Nargin Haruvex

gesalt's page

1,636 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.


RSS

1 to 50 of 1,636 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | next > last >>

Deriven Firelion wrote:

When you think of enough spells, you think in terms of how you want to play using spellcasting as some fuel for your RP and spells to solve problems.

When people like gesalt and I think of enough spells we think in terms of can we win the encounters with available spells and other class feats and abilities.

Thus both opinions can be true. Bard doesn't have enough spells to spend spells on RP or spell problem solving. And the bard does have enough spells with its other class features and feats to win encounters.

I'm fine on non-combat spells too really. Illusions from a staff of phantasms cover a lot by themselves. From the remaining 27 from ranks 01-09, we start with the staples.

Calm or overwhelming presence are your AoE incap spells. Slow is your fort control, Containment is single target ref control and Synesthesia or Confusion cover single target debuff and action denial respectively. Everything but containment can be signatured to get an AoE version too if you need it. Plus quandry for no-save control. Then we have Silence 4 to hose casters and aid infiltration and True target for party advantage. We'll throw in signature soothe as an emergency heal too. So we'll call that 09/27 spells for the bare minimum of combat coverage spread across several ranks.

The other 18 are free to do with what you want. AoE damage? Plenty of options these days. Party too poor to afford personal flight or potion pouches? Fly and Haste. Want some scouting? Clairaudience and/or Clairvoyance. Defensive tech? Shadow Siphon. Invis? Invis and disappearance. Rank 1 minesweeping fodder? Summon X. Etc, etc, etc. You can even grab Lock like Unicore's so passionate about.

Quote:
It is also probably true that my groups play the game at a more challenging level than many other tables, so it is not usually a good idea to put a plan in place without making sure the party is not leaving any bonuses to skill checks on the table, not suffering any needless circumstance penalties to checks, or failing to utilize every possible resource we can get to make a plan work.

Given that one time you extolled the great performance of a gun rogue, I'm going to admit some extreme skepticism for how challenging your tables actually are.


Unicore wrote:
I can see where some would say just give prepared an additional spell slot, but it is pretty clear to me that getting 4 spells per rank in the repertoire is what is really creating the imbalance. People just do not wax on about summoners or Psychics or bards having such an amazing breadth of spells to cast, and if you are only getting to pick 2 of your spells per rank, then you really are pretty limited in your spell breadth.

Psychics and their lousy two slots is one thing, but bards get the exact same number of player-choice spells known as the sorcerer and it's plenty because there are barely enough good spells in the system to fill out 3 choices per level. You don't hear about it because people wax about the other good stuff bard and friends bring to the table.

Doesn't hurt that spontaneous casters also benefit more from staves by being able to spontaneously cast its spells using their slots for a mere charge if you ever need them while prep casters are stuck sacrificing a slot preloading the staff with extra charges that either might not be sufficient or might be overkill. A wizard might get one or two staff spells per day if you need anything that isn't rank 1 or 2, but for a sorc or bard it may as well be an extra 5-20ish spells known depending on the staff.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Give me stuff that at least attempts to enable different parties and playstyles. Weapon rune to 1/round proc all persistent effects on an enemy to reward stacking a bunch of types. Single action snares so that push teams have a payoff other than berms before lightning snares comes online (this is where deployable terrain with collision effects for daredevil also exists). An affliction staff that lets you detonate debuffs like slow, clumsy, etc for bonus effects/damage at the cost of removing them. Stuff like that.


Quote:
I’m not sure when the low end of the sorcerer’s power occurs. However, I decided to make a level 6 sorcerer in a campaign-mode game to try it out, primarily after seeing all the chatter around this on the boards. After three sessions with that sorcerer I immediately rebuilt my low level PFS wizard into a sorcerer because it was so powerfully flexible and a lot of fun.

