Charles Scholz |
Speaking of New52 mess. Superman's reminiscing shows they kept that his parents died when he young and never met Lois Lane.
I know that goes back to the golden age and not as it was in John Byrne's Post-Crisis era, but I still miss Ma and Pa Kent.
Couldn't they have made it so they died after Lois and Clark were married?
Charles Scholz |
Superman took a turn for the weird.
Also, just saw a TP of Superman and Lois (before Rebirth) and it shows Jon can fly at the end (or at least hover), but in Super Sons he falls when Lex startles him while he climbing. Maybe it has something to do with what is going on in Superman.
Damon Griffin |
Perhaps it's because I haven't been a regular reader of Action/Superman (only picked up Action 975/976 and the Superman issues that dovetailed with them) but the whole "resolution" of Superman's continuity seemed both rushed and insubstantial to me.
I mean, Kelex shows Superman three or four memory tapes and this somehow represents a perfect, seamless, logical backstory integrating two timelines?
Superman can't identify anything that's changed; he's entirely unaware of any inconsistencies in his personal history. Yet he and Lois are somehow aware that "It's not us that's important, it's our son." So important that the multiverse will twist itself into knots for Jonathan Samuel's sake?
If that's true, it's a huge turnoff for me. Few things I like less than a Chosen One story.
What I may like even less is that Clark and Lois are somehow aware of the kid's supreme importance to reality -- and serenely so, even if they haven't got the first clue of why it should be true.
Greylurker |
There is also the fact that Conner (IE: the Post-Death of Superman- Superboy) is missing from the records. Death and Rebirth, the destruction of Coast city, Cyborg Sup, Eradicator Sup and Steel all there but no Superboy.
A key thing to remember is that this world is the DCU we knew, and that bits and pieces have been removed by persons unknown for a specific reason.
Conner is a piece that person felt needed to be removed, but at the same time they clearly felt there still needed to be a Superboy
Greylurker |
Ok so after some discussion with other people I think I have a good grasp of what the current situation is
1) The Silver Age and probably a good chunk of the Golden Age seem to have happened
2) Flash causes Flashpoint
In causing Flashhpoint Barry makes the timeline vulnerable to attack (Damn it Barry)
Pandora sensing the attack tries to strengthen the timeline by Blending the Wildstorm universe into the main DCU
The Attack removes large chunks of the DC Timeline includng most of the Silver and Golden Age. The DC Timeline is wounded and then stiches itself backtogether with what's left.
As part of the Attack Superman and Lois are split into "red" and "blue" Red is allowed to remain in the timeline while Blue is discarded along with all the other stolen time fragments. This is a deliberate act to weaken Superman and his relationship to Lois
3) Mega-Brainiac collects various Time Fragments including those discarded by the "Enemy" this includes "Blue" Superman and Lois. These and bottled and sit for years on Planet X under Telos' watch. During this time, his powers lost Superman and Lois have Jon.
4) Convergance happens. This results in "Blue" Superman and Lois re-entering the DCU Timeline. They live their own life and raise their son while avoiding notice. They beleive they are from an alternate reality.
This is not the case, This is their reality with a wounded timeline, and they are infact "half" of the original Lois and Clark.
5) Rebirth: Wally escapes the Speedforce. In doing so Wally heals part of the wounded timeline restoring several key things such as the Titans, Jonny Thunder and maybe even the Legion.
6)Superman reborn: Red and Blue re-merge becoming a whole Superman and Lois Lane. In merging they effectively heal some more of the wounded Timeline, causing a "retcon" that ripples through the DCU altering the lives of many, not just Lois and Clark.
So the DCU that currently exists is the Original DCU, only with a wounded timeline.
The future of the DCU depends on how many more events can be Healed and how many will fail to be Healed.
We also have Paralax Hal on the loose, as well as Pre-crisis Supergirl and Barry Allen. It is possible that merging these with their current selves may further Heal the timeline.
Thomas Seitz |
Grey,
Some of what you said makes sense. It's clear the timeline and reality of that have some how been 'wounded" if not erased at points.
Certainly while Conner isn't around he was there for a time. But it kept fluctuating depending on things. (And of course writers being writers.)
What I think is MOST important for Charles to understand is we had TWO Supermen who are the same but different. Not just alternate realities but a schism of the original Superman Pre-Flashpoint. Same for Lois.
Now how does that dovetail into what we see in say, The Button? Clearly whom ever has this power can hold pieces of the timeline together, as long as they aren't like alternate stuff. I think. So I think what happened with Reborn Superman is clearly an after-effect of that person/individual/entity losing control over that due to unexpected shifts.
