...I do have an undead anarchist assassin avatar. I don't know enough about anarchist theory to know who these anarcho-libertarians you speak of, but if they are Americans and are into markets, they are probably the former. Back in the day, say, mid-19th century, all the anarchists and the communists hung out in the same bars and at the same picket lines, and "communism" wasn't particularly associated with Marx or his followers, so both groups tended to use the term and they both also tended to interchange it freely with "socialism." For example, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, usually considered the father of anarchism (even though, as I understand it, he didn't call himself one for long), guy who coined the phrase "Property is theft," was buddies for a couple of years with Marx, but they ended up disagreeing on stuff. Marx waited until Pierre published his opus, The Philosophy of Poverty and Marx wrote a savage critique of it which he called The Poverty of Philosophy and then they ceased being friends thereafter. For two other examples, leading anarchist theorists Max Stirner and Mikhail Bakunin were in the same philosophers gang/drinking club with Frederick Engels, Die Freien. I think Mikhail and Fred fought on the barricades together in Baden during the 1848 revolutions, but I might be getting him confused with somebody else (apparently, Richard Wagner was there, too). Either way, when The International Workingman's Association (also called The First International) was formed, both followers of Marx (then known as "socialists" or, more accurately, "social democrats") and Bakunin coexisted in the same groups, at least until Marx got them all kicked out. So, my point being, the terms had nebulous and somewhat interchangeable meanings back in the day. "Anarcho-communism," as I understand it, was a particular school of anarchism founded by a Russian nobleman named Peter Kropotkin in, I believe, the waning years of the 19th century. It relied a lot on the concept of "mutualism," but, to be honest, I don't know much about it. "Communism" didn't become "Communism as we think of it today" until after the Bolshevik faction of the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party changed their name to the Communist Party after they had already pulled of the October Revolution of 1917.
So how long does someone has to be dead before it is considered archeology instead of grave robbing?
There was an amusing anecdote that I heard from an an-cap, though. Apparently, Bastiat and Proudhon were both elected delegates to the National Assembly, or whatever it was, that resulted out of the 1848 revolution before the ascension to power of Napoleon II. Apparently, they sat next to each other in the Assembly and spent the long hours arguing vociferously with each other about everything under the sun. But when it came time to vote, they always voted the same. [Looks out the window] Oh, here's Mr. Comrade. Vive le Galt!
Despite my awesome undead anarchist assassin avatar, I don't know much about anarchist theory, so if anyone knows more please speak up, but: Anarcho-capitalism was thought up (finding it hard to find a neutral verb) by Murray Rothbard in like, I don't know, the sixties or something. Wikipedia sez he "synthesized elements from the Austrian School of economics, classical liberalism, and 19th-century American individualist anarchists." So, from what I'm picking up, anarcho-capitalism derives its "anarchism" from a small subset (19th-century American individualists) of a small subset (individualists) of the anarchist movement. I have to confess that I don't know much about the Stirner wing of anarchism, but a quick, and I do stress quick, glance at the pages of Benjamin Tucker and Lysander Spooner (whom I had never heard of, either) looks like they're pretty squarely on the broader (i.e., non-Marxist) left. Most strands of anarchism (dudes mentioned above and their followers, Black Bloc-types, anarcho-syndicalists, liberals with fits of delusion like Chomsky, etc.), though, are without a doubt "far left."
SmiloDan wrote:
Hee hee! She was such a hawtie, even if she was a petty-bourgeois shopkeeper, peddling superstition and obscurantism to the anti-Hellmouth masses. IIRC, she also had something to do with the creation of my Undead Leon Czolgosz avatar.
GeraintElberion wrote:
They also named teddy bears after him. Don't remember that being mentioned. Do they have teddy bears in Britain, Geraint?
Scintillae wrote:
That wasn't an accident! [Boom! Boom! Rat-a-tat-tat!] What's that, Comrade Dingo? I have no idea what you're saying! [Boom! Boom! Rat-a-tat-tat!]
Vive le Galt! The anarchist assassin thing was a no-brainer for me one day when there was a thread about all of the Evil Presidents, but for Whedon nerds: Mrs. Czolgosz (pronounded, roughly Chuul-gosh) was one of the spurned women visited by Anyanka. (She cursed Leon to have an unnatural obsession with McKinley.) I assume that Whedon got him from Stephen Sondheim's semi-hit 1990 musical, Assassins.
Paizo's messageboards are so informative! Presidential Assassinations: The Musical Interlude And it's not by Sondheim.
Gark the Goblin wrote:
It most certainly was NOT Nazi science!
|