Like all casters, the low end of power is levels 1-6 with a marked improvement at 5, but never feeling truly fine to play until 7. Though I'm more critical than others and find any full caster not named bard or cleric to be a straight liability pre-5 in general. It's actually laughable how much easier the early game is the fewer casters you have.


Quote:
The challenging part is that many players don’t realize the strategy starts to change at level 5 and will be completely different by level 7.

Can't say I agree. Pre-05 you buff the martial (magic weapon mostly), AoE control mooks (calm, illusions, etc), AoE damage (electric arc), single target debuff (fear, laughing fit, etc.) Vs bosses and heal the martial as needed.

The only "strategy" changes 01-20 are the addition of AoE damage that isn't cantrips and good non combat utility that isn't just illusions. The rest is just a quality improvement on what you were already doing.


There's not much reason to deviate from keeping both hands on your 2h weapon. If you're really interested in using consumables despite that, you have potion patches, familiars, scroll robes or whatever to cheat the handedness requirements anyway.


The innovation version gets overdrive bonuses, the two action command option, whatever innovations you select for it, and you can take class feats that require "construct innovation."

The construct companion rules state you can only have one at a time.


Claxon wrote:

It's still not sustainable though. It mitigates it to an extent, but you could blow through the 4 guns you have attuned.

Also typical turn order would be:
Combat Starts - 1st round
1 action - Fire 1st gun
1 action - Risky Reload (reload then fire) if you miss
1 action - Activate bandolier, which moves attunement and allows you to draw
2nd Round
1 action - Fire 2nd gun
1 action - risky reload (reload then fire) if you miss
1 action - activate bandolier

You can repeat that 4 times and then you're out of guns. How often are you going to miss on your Risky Reload? Under this rotation its your second attack in a turn, and thus suffering from MAP which is bad. I suppose if you started a turn by Risky Reloading (by having your gun empty at the end of the previous turn you could avoid that, but then you're purposefully not taking a shot in the 1st round)....

You have a point, but it's a band-aid (better than most) to a problem that doesn't really need to exist IMO.

You've already messed up by starting with your initial gun loaded. Why do you think I ordered it with RR first? Only the guns in your bandolier are loaded so that you can immediately fire on action three so that you start each round ready to RR. Guns have plenty of problems, sure, but I can see why you're having even more issues with them if you didn't know to at least start each combat unloaded.

I don't understand what you mean by not taking a shot in the first round though.

Round 1 w/Empty gun:
RR
Reload or drop+activate bandolier
Strike.

Just don't miss it you're using a 2h gun. Wait for your team to set de/buffs to minimize the risk.

Guns do suck compared to bows, but that's no excuse for not knowing how to get the most out of them when somebody insists on using them.


Claxon wrote:

Gunner's bandolier also doesn't solve it because you need to spend an action to "activate" the runes on it. You can't use it with Quick Draw as The Raven Black Mentions.

It's better than some other options, and works better with Risky Reload than other options, but still doesn't really get you there.

The action that activates the bandolier includes an interact to draw the weapon. That's why I said that on a miss with RR, you use a free action to drop the jammed gun, draw from the bandolier, and then shoot again. 3 actions total. This isn't rocket science.

I really couldn't care less about any of the deeds or quick draw though.


Claxon wrote:

That only works at early levels though Gesalt, once you start putting runes on your weapon...it's too expensive to maintain multiple weapons with up to date runes. That's why we have doubling rings and blazons of shared power. Both allow you to have two weapons with maximum runes, without the price. But the blazons only work for a pair of weapons, you can't hot swap them like you can with doubling rings.

So no Risky Reload and drawing new weapons doesn't really fix it.

If Risky Reload didn't cause misfire on a miss, or if blazons of shared power allowed you to give the runes to any ranged weapon in your off hand then it would work.

Gunner's Bandolier solves the rune issue, same as rings or blazons. Cheap, easy, buyable right before non-gunslingers poach risky reload at level 4. Load up on jezails and have at it.


