
Sajan Krama Sumna |

That's just because I absorbed all of their damage output... :)
Well I took a full attack from one but it was a total miss if I recall :). Sadly, Sajan probably doesn't have the HP left to survive a full attack from his next contestant. Then again, she may not have the HP to survive his either...
P.S- Khalid doesn't your custom feat make your fire bolt awesome VS these creatures (and you'd be attacking touch AC)?

Joana |

Where'd you step to, AK, A 10? You're not going to draw her onto land when you all just persuaded Nuveril to go toe-to-toe. Wasn't staying out of range and drawing them onto firm ground Nuveril's strategy to begin with?
EDIT: Sajan needs to admit to himself what he's doing: stepping back and hoping the salamander attacks the women instead. ;)

Sajan Krama Sumna |

I didn't look at a map as there wasn't one provided and I didn't want to scroll up for an older one. If theres no eligible square I trust Dan to make a decision for me.
If Sajan hadn't been on this island drawing her attack, I think Linah would be dead by now. Its all very well sitting safely on the north side of the map screaming about letting them come to us, but no good when half the party haven't arrived to that end safely yet.
Not trying to draw attacks to the women, but Nuveril hasn't been hit yet I think so it wouldn't be the worst thing in the world... I'm banking on the fact that Sajan's the only one to have done significant damage not once, but three times in the combat. I think i'm still going to be her target.

Joana |

Yeah, I actually had to get out a pen and a scrap of paper to work out who was where before I made Nuveril's move. I was totally confused before that. I didn't realize Linah was in the line of fire either before the new update. If Thratnias were to come after Sajan in his new square, she'd take an AoO from Nuveril to do it. I considered staying behind Sajan and not getting threatened, but I was actually hoping he might try to grapple her and hold her there where we could swing at her without risking her ducking back under the lava.
And that 18 points of damage she just took from the AoO begs to differ with your assumption that she hasn't been hit yet. ;)

Zeladiel Araxyll |

I figured after attacking Sajan, cleaving onto Khalid, and abandoning the hit and run, there was enough of her on the island/above the lava to warrant a pit. Since it's just an extra dimensional space I figured the surface of the lava would be as good as most other surfaces. The deck of the ship could be broken from below like the surface of the lava could be broken from below, presumably with the same unlisted results. From above though, they both go into a 20'x 10'x10' pit with stone sides.
Your call. I just like making you work for it though. :-)

DM Dan E |

Fair enough :)
I'm ruling that "surface" means something vaguely solid enough for you to create the pit opening on. It doesn't matter if its half an inch thick (the wooden deck example) but I don't think lava (or water) is enough. Plus I don't think we get that far but if you can create a pit in the lava I would just see the surrounding lava flowing in (sloped sides remember) allowing the salamander to just swim out.

Zeladiel Araxyll |

DM Dan E |

Your fancy science has nothing on every movie featuring lava ever. I'll take Holywood over elitest, commie scientists any day.
Or possibly I'll go with that because otherwise the entire encounter doesn't make sense. Bend before the power of lava swimming salamanders laws of physics!!!
Sorry its 9:30am here and I got approximately two hours of sleep in the middle of a work all nighter. Lets just hope I don't TPK everyone and wreck the campaign before I come back down.

Joana |

If you look at one of the previous maps C10 is pretty lavary and as you say the salamander was swimming there. I'll treat this as a move to A,11 which doesn't end up disadvantaging you.
Sorry; was in a hurry before leaving the house this morning and didn't take the time to read your post carefully. As you say, the madu missed anyway. :)

Joana |

Edit: Just realised Nuveril is going to have to trust Zeladiel to take care of the flamebrother if she doesn't do it herself. Horror!
Especially since he's the reason she was unable to fight effectively in the first place. >:|
EDIT: Not really mad at you, Pryllin, although this won't give Nuveril any more motivation to be Zeladiel's best friend. Just frustrating: I knew the good roll would go to the save. Another combat where Nuveril is able to make no contribution. At least she took damage without being able to deal any back and wasted rounds of rage. :P
EDIT again: If this were a RL game, I would totally be in the kitchen looking for something to eat now and telling someone else to roll my dice for the rest of the encounter and let me know what happens.

Zeladiel Araxyll |

Thanks, dear Joana. I know you're not really mad at me. :-)
(That dice roller does need a good slap around, though.)
I'm thinking it's easier to play hostile relationships online because you have so much time to sit back, disassociate and be objective. At the table it's too easy to become personal because the negative emotions/comments are immediate and reactive.
I think Nuveril may become a puzzle to Zeladiel after resisting his haste. And everyone knows puzzles are only there to be solved. :-)

