| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
It's really a nonissue...
For one, the Efficient Quiver, or whatever it is called, is quite popular and has extradimensional spaces... making the size irrelevant. If it can hold javelins and bows, it can hold large arrows. Even without the magic quiver, it is easy enough to just drop it and pick it up, or let it grow with you and the arrows shrink to large, who cares, sames difference...
Secondly, carrying a large quiver of large arrows really shouldn't be where you start looking for realism. Seriously, THAT is hard to believe... out of everything, a large quiver of large arrows? It sounds like you just don't want the person to do it... for whatever reason.
At that point, just say no. Don't give any BS excuse about it being unrealistic... just tell them no. Maybe you are afraid the extra damage will upset balance or some other BS.
Carrying around larger arrows is a common way to circumvent the contradicting nature of Enlarge/Reduce Person in which archers are given the middle finger. I'd allow it, and don't see any reason not to. Enlarging means they're taking a -2 accuracy penalty so the increase in dmg isn't all that.
All equipment worn or carried by a creature is similarly enlarged by the spell. Melee weapons affected by this spell deal more damage (see Table: Tiny and Large Weapon Damage). Other magical properties are not affected by this spell. Any enlarged item that leaves an enlarged creature's possession (including a projectile or thrown weapon) instantly returns to its normal size. This means that thrown and projectile weapons deal their normal damage. Magical properties of enlarged items are not increased by this spell.
Melee and projectile weapons deal less damage. Other magical properties are not affected by this spell. Any reduced item that leaves the reduced creature's possession (including a projectile or thrown weapon) instantly returns to its normal size. This means that thrown weapons deal their normal damage (projectiles deal damage based on the size of the weapon that fired them).
Have a player in my game who uses a bow as their main weapon. He is part cleric and as the ability enlarge person, he is wanting to craft large arrows since arrows would shrink to their normal size and do normal damage.
Looking for thoughts from GMs on how they would handle this. I've never had this sort of request before. My thinking would be hauling these larger arrows around could be an inconvenience and get in the way when he is normal size. Plus the added weight of the larger item.
I personally would allow it. The Cleric is taking a -2 penalty just to be able to fire arrows that deal 2d6 damage instead of 1d8. Damage dice aren't generally what makes for most of the damage. It generally comes from adding up static bonus.
As for the weight, it's not even that heavy. A large weapon weight double what a medium weapon would. A quiver of 20 medium arrows is 3 Lbs. Which means a quiver of 20 large arrow would be 6 lbs, which is aproximatively the weight of 3 javelins.
The Efficient Quiver VoodistMonk mentionned is also an excellent solution.
Those large arrows would never be the right size unless he makes a point of dropping the quiver before casting Enlarge Person on himself. Since his equipment would be enlarged with him, the arrows would become huge and still be unusable with his now large bow. And, of course, those arrows would be completely unusable when he is not enlarged.
So the whole process would be too much trouble unless he has a few rounds to set everything up just right.
Anything involving Enlarge Person generally takes time to setup... and they should probably be rewarded for that investmemt.
I would go ahead and allow the damage as though the arrows were large, it's not all that much extra per shot, and there are far easier ways of getting 2-3 extra points of damage per shot.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
On the main topic: As mentioned, the Cleric would have to drop the quiver with the large arrows, spend the rull-round action to buff themself, and pick up the quiver again. Since the damage change is +3.5 (longbow) or +4.5 (hornbow or either in combination with Gravity Bow), but there's a -2 to attack rolls, this is comperable to Deadly Aim, and thus definitely within the realm of a 1st level spell.
On Enlarge Person vs. Reduce Person: Looking at the respective versions from 3.5, Reduce Person was almost fully copy pasted from 3.5, but Enlarge Person's part about projectiles was changed - where the 3.5 version said "Melee and projectile weapons affected by this spell deal more damage (...) Any enlarged item that leaves an enlarged creature’s possession (including a projectile or thrown weapon) instantly returns to its normal size. This means that thrown weapons deal their normal damage, and projectiles deal damage based on the size of the weapon that fired them.", the PF version says "Melee weapons affected by this spell deal more damage (...) Any enlarged item that leaves an enlarged creature’s possession (including a projectile or thrown weapon) instantly returns to its normal size. This means that thrown and projectile weapons deal their normal damage."
Most notable, the two texts use the exact same wording for the size change, but with a different "this means that" interpretation. Which makes me wonder whether this was a deliberate nerf, or a change made ebcause of some idea of realism. As in one of the Paizo devs thinking "It doesn't make sense that the spell says the projectile shrinks, but also says it keeps the increased damage. Imma change it." and simply forgot to also change Reduce Person. Since the spells try to give reason for their effects on projectiles, but give different, mutually exclusive explanations, I actually think this was an oversight and not a deliberate choice to nerf archers. As the change to Enlarge Person was an intentional edit for PF, that's the 'correct' version, and Reduce Person should be adjusted to match it.
This actually matches the description of Gravity Bow, which (flavor-wise) alters the projectiles, in line with the concept that in PF the damage is based on those, not the weapon that fired them.