Quote:
Thinking about it from another perspective, if the gunslinger had abilities that let them get off 4 shots per 2 rounds instead of 3, would that be too strong? Would it put them above the damage curve for bows?

Look, this isn't actually a problem for a gunslinger, or any gunner really. For 1h guns especially, this is a solved problem:

1) Risky reload (includes a strike)
2a) on hit, reload, strike
2b) on miss, free action drop, draw from gunner's bandolier, strike.

So with a 1h gun you will always have the option to make 2 strikes per round. For 2h guns, you need to not miss your RR strikes. If your party isn't built well enough to make sure there's enough de/buffing going on to make your initial RR strike very reliable, you probably shouldn't be using anything with fatal to begin with.

Exemplar, unfortunately runs into an issue with 1h guns in that you can't make all 4 in the bandolier your ikon. At best you can get two with twin stars at level 1. At least they can combine any transcendence action with reload.


I think you're too focused on trying to get a bunch of feats that work with using a gun when even most gunslingers grab risky reload, running reload, fake out, and then stop. Most playstyles really just boil down to one or two required feats before just taking generic good stuff.

So for a gun exemplar, I'd take starshot or unfailing bow, which doesn't actually require a bow, sandals for stride on spark, gaze for extra damage on spark, deft epithet to turn those sparks into reloads and archetype gunslinger for at least risky reload. Pretty basic rotation of risky reload, spark or manual reload, shoot again. Starshot's spark comes with a second strike so it all works out. Probably forego a 4th ikon for archetype fakeout at level 08 too. Release gun after 2nd shot, use a gauntlet bow to fake out and regrip while risky reloading the next round.

Weapon would probably be a flintlock musket if dumping str entirely with something like halfling, arquebus if not.

On the crafting end of things, I've got nothing. Just take the skill to legend and use it for making stuff or making money during downtime.


So long as your shield is a buckler, you have the hand free needed for battle medicine, drinking some elixer round 1, tripping or whatever else.

Since your party is one big question mark, and since I'm not sure if you're playing 01-05 or only starting at 05, here's a sample build

Ancestry: Human
Heritage: Aiuvarin
Background: Laborer
Stats: +4/+0/+2/+0/+2/+1

01: nimble elf, defensive advance
02: dual weapon warrior dedication
03: toughness
04: deity domain
05: general training (fleet)

Basic opener will be to drink an elixer from your alch and defensive advance in to raise shield and strike before following up with double slices with your main weapon and whatever you attach to your shield and raising your shield as a 3rd action. As stated, the open hand from using a buckler also enables trips, grapples, battle medicine, whatever.

Nimble elf and fleet increase your engagement range. Deity domain can be anything, you just want an extra focus point for lay on hands.

Buy a pair of weapon siphons and attach them to your weapon and shield and stock them with cheap bombs to push your damage a little higher.


4 people marked this as a favorite.

I would have liked all the post combat healing to not exist. Mostly it boils down to drawing straws on who the local medicine bot is so they can lock in one legendary skill and all their skill feats until level 6-8 or else forcing it on the rogue since they have extra. Then, also locking in their main exploration activity so that their primary interaction with the game world is hp recovery.

It's boring, it's tedious, it's marginally useful for time pressure and preventing full heals between chain encounters but you could also just run chain severes/extremes/extreme+ or simply declare combat isn't over so no healing occurs.

For the verisimilitude argument, well, PF2 has so throughly abandoned it on the mechanical side that it's not really a consideration for me anymore. Full post combat recovery wouldn't even be a blip on the radar.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Sadly, winning initiative is most important on casters to deploy buffs, debuffs, etc and they're the ones stuck with bad perception. Definitely the ones that most benefit from initiative bonuses and getting initiative into a scaling skill like stealth.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

The specialty crafting skill feat gives you a +1/+2 circumstance bonus to some subset of crafting, with alchemy being one of the options.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

I'd care a lot more about forcible energy if witch's elemental betrayal hex didn't exist. Same action cost, available as early as level 4, scales higher (5 at 13, 6 at 17), progresses focus point count, doesn't lock you into an elemental spell and can actually be cast before one so you can benefit from the weakness twice (on cast and the following turn even w/o sustain). I guess being level 12 feat is what allows you to use it from 500ft away with artillery spells, but somehow I don't find that particularly valuable.

