Pre Campaign Setting Poll Poll

[Riley]

- Greyhawk : 23
- Forgotten realms : 15
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 1
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 1

1 for the Greyhawk, Eberron, and Homebrew.

[Just-A-Troll]

Riley wrote:

- Greyhawk : 24

- Forgotten realms : 15
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 1

+1 for Greyhawk, an old girlfriend I still like to look at and +1 for the Wilderlands, my current infatuation

[Big Bucket]

- Greyhawk : 25
- Forgotten realms : 16
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

+1 Greyhawk, FR, Freeport. I didn't add Black Company or Thieves World - I just haven't had time for them yet.

[George Krashos]

- Greyhawk : 25
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

Added +1 to FR. Given my love for the setting, I considered adding +3 but showed mighty restraint.:)

-- George Krashos

[Torpedo]

George Krashos wrote:

- Greyhawk : 26

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

I added 1 to Greyhawk.

[VanDeBeast]

- Greyhawk : 27
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

1 to Greyhawk, and 1 to Birthright (a long-time favorite)

[jasonduke]

VanDeBeast wrote:

- Greyhawk : 28

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

1 to Greyhawk, and 1 to Birthright (a long-time favorite)

Show Ravenloft some love! +1 Ravenloft and +1 Greyhawk.

[evilash]

- Greyhawk : 29
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

1 to Greyhawk. We used Forgotten Realms earlier, but converted to Grehawk as a result of the Adventure Paths and have never looked back since.

[silenttimo]

I find this quite interesting...

I hope Tambryn that you're beginning to see satisfaying results on your poll !!

[Taurendil]

- Greyhawk : 29
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

+1 to Dragonlance and Homebrew. I once used FR but that's al long time ago.

[Teemuu]

- Greyhawk : 30
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 11
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :1
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

1 to Greyhawk, 1 to spelljammer , 1 to mystara

[Evilturnip]

- Greyhawk : 30
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 12
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :1
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 3
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

+1 for Eberron.

[dk]

- Greyhawk : 31
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 12
- Dark sun : 4
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :1
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

Added +1 greyhawk (best generic setting) +1 dark sun (best setting) +1 birthright (I played in there for 10 years!)

[Tambryn]

This is deffinately very interesting. I would have expected Eberron to make a better showing. Also, I wonder if this poll is skewed due to the fact that Dungeon is the only quality source for Greyhawk information, so a poll hosted in the dungeon forum cannot be an accurate sampling of D&D players and DMs as a whole. Maybe I will post a similar poll in the Dragon general forums and see how it differs. Will think about it.

Tam

Long live Greyhawk, where I first died and where I first truly lived.

[Cintra Bristol]

- Greyhawk : 31
- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 13
- Dark sun : 4
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 4
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :1
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

Added 1 to Eberron (where I'm currently running Age of Worms)

[Bill Lumberg]

+ 1 Greyhawk, + 1 Dark Sun and +1 Mystara. Would some one please update this. I am incompetent with anything beyond simple posting.

P.S.
Would you count Gama World, the Black Company setting and the like?

[Fake Healer]

Tambryn wrote:

This is deffinately very interesting. I would have expected Eberron to make a better showing. Also, I wonder if this poll is skewed due to the fact that Dungeon is the only quality source for Greyhawk information, so a poll hosted in the dungeon forum cannot be an accurate sampling of D&D players and DMs as a whole. Maybe I will post a similar poll in the Dragon general forums and see how it differs. Will think about it.

Tam

Long live Greyhawk, where I first died and where I first truly lived.

try it over at WotC also.

[Celestial Healer]

Cintra Bristol wrote:

- Greyhawk : 33

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 13
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 5
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

Added Bill Lumberg's, and 1 GH and 1 Ravenloft for me.

[Ken Marable]

Celestial Healer wrote:

- Greyhawk : 33

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 5
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 2
- Freeport: 2

Bounce between campaigns in FR and Eberron. Also, try to get out into the planes as often as possible for some Planescape fun!

I was tempted to add in Jorune for the d20 conversion a friend of mine DMed for us, but that was a while back, and if I include everything I've played in for a substantial amount of time, there would of course be several more additions (as I'm sure is true of a lot of us).

[Heathansson]

Jorune is cool! What a good friend.

[Bill Lumberg]

Celestial Healer wrote:

Cintra Bristol wrote:

- Greyhawk : 33

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 13
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 5
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2

Thank you, Celestial Healer.
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

Added Bill Lumberg's, and 1 GH and 1 Ravenloft for me.

[Schmoe]

Cintra Bristol wrote:

- Greyhawk : 34

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 13
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 5
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2

- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 9
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 2

[Molech]

Schmoe wrote:

Cintra Bristol wrote:

- Greyhawk : 34

- Forgotten realms : 17
- Eberron : 13
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :1
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2

- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 11
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 2
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2

2 homebrew (long standing campaigns),

1 Ravenloft (1 per year)
1 Planescape(1 per year)

[Molech]

Hard to believe there are so few Homebrews out there. I'm willing to bet, though, that most of the GH & FR campaigns are quite changed from the published material -- just like the 2 campaigns I play in have several GH and FR vignettes.

