So with all the OGL mess, I was wondering if the Astral and Ethereal planes are OGL or if they are sufficiently generic to be used.

So then I found myself realizing that maybe we don't need both transitive planes.

Anyone else ever merged the two?

Ultimate Intrigue gave use the Vigilante class, and more importantly the Warlock, Cabalists, and Magical Child.

The Warlock archetype became my favorite class, but a lot of people get hung up on the Vigilante thing, and not everything else the class offers.

So, I set out to break the vigilante part out and make a more warlock like class.

I've set up a link to an editable word document, and would like feedback either on it or on here. If enough people like it, I'll take a stab at doing the same for some of the other archetypes.

The Tsoli v 1.0a

Elemental Forms

Your mastery of an element allows you to channel the true form of that element.

Prerequisites Elemental Focus, Greater Elemental Focus, Knowledge (Planes) 13 ranks.

Benefit: Pick one energy type which you have elemental focus and greater elemental focus. Half of the damage from that energy is not subject to being reduced by resistance or immunity.

Rationale:
The knowledge is to gatekeep the feat to mid to high levels, I mean I doubt getting it at level 3 would be game breaking, but the Winter Witch gets it at level 8 so min level 13.

Maybe knowledge religion instead, since Abadar's vault contains 'perfect copies of everything' it would have the Platonic Form (or Golarion verion) of fire.

"Trust me kid Everything has a melting point." Mick Rory The Flash, Blackest Night #3

So the Aldori Dueling Sword and the Elven Thornblade. Two of my favorite finesse weapon with art that looks so much alike. So which of the two do people prefer?

The Aldori sword comes with a feat tree to make it more flexible, at the feat cost. It also gets an archetype and a prestige class if you want to go the full Aldori.

The thornblade is a late arrival to the game, like a rapier and scimitar loved each other very much. No feats or archetypes, but it is more versatile out of the box (P/S damage, +2 to confirm crits)

I also wonder which looks more like the Honshu Katana from United Cutlery?

The last PF1 update was in April. So that's at least 4 volumes of an AP that are unsanctioned as well as Chronicle of Legends.

If this has been answered, apologies, my search fu is weak.

(And that I am asking this for the first time in 5 seasons should tell you how often I play prepared arcane casters)

Should the costs of scribing spells beyond 1st level be tracked on an ITS? I was wondering since my PC dropped 490 gold after last scenario on getting spells out of another PC's spellbook.

Ok, I didn't see anyone else mention this, but really?

I'm trying to build a bard for Sunday. Sad that tanglefoot isn't on the bard spell list, so I went for my old standby, prestigitation.

And stopped.

Ok, so the two more 'fun' portions of the spell are no longer available to the bard? 'lift' is worse than mage hand in every possible aspect, and 'make' is not even good for the purpose of making eggs pop out of your mouth, as it is now concentration only.

So apparently the bard should not be able to season his food, chill his wine, clean his outfit after going through the sewers or change the colour of his cape to match his patron's preferences.

Why?

With Season 10 being the last 1.0 season being released...

Any chance we can see some of the races opened up/opened back up? Yes I know it may lead to 'year of the zoo' parties, but if 1.0 doesn't get any more scenarios/support, I'd like to have hard coded the option to play some of the previous boon races I never got to until I run out of 1.0 stuff to run/play.

Based on the art, can they grow hair/facial hair?

Good afternoon,

I need to cancel all my subscriptions except the adventure paths. Loss of income sucks. Thank you

I understand it's likely too late for November, but I'd like to end my module and pathfinder society scenarios subscriptions. The modules just don't hit the right spot anymore and I'm not GMing much society here in Columbus any more.

Just using Paizo products, how many prepared arcane casters are there with 6 levels of spells?

I can think of

Magus
Warlock vigilante
Cabalist Vigilante.

Any I missed?

Ok.

I'm in the all too common situation of the player catching things and the PC doesn't have a clue. Here be some spoilers.

Finding our first cultist

I'm just looking for a bit of lightheartedness. Post your crazy elemental concepts here. A couple of mine will likely see play, but I'm thinking of other silly options. Kind of like my Werechihuahua or the Tengu Summoner I've been threatening... "Greetings. I am Pidge. Pidge Eyoto."

Well, it's posted.

Not going to GenCon, but Columbus is closer? Come join us for three days of gaming in the heart of Ohio! Pathfinder Society and D&D 5E events are going live!

