Flame Blade sneak attacker - could it work?


Advice

51 to 100 of 129 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

Here's what the build is looking like currently:

Tengu (Claws)
Nature Fang druid (Crocodile domain) 6/Arcane Trickster X
strength 8, dexterity 16, constitution 12, intelligence 12, wisdom 18, charisma 10
Dwarf caiman familiar (mauler)
traits: Two-World Magic, Highlander
gear: Deliquescent Gloves, Rod of Ice
1: Weapon Finesse
2:
3: Two-Weapon Fighting
4:
5: Tengu Wings
6:
7: Improved Initiative
8:
9: Defensive Combat Training
10:
11: Improved Two-Weapon Fighting

edit: forgot to include my slayer talents in here, so that should basically give me two more feats (more or less.) Any slayer talents of note?

edit2: I can open up my 3rd-level feat by taking TWF at 4 through Slayer Talent -> Ranger Combat Style. At 6 I can take Combat Trick for another feat. So feat slots are free at 3rd and 6th.

Scarab Sages

RumpinRufus wrote:


edit: forgot to include my slayer talents in here, so that should basically give me two more feats (more or less.) Any slayer talents of note?

Ranger Combat Styles and Rogue Combat Trick are the stand outs.


My plan is to be a giant jellyfish 4 attacks with 15 reach and poison targeting con requiring 2 consecutive saves and full sneak attack progression.


Rogar Stonebow wrote:
My plan is to be a giant jellyfish 4 attacks with 15 reach and poison targeting con requiring 2 consecutive saves and full sneak attack progression.

How do you do this?

Sovereign Court

RumpinRufus wrote:


edit2: I can open up my 3rd-level feat by taking TWF at 4 through Slayer Talent -> Ranger Combat Style. At 6 I can take Combat Trick for another feat. So feat slots are free at 3rd and 6th.

A good feat would be Weapon Focus: Touch Attack. Personally - I'd switch the dex & wis scores - but it depends how much spellcasting you want to do which give saving throws. I think that most of the time you'll hit with consistency as most high ACs rely upon armor/nat armor, but you'll run into some foes who are rough. You'll want to avoid Will O Wisps - they get their full 25AC vs touch. :P

Even at level 12 your to-hit will only be approx +10/+10/+5/+5 if you don't take WF and put your level ups into Wis. (+5 dex/ +7 BAB) If you take WF and focus on dex it would be +13/+13/+8/+8. It also makes it so that the iteratives will hit armored characters consistently, and have a shot at finesse ones.


RumpinRufus wrote:
Rogar Stonebow wrote:
My plan is to be a giant jellyfish 4 attacks with 15 reach and poison targeting con requiring 2 consecutive saves and full sneak attack progression.
How do you do this?

Vivisectionist vermin shape II


Well don't forget to add the flanking bonus in there. If I'm not flanking then there's not a whole lot of point in even attacking.

Speaking of that, I should probably take Gang Up (and Combat Expertise since it's a pre-req.)


Whoa - I can take ITWF at 6 instead of 11 if I use both my slayer talents on Ranger Combat Style.

That means I'll get an iterative with my off-hand BEFORE I get an iterative with my main hand.


Normally you can take "weapon fineesse: touch attack" but the weird part is those two spells specifically cite weapons. So there are some GM's who will restrict it to wielding as those weapons. i.e. weapon finesse: melee touch attack wouldn't apply.
I find it dumb as sticks; since it's still no weight and still just touching. but I know people who have had sessions where they had serious trouble due to phrasing like that in PFS. Figured it was worth mentioning~

Sovereign Court

Zwordsman wrote:

Normally you can take "weapon fineesse: touch attack" but the weird part is those two spells specifically cite weapons. So there are some GM's who will restrict it to wielding as those weapons. i.e. weapon finesse: melee touch attack wouldn't apply.

I find it dumb as sticks; since it's still no weight and still just touching. but I know people who have had sessions where they had serious trouble due to phrasing like that in PFS. Figured it was worth mentioning~

I'm assuming you mean Weapon Focus. And it shouldn't be a problem to take Weapon Focus: Touch Attack and have it apply.

Just don't tell the GM where the bonus comes from to avoid table variations. GMs don't ask about every +1.

