Teridax wrote: I think that's kind of the underlying conclusion to this whole thread: just having spell slots and access to a spell list does not and should not make up the entirety of a class. The most popular casters around tend to have meaty core features that their spell slots supplement, and those whose features aren't distinct or revolve entirely around their slot spellcasting tend to disappoint. Prepared casting in my opinion isn't meant to operate on its own, and is at its most successful on a chassis that has lots of generally useful things to do. I think something very similar could be said for flexible spellcasting, which I think complements its own kind of playstyle. I generally agree with your statement. However, I still think unifying casting style across all casters provides one common ground so that casting classes (when comparing to one another) don't have to be evaluated for the drawbacks or benefits of their casting style, and instead can be written with a focus on providing that "meaty" bit in terms of features and feats. I don't personally find my value in have 2 (or 3 if you count flexible) casting style. I do agree that they feel different and have play styles, but I don't personally find my value in keeping them. But I suppose that's just my opinion.
WWHsmackdown wrote:
I'm with you on this, as that's more of what I'd like to see too. More class features and feats that add power and make the classes unique while spell casting is a bit more limited in terms of spell selection and access to doing "everything". Not less spells per day, or doing a thing less effectively, but not able to do as many types of things. In exchange for some really thematic and good focus spells and class features and feats. Again, classes like Sorcerer and Witch probably wouldn't notice that much because they already have great tools.
Phoebus Alexandros wrote:
With the context provided just prior to this post, I think this is a good way to go about it. "Hey adventure, you look strong! I'll give you a 20% discount if you fight my shop champion in the arena. Your weapons will be temporarily enchanted to deal non-lethal damage and you can't use damaging magic (though defensive, buffing, or debuffing magic is okay). You interested? If you are, give me 1 week to publicize the fight and sell tickets and then you can have the item with discount!"
moosher12 wrote:
Just a point of order, Starfinder draws the distinction between AI and VI as sapience vs non-sapience. Think of Siri or the Google Assistant from 5 years ago, those were VIs. I'm honestly not sure where current Claude or ChatGPT models fall on the Starfidner scale (which is kind of terrifying in itself) though I suspect it's closer to VI status than true AI status.
J-Bone wrote: If the use of AI can bring the price of these products down, I'm good with it. I can understand the pro-consumer sentiment in this, but keep in mind it means that artist (whether producing rules elements/concepts, rules text, or visual artistry) are going to be paid less or that there are less of them. Meaning you have a more people that will be paid less or out of a job. There is a balance to be struck, but I don't know where it's at. Also, with Paizo specifically, all the important rules elements/text are available for free on AoN (though it can take some time for them to be available on the website after release). In relation to the specific pictures being called out...I'm not sure if this a sloppy poor artist or AI work. I would encourage Paizo to investigate, talk with the (presumably) hired external artist and release some public statement.
Azothath wrote:
Not that I disagree with what you've written...but I'm struggling to understand the relevance to the OP's question/problem.
Unicore wrote:
But like...Gandalf is arguably barely a wizard (in the D&D/Pathfinder sense) based on thing we see him do. He is wise, and he is good at making plans. For example, giving the One Ring to a hobbit, because Gandalf knows hobbits are much harder to corrupt than man, elves, or dwarves. Only a hobbit could be the ring bearer. But that kind of activity and planning just isn't represented into the wizard class (IMO). The kind of activity and planning is really dependent on the GM giving you information and knowledge that you as a player couldn't possibly have or act on. Arguably, it might be better done as a bard using bardic lore to "know everything" (or another class that has similar ability). Which is not to say that Gandalf never uses magic, but his magic is a lot more subtle than the magic we typically think of being associated with a table top gaming wizard. To be honest, I would love to be able to play a Gandalf type character, but it would require a GM to give to much focus to an individual player and telling that player a lot of stuff in advance that wasn't shared with everyone else (I think) in order to be successful in game. It's kind of impossible to base a class around that.
Azothath wrote:
Edit: I realized as I was writing this point that I read your statements incorrectly, but wanted to share the following anyways: Gladiatorial combat was rarely to the death, and was primarily for sport/entertainment/betting. Most combatants were prisoners of war or slaves, but in either case the training, food, and housing for them was a significant cost and the the death of a gladiator would have been a significant loss of investment. In any event, I think having an arena for the city/nation that is magical to allow for entertainment that would otherwise push someone to death is a reasonable thing. But I agree it's beyond the means of most individual businesses.
