Do ninjas have to be...ninjas?


Rules Questions


Hi, so there are a few character concepts that I have in my head, and I discover that mechanically, I rather like the Ninja class. It's groovy, they've got cool little tricks, so far so good.

But, do they have to be 'Ninjas'? You know, do they have to walk around in kimonos, do they have to have learned their trade from a ninja clan? Can I play a skulky, stealthy guy who's more European in nature, or who fits in better with the general 'tone' of Golarian?

Thank you for your help.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

You can flavor them anyway you like.

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Confining oneself to one kind of flavor due to the name of you class, is a completely made up restriction.

It happens waaaay too often.

It's sad really.


Well consider that ninja don't really have a specified uniform at all. Never in Japanese history did ninjas ever wear those black stealth suits you see in the movies - that's a convention from Kabuki plays when the ninja was introduced in a kabuki play wearing the costume of a kabuki stage handlers uniform (those black suits). In reality ninjas wear whatever would be best to blend in to the environment they are infiltrating - like a good spy. If infiltrating a temple or church you dress as a monk or clergy. If infiltrating a castle you dress as a samurai guard or household staff. Wearing a black suit only identifies you as someone not in the right place - they don't belong there.

With this in mind, even if using the ninja concept in a generally western setting, the ninja dresses like anybody else. Ninja are the skills and powers of the class, not the costume. It's only an occupation.

I think a secret organization of spies for any setting works well using ninjas as the operatives, and doesn't necessarily have anything to do with Japan.


Ninjas don't have to wear Shinobi Shozoku(the pj's.), nor use ninja stars, nor be from an Asian themed land. Barbarians don't have to be completely unintelligent, unsocial, mouth frothing, illiterates, and samurai don't have to wield a katana and commit seppuku immediately upon dishonor. I'm sure there are many more examples beyond that.

The names of the classes are just a label. Fluff is mutable.


Play the character you want.

I've got a dervish dancing Qadiran trader with loose morals and a taste for fine living whose character sheet happens to say "ninja." I've got a samurai from Minkai who shoots a yumi, wears tatami do and expounds on his heritage and the enemies he's defeated when challenging a worthy foe, and his character sheet happens to say "fighter." The name doesn't have any impact on the character, only the mechanics.

I miss the First Edition Oriental Adventures version of the ninja: You could only take it as a multiclass, sharing experience points and leveling up along with another class. And if anyone ever found out that you were a ninja you lost a boatload of honor, making the character almost unplayable until you fixed the situation.


Assassin's Creed as a ninja ftw


The mechanics are at your disposal to build the character that you want to play. Don't get hung up on the names that are placed on these items.

When my nephew uses his Star Wars and Harry Potter legos to build a rad sports car, I do not call him out and say that I never saw Professor Snape driving that thing on Tatooine.

Grand Lodge

Still, some people are down right dumbfounded that there isn't some sort of flavor restriction.

Even when confronted with reality, they put their hands over their ears and start saying "nah nah nah, I can't hear you".

Others, act like a child who has been told Santa Claus doesn't exist.


MrSin wrote:

Ninjas don't have to wear Shinobi Shozoku(the pj's.), nor use ninja stars, nor be from an Asian themed land. Barbarians don't have to be completely unintelligent, unsocial, mouth frothing, illiterates, and samurai don't have to wield a katana and commit seppuku immediately upon dishonor. I'm sure there are many more examples beyond that.

The names of the classes are just a label. Fluff is mutable.

Unless your class has a code of conduct anyways (Ninja doesn't).


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Well, those people will just have to deal with my Batman/Zorro-esque adventurer.

Thanks, guys.


If you like 3rd party material, you can use the super genius games Talented Rogue, to mix and match rogue/ninja abilities via a talent and 'edge' system, taking what you do like and leaving out what you dont. Could help keep the mechanics closer to the flavor you want while still allowing whatever it is about the ninja you do like.


deuxhero wrote:
MrSin wrote:

Ninjas don't have to wear Shinobi Shozoku(the pj's.), nor use ninja stars, nor be from an Asian themed land. Barbarians don't have to be completely unintelligent, unsocial, mouth frothing, illiterates, and samurai don't have to wield a katana and commit seppuku immediately upon dishonor. I'm sure there are many more examples beyond that.

The names of the classes are just a label. Fluff is mutable.

Unless your class has a code of conduct anyways (Ninja doesn't).

Such codes are poor class design. I'm still surprised PF didn't flush them.


Vamptastic wrote:

Well, those people will just have to deal with my Batman/Zorro-esque adventurer.

Thanks, guys.

Just remember...the pointy end goes in the man.

also

WHERRRRRE'S HARRRRVEYY DENNNT?! WHERRRE IS HEE?!!


Zhayne wrote:
deuxhero wrote:
MrSin wrote:

Ninjas don't have to wear Shinobi Shozoku(the pj's.), nor use ninja stars, nor be from an Asian themed land. Barbarians don't have to be completely unintelligent, unsocial, mouth frothing, illiterates, and samurai don't have to wield a katana and commit seppuku immediately upon dishonor. I'm sure there are many more examples beyond that.

The names of the classes are just a label. Fluff is mutable.

Unless your class has a code of conduct anyways (Ninja doesn't).
Such codes are poor class design. I'm still surprised PF didn't flush them.

That, and alignment restrictions are probably another discussion altogether. Making it optional is a better option than flushing it entirely imo, or adding flexibility. I'm not a fan of being told how my character has to roleplay myself, freedom and choice are big things in this world.

Grand Lodge

Ninjas sometimes also wear orange jumpsuits.

The Exchange

Lamontius wrote:
...When my nephew uses his Star Wars and Harry Potter legos to build a rad sports car, I do not call him out and say that I never saw Professor Snape driving that thing on Tatooine.

Which is too bad, because Professor Snape wouldn't have put up with that whiny little Anakin.


trollbill wrote:
Ninjas sometimes also wear orange jumpsuits.

A shudder of terror went through my body.


Albus Dumbledore vs. Obi Wan Kenobi...

...GO

The Exchange

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Albus vs. Obi-Wan? That depends. Are we rating them according to their ability to concoct amazingly-long-range-and-yet-extremely-unlikely-to-work plans, their ability to lie like weasels, or is this an actual foot race? Because I'd pay to watch that.


How about judging their ability to not actually directly help the heroes they're trying to assist?

Silver Crusade

Vamptastic wrote:

Well, those people will just have to deal with my Batman/Zorro-esque adventurer.

Thanks, guys.

Batman is totally a monk with the Equipment Trick (utility belt) trait. Zorro is a rapier rogue.

:p

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Do ninjas have to be...ninjas? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.