Scarab Sages

Weapon Finesse doesn't require you to specify a weapon, it applies to all finesseable weapons. I could see some argument for denying it based on "you wield this as a scimitar". In that case, take dervish dance.


Yeah, I am now leaning towards the interpretation that the Flame Blade is not finessable. Originally, I was using the fact that "a spellcaster delivering a touch attack spell" is considered to be making an unarmed attack, and unarmed attacks are finessable, as justification for finessing it. But using Flame Blade is not really "delivering a touch attack spell": it is making a melee touch attack but not to deliver a spell. So I don't know how many PFS GMs I could convince to let that work.

Now, does it make any sense at all that Flame Blade attacks would be Str-based? No, but I suppose that's irrelevant...

Should I switch to Str build instead of Dex? Or maybe just bite the bullet and grab Dervish Dance. The unfortunate thing is that Dervish Dance wouldn't even help me use Gozreh's Trident when I'm facing fire-resistant enemies. But I suppose lesser elemental metamagic rods aren't too pricey.


Mark Seifter confirms that Flame Blade would not be finessable. Also confirms that touch spells, in general, are finessable.

Does anything stop me from dual-wielding Frostbite and Produce Flame?

Scarab Sages

RumpinRufus wrote:

Mark Seifter confirms that Flame Blade would not be finessable. Also confirms that touch spells, in general, are finessable.

Does anything stop me from dual-wielding Frostbite and Produce Flame?

No. Normally if you cast a second touch attack spell, the first one dissipates. However, Produce Flame can be used as a touch attack, but it is not a touch spell. You can cast Produce Flame first, then cast Frostbite, and dual wield them.

Sovereign Court

RumpinRufus wrote:

Mark Seifter confirms that Flame Blade would not be finessable. Also confirms that touch spells, in general, are finessable.

Does anything stop me from dual-wielding Frostbite and Produce Flame?

That's sad that you can't finesse Flame Blade or Gozreh's Trident. (I'm not sure I agree. But... I don't work for Paizo.) Though theoretically you could finesse both with a dip in Swashbuckler and Slashing Grace - it wouldn't really be worth it instead of simply using your other touch spell options.

I'd think you can dual-wield Frostbite and Produce Flame at the same time. And I'd think that the Rod of Ice would be finesse-able.


I am torn, because this entire concept was based off Flame Blade, so I would be very sad to abandon it. At the same time, all the great options this thread has provided (Frostbite, Produce Flame, Deliquescent Gloves) have broadened the concept significantly in a way I really like. I'm now thinking of this character as The Elementalist.

Squeezing in Dervish Dance isn't too hard, though. I could do:

1: Weapon Finesse
2:
3: Dervish Dance
4: Two-Weapon Fighting
5: Tengu Wings
6: Improved Two-Weapon Fighting
7: Combat Expertise
8:
9: Gang Up

RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

FYI: There is a slayer trait that gives you Weapon Finesse. It's one of the Rogue traits they can select.

If you still have rogue or slayer levels in your build. Oh! You get talents from your druid archetype. Oy. I'm slow tonight.


No, I admit it's confusing. The nice daisy chain of Druid -> Nature Fang -> Slayer Talents -> Ranger Combat Style is what gives me feats at 4 and 6.

But I'm pretty sure the best way by far to use those slayer talents is early-entry ITWF, so those are locked-in at this point.

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Not to be difficult, but if the official ruling is you need dervish dance to finesse a flame blade, TWF is kinda out the window.

DD says you can not be carrying a weapon or shield in your off hand while you are getting dex to hit on the attack. I am not sure if this would count on claws or those gloves as the "off hand" however, claws would not gain from TWF. The gloves might work as a plain old punch of acid.

If that is the case, I could see Slayer talent going for Combat Trick (for Combat Expertise) or Weapon Training (getting that weapon focus for a scimitar, which should apply to hit with Flame Blade, assuming we are treating it like a scimitar when it helps too)

I would argue, the flame blade should crit on 18-20/x2. It is a scimitar after all.

This also allows you to enter Arcane Trickster at 5th, assuming you still wanna go that path.