There are lots of things to consider, but I want to specifically touch on the context of "lethal vs non-lethal" and "fist fights only?" questions. If you have a relatively high level (of availability of) magical setting, and default PF1 is decently high level magic, then it becomes reasonable to say "Oh, there is a magical ritual that prevents fighters from being killed inside the ring". So combatants can use all sorts of attack methods. Make it so that the ritual causes any injuries sustained to at worst reduce people to unconscious but never dead, and any afflictions suffered during the fight are removed by the magic when the person leaves the arena. Now you have "safe" fights where lethal force is allowed. But some combatants might try to find ways around the safe guards. It also opens the grounds for magical fighters to compete, like magus.
Unicore wrote: But taking away the ability to create plans for heists or dungeon invasions or village defense or for a public assassination or body guard duty or standard dungeon crawl or downtime kingdom operation day would be a loss for the game. Scrolls can allow for some of this, but just because you don’t think spells are powerful enough in the different things they can do doesn’t mean the answer is to take away the ability to cast those spells and deliberately narrow the game down to a small selection of spells every caster must take. I'm confused by this take, because I don't think that's what flexible spell casting would do. You're still preparing a group of spell for the day, but you can change what is prepared on a day to day basis. And you don't have to prepare per spell slot. So, you're still (potentially) changing your load it for guard duty vs a dungeon crawl vs downtime. If anything, for spontaneous casters you're forcing them to choose the most generically effective spells and relying on scrolls to make the difference. And prepared casters have to guess how many casting of a particular spell they need in a day. And unless your GM is working with you to really forecast that, you're probably going to be wrong.
In my opinion, the juice is not worth the squeeze. Players will just be converting back and forth for their own understanding when important, and ignore it otherwise. If you want to sprinkle in some background by saying "this civilization using a different form of time keeping that all your characters would be familiar with, but you as people are not so we're going to talk in units you're familiar with" that's fine. But it would be as bad as starting to describe distances in new made up units "just to make the world unique" without adding any real value for players. Describe things in units your players are familiar with, unless you enjoy forcing them to do conversions. It'd be about like describing everything in furlongs. How long is that sword? 45 ten-thousandths of a furlong (~3ft). Why do that to players or yourself?
AestheticDialectic wrote: In a system where all casters are flexible, why would we have any class except the sorcerer who can choose to be any tradition? What is the thematic difference in casting between an arcane sorcerer, a wizard, and an arcane witch? Why can sorcerers now prepare spells? That's kind of my point though. You would be forced to actually make the classes matter, and be unique through their features and feats. Sorcerers are in a pretty good place. Wizards, as discussed, lack much of identity that makes them thematic or strong if we imagine a future where both the sorcerer and wizard are flexible casters. So! The answer is to give all classes features and feats that actually make them worth writing. And if you (a theoretical developer "you") can't figure out why or how to make that class unique, interesting, and strong then maybe it shouldn't exist. A hot take on my side, as the wizard exist now in PF2, other than being a legacy class and because it is "the" arcane class shouldn't exist. It doesn't have enough to justify it's existence other than it's a prepared spell caster limited to the arcane tradition, which is just enough different from say an Imperial Bloodline sorcerer that it still exists...but only because it's prepared arcane. The witch has their Patron and familiar and hexes to make it unique and interesting. Sorcerers have their bloodlines and some great feats. Wizards...have their spell book, except it doesn't really matter much as currently written. In some future edition I can imagine different things it could be used for, even as a flexible caster. Imagine the wizard has prepared whatever group of spells for the day....but they encounter a (non-combat) challenge that doesn't align with their prepared spells. That's okay! They could have a class feature that allows them to use their spell book to cast any spell from the their spell book, using their spell slots, but the casting time takes one minute per spell rank. Now the wizard is incredibly versatile out of combat! I guess at the end of the day, I don't think type of casting (prepared vs spontaneous) or spell casting tradition are good reasons to have a class exist since those are shared across many classes. I mean, we have the witch that can be any tradition using different patrons and is prepared. We have sorcerers that can be any tradition and is spontaneous. Why do we need any other casters? (This is rhetorical). Because, the witch and sorcerer both have specific themes and abilities outside those features. And we want other classes that have different themes and abilities. And in my mind, unifying the casting type highlights the unique parts of a class in a way that should encourage developers to make different classes have a strong theme and strong abilities.
