
Adamantine Dragon |

By the way, giant cockroach would taste a whole lot like lobster if you boiled it.
My first gaming group went through a period where we speculated on the taste of different monsters. We decided most giant bugs tasted like shrimp or lobster (because they are basically the same thing). Most reptilians tasted like alligator or snake (from Louisiana, yes, eaten both). Most mammals tasted sort of gamey but meaty. But the fun started when we speculated on things like beholders or gelatinous cubes...
After a while, when we started venturing into the sentient races, we started feeling sort of creepy about the whole thing...

Liam Warner |
By the way, giant cockroach would taste a whole lot like lobster if you boiled it.
My first gaming group went through a period where we speculated on the taste of different monsters. We decided most giant bugs tasted like shrimp or lobster (because they are basically the same thing). Most reptilians tasted like alligator or snake (from Louisiana, yes, eaten both). Most mammals tasted sort of gamey but meaty. But the fun started when we speculated on things like beholders or gelatinous cubes...
After a while, when we started venturing into the sentient races, we started feeling sort of creepy about the whole thing...
I remember one character I had grew up on the streets and kept herself from prostitution/theivery by harvesting the bodyparts of various creatures and selling them to mages. She paid for her education that way and saw no reason to stop when adventuring got her access to rare and unusual creatures. Thing is she didn't care what creature it actually was if the party killed it and it had valuable body parts she'd harvest them. The party made her agree not to harvest certain creatures after she started examining the human bandits to see if they had any body parts like a hand or something that might be useful in certain spells.
As far as she was concerned they'd been killed by the party in a legitimate adventure so if they had something useful (unlikely since no one ever seems to find much use for human parts unless their an executed murderer or a whole body) why shouldn't she sell it on and make a bit of extra cash. Had a nice little debate where they had to convince her why she could harvest the dire weasle but not the human bandit.

TheWhiteknife |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

If you just eat the horse parts of the centaur, you're not a cannibal.
Technically, unless one actually was a centaur, one could eat any part of the centaur and not be a cannibal.
*munch, munch*
AAAARRRRRGGGHHH
Pipe down, you! This is totally not an abomination in the eyes of the gods! *munch, munch*

![]() |

@Aleph --> Yeah, my players never had a problem eating lizardman. One barbarian even went so far as to take the highly-recognizable skin of a locally feared lizardman chieftain and make a snazzy jacket with lizardman-skull helm to wear around and intimidate the other tribes. Anyone that challenged him was eaten, and much respect was gained.
Then a girallon killed him.

Kevin Andrew Murphy Contributor |

One game we faced giant scorpions. After harvesting the venom, my gnome broke off the claws, cooked them, and served them with melted butter. As said by one of the other players (who was Chinese) "We're like the Chinese. We eat everything."
I'm certain everything is eaten and used because it's too good not to. Certainly with things like giant crayfish it's a no-brainer.

TheWhiteknife |

I have it on good authority that Ropers taste somewhat like swiss cheese with some earthy overtones. Or at least thats how I'd imagine it would be. Seriously though, at my table, my group has it in their heads that dwarves eat anything they slay, so i constantly have to come up with flavors on the fly (and keep them consistent).

Drejk |

In previous campaign my character, who was vagabond, ranger and wanderer tried to eat anything exotic that happened on our way: wyvern soup, roasted griffin, other things. As a side effect, when some of our characters replaced deities of the homebrew setting we played in and some catastrophic changes to the universe, the new deity of travel and wanderers that replaced the old good Fharlanghn also happens to be the god of cooking and exotic food.

![]() |

Heck, the halfling summoner that I'm currently playing draws a lot from the halflings as presented in Munchkin: if you can catch it, you can eat it. He was very disappointed to find out that a group of fiendish snakes were summoned, and therefore vanished after they were killed. He was in the mood for Hell-hot-snake kebabs. He did manage to keep all of the dire rats that we cleared out of some warehouse and went through various recipes with those; rat potroast, rat stew, rat sammiches, rat-pot-pie, rat-in-a-blanket, and so on. He had the Iron Liver trait & Great Fortitude.
Owlbears tend to get eaten any time we run across them, too. Tastes like turducken, but with bear!
Those proto-scorpions we faced in one of the APs ended up getting cooked, as did a giant spider and a dead monkey gifted by our winged friend in the night.
One of our guys decided to try and eat a dead harpy back in a game I ran. I told him that it tasted like boiled possum and shame.

Nakteo |

Best character idea ever:
An adventurer who travels the globe searching for new and exotic creatures to devour. He sticks with the group of PC's cause they can help him kill said creatures since some of them can be quite vicious. (Dragons don't seem to take kindly to someone sticking a fork in them for some reason.)

Adamantine Dragon |

Best character idea ever:
An adventurer who travels the globe searching for new and exotic creatures to devour. He sticks with the group of PC's cause they can help him kill said creatures since some of them can be quite vicious. (Dragons don't seem to take kindly to someone sticking a fork in them for some reason.)
I think you just described the love child of Bear Grylls and Man vs Food.

Johnico |

Nakteo wrote:I think you just described the love child of Bear Grylls and Man vs Food.Best character idea ever:
An adventurer who travels the globe searching for new and exotic creatures to devour. He sticks with the group of PC's cause they can help him kill said creatures since some of them can be quite vicious. (Dragons don't seem to take kindly to someone sticking a fork in them for some reason.)
I think he just described Toriko, from the manga of the same name. The guys whole goal is to travel the world, kill exotic monsters, and eat them.

![]() |

My last 3.5 Campaign(The 'Dwarf Campaign', as the players were all members of one Dwarf Clan, save the token Gnome...) had a scene where they killed a Dragon-Eel. They Levelled, and one guy took a few ranks in Prof-Sushi Chef...
Clever use of a bag of Holding/full of rice...
They made about 80,000 GP(Higher Level game, still, a nice chunk of change) selling Dragon Eel Unagi rolls.

James the Dark |
So far in my Kingmaker game, everything non-sapient the group has killed, they ate. Well, with one exception. Because of the large group, I layered a couple templates onto Tuskgutter the boar and turned him into a fey-infested troll-regeneration-bearing monstrosity. They didn't want to eat him after they killed 'im.

![]() |

The tail is the only section of the Alligator that we can eat.
It's an interesting experiment to consider what parts of monsters we could or could not eat:
Only the tails of lizard folk.
Maybe only the tendrils of a Beholder.
Etc.
My one group of players killed a dire boar, and harvested it to make pancetta and bacon.

Kevin Andrew Murphy Contributor |

The tail is the only section of the Alligator that we can eat.
It's an interesting experiment to consider what parts of monsters we could or could not eat:
Only the tails of lizard folk.
Maybe only the tendrils of a Beholder.
Etc.My one group of players killed a dire boar, and harvested it to make pancetta and bacon.
I think it's more a case of "want to eat" relative to the amount of time it takes to get the meat out.
One imagines that alligator/crocodile feet are as edible as, say, chicken feet if cooked down slowly for gelatin rich broth. Probably would make a nice stock for a gumbo.
Beholders have this interesting levitation ability. It might be possible to powder their brains to get a cooking agent that would make any souffle rise or even be useful for some novelty presentations. Why look! These creampuffs are so light and airy they actually float!

Threeshades |

I think monsters need a "Taste" stat in their Bestiary statblocks.
I just know that in our evil 3.0 party my water genasi and her best pal, the gnome constantly make food out of our slain enemies. Including humanoids, although they have a strong preference toward boiling their heads and spleens in a soup together.