Friday nights games are to be held at Perkins in Hilliard:
1451 Rome Hilliard Road, Columbus OH 43228-9778

Saturday and Sunday are to be held at The Guard Tower:
3600 Trabue Rd, Columbus, OH 43204

5e Games to be added.

Singups are on Warhorn Here.

Just curious if anyone else has done this.

I'm looking at the Vigilante, and kind of doing it backwards. My character's vigilante identity is his 'real' identity, he was a Pathfinder in training who lost friends in Siege of Serpents. As such he's sworn personal revenge on the Aspis, and cultivated a 'civilian' identity for those times he needs to be subtle. Basically Warlock by day, businessman by night.

anyone else done similar with the meta-plot? New PC was all gung-ho for the Shadow Lodge, then it went sideways, Follower of Lysalla who joined after season 4, etc etc.

And realizing it's almost a Starfinder AP In and of itself.

If you think about Destiny as the connecting glue, you have both the adventure of exploring the Destiny of itself with the various stops on worlds as 'rooms' in a mega dungeon.

Kind of like Reign of Winter... in space.

Realized something with the Jingasa of the soldier who has everything useful, so he bought this.

A crit negation consumable is worth 2000 GP per the PTD.

+1 Deflection (slotted) 2000 GP.

Jingasa = 5000

So there's 3K. For the item's second power, it's 1.5 cost per the item creation rules.

So this means that the formula is either +1 deflection (2000) + Crit negation (2000 * 1.5) or Crit negation (2000) + +1 deflection (2000 * 1.5)

Q.E.D.

Ok, I apologize if this has been discussed elsewhere and my search-fu is too weak to find it...

How does a Warlock add spells to their spellbooks? I am assuming like a magus (all 0 level and 3+ int mod spells at first level, then 2 per level after that) and then they can also scribe as a magus/arcanist/wizard. But want to make sure,

Ok, this came up in discussion with a fellow Pathfinder player.

I have certain characters that I want to play certain scenarios, not because of boon picking, but because of location. My Jadwiga half elf bard, for example has a GM credit for Shades of Ice I, and has played II and III, as well as From Under Ice because they're all set in or around Irrisen.

Likewise, I asked for someone to run Midnight Mauler since I have an Ustalav psychic detective in tier. Is it wrong of me to play characters that regionally 'gel' with the scenario?

Just going to sulk that I can't get 10 dice sets of these still. *sigh*

More specifically, how the abilities are partitioned.

Obviously Paraduke William, loyal neutral citizen of Cheliax can't be seen channeling the blessings of Milani, as does the Steel Rose, Zealot.

But why can't Lord Oblivious, of Taldor, be a dabbler in the arcane arts and not be connected to Baron Strange the mysterious warlock avenger of the bearless?

Good morning!

Going through my humble bundle comics I had a thought occur to me. Would it be possible to use the maps included in the bundles/comics in future scenarios?

They aren't that complex to draw, but having them available would be nice, as my mapmaking skills are poor.

Before I take a shot at unchaining the eldritch scoundrel I thought I'd request a change on something that affects another of my characters...

The Scorpion Whip.

Currently PFS uses the description in the Adventurer's Armoury, a soft cover that has only had one reprinting.

Back in May the whip was FAQed for Ultimate Combat, the more recent publication/ To date, the AR uses the older, less common source of the weapon.

The clarification of the Scorpion Whip makes it clear how the item interacts with both just whip proficiency and with proficiency in both.

It's time to use the most recent version, the wider published version.

Free the scorpion whip.

Good morning,

Just reauthed my card for my monthly order and went to pick up a scenario for tomorrow, and saw my Subcriber discount wasn't applying.

Sure for a scenario it's small change, but heck I need small change :-)

Well, looks like there's a new Thunderbolts coming out.

Just wanted to mention it since, Jim Zub is the writer.

Good morning all.

I'm working on variant Shabti rules, as I find the race neat and want to contribute something. For people who don't have Pyramid of the Sky Pharaoh (End of the Mummy's Mask AP) They are native outsiders with the racial abilities of all knowledge skills are class skills (2 RP) and suggestion once a day as an SLA. My variants are going to be changing those two things. (No plans to do the 'dial an ability combo ala tieflings/aasimars)

The Race builder rules for magical racial traits says "Choose a 2nd-level or lower spell that does not attack a creature or deal damage." ignoring for the moment that suggestion is only a second level spell for bards (it costs 3 rp for Shabti), and ignoring that it, like many of the published plaentouched SLAs do either attack a creature or deal damage, is heroism too good for a 1/day SLA?