Convincing illusion is a great feat for an aiuvarin wis or cha caster though. Easy to poach at 9,10,12 with multitalented if you're so inclined.


Warpriest really is your best bet here. Your rank 1 slots are for magic weapon until everyone gets their weapon runes and then you can move into bless afterwards.

Since you don't want to play a control caster, you can start +3/0/+2/0/+2/+2 and go right up champion for the reaction. For your other spells, just pick generic buffs or saveless whatever. You can use gortle's spell guide if you don't know what the good spells are.

Alternatively, since you seem like you only want some casting out of a feeling of obligation in a 0 caster party, skip all that and just play whatever.


Cantrip/rank 1 is 2gp and you missed a 3rd rank spell.

2x18 + 5x6 + 3x16 is 114. Though the base cost is actually 115 since you spend 1gp on a blank book.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

I do find pf2e's exploration mode rather tedious compared to how exploration works in pre-2000s and OSR systems or the more "open world" style of 3.x and its derivatives where there's little or no distinction between exploration and combat actions.

Follows the usual trend of pf2e making player characters less and less competent by restricting them to one or two things at a time if you take some feats or have a refocus that can be done while doing something else.

Just another one of those things where I wish they'd either commit harder to being a full-on game or else just get out of the way.


Deriven Firelion wrote:

Magic users can very easily deal with a fighter using Disruptive Stance, rooting, and two reactions at the higher levels if you don't stick them in a 30 foot room. That can be said of most monsters.

A lot of tactics I get railed on for I use with enemies too. I do not put caster enemies in 30 foot rooms waiting to get surrounded and jacked. Magic users need room to maneuver and keep enemies at range so they can bring the hard hammer down. Up close magic using enemies just get wasted by almost any martial or group of martials. Disruptive Stance just becomes overkill.

Caster in a small room alone one of the easiest to beat enemies in the game. Found that out fairly early in PF2 and adjusted as DM to not let that occur as I feel like I'm wasting the player's time making or running such encounters.

I wouldn't particularly fear an enemy caster at any range that isn't 500 tbh. They're just too easy to invalidate with silence 4, slow and trip even before you do stuff like rooting or dusrupt stance, and even at that range the only thing they're firing are AoE damage spells you can trivially deal with.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Quote:
A party of four PCs is run by four players, who had many sessions to practice complex tactics together. A party of four enemies is run by a single GM who can barely remember their abilities. The GM can devise some group tactics in advance, but won't be as mentally nimble as the players in devising new tactics on the spot.

The takeaway from this being that maybe people should come up with synergistic enemy comps designed to push optimized party setups or be immune to typical strategies to devalue their opening rounds and add tension that way.

We have plenty of player facing resources, why not a gm combat composition compendium?


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Errenor wrote:
ScooterScoots wrote:
I would add contingency + containment to this list, for the characters who can cast contingency off wand. Use it to block line of effect on the most dangerous attacks targeting you. You’ll be stuck in the containment but that’s well worth blocking a big scary melee monster crit or a boss’s spell. And the enemy will sometimes break you out...

If you meant it like this, I will never allow this combo to prevent any attack or spell. You get hit and then it puts you in containment.

"using the same restrictions as for the trigger of a Ready action"
Also, 'on crit' triggers are absolutely impossible, doubly. And so are any 'on targeting'.
If this is a topic about practical advice, this is important.

It is very practical. Reactions already exist in the game that trigger off being targeted or retroactively after already being hit or even critically hit. Why would contingency, a 7th rank spell which lets you build a reaction with a custom trigger, be unable to use those same trigger conditions or the same retroactive ability to negate actions?