Jonathan Samuel Kent is important ONLY because he provides linkage to both Pre-Flashpoint (the Son of Superman) and the new 52 Superboy (who was ALSO the son of Lois and Clark.) So...that might help? I dunno.
Greylurker |
I wonder if Harvest is still out there. He considers Jon to be his son, would not be surprised if he targets the current one.
On thing I think is neat about Rebirth is that Retcons are not simply the result of the story they are a key part of it.
For each Victory our heroes restore part of DC history.
For each defeat they might loose a part of it forever.
This is a literal fight over DC Continuety, with the final shape of the DCU being the prize.
MannyGoblin |
I don't know if this is true, but I sort of remember a few pages that showed Kid Miracleman before he started the London Massacre and a Dr.Manhatten clone reading a book and wonder if this was an attempt to put more of Moore's works into the main DCU. If so, there is nooooooo way the London Massacre is going to go like it did(NSFW warning before you google!)
Greylurker |
Manny,
Miracle man is now more Marvel than DC....so.....
Grey,
That might be how it works out.
I think it's pretty clever actually.
If you are a new fan, you get to watch the official DC history unfold right before your eyes.
If you are an Old fan, you have a real investment in the story because you are hoping your favorite parts manage to survive.
I mean Jonny Thunder is key to reviving the JSA but depending on how that story turns out will we get back Infinity Inc. as well? When you think about the hints so far the JSA seems to have vanished during the McCarthy Hearings, only 9 years or so after ww2 ended. How old would they be? We might get them back in their late 30s early 40s. How old would their kids be assuming they even have any.
What if we get a Teen-age Infinity Inc?
Greylurker |
Grey,
Among other things that felt forced and weird:
We know have TWO Cyborg Supermen! The original (Hank Henshaw) and also Zor-el!
So....yeah confusion.
Did Hank get re-cyborged. I know he was forming up a Superman revenge squad but I though he was still flesh and blood + whatever he picked up on his way back from Jupiter and that mystery Black Gemstone thing.
(Missed Action this week, didn't realize it till I got home)
Charles Scholz |
Okay, looks like our mysterious antagonist not only split Superman in two, but for some reason he restored Henshaw to his human form and maybe erased that knowledge(?). The ungrateful Henshaw likes his cyborg body better and used the black gem to get it back.
Greylurker |
Grey,
The latest comic proved that already.
Yeah Zod was quick to figure that out. If a bash to the head can hurt him it means the head is more vulnerable than the body, because of the Kryptonite, the weakest point in the head is where the bomb is, thus Heat Vision surgery.
Question is will he play along for a while until he can get people out of the zone or will he just snap Waller's neck and be done with it.
Matthew Morris RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8 |
Matthew Morris RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8 |
Thomas Seitz |
Freehold,
I think he meant Lillian Clay aka Omen, the double use of Victor is probably an error but he meant (I assume!) Victor Stone aka Cyborg and Gar is Garfield Logan aka Beast Boy.
Matthew,
Not sure that's what it is but I think that Time Trapper and/or Superboy Prime MIGHT have a part to play in this. However I remain doubtful.
Greylurker |
Grey,
Yes. Read the latest issue to see what happened.
Got my issue of action.
It's interesting...Before Flashpoint Henshaw had become a nihilist seeking death because his powers and the superborg body had rendered him immortal, resurrecting from every destruction.
Now reduced to ordinary flesh and blood human he wants nothing more than to reclaim that all powerful immortal body.
Charles Scholz |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"Who killed Thawne?" I don't think it was Dr. M. even if he has done it before.
Did anyone notice when he picked up the button, the conversation he was having was with Silk Spectre while they were on the moon during the series?
[spoiler=Superman]Manchester Black[spoiler] Didn't see that coming.
Charles Scholz |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
"Who killed Thawne?" I don't think it was Dr. M. even if he has done it before.
Did anyone notice when he picked up the button, the conversation he was having was with Silk Spectre while they were on the moon during the series?
Thomas Seitz |
but why was Red Robin on the cover?
Try to get more people to buy it maybe? I dunno.
Charles,
Yeah it's kind of been my thinking that there's very little reason for Dr M to do the kind of crap he's been doing. It has to be something with greater control. Maybe Time Trapper?
As for Mister Black, I did see an article where he's on the cover of some upcoming issue. But now that I read more about it, it makes sense.
The Elite are, after all, a proactive force.
jemstone |
Just wanted to say that my old Friendly Local Comic Shop is still my shop of choice, and they'll be shipping me my books on a once-monthly basis - which means I'm going to be behind on all the new stuff as it comes out.
Please go right ahead and post spoilers.
I honestly don't care if you do, as long as they're tagged. If I choose to read them, that's on me, not on you for posting.
I want to talk comic books with you nerds, not worry about who did or did not say something. :)