YuriP wrote:
You're spot on with my what I wanted to examine. I've kind of stepped away from this thread because it became an argument primarily about the wizard, which I don't actually care about specifically in this context. The wizard has problems. I think those problems are made worse by prepared casting and how it works. But solving it wasn't what made me pose the question. I also think that the "balancing act" that the devs do in terms of balancing the bonuses and drawbacks of the different types of casting make several classes unequal. I would prefer to unify it, because then effort could be spent on actually making class have a strong identity and giving them worthwhile class features, while also having a common basis for the power of their "main feature" of spell casting. Remember, my questions was geared toward a future edition, not an attempt to house rule the current edition. Also, I don't think prepared or spontaneous casting actually does anything to make a class unique or interesting, since it's shared by several other casters as a mechanism.
Errenor wrote: Great question! I suppose there should be a distinction in the rules between hurtful pain and painful hurt! The designers clearly fell short of the target! Is it cunningly brutal or brutally cunning? Alls I know is you gots a zoggin' krumpin' either way. But if you want to know pain...ask Slannesh.
Unfortunately it's left to GM interpretation to decide what is a "pain effect". However, even if a GM decides it's nothing, the other benefits are pretty good. Gaining darkvision (if you didn't have it), poison and disease resistance, paralysis and sleep protection, as well as a bonus to saves with the emotion trait.
Kinda, but also not really. We all know spells are magical. Rather than adding the magical tag to each spell, they tell you in the Chapter 7 (of the Core Rule Book, I think, AON isn't clear) that spells gain the tag of their spell casting tradition based on class, which is what you said. And we know those tags also make it clear that items or spells with the tag are magical. They don't add the magical tag to every spell because it'd be thousands (probably, I didn't count) of tags to say something obvious. They don't add the tradition trait tag, because it's possible to get a spell added to a character that isn't on the spell list they normally access (like Clerics and spells their deity provides), and they would have needed some rule about removing/substituting that tag. So yes, in a very technical way only that rule "enforces" that spells are magical, but it's also just the conceit of how the rules on spells are written.
Easl wrote: Sidebar, but I find it intriguing that the runesmith can substitute a skill tag (arcana, occult, primal, or divine) for the magic tag, thus creating a non-magical basic save effect. AFAIK, those are rare to nonexistent. There are some legacy monsters for which this is perfect (golem and wisp, I'm looking at you); you get the "damage on a miss" benefit of spells, while getting around magic/spell immunities. I don't think that works that way, unfortunately. Magical Trait wrote: Something with the magical trait is imbued with magical energies not tied to a specific tradition of magic. Some items or effects are closely tied to a particular tradition of magic. In these cases, the item has the arcane, divine, occult, or primal trait instead of the magical trait. Any of these traits indicate that the item is magical. Arcane Trait wrote:
The arcane, divine, primal, and occult traits don't make it not magical, they make it a more specific magic.
Yes, it's true that holy is more like an associative property, in that it's really the individual who has it and it applies to everything they do...but I personally find it helps to think of it as "you're making a piercing attack, which is also holy...so it's a holy piercing attack". I guess what I'm trying to point out is that the vitality damage and holy damage are separate, and that holy applies to all of it, which is relevant if someone is immune to portions of the damage being inflicted.
Tridus wrote:
I knew there was an errata, but couldn't remember the details and also I remember I personally disagreed with the conclusion, which I think is why I don't remember the details.
Yeah, to expand a bit, if the weapon (let's say a composite shortbow with a striking rune) would deal 2d6+ (1/2) strength damage (which is all piercing damage) to an enemy. You infuse vitality on the weapon. The weapon would deal an additional 1d4 vitality damage (if cast as a rank 1 spell). Vitality damage is normally not applicable to living creatures. If you have the holy trait (such as a sanctified cleric) the attacks also become Holy. So you would deal Holy piercing damage, and Holy Vitality damage. A demon with holy weakness doesn't take the vitality damage, but the piercing damage also is holy damage, which they have weakness to. An undead creature with weakness to holy damage...I'm not sure if the weakness get applied twice since it's two different damage types (holy piercing) and (holy vitality).
I sometimes start combat (if we know one is about to happen) with a consumable in hand but that's kind of the extent of it. I almost never try to pull out a consumable mid combat dropping my grip on a two handed weapon. It's worth saying that I mostly play martial characters, which tend toward using two-handed weapons, or sword and shield, or two-weapon fighting. My point is, there's not that many martial character builds that intentionally leave hands open. Casters are a bit of a different story and depends on what the player intends to do with the character.