Hedge mage at 2
Basic casting at 4
Peer past the hedge as a skill feat
Investigator at 6
Stratagem at 8

That's the best I've got atm unless you have access to the legacy uncommon tattoo feat for humans


3 people marked this as a favorite.

Should probably also include the other generic stuff like skill boosters, speed boosters, perception booster, flight and apex that every character picks up.

Level 01
Gauntlet bow - fake out activator - gunslingers and anyone with the archetype - if 2h gun, release hand as a free action and end your turn unloaded so you can fake out and regrip as part of reloading next round. If 1h gun or bow, just wear on off-hand

Weapon siphon + bombs - free damage - melee magi and melee dual wielders that bypass the increased MAP

Level 02
Silver Salve - silver bonuses - martials

Level 03
Jolt coil - electric arc access - casters who need it

Snapleaf - feather fall - everyone. cheap, beats cliffs, pit traps and any flying monster that tries to lift you up and drop you

Level 05
Shifting spider collar + energy mutagens - free damage - 1h melee martials, doesn't work for unarmed

Level 06
Phantasmal doorknob - 1/enemy free dazzle on crit - every martial - low priority compared to greater version

Staff of illusions - some of the best spells in the game that don't need heightening - casters, especially spont casters that can heighten if needed

Level 08
Potion patch + potion of quickness - single action haste - all characters, too expensive to be realistic until later, but cauldron witch can supply free potions at this level

Level 11
Mask of uncanny breath - suffocation cheese strat enabler - melee martials

Master magus ring - 1/day free action teleport - good on everyone

Other focus items - free focus point - applicable classes, generally low priority item

Level 12
Greater doorknob - 1/enemy free blind on crit - martials, still good post-nerf

Stunning snares + damage snares - push strat & quandry payoff - anyone with snarecrafter archetype, pair with kineticist berms for big push payoffs or deploy in enemy space after quandry for free damage+stun

Level 15
Major saurian spike - precise scent - all characters


3 people marked this as a favorite.

Is this really any different from grabbing a staff of summoning and having a whole bunch of 1st rank summon fodder to minesweep? Or just using useless 1st rank slots at later levels.


Yeah, it scales better with crits than gouging claw+force fang, doesn't rely on bleed ticks (either immunity or it not stacking with other instances of bleed) and forces the opponent to choose between automatic fire damage or moving and eating AoOs even on a miss, so fang's auto damage isn't even an advantage.


Easl wrote:

This is not my experience. In our game, the kineticist only does 'drop a tree every round' against L+2 or L+3 bosses, because they crit the party easily, crit succeed at saves, etc. In that case, wiping the double damage down to trivial damage every round is a major asset because (a) the enemy will get their turn, (b) the enemy will hit you, and (c) focused fire will not necessarily bring the enemy down fast.

In contrast, when we're facing a moderate encounter like L+0 x 2, the kin doesn't bother with the tree; those are ones where 'fast focus firepower' is better because with a good chance to hit or have the enemy fail saves, the party going full offense can often kill an opponent either before they get a second turn or even before they get a first.

Not all creatures are created equal. If spamming the tree was enough to defang a +3 boss to that extent, you (or paizo) picked a bad creature to make a +3 boss, or it was played badly. I don't really consider a +2 creature to be a boss unless it's paired with a second +2 creature or multiple minions that buff it the same way players abuse buffs and debuffs.

As for moderates, meh. Moderates and below can be cleared without expending a single resource. They may as well not even exist unless you have some complex victory condition, some truly egregious terrain advantage or immense time pressure to clear the fight in x rounds.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Not really. If you can clear a fight where one character did little more than mitigate 10*rank strike damage every round, the fight probably wasn't difficult enough to matter in the first place.


Shield isn't nearly valuable enough to skip on aiuvarin's better saves.

