| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
These are fantastic, jsled! I've got a few more suggestions for you, places described the Pathfinder Chronicles Guide to Absalom book:
and Actors’ Guild, the playhouse serves as both the Ivy District Nomarch Alain Always’s home and a theater famous for some of the finest stage performances in Absalom—as well as some of the most scandalously risqué.
their station within the school. Apprentices wear green (and are often called “greens” by natives of Absalom), journeymen blue, and masters black. Tradition dictates that all other clothing be white, at least during performances.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
This monster looks seriously like it's much larger than what is listed (LARGE) , it seems like atleast huge by the look at that picture I have changed it's size to match the picture to HUGE
It does look a little too big for Large, yeah. If it's worth anything, I decided to leave it at the original size and none of my players made any comment. So it might not be as egregious as it looks to a GM's overanalysing mind.
By the way I have a question: In the catacombs, there's 2 ceustodaemons guarding the main entrance of the Skinner's murder cultist lair. They have see invisibility. One of my players cast clairvoyance to spy that location. I described the daemons as realising the eye is there after a few seconds and one of them squashing it between his thumb and index finger.
Would these daemons bother to report this incident? If so, to whom? The guy who summoned them is dead, there's also a bunch of murder cultists in the next room playing with a harrow but I doubt the daemons would report to them. Skinner is a long way away and too out of it to care about something so subtle I think. So... do they just shrug it off?
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Ceustodaemons are neither particularly bright nor particularly loyal...I don't think they'd care.
Update! My players found the Skinsaw cult in the Catacombs of the Fellowship of Prospectus several days before the bank robbery was scheduled to take place. They completely cleared out the Skinner and her cult with 1/2 a day to spare, so...I guess we're skipping the actual robbery?
I could have the Copper Hand try to pull off the robbery anyway, but I feel like its more narratively appropriate and rewarding to the players to have the CH just go into hiding for awhile once they realize the guards are onto them and the Skinsaw cult isn't going to bother them for awhile.
So I guess we're on to book 3 without ever doing the robbery! I feel like I had the Agents work hard to get the info and location of the Skinsaw cult, so I'm happy with that aspect.
That sounds great. Make sure to find a way to communicate the cancellation of the robbery to the players somehow. They should know they indirectly prevented it. Don't ask me how, though, I have no idea.
Did they have any level issues with Skinner by the way? They're supposed to be level 8 or 9 in that fight but presumably they were lower in your game? Or maybe not.
My players are currently fighting Skinner after walking into their front door with some NPC backup but no real plan, triggering the alarm and basically having to fight the whole base wave after wave. I'm a bit worried about them.
@Naurgul: We'll see tonight, they'll have to race to get in contact with the Copper Hand to call off the robbery.
No real issues with the Skinner. She was a real tough fight, but appropriately so for the 2nd boss of the adventure. They're only level 7, but there's 5 of them and they played their tactics very well.
Wow. Did they fight her alone or what? By my calculations, Skinner with 3 excorions is beyond an extreme-threat encounter for 5 level 7 PCs.
The excorions were tougher than The Skinner when we fought her. She didn't have any caster support. It made her pretty easy.
@Naurgul: Skinner got a crit fail against Phantasmal Killer and was running/frightened for awhile. When she got back to the fight she still laid into the PC's, but with some good tactics they were able to take her down.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Nice. In my game she got a crit fail against slow and that basically doomed her. Despite her wild protestations and managing to get practically the whole cult to join the fight in waves, she got killed.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
What is the most common way to strike a monster with a « good » attack? When should I add the 10 hit points from a good weakness to the damage roll?
Tx!
Holy weapon.
Alignment based spell cast by class with good deity like Divine Lance.
Some special ability like a paladin's smite evil which does good damage when activated.
Or plenty of vials of holy water with simple weapon proficiency. 11 damage on a miss is pretty solid when it comes up.
OK, so one of my player characters speaks Aklo, and it seems likely they'll be able to negotiate the Ether Spiders out of the vault non-violently. That means I'll be dealing with the Xill...but I can't figure out how that's supposed to work.
