
PathlessBeth |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Still wondering who Haley's mother is. Did we have some info on this that I missed ?
There were various fan conjectures for a long time (still are, AFAIK) that Haley's mom was/is a celestial. It's been around at least since 309, when Haley's crytogram speech in the next-to-last panel translates to
Elan, it turns out I may not be exactly what you would call-
Several people claimed that she was 'obviously' going to finish the sentence with the word 'human', and claimed that she was not exactly what you would call human due to being half-celestial.
It kept popping up enough that eventually, the author himself made a joke response to the running fan-conjecture (along with other weird fan-conjectures that keep popping up on the forum.)
From what's in the actual comics and books, though, Haley's mom was a human from Greysky City, who died a long time ago from unspecified causes (AFB, but I don't remember anything about her death in OtOOtPCs).

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

The black raven wrote:Still wondering who Haley's mother is. Did we have some info on this that I missed ?There were various fan conjectures for a long time (still are, AFAIK) that Haley's mom was/is a celestial. It's been around at least since 309, when Haley's crytogram speech in the next-to-last panel translates to
Haley deciphered wrote:Elan, it turns out I may not be exactly what you would call-Several people claimed that she was 'obviously' going to finish the sentence with the word 'human', and claimed that she was not exactly what you would call human due to being half-celestial.
It kept popping up enough that eventually, the author himself made a joke response to the running fan-conjecture (along with other weird fan-conjectures that keep popping up on the forum.)
From what's in the actual comics and books, though, Haley's mom was a human from Greysky City, who died a long time ago from unspecified causes (AFB, but I don't remember anything about her death in OtOOtPCs).
Thank you for all this info. I had indeed forgotten this. Note that I am a fan of the Aasimar theory myself. But this is due to an info a long time ago when Rich stated IIRC that Haley and Sabine were reflections of each other on many levels, hence the Celestial vs Abyssal idea.

PathlessBeth |
137ben wrote:From what's in the actual comics and books, though, Haley's mom was a human from Greysky City, who died a long time ago from unspecified causes (AFB, but I don't remember anything about her death in OtOOtPCs).And by "unspecified causes" you mean an arrow with purple fletchings.
Well yea, she was shot with an arrow by an unspecified person for unspecified reasons. And by "unspecified reasons", I almost certainly mean "either a rival for a leadership position in the thieves' guild was trying to bolster their position, or someone who opposed the thieves guild killed her."
:)
Thank you for all this info. I had indeed forgotten this. Note that I am a fan of the Aasimar theory myself. But this is due to an info a long time ago when Rich stated IIRC that Haley and Sabine were reflections of each other on many levels, hence the Celestial vs Abyssal idea.
Oh, yea...
I can't remember whether that was before or after 309. I think it was before, but I'm away from my books now.
![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

2) With all this golem-ruckus, we have all overly focussed on Haley and conveniently forgotten about Durkula. I am betting on vampire action in the coming weeks.
Don't even ask about the train of thought that led me to this, but I just had an interesting thought about why Rich may have inserted this side plot at this time.
If Grubwiggler really is a powerful necromancer, you'd think he'd know something about vampires, and also have high enough will saves to avoid vamp hypnosis. My guess is that he'll either 1) blow the lid on Durkula (unlikely) or 2) cut a deal with Durkula to save his own skin and advance Durkula/Hel's agenda (MUCH more likely).

Tacticslion |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

So. Really old joke (at least by now, relatively speaking). I just got it.
"Philter of Glibness" is an AD&D item.
A potion would be the natural 3.5 version of an old AD&D philter - and glibness would be updated to the spell version.
I feel... so dumb for having forgotten that. Right.

Tacticslion |

Eh, I'm pretty sure her electricity boost is going to run out soon, making her much, much more manageable.

![]() |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

If Grubwiggler really is a powerful necromancer, you'd think he'd know something about vampires, and also have high enough will saves to avoid vamp hypnosis. My guess is that he'll either 1) blow the lid on Durkula (unlikely) or 2) cut a deal with Durkula to save his own skin and advance Durkula/Hel's agenda (MUCH more likely).
So much for my theory. LOL

Alex Martin |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Wow - a situation where we actually see a villain get destroyed. Unless Golems can survive lava, which I am assuming is not the case.
Also:The other reason I am going to kill is that you are a sadistic, unrepentant murder who's like a danger to...everyone. Couldn't put more honestly - no moral grey area there.

