| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I don't know if I should vote for you. You make me giggle. You are well-written though...and your item's powers are clearly delineated...formatting is sound...but the imagery...
Oh, who am I kidding?
*bonk*
Calistrian item. Check.
Pamela made it as well
NEW ITEM! Interesting...because that class is in need of power...uh-huh.
Still better than its partner. Up-vote!
And the bag of MINE made it as well, weird.
interestingly enough at least one item that requires you to have another specific magic item before it can be used made it through the cut.
8 more votes, then I have work to do.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
And another new item! Man I love post-cull voting! :D
Ech, it would be decent spell-in-a-can item but the creator missed the fact that there exist spell doing exactly that. Item ended using up wrong spell in requirements and quite underpriced.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I am seeing new items too
OH NO. Items I refused to vote for against each other. WHY!?!?!?
Sadly, I must use my personal rules and vote for one...
Jesus, it's like I'm seeing nothing but new items now. I must really have been getting all the clunkers before...
So many items that I like in theory, but I just don't know what they do exactly. If, as a GM, I don't know how to arbitrate the effects of your item, I just can't vote for it no matter how cool the imagery.
I don't understand how some items could have made the cull, because some stuff really isn't Superstar, good, ok or average.
like the EMS item.....
I am slowly reaching point of seeing the same decent items again where timers becomes irritating...
Boots against boots. Who will kick whom?
Two items I really like against one another...I take back what I said about loving the post-cull vote. :p
Enough for today.
Post cull voting is all about making the choices between two good items. Those are the votes that count, the mediocre items still hanging around will simply be downvoted from here on.
I encourage people to avoid the neutral vote.
Post cull voting is all about making the choices between two good items. Those are the votes that count, the mediocre items still hanging around will simply be downvoted from here on.
I encourage people to avoid the neutral vote.
Theoretically you should always avoid the neutral vote. I would almost suggest they remove it in the future. If you don't know, just go with your gut and pick one. Your subconscious knows which you like better.
Owner - D20 Hobbies
,
Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Just hit Marathon!
163 of my last votes have been recorded.
258 unique items
Most of which I've seen before I started recording.
Still haven't seen my item.
Have they culled? Because the quality of items in the last 163 votes is significantly better than the first 48 hours of voting.
From comments I have seen, I believe yes.
Have they culled? Because the quality of items in the last 163 votes is significantly better than the first 48 hours of voting.
yes
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Timer is such a pain when you want to find your item.
Timer is such a pain when you want to find your item.
Amen!
...
Okay, I did not expect this particular item to make it post cull.
But hey, it's not a HORRIBLE item, either. Just ... a bit meh in my opinion.
Adamantine vs. Copper.
I melt them both down and sell them and become rich!
YES!
Adamantine vs. Copper.
I melt them both down and sell them and become rich!
YES!
Don't know how rich you would get off of copper.
you had plenty of words to spare, if you had given it a cool visual to tie it in better I could almost forgive your for that random power that you tacked on in the last sentence. As it is, once again a cool item becomes less cool through over tinkering.
Was not expecting this item to make it past the cull. It kind of breaks the "Takes up slot but doesn't take up this slot" rule.
...
Okay, I did not expect this particular item to make it post cull.But hey, it's not a HORRIBLE item, either. Just ... a bit meh in my opinion.
Yeah... I've seen a few of those too.
There have also been several that made me wonder what sort of encounter the player had that inspired that particular item.
...
Okay, I did not expect this particular item to make it post cull.But hey, it's not a HORRIBLE item, either. Just ... a bit meh in my opinion.
Yeah... I've seen a few of those too.
There have also been several that made me wonder what sort of encounter the player had that inspired that particular item.
I find it best if you don't speculate on that subject.
a consumable item that costs HOW much made it though the cull????
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Roll how many d6? This isn't Shadowrun, chummer.
Reminds of someone I know who likes to summon eagles. Sometimes he needs to roll 16d4 for his damage. I said well I have played shadowrun so if they were D6s he would have been set, but not so with D4s
hooded lanterns do not shine in cones, you're looking for bullseye.
New item. Would have been great if they'd studied up on the mechanics for that particular portion of the ruleset. Sadly, they didn't.
|
Owner - D20 Hobbies
,
Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8
|
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
1043 votes total (43rd after Marathon) and I finally found my item (post cull.)
Paired with a bad item, so that probably means I'm in the bottom section.
To top it off I noticed a grammar error, in a section of a last minute change. Advice to all, don't do last minute changes!
