Look: Pathfinder 2e as an incredible bestiary. Between the core trio, sources like "Booke of the Dead" and "Monsters of Myth", plus the additions in the adventure paths, we are spoiled for choice.
But that doesn't mean we can't be greedy and wistful, right?
What are your favourite monsters from Pathfinder 1e that haven't been seen in 2nd edition (yet)?
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
What made me think of this was the Tophet from 1e's Bestiary 3 . A mobile prison/torture room with a pseudo-historical basis? Yes please!
But I'm also a big fan of the Akaname, the Buggane and the Colour Out Of Space.
And, thanks to my well documented love of Mystery Monsters Revisited, I adore the Death Worms. I want to have my players struggle to defeat a monster that can throw every type of damage at them, and then struggle even more to prove to anyone that is actually happened!
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Winterwight looks interesting- kind of an icy Nightwalker?
Lots of people talk about Strange Aeons, and I admit I haven't really looked at it all that closely. Had a look at the bestiary from the first book and saw the Oneirogen and was hooked!
I'd gladly welcome some Numerian robots back.
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
Seconding thirst for more oni varieties and the Colour Out of Space. Up until recently it would have been the now-called darvakka but they've clearly come to join us already.
The manasaputras I find strangely compelling and would be interested to see how 2e decides to reconcile their slightly weird place in the cosmology as celestial natives of the cosmic forge who have undergone numerous reincarnations (in some cases, so numerous as to apparently have survived the previous multiverse!). Their story is interesting but also feels slightly at odds with the story of the cosmos as we know it, and I love learning things that make the multiverse feel even bigger and more mysterious than I thought while also managing to fit together with at least the sense of a greater whole--even when the picture is not totally filled in.
Also, if/when we get winterwights back, would it be too much to get a new name on them? I overlooked them for years because when I saw the name I thought they were just another one of those 'if this common monster were found in a colder region, it's likely to be this variant' monsters with a +0/+1 CR. When I realized that they had no real relation to either winter or wights and that they were about 13 CR higher than I'd expected, I got whiplash. I'd use hatewraith but it doesn't really roll off the tongue and hardly seems more accurate.
If everyone loves the name I'll take it, but just throwing this out there.
Lusca. I would love to see this get statted up again in a hardcover. It's a frelling Sharktopus! One of my favorite 1E monsters
A Lusca is referenced in Dark Archive, so they are around still...
Also, have the xenopterids made a reappearance?
I'd gladly welcome some Numerian robots back.
I've only read the first Iron Gods book at that was many years ago. Other than the aesthetic and story origin, what separates a clockwork from a robot?
I find Manasaputra interesting but never really "got" them- so another look from someone more insightful would be really useful!
Disenchanters and the rest of Misfit Monsters Redeemed (other than flumph) should always been around imo, but I was particularly upset to see Adhearers go away. They were so weird, so spooky and speak to such an interesting bit of world building!
I kinda like that xenopterids are relatively unknown because it is a trick I like to pull on parties who think they're too powerful to be frightened by anything...
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I really need a conversion of the CR 20 Qlippoth, the Iathavos. That thing is simply awesome, and deserve more time into the limelight.
Appart from that, I'd like to see some stat block for the heralds, I know they were made to be a "top level plannar ally" for each deity (which doesn't really exist in 2e given how summonning work), but they also worked great as boss level foes for lower level party, or thematic ally in special circumstances. Not having them at all feel a bit lacking.
I'm hoping we'll eventually get the Planar Dragons back (as well as most other weird Dragons), as well as more of those missing Agathions and Daemons. My other hope, which is quite a bit more far away, is to have stats for Demigods again (Demon Lords, Archdevils, Daemon Overlords etc.) to serve as big fights or antagonists in long/high level campaigns, probably alongside whichever way "mythic" rules make it into the game. Just being able to go against such foes adds the potential for some quite world-shaking events. Maybe as part of a book similar to "Monsters of Myth" or "Lost Omens Legends".
Lusca. I would love to see this get statted up again in a hardcover. It's a frelling Sharktopus! One of my favorite 1E monsters
A Lusca is referenced in Dark Archive, so they are around still...
Also, have the xenopterids made a reappearance?
Lusca was started up in Agents of Edgewatch.
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
I will die on the hill of wanting the annihilator robot I loved my big scorpion doom bot.
I'd love some Numerian robots, and in a similar vein, I really miss the PF1 Outer (Solar, Lunar, Time, Void, and Vortex) Dragons. A little bit more space stuff would go a long way... but they've gotten to everything else I can think to beg for, more of less :p
The special snowflake in me really wants to play a Void Dragon-focused character someday, the same part of me that wants the PF1 Nanite Sorcerer back.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I'd love some Numerian robots, annd in a similar vein, I really miss the PF1 Outer (Solar, Lunar, Time, Void, and Vortex) Dragons.
Oh I adore them! I feel like Lost Omens has been incredible, even more than first edition, at grounding its spacey stuff in a pulpy world (probably because Starfinder handles all the truly sci fi stuff). But I am greedy and I want more, more, more. If every AP has a chapter taking us to a different planet? Yes please!