Dervish Dance only prohibits me from carrying a weapon or a shield in my off-hand. I'm planning to use the off-hand for Frostbite or Produce Flame. The consensus seems to agree with the common-sense ruling that Frostbite does not count as "carrying a weapon".

Also, how could I enter Arcane Trickster at 5? I am not getting my second Sneak Attack die until 6th level (Crocodile domain + Nature Fang) and the current build doesn't give me an SLA until 5th (Tengu Wings.)

Grand Lodge

Apparently I am very tired and will be heading to bed in a moment.

Yes, you will have to wait till 7th level for your first Arcane Trickster.


For the record, you could do a silly build going with greensting slayer for AT entry, and then taking 1-2 levels of collegiate arcanist when the time comes. It's costly, and you may even have to grab a level of wizard for spell mastery (but that lets you nab admixture, so it ain't all bad).


Elemental spell (sonic) is an option. Sadly you need Two-world magic or you could make it free for one of your spells (like flame blade) with Magical Lineage.

Scarab Sages

You can't use sonic with elemental spell. You can only change to the 4 common energy types.


@LoneKnave: noted, but casting Magus spells one level delayed is significantly less attractive than full Druid casting. And by my reckoning, Wizard1/Magus5/AT4/CA1 is the earliest I could get Flame Blade. Versus 3rd level on the druid build. But yes, it's a possibility.

@boring7, the Elemental Spell feats specifically lists which energy types are allowed, and sonic is unfortunately not among them.


One more question: is there any way I can get the Surprise Spells ability (arcane trickster capstone) on Storm of Vengeance? Doing Sneak Attack damage to everyone in a 360 ft. radius is just so tempting.

Surprise Spells wrote:
At 10th level, an arcane trickster can add her sneak attack damage to any spell that deals damage, if the targets are flat-footed. This additional damage only applies to spells that deal hit point damage, and the additional damage is of the same type as the spell. If the spell allows a saving throw to negate or halve the damage, it also negates or halves the sneak attack damage.
Storm of Vengeance wrote:

You create a huge black storm cloud in the air. Each creature under the cloud must succeed on a Fortitude save or be deafened for 1d4 × 10 minutes. Each round you continue to concentrate, the spell generates additional effects as noted below. Each effect occurs on your turn.

2nd Round: Acid rains down in the area, dealing 1d6 points of acid damage (no save).

3rd Round: You call six bolts of lightning down from the cloud. You decide where the bolts strike. No two bolts may be directed at the same target. Each bolt deals 10d6 points of electricity damage. A creature struck can attempt a Reflex save for half damage.

4th Round: Hailstones rain down in the area, dealing 5d6 points of bludgeoning damage (no save).

If the acid came down on the first round this would definitely work, but after they hear the thunder, I'm assuming they'll no longer be flat-footed, so Surprise Spells won't apply. Is there any way to make this work?

Grand Lodge

I may be wrong, but, Greater invisibility would allow it I believe.

Another option is to do some dazing, so they may not act.


The problem is they specifically have to be flat-footed (not merely denied Dex,) and the flat-footed condition ends when their turn comes up in initiative order.


Shatter Defenses? Does the acid count as attacking them? Do you have some way to Fear all of them? Might be a metamagic that lets you do it, if not you want to recruit a dragon for Frightful Presence.


Oh wait! I forgot about the surprise round!

All I need to do is cast the Storm of Vengeance in the surprise round, and then roll high on initiative. Anyone who goes after me takes full Sneak Attack damage, no save!

This makes me very happy.


hard to set up. .but pretty awesome

Do be aware any spellcraft user could potentially roll to realize it's a spell and call out "attack" which has the potential to negate the surprise portion. Depending on the situatoin.
not really an end all or anything but something good to be aware of.


Once they hear the spell being cast, the surprise round is already happening.

Regardless, the idea is to cast the spell from ~1000 feet away. If they can make their Perception with a -100 penalty, I'll be so impressed I won't even care my sneak is ruined.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps Subscriber

Just to add to your touch attack repertoire make sure you grab a wand of cure light wounds. Not only good for healing your party but great for sneak attacks undead as a touch attack.

One problem you will run into are demons/devils/outsiders with lots of resistances, but hey you still have full druid casting right?


RumpinRufus wrote:

Once they hear the spell being cast, the surprise round is already happening.

