is always going to fall to one of the caster classes, people concerned with power can pick something else, and people who love the class will stick with it even when it's mediocre (goodness knows I've played a Monk in so many editions where it was a bad class.)
If there is a problem here it's in the feelings of people who were drawn to the Wizard as the strongest class who feel let down now that it's not.
| Dubious Scholar |
As another way for the studious Wizard to show up, maybe a thesis about knowing your enemy. On a successful Recall Knowledge against an enemy you get +1 circumstance to spell attack/DC to that enemy for the rest of the encounter and +2 on crit. The knowledge of your enemies and the knowledge of how your own spells works allows you to tune them on the fly to the current foe.
In general I think that thematically wizards are best suited by things that play in the area of knowledge. Knowing more spells, knowing how spells work, etc. If wizards became spontaneous then just having a thesis where you get +2 spells/rank in your repertoire would be a valid option.
| Theaitetos |
I think you mean "curriculum spells" rather than "school spells."
Yeah, mixed them up for a moment.
As another way for the studious Wizard to show up, maybe a thesis about knowing your enemy. On a successful Recall Knowledge against an enemy you get +1 circumstance to spell attack/DC to that enemy for the rest of the encounter and +2 on crit. The knowledge of your enemies and the knowledge of how your own spells works allows you to tune them on the fly to the current foe.
In general I think that thematically wizards are best suited by things that play in the area of knowledge. Knowing more spells, knowing how spells work, etc. If wizards became spontaneous then just having a thesis where you get +2 spells/rank in your repertoire would be a valid option.
Both of those options are too op.
The Raven Black
|
I also don't think "the Wizard is the weakest casting class" if it were true would even be a problem. That identity is always going to fall to one of the caster classes, people concerned with power can pick something else, and people who love the class will stick with it even when it's mediocre (goodness knows I've played a Monk in so many editions where it was a bad class.)
If there is a problem here it's in the feelings of people who were drawn to the Wizard as the strongest class who feel let down now that it's not.
I think the problem comes from being the strongest caster in previous editions to being the weakest now. That is a pretty big fall.
And the description of the class does set up some expectations of awesome power that are just not there.
Not to mention what is described as the results of the Wizard's great knowledge/mastery of magic is actually something any caster can do and Spontaneous in fact are better at it than Prepared.
| Sibelius Eos Owm |
| 7 people marked this as a favorite. |
Personally, the remaster schools from a narrative standpoint were the first time I saw a wizard that had an actual in-universe identity. I love that new schools act like the major you studied at magic university, whether it's magic grammar, magic civil engineering, or magic pyrotechnics. I'm not married to the idea of your school granting you specific spells, but if I'm being honest, I'd rather have curriculum spells than a boring "+1 spell" no matter how objectively powerful getting +1 spells is--I'd rather spend that mechanical power on something more interesting, if one of them had to go.
(admittedly it would make it hard for the wizard to feel like 'the caster of magic class' when it has fewer spells/day than the sorcerer, but then maybe 4 slots a day is a mistake on any caster when it consumes the majority of the power budget in one feature).
Meanwhile, I think it would be cool if a wizard could learn a bunch of tricks that were magical but not spells. Back in PF1e, Wizards could choose to gain an "Arcane Discovery" every 5 levels you could pick a magical ability, ranging from learning to speak to animals to being able to block teleportation effects within a certain range of you.
Admittedly a lot of these discoveries in practice were flat +number when you do thing, but I think the core concept has legs. 2e already has feats like Spell Protection Array where you can throw down defensive runes as a form of non-spell magic. I would like to see more feats that show that wizards have studied enough magic that they know more tricks than just how to cast the same Arcane spells everyone else has.
And then as others say, if they have a few more ways to work those basic spells in ways others cannot, that's pretty cool, too. I kind of like wizards being masters of spellshape such that it makes spellshaping more attractive to use. Even if it was just a small list of like 4 barebones situational spellshapes any wizard can use for free to slightly adjust the parameters of their magic on the fly--like this spell reaches 10' further (stackable with real Reach spell), or this spell leaves a glowing after-effect or a spot of haze that counts as concealment, or you can skip 1 square of AoE with this spell.
| OceanshieldwolPF 2.5 |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I had a group new to PF2 with a wizard in it. He didn’t like *any* of the Wizard schools, nor did any fit his character thematically. It was bad, and a poor introduction.