What's interesting is:
However, if you had to use Trick Magic Item, I think you would have to use Religion skill to successfully trick it. This could lead to an interesting thing, where like fighter multiclass wizard who worships Erastil could get a faith tattoo with Sure Strike in it, and have a backup Sure Strike available to them.
The main thing to me, is that the item (Faith Tattoo) specifically calls out that to activate it, you use the Cast A Spell activity. That means, if you can't cast a spell you can't use the item. Imagine that the tattoo is basically storing the power of a spell inside of it, and you're using your spell casting to coax that power out. But it's not your magical power, it's the power that it stored in the tattoo (that regenerates daily). That's why the DC and spell rank are based on the item. Now, if you have Trick Magic Item you could use that (which is its own action) to allow you to use the item.
ElementalofCuteness wrote:
Yep, guns are only good/better if you're getting critical hits. And even with a gunslinger's higher than most proficiency, it's not enough to make critical hits common. I would honestly rather have a firearm that is 1d8, reload 0, martial proficiency, 1 or 2 hands I don't care, and 50ft or more range. I think that's fair, it's not going to be broken. But the game blocks you from that.
You make a great point about Flurry of Blows/Feral Combat Training with Wild Shape. Especially if we look at the Allosaurus form the OP mentions wanting to use. The allosaurus has a bite and 2 claws. The claws aren't as good as the bite, but they aren't so much worse that it makes getting Flurry with the Bite substantially better. It's not until 8th level where the monk can make flurry of blows with 4 attacks that it's better than the 3 attacks provided by that wildshape form.* *Edit: Of note I'm actually not remembering the rules on how to combine the BAB when multiclassing between monk and another class to determine when you get additional attacks with Flurry of Blows. So the progression will be worse because Druid is not a full BAB class. Taking Feral Combat Training can probably wait until at whatever point the character would get access to 4 attacks from FoB. I'd focus on getting natural spell, weapon focus (in whatever natural attack is most common in the forms you like to you), and shaping focus. While mage armor and barkskin can help with AC issues, we shouldn't overlook needing another caster to use a wand of mage armor. And we shouldn't overlook that Beast Shape and other spells that Wildshape emulates grant some natural armor (that won't stack with barkskin).
It's still not sustainable though. It mitigates it to an extent, but you could blow through the 4 guns you have attuned. Also typical turn order would be:
You can repeat that 4 times and then you're out of guns. How often are you going to miss on your Risky Reload? Under this rotation its your second attack in a turn, and thus suffering from MAP which is bad. I suppose if you started a turn by Risky Reloading (by having your gun empty at the end of the previous turn you could avoid that, but then you're purposefully not taking a shot in the 1st round).... You have a point, but it's a band-aid (better than most) to a problem that doesn't really need to exist IMO.
AestheticDialectic wrote:
The problem (from my perspective) is your mixing real world descriptions and ideas with game world stuff. And the devs did it/do it too. And so does everyone else. So I see what you're getting at. But within the game world, Arcane magic isn't "ecret knowledge, mysterious, esoteric etc". The wizard class thematically, in universe lore, is the class that is approaching magic in a scientific way. And while they've figured out a lot of stuff, just like with physics (especially) science still hasn't figured out everything.
gesalt wrote:
Gunner's bandolier also doesn't solve it because you need to spend an action to "activate" the runes on it. You can't use it with Quick Draw as The Raven Black Mentions. It's better than some other options, and works better with Risky Reload than other options, but still doesn't really get you there.
Squark wrote:
That's a good analogy, the UPB is kind of like the Gold Standard was for real world currency, where 1 UPB (which is likely a volume) is equal to one (digital) credit.
That only works at early levels though Gesalt, once you start putting runes on your weapon...it's too expensive to maintain multiple weapons with up to date runes. That's why we have doubling rings and blazons of shared power. Both allow you to have two weapons with maximum runes, without the price. But the blazons only work for a pair of weapons, you can't hot swap them like you can with doubling rings. So no Risky Reload and drawing new weapons doesn't really fix it. If Risky Reload didn't cause misfire on a miss, or if blazons of shared power allowed you to give the runes to any ranged weapon in your off hand then it would work.
