|1 person marked this as a favorite.|
One of the biggest reasons I'd say CotCT would get the attention if the opportunity came up for another compilation is because it's nearly a perfect campaign.
It's got one of the best stories Paizo has ever done.
It has some of the best, most intriguing, most fun, most engaging NPCs they've ever created.
The narrative flows much better than 90% of the APs they've written.
It's got the full gamut of experiences, and has the most thorough, most complete story I've seen in an AP ever. You start small, dealing with extremely mundane, extremely local issues, and by the end of the campaign you're dealing with something suitably epic and large-scale, and the majority of the stuff in between doesn't feel like too large of a jump or gap.
It's got something for everyone. It's got high-stakes diplomacy. It's got skeevy street crime. It's got taking down an evil cult. It's got stealth- and espionage-based scenes. It's got a mystery plot. It's got a ginormous dungeon crawl. It's got puzzles and riddles. It's got a exploration-based trek. It's got storming the castle. The only thing it really doesn't have is sandboxiness - since it's an urban adventure mostly contained in one city - and that lack is probably one of the main reasons Kingmaker is up there as one of the more popular alongside it.
Most of all though... it's the least flawed of the older campaigns other than Runelords. Legacy of Fire is a cracked gem, some people will love it despite its flaws and/or polish off the edges on their own a bit when they run it, and Second Darkness ... well, Second Darkness is still mostly ore, and even the Paizo staff have said that a refit of SD would take some working to clean up and straighten out, to fix some misconceptions and some things that didn't work out well (the jarring jump in location and theme and atmosphere from Riddleport in Books 1 and 2 to being selfless heroes the rest of the story is one, and the hostility and arrogance of the Elves being another) before they'd want to release a remake.
Crimson Throne doesn't really have those problems. What faults it has are mostly minor overall, or due to personal dislike of one or two parts of the story. Some people don't like A History of Ashes leaving the city for so long and at such a crucial point in the plot; others don't like how Skeletons of Scarwall is just a huge dungeon crawl all chapter. But I call those less flaws and more just conflicts of theme between what the AP offers and what the individual player/GM wants out of it. (I'll admit I'm personally in the first group regarding HoA, hence why I pulled it out and used it in Kingmaker instead, and replaced it with something else for when I run CT in the future.)
Speaking of Kingmaker, the main reason CT edges it out in my prediction of an "if they do, then" scenario is because KM doesn't really need the update. If KM got an update, it really would just involve polishing up the plot to make some of the connect-the-dots more apparent to players so that Sound of a Thousand Screams stops blindsiding so many people. Given that the Kingdom Building stuff got updated in Ultimate Campaign I seriously doubt it would get packaged with a KM re-release (though I could be wrong!); rather, I think it would just refer to "use the rules from this other book", or tell them to check the PRD.
CT, for all the near-perfection of its story, characters, and concepts, could not only use a little polish in its plot - no more than KM, and probably less to be quite frank - but its mechanics are immensely outdated, as it's only six months younger than Runelords and operates on an extremely similar mindset by the writers. The NPCs' classes and feat selections, monster stats, and many other ideas could use some updating in such a re-release, especially with the addition of several new base classes and ARCHTYPES in the years since. I mean come on, can't you see Blackjack as a Swashbuckler? Laori as an Inquisitor? Sabina as a Cavalier? Heck, Ileosa herself could pick up a handful of different archetype options, any of which would suit her character just fine, presuming they wanted to keep her a Bard and not change her class to something else entirely.
So yeah, if I had to pick money on a "if Paizo were to re-release another AP" bet, that's why I'd wager on CT.