The list has "Toymaker's Hammer" and "The Toymaker's Hammer"
is that a mistake or is that this year's Orc Torc?
There seem to be two "Grasping Shields," two "Guiding Stars," and two "Rings of the Champion" in the running this year. Can anyone confirm that?
Also, a "Rod of Imaging" and a "Rod of Imagining" both appear on the list. Can anyone confirm that one is not just a typo for the other?
I'll confirm the first three, the last one I am unsure of for now.
I have seen 2 different Guiding Stars
As far as I can tell there is no rod of imaging.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
As far as I can tell there is no rod of imaging.
Just like there is no spoon...
;)
Staff of the Cacophonous Earth just came up in my voting pair, so that's definitely the correct version. Not sure though whether there's also one without the "the" in it, though I also would assume that's a duplicate.
If it wouldn't break the autosum, it could be beneficial to add a header row for a big red warning along the lines of "Please check for your item's name both with and without "The" included in it anywhere".
Possibly reduce the chance of this type of duplication from recurring.
Staff of the Cacophonous Earth definitely did have the "the" in it.
"The Toymaker's Hammer" is definitely an item. I just had it show up.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Marathon is getting close now, less than a 100 votes to go :)
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
And I'm there - "Mr Triple Snickers Bar" is mine! :D
(Snickers used to be manly and ruggedly named as a "Marathon" bar before they globalized to the derisive laugh name it now has!)
Unique items seen 726
Approx unseen items - 70 to 80 or so.
RPG Superstar 2014 Top 16
,
Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8
aka Jrcmarine
|
Now that we have almost two weeks of voting complete, I am sure many of you have lists. I am more than willing to share my list with anybody that is interested and of course I ask anyone interested to share their's with me. If interested please PM me.
Last year this was a great exercise for me. It helped me to re-examine some items that I originally kept, some items I had dismissed and it let me know there were items out there that I hadn't seen yet, which helped me to continue the slog that voting sometimes becomes.
Owner - D20 Hobbies
,
Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8
|
There seem to be two "Grasping Shields," two "Guiding Stars," and two "Rings of the Champion" in the running this year. Can anyone confirm that?
Also, a "Rod of Imaging" and a "Rod of Imagining" both appear on the list. Can anyone confirm that one is not just a typo for the other?
items/Ring of the Champion - 124 Words items/Ring of the Champion - 287 Words
items/Grasping Shield - 149 Words items/Grasping Shield - 218 Words
items/Guiding Star - 271 Words items/Guiding Star - 298 Words
I only see one Rod:
items/Rod of Perfect Imagining - 112 Words
There seem to be two "Grasping Shields," two "Guiding Stars," and two "Rings of the Champion" in the running this year. Can anyone confirm that?
Also, a "Rod of Imaging" and a "Rod of Imagining" both appear on the list. Can anyone confirm that one is not just a typo for the other?
items/Ring of the Champion - 124 Words items/Ring of the Champion - 287 Words
items/Grasping Shield - 149 Words items/Grasping Shield - 218 Words
items/Guiding Star - 271 Words items/Guiding Star - 298 Words
I only see one Rod:
items/Rod of Perfect Imagining - 112 Words
I'm pretty sure there is both an Imagining and an Imaging Staff, two similar yet very different entries.
|
Owner - D20 Hobbies
,
Marathon Voter Season 7, Marathon Voter Season 8
|
I'm pretty sure there is both an Imagining and an Imaging Staff, two similar yet very different entries.
I can say authoritatively in 745 votes, I haven't seen either item:
snort round-1 # ls items/*magin*
items/Rod of Perfect Imagining - 112 Words
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
(•_•)
All you Unix/Linux nerds...
( •_•)>⌐■-■
Need to get a grep...
(⌐■_■)
The Kyoketsu Shoge item was in twice using two different names. I deleted the one using only a single name.
I located another "The" duplicate and deleted it.
Finally, the longest named item is definitely a ring, stated so in the title and description. Ignore the mistake in the requirements line. I just tried to edit that and for some reason couldn't.
Also, there is ring I suspect is a duplicate of the one right next to it but can't say for certain. If I see the item again, I'll be able to say.
I added an item that was not on the list and determined that are definitely two items that I haven't seen yet. One is most definitely the last chakram. >.<
I've removed "Blood Letters Ring" several times, since I've only ever seen "The Blood Letters Ring" (which is also on the list), but people keep adding "Blood Letters Ring" to the list again. I'm fairly sure it shouldn't be there.
Edit: Also, "Elemental Sword" and "The Elemental Sword" may be duplicates. I'm not sure.
Yep, Elemental Sword was a duplicate. I removed Blood Letters Ring as that was duplicated. I added another item that wasn't on the list that I missed by not realizing that particular duplicate was there.
"season" is the possible duplicate that I'm keeping an eye out for at this time.
Why not take all of the "the" entries and rename them to "[Item Name], The"?
It'll be easier to spot any new duplicates that way.
Suggestion, now that the cull has happened: rather than having to make a second list (though I see the sheet has already been there), just highlight items with a different text field background color as they get seen post-cull?
LOL.
Nah, looks like people solidly committing to remaking the list... :P
Has it been started?
Yes. Look at the bottom of the sheet, there's another tab that links to the post-cull list.
Whoo! Made the cull! :D
EDIT: Okay, I moved a few things around, made a new statistics table, and started assigning categories to the post-cull items. Seems we've got some collaboration going, so it should all be good to go soon.
Interesting. So far -- and it's probably still early -- a higher percentage of rings have been culled.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
You can't upgrade named weapons
lolwut?
I'm just curious.
Did everyone include the first two items in their que after the cull? Chances are those were left there in the same way last year's items showed up as the first vote this year.
I could be wrong, but it makes sense.
Interesting. So far -- and it's probably still early -- a higher percentage of rings have been culled.
Agreed, most of the other categories seem to have moved only about 2% so far.
I'm just curious.
Did everyone include the first two items in their que after the cull? Chances are those were left there in the same way last year's items showed up as the first vote this year.
I could be wrong, but it makes sense.
I did not, for that very reason (the countdown timer was less than 60 seconds, indicating it was an old pair).
Whew, saw mine on the list.
Well mine got cut:( How do you know these items got cut/culled?
Well mine got cut:( How do you know these items got cut/culled?
I don't think anyone knows (other than Paizo people) what items have been culled, it's just a list of items that have been seen so far post-cull.
Can we tell if they did a 25% or a 50% cull yet? I haven't spotted a new item in a while which makes me think they culled at 50%.
Can we tell if they did a 25% or a 50% cull yet? I haven't spotted a new item in a while which makes me think they culled at 50%.
If they use past criteria, they will have cut any items that failed to get at least 40% up-votes each time they were paired. So the exact percentage of items could vary from year to year.