I’m definitely not a fan of Boggy Trotter, I found its concept of nob-college wonks gadding about to be completely noisome and the whole affair entirely basic and derivative. Wizard academies and colleges are equally distasteful.
I remember Palladium’s Ninjas and Superspies had a concept that divided martial artists into “dedicated’ and “wordly” - dedicated characters had few skills compared to worldly ones who had a measure of real life experience. Definitely makes sense that the more rough and tumble “Wizzard” might have the odd skill or two, moreso than cloistered academic wizards. And not at all related to how high their Intelligence is. I think this whole discussion really brings to light the tension of the so-called mental attributes of Wisdom, Intelligence and Charisma, given their deeply entwined interrelationships and interdependencies.
Even though Dragonlance was entirely execrable (love the bit where the guards in Tarsis who attack the party are wielding….hauberks….) the character Fizban, (again, apologies for actually being a god) as a wizard was definitely funny, and kind, and silly, and doddering, and powerful. But his “smart” was difficult to define - cagey, hidden, perceptive, wise. Possibly not high Intelligence.
| WHW |
Thinking about it, the way I actually really liked current Curriculum and School rules being used is the remastered Runelord. While anathemas are a pain, the ones you deem playable are actually interesting, and more importantly, I really liked the combo of core curriculum spells + supplementary specialized ones. But what I liked the most, I think, is Runelords ability to spell substitute into their curriculum spells.
So for the current system, a big improvement for me would be:
1. Add a way to runelord substitute into your curriculum for other schools (it can be a feat, I guess).
2. Add an ability to expand your curriculum. Even adding one spell per feat to make curriculum more 'yours' would be welcome. You could make it a level 2 feat that can be taken multiple times every X levels.
Another thing I've recently found myself lacking is the ability to have diverse study equivalent. I would love an ability to get another schools school spell and add one or two curriculum spells from them to my own. And I would love an ability to add mini-version of another thesis to create a hybrid thesis. I love the School and Thesis flavor, but I would like an ability to keep the academic spirit alive by letting wizards get interdisciplinary.
| Tridus |
One way to lean into the "my character is a genius who should have a plan for this" aspect of high intelligence would be to give them options that do that. Blend Prescient Planner with Scroll Adept, to allow them to have a scroll that they didn't declare as prepared at the start of the day, but make it on the fly because they "knew."
That would be cool and fit really well.
Though a lot of this "studious" stuff actually exists somewhat: Tome Thaumaturge can study at the start of the day to be good at whatever they need to do, gets free RKs for bonuses, and in general is straight up just the best in the game at knowing stuff.
Meanwhile Whispers of Weakness gives Oracle the key info for targeting a spell with no check at all.
Spell Substitution being a thing the Wizard can do a lot faster would really help. Like a 1/hour ability to just cast a spell from your spellbook by expending a slot regardless of what's prepared in it. Suddenly the spellbook is hugely valuable instead of a thing that doesn't really do anything except be more work than a Cleric has to do. That's ummatched "I have what I need" for spells, and it also pairs great with Counterspell (because you'll be able to get the right spell a lot more readily without any fiddly bits).
PF2 just doesn't reward prepared casting the way PF1 did because the games are fundamentally different. So making the Wizard able to deal with that will help a lot, whereas right now it has the downsides of prepared casting but not enough other stuff to make up for that (unlike say Cleric, where Divine Font does a ton of heavy lifting).
| NoxiousMiasma |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The reason I suggested (in the other thread) that all wizards should get Spell Substitution as a base feature is twofold: one, spending ten minutes poring over your spellbook to rejigger your spells is a nice bit of flexibility, and two, it actually gives a reason for wizards to have a spellbook (instead of just being unrestricted prepared like cleric or druid). Incentivises learning more of the more situational spells. Like, yeah, there's less of them in 2e, but they still very much exist (dehydrate, temporary tool, cleanse air, gecko grip, knock, etcetera).