ElterAgo |

I like it. As soon as they were portrayed walking and talking, I knew she was leading to an ambush/trap to finish off the golem.
Yeah, flesh golems are slowed by fire damage. She's not getting out of that.
But in the earlier versions, wasn't it just slowed but no actual damage? I can't really remember.

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

I like it. As soon as they were portrayed walking and talking, I knew she was leading to an ambush/trap to finish off the golem.
TriOmegaZero wrote:Yeah, flesh golems are slowed by fire damage. She's not getting out of that.But in the earlier versions, wasn't it just slowed but no actual damage? I can't really remember.
Magical fire. It's one of those weird physics of D&D that a meteor Swarm will do nothing, but enough alchemists fire will toast it.

Drejk |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

ElterAgo wrote:Magical fire. It's one of those weird physics of D&D that a meteor Swarm will do nothing, but enough alchemists fire will toast it.I like it. As soon as they were portrayed walking and talking, I knew she was leading to an ambush/trap to finish off the golem.
TriOmegaZero wrote:Yeah, flesh golems are slowed by fire damage. She's not getting out of that.But in the earlier versions, wasn't it just slowed but no actual damage? I can't really remember.
Meteor swarm, fireball or any other Evocation spell that allows Spell Resistance is a magic energy formed into semblance of fire but it's still magic energy first and as such fails to affect magic immune golems. Alchemist fire, lava, or a "SR No" conjuration spell affects the subject with actual, honest-to-fire-gods flame (with only enough magic in it to be able to affect creatures immune to non-magical flame in the case of the later but not enough to fail to affect magic immune beings).

PathlessBeth |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
So one idea that has been bouncing around in my head is that Grubwiggler's speech about memories and emotions could be foreshadowing something: since emotions are "tricky", absorbing someone's memories might accidentally result in absorbing some of their personality. Which would be important if, say, an evil negative energy spirit were absorbing Durkon's memories. We've already seen him start to take on Durkon's accent, even in spirit form.
I could just as easily be wrong, though.
ElterAgo wrote:Magical fire. It's one of those weird physics of D&D that a meteor Swarm will do nothing, but enough alchemists fire will toast it.I like it. As soon as they were portrayed walking and talking, I knew she was leading to an ambush/trap to finish off the golem.
TriOmegaZero wrote:Yeah, flesh golems are slowed by fire damage. She's not getting out of that.But in the earlier versions, wasn't it just slowed but no actual damage? I can't really remember.
Unless it's non-magical fire generated by a spell, like Orb of Fire:)
Anyhow, the author recently commented on how he writes and other stuff (plus more in that thread that I don't feel like linking to.)

Alex Martin |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Magical fire. It's one of those weird physics of D&D that a meteor Swarm will do nothing, but enough alchemists fire will toast it.
I also forgot that when it comes to flesh golems, one of the original source materials of inspiration was Frankenstein's monster. Not the book; more the old Universal movies. Villagers with torches and all that. ;-)

Hitdice |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

I feel like there's a very quiet genre joke in the placement of the Tinkertown Municipal Waste Disposal Facility over a lava chasm, and the composition of Crystal's death being so similar to Gollum's.
I would have loved to see Crystal and Thog wander off into the sunset to populate the world with a generation of tertiary colored stock villains, but I guess that's just not in the cards.

PathlessBeth |
3 people marked this as a favorite. |
982: Respirate in Peace
Turns out there are some physical skills of Durkon's that HPoH hasn't learned....

Andostre |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

It can all be attributed to the new art style that came with the start of the new book.
Although the belt came much earlier.