Am I right; what say you GH & FR?

[Heathansson]

Greyhawk wins!

[MaxSlasher26]

Quote:

- Greyhawk : 35

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2

- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 12
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 2
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 3
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 5
- Iron kingdoms : 3

Greyhawk is in the lead, while Scarred Lands, Maztica, and Kara-tur are in dead last!

[SgtHulka]

MaxSlasher26 wrote:

Quote:

- Greyhawk : 36

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2

- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 12
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 3
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 3
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 5
- Iron kingdoms : 3

I added 1 to Greyhawk and 1 to Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord.

[Steve Greer]

You can add another Greyhawk vote from me.

[farewell2kings]

Steve Greer wrote:

You can add another Greyhawk vote from me.

CONFORMIST!!!! ;)

[farewell2kings]

SgtHulka wrote:

and 1 to Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord.

Is that any good? I loved Judges Guild stuff because it was so open ended and adaptable, even though everything was described, it seemed. I've thought about taking a look at it.

If you don't want to threadjack this discussion like I have, would you post a review of the setting here at Paizo?

[Steve Greer]

SgtHulka wrote:

- Greyhawk : 37

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2

- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 12
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 3
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 3
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 5
- Iron kingdoms : 3

There. Added my Greyhawk nod.

[Steve Greer]

farewell2kings wrote:

Steve Greer wrote:

You can add another Greyhawk vote from me.

CONFORMIST!!!! ;)

Bah! You FR sympathizer!

[Heathansson]

farewell2kings wrote:

Steve Greer wrote:

You can add another Greyhawk vote from me.

CONFORMIST!!!! ;)

It's not too late! You can come back.

Do we need to do an Eberron intervention?

[Enjego Montoya]

- Greyhawk : 22
- Forgotten realms : 16
- Eberron : 10
- Dark sun : 3
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 8
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 1
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 1
- Freeport: 1

Added 1 to FR (weekly game); and 1 to homebrew (whenever I can get the players together).

[kikai13]

Steve Greer wrote:

SgtHulka wrote:

- Greyhawk : 38

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 12
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 4
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 5
- Iron kingdoms : 3

+1 for Greyhawk (which rocks like no other setting), +1 for City State of the Invincible Overlord, +1 for Planescape.

[Tambryn]

While the numbers could deffinately be skewed due to the target audience of this poll, I think it is deffinately safe to say that Greyhawk is of at least much interest to gamers as Forgotten Realms or Eberron. I hope everyone is paying attention.

Tam

Man do I love Eberron.

[ZimlonBane]

kikai13 wrote:

Steve Greer wrote:

SgtHulka wrote:

- Greyhawk : 39

- Forgotten realms : 18
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 12
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 4
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

+1 for Greyhawk (APs) and +1 for Ptolus. The Big Book of Ptolus is just freakin' amazing and we have only just started. What a way for Monte to go out...

I, also, am very interested in the 'Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord' setting. Please write a review!

[silenttimo]

- Greyhawk : 39
- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 13
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 4
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

I added Enjego Montoya's votes (despite the fact he didn't vote for GH ! ; see his post above): he replied to an "out of date" post...
so +1 to FR & +1 to homebrew !

[David Roberts]

Byron Zibeck wrote:

- Greyhawk : 23

- Forgotten realms : 15
- Eberron : 10
- Dark sun : 4
- Spelljammer :
- Ravenloft : 3
- Dragonlance : 4
- Al-Qadim : 1
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 4
- Iron kingdoms : 2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 7
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 1
- Birthright : 2
- The Styes: 1
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 2
- Freeport: 1

I'm just finishing up a 6 year long Planescape campaign I DM next saturday, so I had to add 1 for that. The next campaign I'm doing is in Greyhawk (Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil) so I added 1 for that. I also added 1 for Dark Sun since I've had some memorable times there, and I love psionics (the only setting that included it as a core component).

[Sven]

silenttimo wrote:

- Greyhawk : 39

- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 5
- Spelljammer :2
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara :2
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 13
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes: 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape: 4
- Freeport: 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

I added Enjego Montoya's votes (despite the fact he didn't vote for GH ! ; see his post above): he replied to an "out of date" post...
so +1 to FR & +1 to homebrew !

since 10 years, only GREYHAWK for me!!!!

But I fondly remember playing
DARK SUN
SPELLJAMMER
and the Mystara setting for old D&D...
Alphatia rulezz!!!!!

[Troy Taylor]

silenttimo wrote:

What's the wheel of time ?),:

Wheel of Time is the licensed d20 setting Wizards of the Coast produced in 2001, based on the novels by Robert Jordan. Charles Ryan, Steven S. Long, Christian Moore and Owen K.C. Stephens were the designers. Wizards produced a roleplaying game book and an "adventure path" supplement. The license was not renewed in 2004 or thereabouts. Most of the character classes have D&D analogs , i.e. fighter/armsman, initiate/wizard, noble/bard; wanderer/rogue, wilder/sorcerer, woodsman/ranger, algaidisiswai/barbarian. The magic system was unique, men and women used it differently, and it was primarily based on the elements. Spells (called "weaves"), varied on intensity and effect, depending on how much of the "one power" was channeled by the spellcaster. The book is out of print. I've seen used copies listed anywhere from $25 to $2,245.