Definitely wish the nerdiest caster got more options for RK too - like, some action compression with a spell or something? Or more skill increases, but restrict them to Arcana or Lores or something?
| Deriven Firelion |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I also don't think "the Wizard is the weakest casting class" if it were true would even be a problem. That identity is always going to fall to one of the caster classes, people concerned with power can pick something else, and people who love the class will stick with it even when it's mediocre (goodness knows I've played a Monk in so many editions where it was a bad class.)
If there is a problem here it's in the feelings of people who were drawn to the Wizard as the strongest class who feel let down now that it's not.
In PF1 the sorc and wizard both felt strong. The sorc was more specialized and a better damage caster.
The wizard was more versatile and better metamagic. A specialized school felt far more substantial than a curriculum feels now.
It had way, way more slots for versatile casting. With the small number of slots and the arcane list being stripped of many power spells, it feels super weak as a caster, very limited.
I don't understand why players can't see this. It's so easy to see. When you write a wizard spell list, it's very limited if you want to use a spell more than once or vary your spell list.
Whereas a sorcerer has 45 spells at high level for arcane or occult that works like a matrix of choices with 4 spell slots having access to a far wider number of spells.
The PF1 sorcerer was very limited in spells known. This was a good tradeoff for having more blasting power and bonuses from the bloodline. But now that they have 36 spells known base, then add on another 9 with feats and then another one with Arcane Evolution or Occult Evolution and you're talking an absolutely amazing number of choices that don't count against the number of slots if you prepare them.
Once again:
Wizard: 9th level slots with blending: Falling Stars, Dispel Magic, Foresight, Wails of the Damned, Falling Stars with one use of Arcane Bond
That is 3 uses of Falling Stars then one use of level 9 Dispel Magic, one Foresight, and one Wail of the Damned.
Sorcerer:
9th Level known: Falling Stars, Dispel Magic, Foresight, Wails of the Damned, Power Word Kill.
2nd level: Dispel magic signature spell
1st Force Barrage signature spell
3rd: Slow Signature spell
4th: Vision of Death signature spell
5th: Howling blizzard Signature Spell
6th: Chain Lightning Signature Spell.
7th: Teleport Signature Spell
8th: Summon Undead Signature spell
Arcane Evolution: Dominate 9th level
So Mr. Wizard with Supposed versatility with Spell Blending so can't change out spells in 10 minutes has 4 total spell choices at level 17.
Mr. Sorcerer has 14 total choices to use with his 9th level slots. Heightening was needed.
They don't even need a 9th level slot for heightened slow, just a 6th level slot.
So this supposed versatility with prepared casting is an all an illusion whereas the sorcerer has real on-demand versatility.
This means the sorcerer does a better job of quickly adapting to fights than the wizard. While also getting a bonus to damage and healing.
It doesn't much matter how much we argue, in game the sorcerer is eating the wizard's lunch. A well built, well played sorcerer seriously outshines a wizard the vast majority of the time.
You never hear the words, "I used my only prepared dispel magic, sorry, can't do that again."
The prepared versus spontaneous trade off was worth it in PF1 because of the huge number of slots allowing a wizard to load a massive versatile spell load out. That just isn't the case anymore.
In PF2 the sorc is outwizarding the wizard and still being more powerful as a blaster.
| QuidEst |
Like I've said before, I'm pretty happy with the Wizard class. But I'm also happy to give a few takes on simple improvements that I don't think would be too broken in the PF2 framework.
I'd only apply one of these at a time, personally.
1. Give them all of the Hedge Mage feats as in-class options. The dedication and basic/advanced/master casting feats are special extra slots that can be used to prepare from another tradition, with the same cantrip/1st/2nd/3rd restrictions. Things like the heighten feat apply to all your Wizard spells, though, and don't require the "dedication". Finally, the level 14 feat instead gives them a second thesis of their choice (since otherwise it'd be useless on spell substitution).