PathlessBeth |

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

I forgot he had prestige class levels. He mentions planning to swap a 4th level spell for Cure Critical, but he's still not allowed to swap 4th level spells until he has 6th level spells, so that's only at 17th (or I guess 20th) level of Bard.
And since he mentions learning two new 5th level spells, that panel occurred just after gaining 13 levels in bard (with some unknown number of Dashing Swordsman).
Two possible conclusions here:
1) Elan is at least 17th level of bard, plus some of Dashing Swordsman (possibly making the party 20th level, nearing the end game), and we should see 9th level spells immiently.
2) Burlew forgot/deliberately ignored the rule about bard swapping spells only two or more levels below their highest spell level and Elan swapped at 14 levels of bard, making the party as a whole somewhere in the neighborhood of 15-17th level.
he has at least 16 levels of bard plus an unknown number of levels of dashing swordsman
We know this because he used song of freedom, a bardic class feature gained at level 16 near the end of the desert arc
Caineach |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Ross Byers wrote:I forgot he had prestige class levels. He mentions planning to swap a 4th level spell for Cure Critical, but he's still not allowed to swap 4th level spells until he has 6th level spells, so that's only at 17th (or I guess 20th) level of Bard.
And since he mentions learning two new 5th level spells, that panel occurred just after gaining 13 levels in bard (with some unknown number of Dashing Swordsman).
Two possible conclusions here:
1) Elan is at least 17th level of bard, plus some of Dashing Swordsman (possibly making the party 20th level, nearing the end game), and we should see 9th level spells immiently.
2) Burlew forgot/deliberately ignored the rule about bard swapping spells only two or more levels below their highest spell level and Elan swapped at 14 levels of bard, making the party as a whole somewhere in the neighborhood of 15-17th level.
he has at least 16 levels of bard plus an unknown number of levels of dashing swordsman
We know this because he used song of freedom, a bardic class feature gained at level 16 near the end of the desert arc
Do we know what dashing swordsman gets for class features? I t could get song of freedom early. I was under the impression that they were only 15th-16th level. We haven't seen a 9th level spell yet that I know of.

PathlessBeth |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Ross Byers wrote:I forgot he had prestige class levels. He mentions planning to swap a 4th level spell for Cure Critical, but he's still not allowed to swap 4th level spells until he has 6th level spells, so that's only at 17th (or I guess 20th) level of Bard.
And since he mentions learning two new 5th level spells, that panel occurred just after gaining 13 levels in bard (with some unknown number of Dashing Swordsman).
Two possible conclusions here:
1) Elan is at least 17th level of bard, plus some of Dashing Swordsman (possibly making the party 20th level, nearing the end game), and we should see 9th level spells immiently.
2) Burlew forgot/deliberately ignored the rule about bard swapping spells only two or more levels below their highest spell level and Elan swapped at 14 levels of bard, making the party as a whole somewhere in the neighborhood of 15-17th level.
he has at least 16 levels of bard plus an unknown number of levels of dashing swordsman
We know this because he used song of freedom, a bardic class feature gained at level 16 near the end of the desert arc
Song of freedom is gained at bard level 12th, not 16th.
He didn't take CCW at 13th level (since he took Neutralize Poison instead). He got at least enough xp to have a total level of 16.
Maybe the Giant forgot that he can only retrain spells two below his max. Alternatively, maybe he took Extra Spell (Complete Arcane, pg 79) as his 15th level feat. Or maybe the Giant just wasn't thinking very much about Elan's spell list.

Itchy |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

"Wait, did he just say, 'vampire?'"
I think that the gods of good are on to Hel's scheme (whatever it is) and are trying to counter it somehow without her knowledge. Sounds like all the good clerics are on the lookout for a Dwarf vampire.
Also, I'm betting that all the good clerics are meeting up at Durkon's old hometown. That would fit with the prophecies.
I'm probably wrong, but that's my guess for now.

thejeff |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"Wait, did he just say, 'vampire?'"
I think that the gods of good are on to Hel's scheme (whatever it is) and are trying to counter it somehow without her knowledge. Sounds like all the good clerics are on the lookout for a Dwarf vampire.
Also, I'm betting that all the good clerics are meeting up at Durkon's old hometown. That would fit with the prophecies.
I'm probably wrong, but that's my guess for now.
Maybe, but whatever's going on with the cleric migration, Durkula knows about it and wants in on it. So that Hel can find out some secret location or something?