Red Griffyn wrote:
When you sell your gear, you generally only get 50% of the original value. That is why if you convert it to UBP you get 50% of the original value as polymer when converting. Universal Polymer Base Conversion wrote: These services can be found at most major settlements and allows the conversion of any tech gear into its base components, resulting in 50% of the equipment's value in UPBs. Because credits and polymer are interchangeable 1 to 1. The only 100% is converting between UBP to credit (or credit to UBP).
Easl wrote:
It's true that OP's example was about Exemplar's and not gunslingers, though if the fixes we've discussed we're available to gunslinger, they would also become available to multiclass gunslingers. I'm taking your above suggesting to be things that example could combine would reloading (as a hypothetical). If one could combine reload with Gaze as Sharp as Steel, then I would say absolutely worth it. Skin as Hard as Horn...I don't actually like that much because it's easy to pick a damage type that isn't as relevant, or at least that you will encounter monsters that can go around it. If it was resistance to all physical damage, or even if you could choose two out of the 3...
Easl wrote:
I general don't find them impactful, because I guess I find them too specific. Like, generally speaking I don't want a gun slinger who mixes it up in melee. So the ability to reload and make a melee attack is something I distinctly don't want. Intimidation to demoralize can be good, but the penalty against things that don't share your language hurts. But it's honestly the best of the ways. Way of the Sniper's ability to hide after shooting isn't bad...but in general sniping just doesn't work well with a party or typical gameplay. And the others are honestly all very niche, IMO. Like, you could honestly give every gunslinger all the Slinger's Reload ability from every way, and I still think people would have a hard time to find a use most of them. Thinking about it from another perspective, if the gunslinger had abilities that let them get off 4 shots per 2 rounds instead of 3, would that be too strong? Would it put them above the damage curve for bows? You could theoretically do that with the imaginary feat I suggested that would allow you to reload and strike (in either order) once per round. It's basically Risky Reload, without the potential misfire penalty. Use that and running reload to fire, reload/fire, reload/move (repeat). Would that be bad? Alternatively, I'm open to hearing ideas for actions that are of "near equal value" to a strike that could be coupled with reloading. Demoralize is the only one that I think comes close, besides Running Reload. But you don't always want to reposition. And if you're fighting a single boss, you'll get to make one intimidate and then the boss is immune. Even when you have multiple targets, they're not usually all going to be useful to actual intimidate. And not being able to extend the frightened condition and the immunity...it just doesn't work that well IMO.
SuperBidi wrote:
Yeah, that sounds awful (in the context of PF2). Not every GM is fit for every kind of game.
Easl wrote:
At a macro level, I agree (almost) no one (except flurry rangers) should be making more than 2 attacks per round, so if the Gunslinger could make 4 attacks over two rounds, they'd be fine. But as it is, gunslinger only make 3 attacks in 2 rounds. If they had something they could do that felt generally impactful to make up for that lost attack I'd feel they were okay. The option to move (via running reload) is only partial there. Because I don't feel like you need to reposition every turn. Heck, if there was an ability that let you reload and aim (providing a bonus on the next shot taken before the end of the next round) that might be worth it. As you may have guessed, I don't find the additional weapon traits to be worth the action cost of reloading. Ultimately, I find the balance struck with reloading to be...underwhelming.
Yeah, the UPB conversion rule is there because you could sell an item for 50% of the item value listed in the rule book. Instead you can also simply covert it to UPB, instead of selling it and then using that money to buy UPB at a 1:1 ratio with the credits, it works out to the same value/amount of credit/UPB.
Easl wrote:
I'm actually surprised there aren't items/archetype to support having a bunch of holstered pistols that you quick draw. Of course the main problem is also keeping up with runes required to keep them relevant (because quick draw does this and does allow for what I'm describing, but at high levels breaks down because of runes). There are blazons of shared power, but they link a specific pair of weapons. You can't hot swap in a secondary weapon.
Squiggit wrote:
Agreed. To me, gunslinger using firearms feels pretty awful (though one using crossbows can be good). A gunslinger shouldn't be overwhelmingly better than other ranged classes, but it shouldn't substantially feel worse either.
Mathmuse wrote: But reload weapons can be used reasonably well in functional builds if the character has a reason to never take more than one shot per turn anyways. Actually, I absolutely agree with this statement. The problem is, most people who want to use firearms want to do so focusing primarily on striking with firearms. Thus it ends up...challenging to find other things they should be doing that isn't striking or repositioning. I think the trouble is finding a non-strike activity that is really worth doing in general circumstances. Like intimidation (pistolero way) to demoralize is good sometimes, but not always useful (due to creature type). Running Reload partially fixes the problem, allowing you to reposition and reload (although you don't always want to reposition either). The real rub is finding/having another generically good activity to do that can combine with reloading to make you're turns feel less bad. I'm imagining (and I'm way out here) if a character could somehow cast a damage cantrip and reload their weapon. I suspect something like that would be a must choose option for every gunslinger.
