| 17 people marked this as a favorite. |
As it was in Season 8, so it shall be in Season 9.
First, please note:
1: Be sure to respect the submitted items. Don't sacrifice reading them to speed-add them to the list.
2: Don't self-identify by putting your item on the list ASAP. Add only the items you've seen in voting
3: Alphabetical order, please.
Bonus note: The first two items I saw were from Season 8. Don't add the first two items you see to the list.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Glad you're doing it! I couldn't get myself to make it yet!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Don't see mine. Argh! :p
20 minutes later:
AHHH! IT'S THERE! I WAS SO WORRIED.
I wouldn't worry until the list starts going past 700 items or so.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Thanks for doing this.
I believe that last year there were over 800 items. We're up to 407 as of time of post.
Something seems to have gone wrong with data validation. I'm not sure how because Insert Row doesn't mess it up.
I've fixed it, but I am curious as to why it happened. If someone figures that out, let me know.
Fun fact edit: Only 10 shields thus far, under 2.5% of all items.
Well, mine's not on there yet. I'll just have to keep watching.
I'm trying to edit (no, not to add my own item), but it doesn't work. Nothing happens when I click around.
Well, mine's not on there yet. I'll just have to keep watching.
I'm trying to edit (no, not to add my own item), but it doesn't work. Nothing happens when I click around.
Anti-Kobold filters, sorry.
(Did you have it open since it was view-only last night? If so, refresh.)
Well, I see my item on the list as well as an item that sounds like it may be similar...I hope to see the other item in voting.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Wasn't Earthcracker an item from last time?
It is, but then again I wouldn't be surprised if someone came up with the same name entirely on coincidence. I'll mark it for confirmation.
I think "blood" may be the theme, Fox, though there have been a fair number of nautical items.
And yeah, Earthcracker was from last year (I happened to be reading up on old items last night). Odds are someone got it from that initial outdated voting box lag.
And no, Petty Alchemy, I opened it today, and I've been refreshing it.
Thank you Petty Alchemy, I know a lot of the people the normally get really involved sorta couldn't this time as they didn't plan the time into their lives on short notice. Nice to see some people still around doing the lovely things they do for this community. :D
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Law of large numbers it should all balance out.
KC, I dunno what's going on for you. Other people seem to have no trouble editing. Have you tried signing in with a google account?
(And please, call me Petty or PA).
I'm already signed in. Huh.
I think "blood" may be the theme, Fox, though there have been a fair number of nautical items.
Blood + Water = Sharks. :)
450 items at the time of this post, and about half of the pairings I'm seeing have an item not yet on the list.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I've gotten about two or three shark items, actually—four if you count my repeated misreadings of the Snark thread.
Would it be alright for me to post the items/name informations here for someone else to enter into the document? I'll make sure to check and see if it's on the doc first, of course.
There are several items in the list that I haven't seen but really hope to see. Their names are quite evocative. I'd love to look at them and possibly use them in my home game.
And they're shark-themed!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Oh good, someone else noticed the blood theme- I thought it was just me, which wouldn't be good; pops says I gotta go to the doctors if I start seeing the word "blood" everywhere again
Would it be alright for me to post the items/name informations here for someone else to enter into the document? I'll make sure to check and see if it's on the doc first, of course.
Go for it I'll put it in there :) I'm still hoping to see mine. It still hasnt made the list :(
Blade of Many Forms
Weapon
Funnily, I've gotten this several times now, so I was surprised to see it wasn't listed.
Knuckles of Fire Seeds
Weapon
ANOTHER!
Atlatl of Volcanic Eruption
Weapon
TWO MORE!
Quiver of Plenty
Wondrous Item
Greater Hopeknife
Weapon
YET MORE!
Gossamer Veil
Wondrous Item
EDIT: MAS!
Sword of the Maytr
Weapon
This post is getting very edit-bloated!
Gorgon Sinew Lariat
Weapon
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I think it's quite exciting that someone, or multiple someones, have looked at my item and have bothered enough to consider it in any respect.
Sure I can't say "that one was mine", but knowing that it's been looked at is... well, exciting!