DM Dan E |

Heres Thratnias for those who are interested. Technically a CR7 although I think she was closer to an 8.
I did a lot of different versions for this encounter. Paizo flubbed the integration of the set piece with the rest of the AP so it was balanced for a level 4 party and thus I needed to make a lot changes.
An initial version had her with improved bulls rush and true strike and after thinking about it for a minute I realised I was being an ass. Punting someone into the lava was not only going to kill them but do it permanantly. A second had her with a long spear and combat reflexes and as the combat unfolded that would have been pretty nighmarish as well. I'm happy with how she ended up.
Oh and the barbarian flamebrother hiding in the pool and throwing mud at the rope was a suggestion of the module writer rather than me being mean :)
THRATNIAS CR 7
Female Salamander Fighter (Mobile Fighter) 1 Sorcerer 1
CE Medium Outsider (Extraplanar, Fire)
Init +1; Senses Darkvision (60 feet); Perception +17
--------------------
DEFENSE
--------------------
AC 23, touch 12, flat-footed 21 (+4 shield, +1 Dex, +7 natural, +1 dodge)
hp 119 (9d10+1d6+60)
Fort +14, Ref +7, Will +9
DR 10/magic; Immune fire
Weakness Vulnerability to Cold
--------------------
OFFENSE
--------------------
Spd 20 ft.
Melee +1 Shock Shortspear +15/+10 (1d6+8/20/x2) and
Bite (Serpent's Fangs) +9 (1d4+2/20/x2) and
Constrict (Salamander) +9 (2d6+2/20/x2) and
Javelin +14/+9 (1d6+5/20/x2) and
Javelin of Lightning +14/+9 (1d6+5/20/x2) and
Javelin of Lightning +14/+9 (1d6+5/20/x2) and
Tail Slap (Salamander) +9 (2d6+2/20/x2) and
Unarmed Strike +14/+9 (1d3+5/20/x2)
Special Attacks Serpent's Fang + Poison (1 CON) (6 rounds/day) (DC
Sorcerer Spells Known (CL 1, +14 melee touch, +10 ranged touch):
1 (4/day) Shield, Vanish
0 (at will) Resistance, Mage Hand, Message, Spark (DC 13)
--------------------
STATISTICS
--------------------
Str 20, Dex 13, Con 22, Int 14, Wis 16, Cha 16
Base Atk +9; CMB +14; CMD 26 (can't be Tripped)
Feats Cleave, Dodge, Eschew Materials, Furious Focus, Iron Will, Power Attack -3/+6, Skill Focus: Perception
Skills Acrobatics +14, Bluff +16, Craft: Armor +8, Craft: Blacksmith +4, Craft: Weapons +13, Intimidate +14, Knowledge: The Planes +13, Perception +17, Sense Motive +14, Spellcraft +10, Stealth +12
Languages Common, Ignan
SQ Heat (Ex), Serpentine
Combat Gear +1 Shock Shortspear, Javelin, Javelin of Lightning, Javelin of Lightning,
--------------------
SPECIAL ABILITIES
--------------------
Cleave If you hit your first target, attack an adjacent target at the same attack bonus in exchange for -2 AC.
Damage Reduction (10/magic) You have Damage Reduction against all except Magic attacks.
Darkvision (60 feet) You can see in the dark (black and white vision only).
Eschew Materials Cast without materials, if material cost is <= 1gp.
Furious Focus If you are wielding a weapon in two hands, ignore the penalty for your first attack of each turn.
Heat (Ex) A salamander generates so much heat that its mere touch deals an additional 1d6 points of fire damage. A salamander's metallic weapons also conduct this heat.
Immunity to Fire You are immune to fire damage.
Power Attack -3/+6 You can subtract from your attack roll to add to your damage.
Serpent's Fang + Poison (1 CON) (6 rounds/day) (DC 16) (Ex) Bite attack deals 1d4 damage + Poison (Bite-injury; DC 16; frequency 1/round for 6 rounds; effect 1 Con damage; cure 1 save)
Serpentine Your mind-affecting and language-dependant spells can affect animals, magical beasts and monstrous humanoids as if they were humanoids who understand your language.
Vulnerability to Cold You are vulnerable (+50% damage) to Cold damage

Grall |

These creatures had the complete situational advantage on us. This is an actual example where their CR should be higher due to favored terrain IMO.
Grall is with Nuveril on this one...no contribution other than causing a bunch of uses of the CLW's wand but from his view Sarenrae chose Sajan to be her champion in this battle. I for one was glad Alex had the good rolls otherwise we were looking at a party wipe.
Can't wait to see if the chamber floor drops out if I pull the lever!!!! :)

DM Dan E |

She doesn't speak Ifrit? Were those Ifrit spoilers meant to be Ignan? Can I read them? :-)
Doh! Brain said Ignan, hands wrote Ifrit. Read away.
I certainly took into account the terrain for the overall encounter. It was a tough fight although to be honest I'm pretty happy with the difficulty of it.

Sajan Krama Sumna |

Grall is with Nuveril on this one...no contribution other than causing a bunch of uses of the CLW's wand but from his view Sarenrae chose Sajan to be her champion in this battle. I for one was glad Alex had the good rolls otherwise we were looking at a party wipe.
When will people accept Sajan is a champion of Gruhastha, not your damn sun goddess ;).
Well having been put to 9HP from a series of lucky hits by Thratnias, your contribution as damage soaks was appreciated both of you.

Joana |

Well having been put to 9HP from a series of lucky hits by Thratnias, your contribution as damage soaks was appreciated both of you.
Nuveril wasn't even that. She took an AoO that never would have been rolled if she hadn't gone out there and part of the lightning damage that would have been yours alone (and which you saved against). The one actual attack she drew missed her AC so would have missed Sajan's by a mile. She did do 10 points of damage the one time she connected, though, which I guess ended up being important.

DM Dan E |

The 10 as it turned out was vitally important. Sajan took her to -5 or something. It wasn't far off the point where Zeladiel had to decide whether to save Linah and Khalid or Sajan or risk splitting magic missiles and possibly losing all three with bad rolls...
Someone was likely dying if the baddies got another attack.