Cooperative nature is unnecessary when the aid dc is as low as it is. Proud mentor is also overkill for hedging against a natural 1 on the aid check. You can also use either of those feat slots to grab shield with an elf feat if you really want it.


Quote:
It is worth noting that the tree does not work well in aerial combat (with allies in flight) for obvious reasons.

Certainly, but the kineticist archetype is funny in that you can get useful stuff and exit early like protector tree and produce and then let it sit until 16 where you gain unlimited all-day party flight or infinite invisibility.

Also helps to keep in mind that nothing is stopping you from spawning the tree along a wall or from a ceiling which makes using it during indoor aerial combat more of a possibility.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
SuperParkourio wrote:
Cyclonic Ascent does have a downside in that it only works on the user. The fly spell can target one touched creature. Timber Sentinel is just unlimited uses of protector tree without the manipulate trait.

Level 14 makes it unlimited full party flight. Also a popular archetype feat for level 16.

Not uncommon to see some casters and ranged characters grab protector tree and then add air for cyclonic ascent.


shroudb wrote:
HammerJack wrote:
gesalt wrote:

If you're a melee character you're contractually obligated to buy a collar of the shifting spider and a large stack of energy mutagens to use with it.

If you're also dual wielding or make only one attack each turn, you then buy 1 or 2 weapon siphons and a large stack of bombs to use with them.

Makes it easy to cover elements between three runes and 1-3 extra alchemical damage ticks of others.

If you do this, remember that you need to keep a hand free to activate it during initiative. A lot of people try to keep both of their hands full all the time, even before an encounter starts, and this is one of the many things incompatible with that plan.

I'm pretty sure that particular rule has eluded a lot of the writers of the items as well, so I do tend to be much more forgiving as a GM as well.

Prime example is stuff like Propulsive boots:
"You stomp three times and gain the quickened condition for 1 minute."

where by the RAW you need a free hand to "stomp 3 times"...

Do you need a free hand? As far as I know you just need a valid appendage, not that it needs to be free/unused.

Edit: oh I see now. It's in the activate an item rules that having the manipulate trait means it's an interact and that interact specifies needing a free hand. How bothersome. Still works as a prebuff at least.


If you're a melee character you're contractually obligated to buy a collar of the shifting spider and a large stack of energy mutagens to use with it.

If you're also dual wielding or make only one attack each turn, you then buy 1 or 2 weapon siphons and a large stack of bombs to use with them.

Makes it easy to cover elements between three runes and 1-3 extra alchemical damage ticks of others.


5 people marked this as a favorite.

By all means Unicore, put your money where your mouth is and tell us all about these great niche spells that surpass the meta spells to such a high degree that it makes the wizard worth playing over an arcane sorc when you have prep time and advance knowledge.

Tell us also about these great downtime spells that arcane sorc definitely doesn't have room for, either in their spellbook or simply taken as a spell known after you've taken one or two meta combat spells.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

What would I need to care about the pf2e wizard...

Remove the idiotic school restriction on their 4th slot.

Some very powerful arcane silver bullets that reward prep time and learning a lot of spells. Similar to how divine can punish undead and such, give arcane the tools to break normal scaling on targets with the right traits.

Similar to the above, bonuses that scale directly with spells known. Everything from discounting the cost on the learn a spell table to empowering your spells with things learned from other spell formulae.

All the theses. If not for free, then offered as feats or for free as options at certain levels. Not like anyone's picking anything other than blend or sub anyway.

I would love an option to increase DC in exchange for giving up any chance of an enemy crit fail. Call it regulated magic or something and give +1 DC and then +2 DC to first remove crit failure and then crit success. Never liked the 4 degree of success system in the first place.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

As far as I can tell, nothing about Learn a Spell limits you to only learning spells of a rank you can currently cast, as long as you can pass the checks.

Hedge mage is the only thing explicitly limiting you to cantrips and nothing about the other feats lifts this limitation.