Blade of Many Forms
WeaponFunnily, I've gotten this several times now, so I was surprised to see it wasn't listed.
I had several that kept coming up for me all day and weren't on the list when I found it. Thats why I'm trying to add everything I can.
I've had the honor of seeing my item come up twice, and it was listed before I could put it up there, which means it has been seen at least three times.
I'm gonna keep editing that post in with new items, for the record, to avoid spamming this thread.
Maybe instead of pre-cull, 1st cull, etc., maybe use dates in case culls are not announced.
Yeah, if the culls aren't announced then I was thinking to redo confirmations every 5 days or so.
Let's see how it goes. I think Owens hinted elsewhere the first cull may be in two days.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I've had the honor of seeing my item come up twice, and it was listed before I could put it up there, which means it has been seen at least three times.
I can't even lie; one of the reasons I've been voting all day is the vague hope that I will come across my item and see if I can objectively say it beats out its random competitor. I haven't found it yet, but hey, at least others have as it is on the list.
Yeah, I gotta admit, I've been doing the same thing. No luck yet. We do worry.
And another item:
Security Blanket
Wondrous Item
Trident of the Kraken Lord
Weapon
Cloak of the Guardian Interloper
Wondrous Item
I've had the honor of seeing my item come up twice, and it was listed before I could put it up there, which means it has been seen at least three times.I can't even lie; one of the reasons I've been voting all day is the vague hope that I will come across my item and see if I can objectively say it beats out its random competitor. I haven't found it yet, but hey, at least others have as it is on the list.
Same here with mine, but I've seen multiple items multiple times. I don't know if that's good news for me, or bad.
Fret not, the average thus far is over 1 item/minute.
Last year there were over 800 submissions and we've only up to 530 right now.
I've had the honor of seeing my item come up twice, and it was listed before I could put it up there, which means it has been seen at least three times.I can't even lie; one of the reasons I've been voting all day is the vague hope that I will come across my item and see if I can objectively say it beats out its random competitor. I haven't found it yet, but hey, at least others have as it is on the list.
Me too. I've seen two that are similar to mine, but not mine. It's not on the list either.
What if we added 3 columns to the google sheet so people could post if they voted up, down, or tie (just keep a tally so we can check how our items are doing). Would this be allowed because it's anonymous, or would this be frowned upon because it could potentially influemce voters?
It is still at 542 items, guys. Last year we reportedly hit around 800, so I wouldn't start worrying yet. We're still adding new items to the list.
EDIT: Oh, and I'll start another list here:
Wondrous Item
EDIT: Another
Diver's Float
Wondrous Item
Clockwork Armor
Weapon
Wondrous Item
Armor
ANOTHER
Mug of Agreement
Wondrous Item
Alchemist's Gift
Weapon
Hungry Ghost Incense
Wondrous Item
Cloak of the High Plains Wind
Wondrous Item
Psalter of Devotion
Wondrous Item
Primordial Keys
Wondrous Item
Defender's Door
Armor
Scourge Rat Spear
Weapon
Joel Flank, that's a great idea.
What if we added 3 columns to the google sheet so people could post if they voted up, down, or tie (just keep a tally so we can check how our items are doing). Would this be allowed because it's anonymous, or would this be frowned upon because it could potentially influemce voters?
I can see why that's tempting, but we won't be tallying votes.
Dedicated Voter Season 7, Dedicated Voter Season 8, Dedicated Voter Season 9
|
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
What if we added 3 columns to the google sheet so people could post if they voted up, down, or tie (just keep a tally so we can check how our items are doing). Would this be allowed because it's anonymous, or would this be frowned upon because it could potentially influemce voters?
That would be a bad thing to do.
Hey, I noticed a typo in the list—it's Anathema Brand, not Band.
Also, why are some of the "last seen" dates saying numbers like 8/22/15? Do we have time travelers among us?
New List (and I'll paste one from the previous so it doesn't get lost in the shift):
Scourge Rat Spear
Weapon
Dimensional Razor
Weapon
Lovelorn Harp
Wondrous Item