Xill have no way, as written, to travel between planes but their innate, limited Plane Shift spell, but there's no indication that it takes them less time than the 10 minutes it usually takes to cast, and it also doesn't indicate that it functions differently regarding arrival location than the spell as written. By my reading, the enraged Xill would cast Plane Shift and end up *somewhere* on Golarion 10 minutes later, which is unlikely to be anywhere near Absalom, and by which time my players will probably already have wandered off to the next candidate bank-job target so the Xill wouldn't find them where they left them anyway, even if I handwave the location thing. Should I handwave the location and casting time? By how much?
Anyone have any advice on this? Mr. Sayre, any clarifications on intent?
Perhaps you can have the Xill start casting as soon as the players start talking amicably to the spiders. Then depending on how long the PCs take to resolve the situation and leave you get a bunch of possible outcomes: if they finish too early the Xill loses them but maybe attacks the banker. If they take too long then the Xill appears and hides, perhaps forcing a free-for-all fight or a tense negotiation + fight at the same time.
Or you can hand-wave BOTH the location and the casting time.
Alternatively, you can completely remove the Xill from the situation. It's not like it's critical to the plot or anything. It's a throwaway more or less random encounter.
|
OK, so one of my player characters speaks Aklo, and it seems likely they'll be able to negotiate the Ether Spiders out of the vault non-violently. That means I'll be dealing with the Xill...but I can't figure out how that's supposed to work.
Xill have no way, as written, to travel between planes but their innate, limited Plane Shift spell, but there's no indication that it takes them less time than the 10 minutes it usually takes to cast, and it also doesn't indicate that it functions differently regarding arrival location than the spell as written. By my reading, the enraged Xill would cast Plane Shift and end up *somewhere* on Golarion 10 minutes later, which is unlikely to be anywhere near Absalom, and by which time my players will probably already have wandered off to the next candidate bank-job target so the Xill wouldn't find them where they left them anyway, even if I handwave the location thing. Should I handwave the location and casting time? By how much?
Anyone have any advice on this? Mr. Sayre, any clarifications on intent?
I wouldn't worry about it. PF2 is full of monster abilities that don't work exactly the way they do for the players. If he is hunting the spiders who is to say he isn't equipped with a consumable that he uses to chase them?
Are you aware that you can't trip or grapple as part of an attack of opportunity?
And that you only have one attack of opportunity per round of combat ?
So if he gets an attack(not a trip or grapple) on one of the ennemies rushing him, cool, the others will still reach him and hit him, most likely gritting him cause of low AC.
Plus he's easier to flank. That build is really not cheesy it's just adequate.
They can, just not by lower level ennemies.
Look if his build works well for the map more power to him.
I had a badger riding champion with reach controling choke points, it was infuriating for the ennemies, but the players had a blast.
No need to tweek.
(Also if he's doing maneuvers he's not doing damage so it's a tradeoff)
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
If you don't mind converting from 1E, there's a wealth of adventures set in Absalom ripe for the looting, already categorized and filed by the fine folks at Pathfinder Wiki. There's even 3 scenarios and 1 module set in the Precipice Quarter!
I appreciate everyone's thoughts on filling the missing experience in this volume and I liked the idea of using a PFS adventure to bridge that gap. I have one player who has done every PFS scenario in 2e, but none of them played Pathfinder Society in 1e. I decided to adapt Mists of Mwangi - making the location the Mwangi Pavilion at the Radiant Festival (a collaboration between the Magaambya academy and the Pathfinder Lodge in Nantambu). The map of the Blakros Museum in that scenario looks nothing like the museum as it's presented today - the perfect size for a pavilion.
Some of the treasure awarded in the sidequest will be items of an appropriate level from Strength of Thousands adventure path and Threshold of Knowledge. For supporting the Pathfinder Society to solve a problem in the Precipice District I’m also thinking of opening up some feat and alchemical formulae options from the society as a reward.
Barbarians can't have flat footed also he blocks the entire map due to how small they are. A lot of enemies are lower level. He also uses trip which he succeds a lot and with slow as a GM it comes to a grindfest of doing nothing. I get that I give potions of quicken to my enemies and manipulate them a bit.Are you aware that you can't trip or grapple as part of an attack of opportunity?
And that you only have one attack of opportunity per round of combat ?
So if he gets an attack(not a trip or grapple) on one of the ennemies rushing him, cool, the others will still reach him and hit him, most likely gritting him cause of low AC.
Plus he's easier to flank. That build is really not cheesy it's just adequate.
