
BigNorseWolf |

Over on the rpg.net forum, someone posted the crazy and scary thought that Cersi might win the game of thrones because everyone else is either dead or too weak to challenge her. *eek*

MannyGoblin |

So Cersei is no doubt going to find out that having such a passive son works against her. I read a post where someone was so irritated at Tom's passiveness, that he actually wanted Joffery there so we at least could see the highly amusing and violent results of the Sparrows trying to snatch Magarey.
Personally, I would love to see Tom run to Qyburn and beg for help, saying that he doesn't care what happens, just save his mommy and wife.
Cue FrankenGregor.

MeanDM |

Storyteller Shadow wrote:Best episode of the season I thought. Barely any scenes from the books interestingly enough.They can either pass the books, install some action by changing things, or have nothing happen. (they've been doing some of each)
This.
Although I expect we're seeing some things that will pop up in Winds of Winter as well.

Molten Dragon |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

I hope Ramsey's little commando raid doesn't involve him pulling any more ridiculous loin-cloth fighting like before. Super-psycho is very tiresome.
Glad to see I wasn't the only one who thinks the Ramsey character is so very dull.
Whenever he's on screen I'm tempted to fast forward. I don't of course...

Troodos |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

I'd also like to say this: Jaimie's storyline going off rails was easily the worst decision made this season. Even more so than excluding Griff, the Greyjoy bros, LS, Lord Manderly (which I will never forgive), and others. Worse than killing Mance, and even worse than turning Sansa into a victim again.
Jaimie's development during the Riverlands arc is probably the best part of the entire series. Leaving that out further hollows out his character, making him develop little if any, and given the lack of a certain revelation last season, he has no reason to fulfill the prophecy (which they left out) It's like the writers hate him for some reason.
Also, regarding the wildlings

MMCJawa |

Why didn't they (Save for Wun Wun of all people/sascwatches) use fire against the wights?
I don't think they had enough time or organization to extensively bring fire to bear against the wights. The wights pretty much overran Hardhome in less than a hour I would guess.
Had they had any sort of area they could realistically hold and defend while they got their stuff together...than yeah they probably would have.

Troodos |

Troodos wrote:Why didn't they (Save for Wun Wun of all people/sascwatches) use fire against the wights?I don't think they had enough time or organization to extensively bring fire to bear against the wights. The wights pretty much overran Hardhome in less than a hour I would guess.
Had they had any sort of area they could realistically hold and defend while they got their stuff together...than yeah they probably would have.
I'd buy that, but the wildlings are smarter than that. They KNOW the Others are coming. They KNOW that wights need to be killed by fire to stay that way. They're paranoid enough to burn every dead body they find, but they don't have any defenses against the wights, like fire arrows or at least torches? Who did they think was going to attack them all the way in Hardhome, Shadowcats?

MannyGoblin |

I think that even with 10 seasons(if the rumor is true) that characters and plots will still have to be chopped right and left. Right now, we are almost at the end of season 5 and 20 episodes to get everyone back to face off against the WW (if 7 seasons is the limit HBO will go) is darn tight.
If the TV series can't be finished, then there might be a comic run.

![]() |

I think that even with 10 seasons(if the rumor is true) that characters and plots will still have to be chopped right and left. Right now, we are almost at the end of season 5 and 20 episodes to get everyone back to face off against the WW (if 7 seasons is the limit HBO will go) is darn tight.
If the TV series can't be finished, then there might be a comic run.
10 seasons? I'm pretty sure HBO and/or the producers have there will be just 2 more seasons after this one ...

Storyteller Shadow |

I think that even with 10 seasons(if the rumor is true) that characters and plots will still have to be chopped right and left. Right now, we are almost at the end of season 5 and 20 episodes to get everyone back to face off against the WW (if 7 seasons is the limit HBO will go) is darn tight.
If the TV series can't be finished, then there might be a comic run.
OR a movie.
I am waiting to see the Jamie storyline play out before I decide if I like the decision or not.

MMCJawa |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

MMCJawa wrote:I'd buy that, but the wildlings are smarter than that. They KNOW the Others are coming. They KNOW that wights need to be killed by fire to stay that way. They're paranoid enough to burn every dead body they find, but they don't have any defenses against the wights, like fire arrows or at least torches? Who did they think was going to attack them all the way in Hardhome, Shadowcats?Troodos wrote:Why didn't they (Save for Wun Wun of all people/sascwatches) use fire against the wights?I don't think they had enough time or organization to extensively bring fire to bear against the wights. The wights pretty much overran Hardhome in less than a hour I would guess.
Had they had any sort of area they could realistically hold and defend while they got their stuff together...than yeah they probably would have.
Several Points:
The Wildlings didn't intentionally want to go to Hardhome...it was an unplanned detour after Stannis broke their army and caused them to flee. Likely a lot of supplies were left behind. I mean...Hardhome is a pretty horrible place to flee to.
They are basically sheltering in a ruined fort on a icy bay. Based on what we saw, there is very little in the way of wood or other fuel. They just don't have the supplies to set aside considerable stocks of oil and wood for defense, or to keep it readily available. and what stocks they have are probably better spent staying alive.
Finally...the Wildlings are notoriously undisciplined. That is the single biggest reason why they have continuously beaten by the Night Watch/Starks, even with superior numbers. Without discipline its difficult to keep stocks well prepared and ready for use, or to organize a good defense.

MannyGoblin |

MannyGoblin wrote:10 seasons? I'm pretty sure HBO and/or the producers have there will be just 2 more seasons after this one ...I think that even with 10 seasons(if the rumor is true) that characters and plots will still have to be chopped right and left. Right now, we are almost at the end of season 5 and 20 episodes to get everyone back to face off against the WW (if 7 seasons is the limit HBO will go) is darn tight.
If the TV series can't be finished, then there might be a comic run.
Well if it really is 7 seasons, in 2 seasons+2 episodes this will have to be dealt with,
Stannis/Bolton war (Sansa/Reek)
Tyrion/Dany &co.
Kings Landing(Cersei/Sparrows)
Bran
Arya
Jon/Wall and the WW
Dorne
Many plots. No surprise that things like Lady Stoneheart was cut and I doubt we'll see any of the fallout with the Freys.

BigNorseWolf |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

How long she spent in the river
Bendric not being a red priest himself exactly,
Bendric having himself being resurrected more times than a bard with a bulls-eye corset
Resurrection seeming to take a bit out of you
Her throat getting cut
and/or some extreme emotional trauma she seems to have come back wrong, or at least with a nasty streak a mile wide.
We're not sure if she's alive and disfigured, or undead properly.
They seem to have cut that story line, but as it didn't go anywhere in the next two books there's still little if any reason they couldn't put it back in now if they chose. They could even use a different actress if they wanted, because she's under a hood most of the time.