Aside, the variants I'm looking at also include one that does prayer one that does arcane sight and a final one that does nondetection.

Is there any PFS going on? I'll be visiting family and might be able to sneak away.

I could bring bonekeep...

I tried a search, and while I could find the topic, I couldn't find an answer, either on the boards or the errata.

for the Draugr Captain what is the DC to resist/remove the negative level? Is it 12 like the regular Draugr's Nausea?

Glad to see the evil iconics getting an appearance in the book

Ok, the feat True breed...

So is my reading of the feat's text that you no longer count as human or elf (for example) for FCB options seem a bit harsh or does it make sense?

Ok, per the AR page, Inspire Imitation is legal (But coin shot isn't... but that's for another rant) problem is...

It replaces skilled on the half elf. So it's legal and doesn't work (much like Obamacare)

Should it replace multitalented?

OK, I just checked the GTOP v 6.0 and couldn't find anything so I need help.

Prepping Carrion Hill and stumbled across this:

Now,as far as I can tell, since this is a spellbook, and not a set of scrolls, this means that if I've a prepared arcane caster at the table Friday (Wizard/Arcanist/Magus/Witch) they can add the spells to their book/familiar, correct?

Not unbalancing as far as non of the spells really come into play until highest Tier/Seeker play, but I want to make sure.

Ok, don't know if this had been thought of before...
(Disclaimer, this came to me while listening to Prince of Wolves in my normal idea place*)

There are at least two scenarios that open up options for a specific other PC** and a couple that open up options for all your PCs***

Has there been any thought about opening up races this way as well? To paraphrase text from <redacted>

New Recruits: Your success at impressing <insert race here> inspires some <race> to join the Society. You may designate one newly created PC under your Pathfinder Society number as a new recruit. This additional training allows the new PC to be <race>. You must include a copy of this Chronicle sheet with the new PC’s records, though that PC gains no additional boons, equipment, or wealth from this Chronicle sheet.
Character receiving this boon: – Faction: GM Initials:

Thus a player could have no more than two of <race> preventing Aasimar spam, for example (One as GM credit and maybe one as PC). Just include other language so that the Core character/GM credit can't be applied to a non-Core PC. (at least to start, they can convert like normal PC's later) That way there's no "I got this off a core PC, but rebuilt him into a drow bloodrager..." It could be restricted even further by limiting it to faction specific as well.

I was thinking specifically of races like catfolk/ratfolk/skinwalkers, etc.

There's an off topic talk about earning fame in the Eldritch Archer thread, so I thought I'd move it over to it's own thread.

I've found with the older scenarios the second prestige point varies wildly from scenario to scenario Some are automatic (completing the primary condition completes the secondary) Some are pretty much required. (defeating the final enemy who can't escape you) Some are bloody near impossible (looks at Among the dead suspiciously)

Of course, the little of season 7 I touch seems to fall into the later catagory. When I ran Six Seconds to Midnight, the puzzle ruined the scenario more that the flying buggers of death. I gave them the secondary PP because they technically did complete the objective*

Premise: An option is banned only if it conflicts with the nature or goals of the campaign.
Premise: Wasp Familiar does not conflict with the nature or goals of the campaign.
Conclusion: Wasp Familiar should not be banned.
-------------------------------
Reasoning:

Premise #1:
I’m using Jiggy’s guidelines for arguing my point. So there’s more cut & paste

One method is that nothing outside the Core Assumption is allowed, unless it appears to specifically benefit the campaign. That is, when a new book comes out, we "start" with everything banned, and then Tonya and the VO’s looks through it and sees something and says "Hey, X would make the campaign better" and makes an exception for it (i.e., legalize it).

The other method is that new content is generally legal, unless it appears to specifically hurt the campaign. That is, when a new book comes out, we "start" with an assumption that its content will be legal, and then Tonya and the VO’s look through it and sees something and says "Hey, X would cause problems with the campaign" and makes an exception for it (i.e., ban it).
It is my understanding that the latter is the stance of PFS leadership, hence Premise #1.

Premise #2:
I am not aware of any aspect of the campaign with which Wasp Familiar conflicts.
It does not affect wealth.
It does not invite unregulated customization.
It does not skirt alignment restrictions.
It does not slow down gameplay.
It does not have canon issues.
It does not skirt PvP rules.
The above list should all be pretty self-evident.
Since we don’t know why it is banned. I will contend that it should not be.

