This game is not going to a fantasy MMO. This game is going to be a PVP survival fantasy MMO. Basically what the PVP people and the developers are saying is "If you dont want to get ganked then stay at home with the women and children". I have no problem with that since I would simply not play. But the developers should be clear about their intentions. I pledged in the original kickstarter and I already feel burned since it seems I wont be playing the game.
PVP people are always talking about the holy grail that is world PVP on message boards and how fun it is. Instead what you get in game, no matter the MMO is.
Level 9000 rogue in full stealth ganking a level 1 priest trying to gather herbs. This usually causes the poor player to scream "ITS OVER 9000!"
PVP guild that entertains itself raiding the low level zones or killing all the quest NPC's in a area.
Then there is always the guy that follows you around then suddenly turns on you when your health is half way down.
In 15 years of MMO experience from UO to EQ to WOW and now RIFT, I have never seen a single case of what I would call honorable PVP. I hope the game success. But its not looking to be the kind of game I would play. It looks like its going to be a hardcore PVP game with survival of the fittest in mind.
This games success will not depend on whether it is a sandbox MMO. It will depend on the community. I hope that those interested in making PFO a great experience for others will be the majority. I hope that there will be guilds that actually fight for justice in PFO. Band together because the CE players will work together to try to minimize the penalties for being Chaotic Evil. Anyone who thinks otherwise is just naive.
Dont let the griefers and those that are only interested in wealth dominate the game. And please don't let those people be the vocal majority on these boards. Those of you that get in early don't become elitist jerks to the newbies that join 2 or 3 years later. One of them could be me.
I hope that the game is a success for all backers. Disengaging from discussion.