Eldritch Scoundrel (U.Rogue) vs. Warlock (Vigilante)


Advice

Grand Lodge

Which is stronger? Why?

-Both have prepared Wiz/Sorc 6th level casting.

-Warlock has Mystic Bolts / ES has stunted Sneak Attack.

-Warlock can cast in light armor.

I am leaning towards the Warlock due to the strength of Vigilante talents even if you receive fewer than normal.

Scarab Sages

Warlock is stronger imo, vigilante talents are awesome, tattoo chamber is just about the coolest thing ever, and while there aren't a lot of ways to optimize mystic bolts the do median DPR without much effort, and still do okay at higher levels once arcane striker comes online.


VMC magus makes both classes better in a lot of ways.

The returning weapon vigilante talent can make all of your weapons that you use the same as your primary, so get a throwing dagger or whatever with conductive on it and enjoy adding weapon damage to your bolts.

Eldritch Scoundrel is all about that dimensional savant feat chain getting self-sufficient sneak attack going. Improved sneak attacker and some magic items up the sneak damage.

For both builds, spells cover utility more than feats and skills do. But you still get a sh*t ton of skills.

Warlock is more rewarding early game.


master_marshmallow wrote:

VMC magus makes both classes better in a lot of ways.

The returning weapon vigilante talent can make all of your weapons that you use the same as your primary, so get a throwing dagger or whatever with conductive on it and enjoy adding weapon damage to your bolts.

You can only use the Conductive property once per round.


Warlock.

Stunning Sneak Attack makes it harder to keep reliable. Way more talents. Better talents. It's not really a fair fight.

Silver Crusade

Warlock by a wide margin, even stunted vigilante talent progression beats the hell out of anything the rogue gets.

Scarab Sages

PhD. Okkam wrote:
master_marshmallow wrote:

VMC magus makes both classes better in a lot of ways.

The returning weapon vigilante talent can make all of your weapons that you use the same as your primary, so get a throwing dagger or whatever with conductive on it and enjoy adding weapon damage to your bolts.

You can only use the Conductive property once per round.

You can use conductive once per round per conductive weapon. Since the returning weapon vigilante talent lets you apply the enchantment to all weapons you throw, you can use it for all attacks. You have to be high level, but it works.


If you're using Core Rogue, then the Eldritch Scoundrel is really lackluster and doesn't do much. It has 3/4 BAB with 6-level casting so it's at very least passable, but definitely near the bottom of the barrel of classes with that chassis. If you're using Unchained Rogue, however, then Eldritch Scoundrel gets to rock out. With Finesse Training and Debilitating Injury he's got more than enough tools to be successful in melee in spite of the sneak attack loss.

Still, as others have noted, Vigilante talents are mostly better than Rogue talent, with Vanishing Trick being the only standout for the Eldritch Scoundrel.


Imbicatus wrote:
PhD. Okkam wrote:
master_marshmallow wrote:

VMC magus makes both classes better in a lot of ways.

The returning weapon vigilante talent can make all of your weapons that you use the same as your primary, so get a throwing dagger or whatever with conductive on it and enjoy adding weapon damage to your bolts.

You can only use the Conductive property once per round.
You can use conductive once per round per conductive weapon. Since the returning weapon vigilante talent lets you apply the enchantment to all weapons you throw, you can use it for all attacks. You have to be high level, but it works.

Not anymore.

UE Errata wrote:

Page 137—In conductive, change the last sentence to

“A given character can use this weapon special ability only once per round (even if she has several conductive weapons), and the power works only with magical abilities of the same type as the weapon (melee or ranged).”

With the Returning Weapon vigilante talent a character can give the Conductive ability to all of her weapons, but she can only use the Conductive ability from one each round.


master_marshmallow wrote:

VMC magus makes both classes better in a lot of ways.

The returning weapon vigilante talent can make all of your weapons that you use the same as your primary, so get a throwing dagger or whatever with conductive on it and enjoy adding weapon damage to your bolts.

Eldritch Scoundrel is all about that dimensional savant feat chain getting self-sufficient sneak attack going. Improved sneak attacker and some magic items up the sneak damage.

For both builds, spells cover utility more than feats and skills do. But you still get a sh*t ton of skills.

Warlock is more rewarding early game.

If you're going Eldritch Scoundrel VMC Magus, Prescient Attack might be worth picking up, especially together with Sense Vitals.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Advice / Eldritch Scoundrel (U.Rogue) vs. Warlock (Vigilante) All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Advice