
Alphavoltario |

Okay gonna star this off with that I am already aware of the wording in this ability; Craft (Alchemy) bonuses are gone, identifying potions is gone, and the Alchemist Discovery Talent is now null for your character.
A star watcher’s horoscope is always keyed to a specific creature that must be willing and present when the star watcher prepares the horoscope. Only the creature to which a horoscope is keyed can activate it and be affected by it. A horoscope is “cast” by reading it as a standard action, though a star watcher can draw and read a horoscope as a single standard action.
A star watcher doesn’t gain a competence bonus on Craft (alchemy) checks to create alchemical items, and he cannot identify potions with that skill. Furthermore, a star watcher cannot select alchemist discoveries as investigator talents. A star watcher can study a wizard’s spellbook or alchemist’s formula book to learn formulae, but a star watcher’s formula book is too esoteric for anyone except another star watcher to learn spells from.
This alters alchemy.
The problem is arising from other talents, such as Numerical Alchemy.
The investigator obviously has nothing class related to alchemy anymore, but given that Horoscopes act as Extracts, this talent should still work, albeit in a very strange way, since the wording was likely not expecting a scroll based spell system to take the place of potions and such.
Am I overthinking this or should this talent still work? Or is it just a reflavor thing?

blahpers |

It still works.
In many ways, the star watcher’s horoscopes function like extracts, with the following exceptions."
This means horoscopes are like extracts except for the listed exceptions. None of the exceptions listed preclude numerical alchemy from substituting "make a horoscope" for "mix an extract" to fulfill the "horoscopes function like extracts" rule.