
strayshift |
In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.

Durinor |
Not so much impatient, more that this is a busy, active board and any rules question is normally answered within a few minutes.
In this case I had laready looked around and found nothing, but wanted to check if I'd missed anything. The lack of response confirmed for me that the answer was indeed 'no'.
In a way my 'impatience' was a compliment to the efficiency of the posters here! :)

blahpers |

In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.
Only specific bloodlines get that ability anyway, and they pay for it by being forced to take one of those bloodlines. If it fits the character concept to be that kind of sorcerer, why not let 'em have it.
Just my take though. As the GM, you're the boss.

Remy Balster |

strayshift wrote:In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.
Only specific bloodlines get that ability anyway, and they pay for it by being forced to take one of those bloodlines. If it fits the character concept to be that kind of sorcerer, why not let 'em have it.
Just my take though. As the GM, you're the boss.
Exactly this. The price they pay to change their casting stat is that the ability to change their casting stat IS the only bloodline arcana they get. All the other bloodlines have an ability to do something nifty... these two bloodlines have the ability to use a different primary stat INSTEAD of having some other ability.
And they're locked into that exact bloodline for this ability too, they have to accept the entire bloodline as a whole, whether they like it or not, it is a package deal. Not even crossblooded archetype works, because the bloodlines that allow the stat changes are both wildblood variants, and you cannot use both archetypes.

strayshift |
blahpers wrote:strayshift wrote:In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.
Only specific bloodlines get that ability anyway, and they pay for it by being forced to take one of those bloodlines. If it fits the character concept to be that kind of sorcerer, why not let 'em have it.
Just my take though. As the GM, you're the boss.
Exactly this. The price they pay to change their casting stat is that the ability to change their casting stat IS the only bloodline arcana they get. All the other bloodlines have an ability to do something nifty... these two bloodlines have the ability to use a different primary stat INSTEAD of having some other ability.
And they're locked into that exact bloodline for this ability too, they have to accept the entire bloodline as a whole, whether they like it or not, it is a package deal. Not even crossblooded archetype works, because the bloodlines that allow the stat changes are both wildblood variants, and you cannot use both archetypes.
Then archetype or no, why is it we see no Clerics or Wizards converting to Charisma for their casting stat...
Exactly.

Alexander Augunas Contributor |

blahpers wrote:strayshift wrote:In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.
Only specific bloodlines get that ability anyway, and they pay for it by being forced to take one of those bloodlines. If it fits the character concept to be that kind of sorcerer, why not let 'em have it.
Just my take though. As the GM, you're the boss.
Exactly this. The price they pay to change their casting stat is that the ability to change their casting stat IS the only bloodline arcana they get. All the other bloodlines have an ability to do something nifty... these two bloodlines have the ability to use a different primary stat INSTEAD of having some other ability.
And they're locked into that exact bloodline for this ability too, they have to accept the entire bloodline as a whole, whether they like it or not, it is a package deal. Not even crossblooded archetype works, because the bloodlines that allow the stat changes are both wildblood variants, and you cannot use both archetypes.
Well, what if you're an oddball like me who wants a Charisma-based witch because of how gosh-darn thematic it is? I grew up watching Disney's Hocus Pocus and let me tell you, those witches' primary casting stat is NOT Intelligence.

blahpers |

Remy Balster wrote:Then archetype or no, why is it we see no Clerics or Wizards converting to Charisma for their casting stat...blahpers wrote:strayshift wrote:In a word 'no'.
I'm not a big fan of Sorcerers having alternative casting stats either and so don't allow them when I DM.
The argument I would make is that you don't have the same desire for Wizards and Clerics to have alternative casting stats. Why? Because Int and Wis are have other advantages as well as being a casting stat, yet Charisma is perceived as being less useful. Metagaming.
Only specific bloodlines get that ability anyway, and they pay for it by being forced to take one of those bloodlines. If it fits the character concept to be that kind of sorcerer, why not let 'em have it.
Just my take though. As the GM, you're the boss.
Exactly this. The price they pay to change their casting stat is that the ability to change their casting stat IS the only bloodline arcana they get. All the other bloodlines have an ability to do something nifty... these two bloodlines have the ability to use a different primary stat INSTEAD of having some other ability.
And they're locked into that exact bloodline for this ability too, they have to accept the entire bloodline as a whole, whether they like it or not, it is a package deal. Not even crossblooded archetype works, because the bloodlines that allow the stat changes are both wildblood variants, and you cannot use both archetypes.
Because there's no option to do so? I'd do it in a heartbeat for some characters. Clerics, in particular.

blahpers |

Well, what if you're an oddball like me who wants a Charisma-based witch because of how gosh-darn thematic it is? I grew up watching Disney's Hocus Pocus and let me tell you, those witches' primary casting stat is NOT Intelligence.
I'm amazed that they use Intelligence. Either of the other two mental stats seem more appropriate; Intelligence seems like it'd be the least appropriate, though not by all that much.

![]() |

The main problem I see is that the Oracle and the other Spontaneous casters typically are a version of one of the Vancian casting classes (Cleric, in this case) and except for one, they all use Cha for their caster stat. Cause I get magic from being pretty.
I see it as a downfall for choosing a class with different (Superior?) mechanics than it's mentor. I do like having characters with high Cha, but sometimes I miss the other stats when I can't perceive anything and have a hard time getting skills.