[silenttimo]

- Greyhawk : 41
- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 14
- Dark sun : 7
- Spelljammer : 3
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 2
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara : 3
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 13
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes : 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape : 5
- Freeport : 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

I added Sven and David Roberts' votes (including votes for "fond memories"), totaling +2 GH, +2 Dark Sun, +1 Spelljammer, +1 Planescape, +1 Mystara...

(It looks like the dread pirate Roberts didn't go to "page 2" of this thread..., and that Sven voted but didn't add his votes !!

[silenttimo]

Troy Taylor wrote:

silenttimo wrote:

What's the wheel of time ?),:

Wheel of Time is the licensed d20 setting Wizards of the Coast produced in 2001, based on the novels by Robert Jordan. Charles Ryan, Steven S. Long, Christian Moore and Owen K.C. Stephens were the designers. Wizards produced a roleplaying game book and an "adventure path" supplement. The license was not renewed in 2004 or thereabouts. Most of the character classes have D&D analogs , i.e. fighter/armsman, initiate/wizard, noble/bard; wanderer/rogue, wilder/sorcerer, woodsman/ranger, algaidisiswai/barbarian. The magic system was unique, men and women used it differently, and it was primarily based on the elements. Spells (called "weaves"), varied on intensity and effect, depending on how much of the "one power" was channeled by the spellcaster.

Thanks. The magic system seems to be very interesting...

I can't explore every setting or world, I guess...

[farewell2kings]

Fond memory votes count?

[silenttimo]

farewell2kings wrote:

Fond memory votes count?

I am not sure...

Ask Tambryn !!
However, Sven's post was very enthusiastic about those 3 settings he had played in, and I thought that he played several years in those worlds and could even try revival sessions...

Maybe I guessed wrong !

I forgot, but nobody mentionned the Lankhmar setting...

You know, a world full of ROUGE... as some people may say !

[Jack Dangers]

silenttimo wrote:

- Greyhawk : 42

- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 15
- Dark sun : 7
- Spelljammer : 3
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 3
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara : 4
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 13
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes : 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape : 5
- Freeport : 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

One for Greyhawk...my favorite of all settings to DM/play;

One for Eberron, because I enjoy it conceptually, even if I have yet to play it;
One for Al-Qadim, as I have fond memories of a short-lived campaign I ran set there;
and lastly, One for Mystara, which I also enjoy...and I suspect will one day be "absorbed" into the greater map of Oerth.

JD out....

[Fake Healer]

silenttimo wrote:

.....the Lankhmar setting...

You know, a world full of ROUGE... as some people may say !

Carry on, citizens. Nothing to see here. *Turns to Silenttimo* Don't you get smart with me, boy. *flicks 3X5 stat card across the underside of Silenttimo's chin* Watch yourself, son. I will.

*Arrogantly strides back to Red patrol car, shiny, black boots clicking on the small peebles in the road with every stride.*

FH (always red-y to serve and protect)

[AllFather]

- Greyhawk : 42
- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 15
- Dark sun : 7
- Spelljammer : 3
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 3
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara : 4
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 14
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes : 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape : 5
- Freeport : 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

One for homebrew

[silenttimo]

Fake Healer wrote:

silenttimo wrote:

.....the Lankhmar setting...

You know, a world full of ROUGE... as some people may say !

Carry on, citizens. Nothing to see here. *Turns to Silenttimo* Don't you get smart with me, boy. *flicks 3X5 stat card across the underside of Silenttimo's chin* Watch yourself, son. I will.

*Arrogantly strides back to Red patrol car, shiny, black boots clicking on the small peebles in the road with every stride.*

FH (always red-y to serve and protect)

What if a red-haired rogue turns rouge living in Baton-Rouge, meets a rouge alred-y red called the D-red pirates Roberts, cooking a lobster turning rouge with a roguish grin ?

I guess his name is F-red, he is af-red of the infra-rouge, he likes b-red & butter, and a nice rum g-rogue !

[meomwt]

- Greyhawk : 43
- Forgotten realms : 19
- Eberron : 15
- Dark sun : 7
- Spelljammer : 3
- Ravenloft : 6
- Dragonlance : 5
- Al-Qadim : 4
- Maztica :
- Kara-Tur :
- Oriental adventures / settings : 1
- Mystara : 4
- Scarred lands :
- Homebrew : 14
- Wilderlands of High Fantasy/City State of the Invincible Overlord: 4
- Birthright : 4
- The Styes : 2
- Council of Wyrms (v.3.5): 1
- Planescape : 5
- Freeport : 2
- Midnight :
- Ptolus : 6
- Iron kingdoms : 3

One for Greyhawk (best ever) and one for Al-Qadim which gave a great Arabian Nights feel.

Were Glorantha a D&D World, I'd vote for it!