And you are using the Multiple Attack Penalty on the trips? Trips count as attacks for the Multiple Attack Penalty. So each additional trip attempt is at -5 and then -10. Only one AoO per round. Fighter Multiclass won't get the extra AoO feat until level 20 since you only count as half your fighter level for fighter feats.
Thanks for the answers but we separated our paths with the player. He wasn't a good person to play with in the first place with constant complaining. Now I had a relook I could actually turn him into my pet by making enemies challenging him constantly in the opposite side of the room. That would be hilarious :DBarbarians can't have flat footed also he blocks the entire map due to how small they are. A lot of enemies are lower level. He also uses trip which he succeds a lot and with slow as a GM it comes to a grindfest of doing nothing. I get that I give potions of quicken to my enemies and manipulate them a bit.Are you aware that you can't trip or grapple as part of an attack of opportunity?
And that you only have one attack of opportunity per round of combat ?
So if he gets an attack(not a trip or grapple) on one of the ennemies rushing him, cool, the others will still reach him and hit him, most likely gritting him cause of low AC.
Plus he's easier to flank. That build is really not cheesy it's just adequate.
And you are using the Multiple Attack Penalty on the trips? Trips count as attacks for the Multiple Attack Penalty. So each additional trip attempt is at -5 and then -10. Only one AoO per round. Fighter Multiclass won't get the extra AoO feat until level 20 since you only count as half your fighter level for fighter feats.
Good for you then !
|
|
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I really like the idea (from way earlier in this thread) about making the Chapter 1 investigation more rewarding and open ended. Lifting from Naurgul’s ideas, here’s how I’m planning to adapt this for my game.
THE PARADE ROUTE: The PCs have already decided they want to walk the parade route to scout out potential bank targets. I’ve located the staging area for the parade around the Starstone Cathedral, with the route starting south down the Avenue of the Hopeful, turning east across the Coins district to the Gallery of Innovation, then heading south through the Docks to the Precipice Quarter and the Festival Grounds.
TARGETS AND KEY LOCATIONS: In their scouting mission, they will find the three banks listed in the adventure on the parade route. I’m placing Chadraxa’s Cheap Loans in the Mudhaven neighborhood of the Coins, and I’ve placed Gilel’s Tannery in the Docks district on the parade route not far from the Precipice District.
INVESTIGATING/GATHERING INFO ON THE BANKS: After scouting out potential targets, the PCs can either visit each bank and/or gather information in the Coins about them. A success will give them general info about the bank (i.e. the largest of the banks, the manager’s name etc.) while a critical success will give them all of the information they would have otherwise found in the file.
INFO FROM THE TOKEN GUARD: The PCs can also access this information by paying the Token Guards at the Bail House a ‘consultant fee’ to look at the files they have on each bank – and later on Chadraxa (I’m thinking 10gp per file)
GATHERING INFO ON THE PARADE/FLOATS/ETC.: The PCs can also gather information on rumours about the parade itself to learn about the vandalism of Gilel’s float, or topics related to law and order in the Coins district to learn of the Token Guard’s dubious reputation, and of Chadraxa having her finger on the pulse of banking/crime in the Coins. I’m sure the players will come up with some out of the box ideas, and these nuggets are also options to reward them for creative play.
ADDITIONAL INFO THE PCs KNOW: If they don’t uncover all of this information through investigation, Orvington will mention when the parade comes up that one of his customers (Gilel) had his float vandalized – could that be related? And Rohka Stonesworn will ask if they’ve spoken with Chadraxa… that she often has more information on bank-related issues than the Token Guard.
I’m hoping this plan will allow the PCs to pursue the trail of clues to advance the story while being more satisfying/engaging than being handed a case file.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Very nice, I like the idea of preparing how to give additional information to players if they fail to make the connection themselves or are lost.
For the Token Guard, don't forget to include retrievable information on that goblin burglar Quidley. In my game when the PCs visited the token guard they were told no goblin of that name had ever been arrested but they managed to take a peek at the papers and saw that the name was actually in the files but crossed out.
I'm going to make a full thread soon to share everything extra I prepared for the investigation in this book.
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
For the Token Guard, don't forget to include retrievable information on that goblin burglar Quidley. In my game when the PCs visited the token guard they were told no goblin of that name had ever been arrested but they managed to take a peek at the papers and saw that the name was actually in the files but crossed out.
