The problem with "everything must be archetypes or alternate classes" is that locks you into a basic framework that restricts the ability to introduce new concepts. I guess - if you really, really stretch it - I can see an excuse for Alchemist as a Rogue archetype, especially since they have the Investigator and the Vivisectionist both going back and stealing Rogue's stuff. But what class should Inquisitor be an archetype of? Or Magus? Both are too different from any Core class to truly be pulled off with an archetype or alternate class.
WHAT'S THIS...A RATIONAL DISCUSSION, NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
Vivianne Laflamme wrote:
This sounds perfectly rational