That gives them the "master of magic" feel, off-list spell access without being able to sling five max-rank heals, and some additional flexibility, but you're not making radical overhauls.
2. Give them Arcana advancing at 1st, 3rd, 7th, and 15th. Give them an Arcana skill feat at those levels. They still keep the 2+Int limit and don't get a universal knowledge skill, but they get to feel more well-rounded by having their most iconic skill taken care of. Having free identification feats if they want lets them feel more wizardly.
If you're feeling especially generous, add that a Wizard can always roll Arcana to know a creature's weakest save, although that feels like a healthy house-rule for all four magic skills.
3. Add a fourth-level feat that gives Wizard a one-action focus spell: use a one-action spellshape from a common Wizard feat. It must have a level no higher than the spell's rank. If you have the spellshape thesis, you can instead use this to swap your daily spellshape to anything you could have chosen, using it immediately.
It's a third in-class focus spell for Wizard, it taps into the flexible spellshape stuff some folks wanted, and it keeps a small limit on it.
| WHW |
BishopMcQ wrote:Suddenly the spellbook is hugely valuable instead of a thing that doesn't really do anything except be more work than a Cleric has to do. That's ummatched "I have what I need" for spells, and it also pairs great with Counterspell (because you'll be able to get the right spell a lot more readily without any fiddly bits).
Let me spend gold at market rate to cast spells out of my spellbook like they are scrolls. Or even at a premium. I *like* scrolls gameplay, but there is always something little bit wrong about them being best bought from a rando shopkeeper, rather than being my own work (because time sink is time sink). Let me vaporize magical reagents to complete spells from the spellbook or something, or just let me vaporize gold during daily prep to produce scrolls literally the same way as if I would buy them, but reframed as me scribing them myself.
Let me have a Scroll Folio: keep my scrolls in a book-binder, so I can constantly keep a book-aesthetic item and use it to access my scroll collection at a cost of a hand slot.
| Unicore |
45 spells known is about 1/3 of rank 1 arcane spells. With my wizards I usually get to 45 spells known somewhere between levels 5 and 7. I get there by spending close to half my wealth on scrolls and I almost always have the spellbook prodigy feat at the point that I am really going all in on spells. Because a wizard can heighten any spell, there comes a point where it is nonsense not to have nearly ever 1st rank spell (at least every common one and any uncommon or rare ones you get access to), and eventually that becomes true with most of the other lower rank spells as well. You buy a scroll at the lowest rank you can get the spell and then you can use it as you need it later. Maybe around 200 to 250 spells in my spell book I train out of Spellbook Prodigy and reduce the amount of extra spells I am adding to my book each level to 8-10 instead of 25+. But Unicore, what do you do with all those spells in your spell book?
It is true that wizards kinda need to start the day knowing what spells they are going to cast. As I said before, my playstyle lends itself more towards spell substitution than spell blending, as that lets me get the versatility I love out of my spell slots. The party reaches a non combat challenge with no immediate time pressure and we basically have a huge chunk of the arcane spell list at our disposal to problem solve with. As a spell blending wizard, I tend to find I only usually need enough enough "suprise! Its combat!" spells ready to go to get through 1 severe encounter. If my party is getting surprised by more than severe encounters, then we should be running away, or looking to move past them quickly, fighting as few of them as possible, because, yes, the wizard does not do well being ambushed. On the 1 to 2 days per level where we know we are going in against the whole dungeon, I have a completely different spell load out then on nearly every other day I am adventuring.
What this has taught me is that:
1.Wizards get too many spells in their book to have super flexible top rank spell slots. It will cause the whole table grief if players are regularly stopping everything to decide which of their 200-400 spells is the best spell to cast in this exact encounter round. I think that is why the feats that already enable wizards to be flexible with their slots are either giving either or options to spells top-rank-1, or more flexibility to top-rank-2...because my wizard already pretty much has top-rank-2 flexibility in the form of carrying around 100 scrolls (with most of those in magical storage, but 20ish combat ones worn in a bandolier and accessible to both me and my manually dexterous familiar (learned the hard way about the dangers of walking around with a scroll in each hand, especially anywhere near a cliff). Any options giving them more scrolls or lower rank spells (like the Reprepare Spell), are not really power boosting the wizard class when played to its maximum efficiency because the wizard is already accomplishing this with scrolls already.