The first argument I have seen is concern about it being a way to get a familiar or improved familiar without the need for Iron Will (Familiar Bond) or Skill Focus (Eldritch Heritage: Arcane). We already have one step familiar feats with qualifications (Aberrant Tumor) that grant a familiar, as well as the religion feats that grant class abilities to worshipers. (Bloodletting and Blood Vengeance both give a bleed attack at first level, disciple of the sword gives weapon specialization and access to fighter only feats, Dreamed Secrets gives arcane spells to divine casters, Ironbound Master gives armor training.) So this feat is on par with those. For arcane casters with a familiar it is a ‘flavourful familiar’ feat until 5th level, when it becomes similar to a weakened imp familiar.

The next argument I see is that the familiar is ‘better’ than the greensting scorpion because it has a fly speed. In rebuttal, I point to the compsognathus. This familiar gives a +4 bonus to initiative, has a swim speed (instead of fly speed) does slightly more damage, has a more effective poison (dc 12 vs 10, strength damage vs sickened), and scent. Thus the wasp familiar (already costing a feat) is not ‘better’ than end any other familiar.

Now comparing the improved wasp to the imp.
The familiar uses the statistics for an imp but just the statistics. It is still a wasp (albeit an lawful evil outsider) and thus does not have the ability to use magical weapons and items like an imp. Unless you choose to argue that the regular wasp familiar has no wings, 8 legs, and a segmented tail. Also it loses the at will invisibility (2nd level spell, albeit self only) for the 3/day unnatural lust. Much more fun, sure, but much less effective.* That brownies and sprites can use items makes the greater wasp familiar comparable to them. For non-familiar classes, the familiar takes *another* feat to activate, which can be done with improved familiar.

Since it is unlikely that Dirty Tactics will receive an errata, Pathfinder Society should include the errata that it also loses the lawful, evil, and devil subtypes but gains the chaotic subtype. Modifying existing material to better fit the society also has precedent. (True Breed comes immediately to mind, as does alterations of scribe scroll for wizards and brew potion for alchemist)

Finally, I see some people note concerns about the brawler archtype. While I’m unaware of what would make the brawler so uniquely powerful for either incarnation of the familiar. I’d point out that the improved wasp does not qualify, since it does not have ‘speak with others of its own kind’ to replace.

-----------------------------------
Based on the argument above, I believe it follows logically that Wasp Familiar should not be banned.

(Decided to start a new thread to avoid the clogging of the updates thread as was suggested)
Long rant incoming…
I’m very disappointed by the latest updates from the Additional Resources. Many things were banned, apparently with no rhyme or reason I can see. I’m going to go over the ones that I read and stuck out in my mind.

Races of the Inner Sea:

Pretty self explanatory. Sure Toughness is a better choice but I found myself curious.

Edit, wrong feat name

Good eve all.

Just got home, excited to download Bonekeep II Electric Boogaloo, and none of my downloads are, well downloading.

Windows 10, chrome browser. No changes from my last download.

Still wish we could get 10 dice sets.

Ok, the Vanguard is one of my favourite 3pp (that isn't Dreamscarred) so I've been looking at archtypes for it.

I'm thinking..

Good morning,

It appears my subscription auth email hasn't gone through for July.

slime grenade for reference.

Ran Emerald Spire with a level two alchemist who had two of them. The damage isn't absurd, but the damage to items... wow. How to disarm the BBEG in one pop.

They saved the party from a TPK, and I at least got to see it eat the archer's 600 GP bow when the bad guy grabbed it to shoot and the alchemist tossed the other grenade. But wow.

(for quick reference, a greatsword has 10 hp per my item sheet, a metal hafted weapon has 20. A bow has 5)

Thank you.

Well with most all of the vanities gone, on what are people spending prestige?

Obviously getting better, (removing conditions, raise dead, etc) but what else is there?

Ok, was just prepping this for a core game and noticed something:

So this works for the Darchive faction card, right?

Well assuming my party doesn't kill my core bard in the next two hours...

He's sovereign court, but I clicked on exchange in mistake.

Edit: I tried searching for a thread on this.

Does a sleep arrow have a hit dice cap? Came up in combat today, and the decription on the prd doesn't list hit dice or duration, but based on the DC, it seems like sleep.

Ok, was playing with HeroLab and came across the Wealthy Dabbler trait. Text from the source (not Herolab) reads:

As I read it, you *are* casting these spells, not spell like abilities. So I'm reading this opens up Arcane Strike, albiet 'stuck' at level 1.