Regardless, the idea is to cast the spell from ~1000 feet away. If they can make their Perception with a -100 penalty, I'll be so impressed I won't even care my sneak is ruined.

OOh it's got a pretty big range ? Nice I didn't look up the spell just going off your quote.

The issues is the first round is the thunder clap of deafness. If the spellcraft fellow rolls upon seeing that or hapens to have some sorta magic sight (not unreasonable when your at levels where you have surprise spells) they could roll to see what's happening. Then the round after the thunder clap the acid falls right? I mean if the group is fairly set up, then chances are the nature guy will say "This isn't a normal storm" and the magic or knowledge guys will go "Oh crap hit the deck!"

not sayin it's not epic. 'Cause thats some shiny goodness. But just something to note for possible occurances in game and maybe have a backup of some sort. Too bad it's not valid for impromtu sneak attack. I'll never get why they didn't word that or have an adendum at lv 10 that you could make surprise spells an impromtue. That would just be so useful.

haha. Though.. You could totally set up some cool plans. Have some ally near the zone Stand up and yell when the deafness is occuring. Then the rain is a surprise. Well some gm's would be squiffy with the meta concept of the "not on guard vs me" part so nvm actually. Just a cool cool visual.

==================
I wonder.. if surprise spells works with those berry bombs? That lv ...6? spell where you make abuncha berries that explode on command word.. That would be a good defensive set up or sneak in invisibly and explode things set up. Haha or if you ever go evil.. there are even more uses.

----
Edit: whoops spellcraft is for if they magically hear you, Knowledge Arcana is for realizing that is a spell effect going on. Which they wouldn't get a penality for if they were in the area of effect.


RumpinRufus wrote:

Flame Blade lets you attack touch AC. So assuming you can find a way to apply your sneak, it should be easy to hit and get sneak damage.

Nature Fang druid lets you cast Flame Blade, gives you some sneak damage, and gives you an animal companion to act as dedicated flank buddy.

So, after Nature Fang 4, what is the best course for this character? Ninja X? Are there any feats or items that could make this more viable?

you could try a UMD rogue and just pick up a wand of flameblade, going full rogue. or a slayer/ninja doing teh same thing, but less skill points to toss around.


Imbicatus wrote:
Endoralis wrote:
You will have to dip regardless Druid only gets one Sneak Attack Dice
Look up the crocodile domain.

do you really think that the sneak attack does not progress like a rogue? is there a faq about it somewhere?

Sneak Attack (Ex): At 4th level, a nature fang gains sneak attack +1d6. This functions as the rogue sneak attack ability. If the nature fang gets a sneak attack bonus from another source, the bonuses on damage stack. This ability replaces resist nature's lure.

Sneak Attack: If a rogue can catch an opponent when he is unable to defend himself effectively from her attack, she can strike a vital spot for extra damage.

The rogue's attack deals extra damage anytime her target would be denied a Dexterity bonus to AC (whether the target actually has a Dexterity bonus or not), or when the rogue flanks her target. This extra damage is 1d6 at 1st level, and increases by 1d6 every two rogue levels thereafter. Should the rogue score a critical hit with a sneak attack, this extra damage is not multiplied. Ranged attacks can count as sneak attacks only if the target is within 30 feet.

With a weapon that deals nonlethal damage (like a sap, whip, or an unarmed strike), a rogue can make a sneak attack that deals nonlethal damage instead of lethal damage. She cannot use a weapon that deals lethal damage to deal nonlethal damage in a sneak attack, not even with the usual –4 penalty.

The rogue must be able to see the target well enough to pick out a vital spot and must be able to reach such a spot. A rogue cannot sneak attack while striking a creature with concealment.

seems to me like it would progress like the rogue +1d6 every 2 levels

Liberty's Edge

Avoid Produce Flame as all it does with your standard action casting is "producing Flame", you won't be able to hit until Next round.

Btw. Someone above spoke about dual wielding Touch spells.. But I believe the first one is removed as soon as you cast your second.

GL all


TorresGlitch wrote:


Btw. Someone above spoke about dual wielding Touch spells.. But I believe the first one is removed as soon as you cast your second.