2. A spell like Dispel Magic is a great spell for a spontaneous to make a signature spell, but it doesn't have to take up nearly as much real estate in a wizard's mind, because there are other cooler spells later on that will accomplish that same thing and then some that the sorcerer probably won't bother learning, but a wizard can. My wizard is unlikely to have a dispel magic spell memorized at rank 9 (unless I have a specific purpose for it that I know in advance), for example, because, if I am going into combat, I'd probably rather have Detonate Magic in that slot. Falling stars is a fun spell, if I know I am going to be in a location where there are lots of enemies to face and the area to drop very large AoEs, but if I am in a location where blowing up everything and everyone is not a great idea, I might have phantasmagoria, massacre, Implosion, or (very likely) 2 or 3 power word kill spells memorized and more 8th rank arctic rift, desiccate, or even just heightened Chain Lightnings memorized for use as my 2 action spell to go along with a power word stun or blind or kill.
I think one of the reasons I like wizards more than sorcerers is because it is unsual for my parties to have no idea what we will be facing in a day.
| Claxon |
Claxon wrote:I never thought about it before, but a feat that let a wizard (once per round) reduce the action cost of a spell by 1 action (minimum 1) would be an amazing feat.That's just Quickened Casting on steroids. Too op.
You have a fair point, maybe timing restriction should be like once per 10 minutes. I think it would be fair to allow a wizard to basically do this once per combat (but writing it that way would be too meta) so make it once per 10 minutes. It's good. It's something every wizard should probably grab.
As it sits the Quickened Casting feat is just okay IMO. The spell level restriction and the once per day restriction make it not bad, but it's not amazing either.
It's not as good conceptually as Haste if it gave an extra action instead of an action restricted to striking or striding.
| Squiggit |
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Part of the problem I think is that the Wizard has a really weak internal definition. Like.. it's dude who casts spells and has a spellbook but those are all pretty low level concepts. I feel like right now the Wizard is almost more defined negatively (as in, in terms of the things they can't do, like heal very well) than in terms of like... what they're actually selling.
Looking at other media, wizard fantasies either tend to be very generalist (the 'I know all the magic' type) or very specific (themed spellcasters) and the PF2 wizard kind of.. doesn't do great at either? Instead we get a class that's very self referential. It's the PF version of the D&D wizard and most of its mechanics are informed by the history of how D&D wizards have historically worked. Ironically despite the class being open ended and based on an archetypal fantasy trope I think the PF2 wizard is a really bad starting point for actually making something in line with the broader fantasy.
That said I think if the goal is 'fixing the wizard' some of the consideration here is too grandiose. If the class had more interesting focus spells and a few more unique feats it'd probably be fine. In terms of "right here right now" problems I'd say the main things are that the class just has such anemic focus spells and class features, the chassis is so empty.
It was a huge step back imo to remove school based class features in the PF1 to PF2 transition, and an even bigger miss to not reintroduce them with the way schools were redefined in the remaster.
| Unicore |
Another complicating circumstance to giving the wizard more toys via spell shape feats is that the system is really built around adding more spells as the way of already accomplishing this.
Like a spell shape that changes lines into cones, for example is doing a very different thing with lightning bolt and enervate (not to mention higher rank spells like massacre and arctic rift. The balance of spells is already so all over the place and tied to limits about area and range that the amount of stuff a one action activity can do.
Like at this point, we have gotten enough 1 action spells of quality (assuming GMs grant access to the higher rank uncommon ones), that quickened casting round (with a top rank -2 spell isn’t that much better than what you can pull off several rounds a day with casting a 1 and a 2 action spell in the same round. And the wizard already has spell shape feats for bypassing resistances and adding weaknesses to enemies, so being able to change damage types isn’t really something they desperately need either. (Although why shadow blast isn’t arcane seems a little silly, even if the arcane list generally has better options).