4 people marked this as a favorite.
Quote:
Some of us really like that there is a class that affords us as players the ability to test our creativity and ability to prepare for adventures. Other people really don't like the class because missing on a plan is a much bigger set back to the wizard than to any other class.

As much as I also enjoy this sort of thing, pf2e doesn't provide it. There is a distinct lack of silver bullet spells that significantly outperform the generic top tier spells in niche scenarios that makes this sort of thing rewarding.


5 people marked this as a favorite.
AestheticDialectic wrote:
gesalt wrote:

The pf2e wizard simply offers nothing mechanically good or interesting compared to other casters. You could delete the whole class and nothing of value would have been lost.

If I ever want to play a scholar-caster again I'll just save it for a system where it isn't bad.

Whatever problems the class has, this hyperbole hurts your case. Having the most top slots at minimum is mechanically good

5 inflexible prepared slots with blending with 1 locked often as not to a mediocre spell is inferior to 4 spontaneous slots I can use on whichever top-tier spell as needed.

So no, I don't think the wizard is mechanically good and would recommend that nobody ever play one in this system.

Edit: not to mention how much better CHA is as a stat, the better focus spells, etc


1 person marked this as a favorite.

The pf2e wizard simply offers nothing mechanically good or interesting compared to other casters. You could delete the whole class and nothing of value would have been lost.

If I ever want to play a scholar-caster again I'll just save it for a system where it isn't bad.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Start with making striding less of an issue I guess.

How to increase one's reach

Don't suppose there's anything stopping you from doing the same thing melee magi do where you dump int and do the usual champion archetype line for plate armor, the reaction and a focus point or nimble reprisal?


Aside from what Deriven said

Shifting spider collar for free action energy mutagen at combat start

Eye slash as the perception item because it doesn't get in the way of any other face items like a goz mask

Soaring flight tattoo if you have no other source of permanent flight

Items for your three legendary skills

Greater phantasmal doorknob

Greater saurian spike if you want precise scent

Lesser potion patches with potions of quickness for single action haste at combat start

Nothing barbarian specific really. Just about every character in this system looks near identical when it comes to items.


Ancestry: Elf
Heritage: Ancient

Ability modifiers: 0/3/1/0/1/4

01: nimble elf or otherworldly magic (electric arc, swashbuckler dedication (from ancient elf)
02: multifarious muse (maestro)
03: adopted ancestry (human)
04: basic flair (one for all)
05: natural ambition (reach spell), boost dex/con/wis/cha
06: dirge of doom or any focus spell (mostly for an extra focus point)
07: fleet or toughness

That should cover the early game. Grab a bow, sit at range. Lingering inspire from maestro is a 3 round buff and one for all is a good use of your 3rd action and reaction. Reach spell is useful if you ever need it. Skills are performance, diplomacy, and any one of your choice.

Pick the usual good spells and it basically plays itself.


Makes me miss human's 3boost/2flaw that got killed by the patch that gave everyone 2boost.

From an optimization perspective, there is a very short list of ancestries that matter and it's more down to ancestry feats or heritage bonuses than boosts and flaws. Off the top of my head, only halfling is really considered for its boosts since they're ideal for many rogues and ranged builds while also having great ancestry feats.

With that in mind, I don't think you have anything to worry about. At worst, an ancient elf puts their con flaw somewhere else instead of doing 2boost/0flaw


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Start with the new character wealth table and project upward from there as that tends to lowball what characters end up with from natural progression.

In my experience though the budget for random nonsense is still kinda thin and mostly comes from just getting something neat as a do instead of paying for it. I've also seen pure casters use their extra budget from not needing a weapon to accelerate martial item progression since they don't really scale well with items.


3 people marked this as a favorite.
pauljathome wrote:
gesalt wrote:


I'm not sure I'd call any system that prints options directly to a ban list as "brilliant." Makes me wonder why they waste page space on it really.
You're right, that WOULD be silly. Good thing that in no way whatsoever resembles the Rarity system as it currently exists

When a card game like ygo adds cards to a ban list, no player may put those cards into their decks or are limited in how they may add them to their decks (limit, semi-limit, etc). This can, of course, be modified at your own kitchen table games.