That's a good call out. I've been cribbing your stuff since I started this campaign and it's definitely making the AP way more interesting to me as a GM and believable/credible to my players. Your advice to me on the Precipice Quarter/Radiant Festival map and Book 1/Chapter 1 encounters took me off the fence about GMing this AP. Definitely looing forward to your expanded notes!
I'm glad to hear that :D
As promised, I wrote a big expansion for the bank robbery investigation, which you can read here.
OK, so I have questions about the Copper Hand Hideout. As written, the captured bank robbers give the PCs the location of the Hideout, but it's not detailed what information they give outside of that. This led to an awkward moment where Melipdra says "I’d recommend a tactical, stealthy approach, especially since we have reason to believe the thieves might be holding a hostage," and I had to go, "wait, what?"
I knew about Gribse, of course, but there's zero hints that the PCs would have learned about him prior to this line. I had to improvise a bit on the spot, and now they want to know what all they know about this person. Were they reported missing (obviously Absalom has a Missing Persons reporting system, as they were working a portion of that list a week or two ago), and if so from where and by whom, and if not why not? And I don't really have very much in the way of answers for them. One can assume Gribse is either an Absalomian native or a childhood immigrant as he was bitten by a Sleepless Suns animal 8 years ago, so now I have to make up sufficient backstory for this character that made enough of themselves to become an engineering student but not so much that there's an especially active investigation into their multi-week disappearance from their life!
Any tips on how you handled this, or the level of information your party got from the captured Hands?
Could be that the Sleepless Suns were able to piece it together as part of their own investigation into the Copper Hand, and offered the tip to the agents when they showed up asking to raid their hideout. Maybe there were reports of a man matching his description around the location or the kidnapping a few weeks ago left some clues suggesting the Copper Hand were responsible.
Designer
|
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Could be that the Sleepless Suns were able to piece it together as part of their own investigation into the Copper Hand, and offered the tip to the agents when they showed up asking to raid their hideout. [...]
I have limited insight into the intent of this particular character because who they are and what their role is changed a lot between the turnover and final release, but this is exactly how I'd handle it. Remind the PCs that they're just one unit from one jurisdiction and that there's a bunch of other NPCs out there doing the same job with varying degrees of competence and success. Makes it feel more like something where you have those interdepartmental rivalries while also allowing you to inject information into the story as necessary.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Thanks for the guidance, Michael, much appreciated!
Here's what I wound up giving my players:
Each district keeps its own missing persons lists, reporting unsolved cases up to the Starwatch (Absalom's FBI equivalent) bi-weekly, who then distribute briefs on still unresolved cases down to the other districts after another week. The robbers weren't sure how long Gribse had been kept prisoner, but it's been at least a couple of weeks. The latest one of those lists at Edgewatch HQ is about a week old, and doesn't have anyone by that name. The Sleepless Suns list, though, does have a case opened by a student at the Clockwork Cathedral in the Coins who had been turned away by the Token Guard for not being able to pay an inquiry fee, but had remembered that his tutor, one Gribse Burlish, lived in the Foreign Quarter, and had reported the case to the Utterhome after the second missed paid weekly session. The Sleepless Suns hadn't been able to confirm his place of residence, but were able to confirm with the Clockwork Cathedral that he was enrolled there as an advanced research student. He had missed a couple of weeks of classes, but the absence rate has been unusually high at Universities across the city due to the festival, and no one but the student who had been paying him had realized anything was truly amiss.
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I'm glad someone flagged the point about Melipdra mentioning a possible hostage as my group should reach that point in a couple weeks. I'm inclined to remove the reference to the hostage entirely as it just doesn't make much sense if Melipdra has almost no information on the Copper Hand, but enough to suspect a hostage (and then to have taken no action to learn more about it).
It doesn't seem essential to the plot for the party to know about the hostage in advance - and there are visible clues that can be provided for the PCs to pick up on his hostage status when they encounter him.
Well it does help establish the tone that the entire city is overwhelmed by the Radiant Festival and that they may just not have the personnel to follow up on every lead as soon as they get them.
A potential kidnapping is definitely a high-priority issue, but the involvement of a gang means that much greater resources would be required for the big bust and that even verifying the rumor requires some subtle investigation.