Easl wrote:
As a GM, I would allow you to put the dagger pistol into the sheath, but when the Shadow copy comes out, it's not loaded. But you could throw it, just like a regular dagger that the melee portion of it is made to emulate. No sane GM should ever agree to letting you draw loaded shadow copies, it's clearly not an intended interaction.
The Raven Black wrote:
You do realize that the dagger pistol is a pistol, with a dagger mounted underneath and not a pistol that shoots daggers, right? it shoots regular ammunition. And I don't think reasonable people would believe that Shadow Sheath's description of "With an infinite array of darts, throwing knives, or similar weapons" is meant to include regular firearm ammunition. And even if did, it only allows you draw the item from the sheath as a free action. Not reload it into a firearm. It's an absolutely huge stretch to think it would allow for free reloads. But it does highlight that you could (probably) use a chakram (1d8, 20ft range) with the shadow sheath and throw weapons without the same dissatisfying action economy of firearms.
Mathmuse, I think the main thing is the people general want some way to make firearms not "suck". With the main issue being that firearms have action economy problems, with only being able to fire 3 shots in two rounds (assuming reload 1, and at the exclusion of doing anything else). And most of the action economy fixers, don't reduce that in any way, but do allow you do something else while reloading (that isn't firing). And then you compare that to the simplicity of using a bow...and it feels very disappointing. Heck, even just using the Crossbow Infiltrator archetype to dual wield repeating hand crossbow feels much better. But it absolutely misses the thematic parts of being a firearm. In general, firearms are just worse than bows or crossbow. I wish, looking back on things as they are now, we didn't necessarily have firearms, bow, and crossbows, but instead had ranged weapons with 1 handed and two handed configurations and different trait/properties (including reload time) and that anyone could decide represented these. Like imagine you had bow stats, but could call it a firearm. I mean, anyone would be free to do that in a home game.
I suppose so, I just wish it were a bit more explicit. I couldn't actually find the rules for integrated weapon in armor, but I'm also not familiar with all the SF2 rules. Ultimately I suppose I wished the written the special line a bit differently, saying something along the lines of "If you have a combat SRO heritage you can accommodate weapons that require two hands, but you're free weapon is limited to a martial one handed or simple two handed. Utilizing weapons mounted on your chassis still require you to use the proper number of appendages." Cause it's also not really clear if the weapon mount would replace a hand for instance. I think it probably doesn't and would actually be a bad idea to choose that. More likely being mounted on a forearm. And it doesn't address whether or not hands associated with using the weapon are otherwise blocked/occupied while the weapon is in use. Perhaps I'm just missing references to other relevant sections that cover these issues.
As a player, I quite like the idea that at least from a damage stand point, you can take fireball and heighten it up to your highest castable slot, and it be on par damage wise. It means someone who wants to "focus" on a single spell can do so. (I mean there's not really that much in PF2 that allows you to focus on a single spell, but you can choose to cast it a lot without being significantly worse off from heightening a low level spell versus casting a spell that becomes available at higher level). For example, Falling Star spell (randomly chosen) is a 9th level spell that deal 33 (avg) bludgeoning damage and 49 (avg) energy damage with a basic reflex save as a 9th level spell. That's 82 average damage total. A 9th level fireball will deal 63 average fire damage. It's 20ft burst vs falling stars more complicated larger coverage, which also has multiple energy types to select from. Falling stars is a better spell if you're looking for damage, but if you really want to cast fireball it's at least kinda keeping up. Anyways, my main point is the spells remaining useful by heightening them is a great feature. In theory, it reduces the amount of spells needed to be published because rather than producing damage spells of every energy type at every level, you can heighten lower version and periodically produce version that are better in other ways (and possibly also in damage). The flexible casting style plays into this even more. Which again, I think is a positive thing. Ultimately in my mind, in a PF33 future thought way, we don't need prepared or spontaneous. Just make everyone flexible and they can all have this nice QOL and flexibility without all this legacy baggage. I really don't see a reason to keep it other than some people just like the (old) things they like or like the additional challenge it imposes.
|