When paizo adds rarity to an option, no player may put those options on their character sheet or are limited in how they may add them to their sheet (the access rules, common things that add uncommon things, etc). This can, of course, be modified at your own kitchen table games.

By all means, tell me how those two things are different in any meaningful manner.

PossibleCabbage wrote:
Yeah, everything with a rarity canonically exists somewhere in the Universe. It might just be the case that it doesn't exist in your immediate vicinity and you have to go somewhere to encounter it. Even "disruptive" rarity stuff (like teleport) is just something that gets restricted while it's bypassing plots, but eventually you're just going to give it to your characters unless "the journey" is the entire point of the campaign.

I'm not quite sure what your point is here. If players can't take it then it's banned, whether it exists in universe or not.

I'm not arguing against a ban list, I've used one too often in other systems and on a campaign by campaign basis. I just find the rarity ban list to be a failure of a ban list, and that so many things go straight onto it to be an absolute waste of paper, ink and dev time.


Well yeah, plenty of stuff is going to be build dependant, but I want to know about it all anyway.


Given the long rarity thread, I decided I'd like to ask around about what people consider the best stuff locked behind paizo's rarity tags.

I want to be clear that I don't care about flavor in the slightest here. I want the stuff you'd bring to extreme+ combats and all the good non-combat utility so that you can just ship a list of good stuff off to the gm and save your whole group some time, or if the gm says something like,

Unicore wrote:
I also tell my players before session 0 that they can have one uncommon option without having to run it by me, but they can still ask about any number of others.

then you know what stuff to grab.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Quote:
The brilliance of the rarity system is that the GM doesn't have to look at any uncommon options at all unless one of their players comes to them asking about them, or they are trying to come up with something like a speciality shop or an uncommon treasure. The GM doesn't have to go looking for options to rule out.

I'm not sure I'd call any system that prints options directly to a ban list as "brilliant." Makes me wonder why they waste page space on it really.

I am sort of curious though. Among all the uncommon spells, items and feats that are actually good, how many of them don't just get banned?

I'm not super familiar with the full uncommon list myself, since I don't bother with stuff I can't be sure I'll get, but surely we can put together a good list of the strongest options around so others can just send that off to any prospective GMs to see what ends up banned at their tables.

Edit: decided to just make a separate thread for that


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Unicore wrote:
gesalt wrote:
PossibleCabbage wrote:
I think anything with an access option (like "being from a region") is pre-cleared from being disruptive in a mechanical sense, it just might not meet the aesthetic or thematic premise of the campaign but that's also potentially true of common options.
Except we already have instances of common options giving access to things that usually get banned (wizard schools, deity spells, etc) as well as examples up-thread of people just disregarding access conditions/rules anyway.

The thing about common options giving access to uncommon options is that the GM is no more forced to allow the player the uncommon option if it is going to ruin their game than they were if a player just asked for the spell in the first place. Hopefully a conversation happens with character creation, and the vast majority of the time I think most GMs are going to let players have uncommon options they are making build choices to enable, but it’s not like the GM can’t work with a player to change up curriculum spells or focus spells or whatever works out best for the whole table.

Again, the number one thing rarity tags accomplish, and why they always work, even when it feels like it could work better, is because it says, “pause for a second and check with your GM before picking this.”

Yeah, because it's just a ban list.

Hey Mr. GM, paizo has this thing on their default ban list. Is it on yours? To which the usual answers are:

1) Yes.
2) Yes, unless you meet access conditions or something else gives it to you.
3) Yes, unless your backstory meets some arbitrary criteria.
4) No.

And then you have some guys like Purple up there with funny answers like
5) Yes, but you can have one thing from the ban list.

1 to 50 of 1,636 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | next > last >>