GL all

That is true of spells with range "touch" (like Frostbite) but not of spells with range of "0 ft." (like Flame Blade or Produce Flame.)

So, if you cast Frostbite and then Flame Blade, the Frostbite effect will end.

But if you cast Flame Blade and then Frostbite, both are active and you can dual-wield.


'Sun Metal' spell plus flame oracle revelation 'burning magic' plus heighten spell meta-magic = one to four rounds of the heightened spell level as damage (and in the case of sun metal this would be per hit for multiple attacks) = a large amount of additional fire damage without sneak attack. Even more with it.


strayshift wrote:
'Sun Metal' spell plus flame oracle revelation 'burning magic' plus heighten spell meta-magic = one to four rounds of the heightened spell level as damage (and in the case of sun metal this would be per hit for multiple attacks) = a large amount of additional fire damage without sneak attack. Even more with it.

But this doesn't let you attack vs. touch AC in any way, unless I'm missing something. Plus, I don't think you would get to apply Sneak Attack to the burning damage on subsequent rounds anyway.


As a backup to Flame Blade, Rumpin, Consider Divine Trident. Lower crit range but it is Lightning and can be thrown.


I was digging the Divine Trident (Gozreh's Trident) idea until I realized there's no way to make it finessable without dipping swash/daring champ. I think Elemental Flame Blade will have to do instead.


RumpinRufus wrote:
strayshift wrote:
'Sun Metal' spell plus flame oracle revelation 'burning magic' plus heighten spell meta-magic = one to four rounds of the heightened spell level as damage (and in the case of sun metal this would be per hit for multiple attacks) = a large amount of additional fire damage without sneak attack. Even more with it.
But this doesn't let you attack vs. touch AC in any way, unless I'm missing something. Plus, I don't think you would get to apply Sneak Attack to the burning damage on subsequent rounds anyway.

No it doesn't target touch ac, merely flat-footed if you get sneak attack but it does highlight a way to benefit from multiple attacks, and that is all I claimed. Burning magic certainly does not rely on the vagaries of sneak attack - just cast sun metal on a fighter and they hit them a lot of times for lots of additional (heightened) fire damage. If you could add sneak attack damage all the better. Simple.


RumpinRufus wrote:
I was digging the Divine Trident (Gozreh's Trident) idea until I realized there's no way to make it finessable without dipping swash/daring champ. I think Elemental Flame Blade will have to do instead.

If you throw it, do you need to make it Finessable? Again, just an option until you get 3rd level spells can can cast an elemental Flame Blade.


Heres a weird thing... look up spiritual weapon. Its not on your list though. but. it specificall ycalls out as "striking as a spell" so it might be a weird way of getting force sneak attack on occasion.

========

Problem with Divine Trident is it's pretty limited use until you get higher levels. It's pretty hard to blow one of your few spell slots (fewer still if your combat) on such a limited use.. Might be worth while as a initiator though.

later levels, with impromtu sneak attack it can be pretty useful


just a quick question , how are you getting mage hand , to qualifies for the arcane trickster?

Sovereign Court

Kefler wrote:

just a quick question , how are you getting mage hand , to qualifies for the arcane trickster?

RumpinRufus listed the Two-World Magic trait in the build. It lets a spellcaster put a 0 level spell from another spell list onto their own. Mage Hand for a druid is even the example given.


Charon's Little Helper wrote:
Kefler wrote:

just a quick question , how are you getting mage hand , to qualifies for the arcane trickster?

RumpinRufus listed the Two-World Magic trait in the build. It lets a spellcaster put a 0 level spell from another spell list onto their own. Mage Hand for a druid is even the example given.

ahh i see now ,,, thnx

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps Subscriber

You don't progress sneak attack as a rogue. You get the 1d6 from Nature's Fang, the 1d6 from Croc domain.


I just remembered, Frostbite activates on a successful natural weapon attack.

That means if I bite/claw/claw I have three chances per round to get off a Frostbite (granted I'm hitting normal AC.)

And at level 6 when I'm doing Flame Blade/Frostbite/Frostbite/bite, the bite can potentially deliver a third Frostbite.

I feel like Christmas is coming over and over on this build.

1 to 50 of 129 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Advice / Flame Blade sneak attacker - could it work? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.