
Lord Fyre RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32 |

Depends:
In that case, Sir Patrick Steward was in better physical condition that William Shatner was. So, I would think that Picard would win.
Pacard's Enterprise at 70 to 100 years of technological improvements over Kirks Enterprise. So, Picard wins again.
So Yeah.

Loztastic |
I once read a great article
a group of klingon's are guarding a tunnel that a starship captain and his/her friends want to go through
Kirk gives the klingons a kicking, then walks through
Picard negotiates with the Klingons, anyone can go though
Sisko goes back in time, and goes through before the Klingons get there
Janeway blows up the tunnel, noone can go through
noone knows what Archer does, because noone is watching

Steven Tindall |

My vote..Janeway for the win.
She was tougher than both of the nancy boys from the enterprise.
Kirk needed his vulcan to get his ass outta everything
Picard didnt even have a vulcan
Janeway taught her vulcan to kick ass and had a really hot second in command to boot.
Ok OK so picards second in command was mega hot with the beard and all but still over all Janeway for the win in the tough captain competion

![]() |

My vote..Janeway for the win.
She was tougher than both of the nancy boys from the enterprise.
Kirk needed his vulcan to get his ass outta everything
Picard didnt even have a vulcan
Janeway taught her vulcan to kick ass and had a really hot second in command to boot.
Ok OK so picards second in command was mega hot with the beard and all but still over all Janeway for the win in the tough captain competion
Wow there are just some thoughts I don't want in my head Steven.

Steven Tindall |

Steven Tindall wrote:Wow there are just some thoughts I don't want in my head Steven.My vote..Janeway for the win.
She was tougher than both of the nancy boys from the enterprise.
Kirk needed his vulcan to get his ass outta everything
Picard didnt even have a vulcan
Janeway taught her vulcan to kick ass and had a really hot second in command to boot.
Ok OK so picards second in command was mega hot with the beard and all but still over all Janeway for the win in the tough captain competion
Then I would suggest staying away from anything resembeling slash fanfiction CJ. The sites dedicated to cha-co-tey/paris/kim love affairs are very popular but then again so are the janeway/7 sites so 6 of one half dozen of the other. Some of the best stories are of riker and his clone becomeing involved, after all riker could never really love anyone that wasnt as pretty as himself so perfrect solution.

![]() |

Crimson Jester wrote:Then I would suggest staying away from anything resembeling slash fanfiction CJ. The sites dedicated to cha-co-tey/paris/kim love affairs are very popular but then again so are the janeway/7 sites so 6 of one half dozen of the other. Some of the best stories are of riker and his clone becomeing involved, after all riker could never really love anyone that wasnt as pretty as himself so perfrect solution.Steven Tindall wrote:Wow there are just some thoughts I don't want in my head Steven.My vote..Janeway for the win.
She was tougher than both of the nancy boys from the enterprise.
Kirk needed his vulcan to get his ass outta everything
Picard didnt even have a vulcan
Janeway taught her vulcan to kick ass and had a really hot second in command to boot.
Ok OK so picards second in command was mega hot with the beard and all but still over all Janeway for the win in the tough captain competion
LMAO yes I could see him going for his other half. Now I am going to have to go scrub my brain. My friend loved Slash fic but preferred the Harry and Malfoy ones. ~shivers~ Must. use. more. brain. bleach.

Loopy |

![]() |

Studpuffin wrote:Loopy wrote:Right...
EDIT: and he's kind of Space Jesus or something.
No! Really!
Oh I wasn't disagreeing. I've watched the whole series. It just seemed a really odd thing to add to Star Trek after TNG.
However, I would call anyone who designed the defiant as someone with a god-complex.

Loopy |

Loopy wrote:Studpuffin wrote:Loopy wrote:Right...
EDIT: and he's kind of Space Jesus or something.
No! Really!
Oh I wasn't disagreeing. I've watched the whole series. It just seemed a really odd thing to add to Star Trek after TNG.
However, I would call anyone who designed the defiant as someone with a god-complex.
Hell yes. They should have named it "The Machine of Great Reckoning".

Steven Tindall |

space jesus or not. I still say janeway for the win. Sisko as much as I love him was still all "must not violate prime directive" he did to get the romulans involved in the dominion war but he was all guilty and as emo-ey as a sparkly vampire over it.
Janeway was like"were over 170 light years from the nearest starbase Mr. Nelix I dont think starfleet cares, tuvox fire"
Plus sisko was like a half-breed celestial template type janeway was just a plain old human.

![]() |

Oh, I love unwinnable arguments.
But I'm for Kirk. The only character with balls on the Next Gen Enterprise was K'Ehleyr, and she was just visiting.
What did Sisko do when he met Picard in Emissary? Told him off (since he'd already 'met' him as Locutis, in the battle where his wife died).
What did Sisko do when he met Kirk in Trials and Tribble-ations? Got his autograph!

Lord Fyre RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32 |

space jesus or not. I still say janeway for the win. Sisko as much as I love him was still all "must not violate prime directive" he did to get the romulans involved in the dominion war but he was all guilty and as emo-ey as a sparkly vampire over it.
Just remember, in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Captain Benjamin Sisko was still on the frontier of Federation space. If he goes and starts ignoring the "Prime Directive" Star Fleet security would come an "have a polite chat" with him. Justified as it was, the way he got the Romulans involved in the Dominion war would get him sent directly to a "re-education" colony, if the Federation ever actually found out what really happened.
Now, with Star Trek: Voyager, Kate Mulgrew had to overcome some of the worst writing ever shown on TV. Exceeded for pure awefulness only by Star Trek: Enterprise. So in some real ways, comparing Captain Kathryn Janeway (or Jonathan Archer) to either Kirk or Picard is just plan unfair.

DoveArrow |

Picard is my favorite captain. Nevertheless, I have to say that Kirk would kick Picard's ass in a fist fight. How do I know this? Simple logic.
Observe the transitive property in action.
Fact: Soran kicked Picard's ass.
Fact: Kirk kicked Soran's ass.
Conclusion: Kirk can kick Picard's ass.

Emperor7 |

Emperor7 wrote:Chuck Norris could kick all their asses. At the same time!Even Chuck Norris wouldn't survive a photon torpedo bombardment from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.
The tried that on DS9, episode 3 and the torpedoes got stuck in the tubes out of fear. Chuck Norris is an Elder God. ;)

Turin the Mad |

Turin the Mad wrote:The tried that on DS9, episode 3 and the torpedoes got stuck in the tubes out of fear. Chuck Norris is an Elder God. ;)Emperor7 wrote:Chuck Norris could kick all their asses. At the same time!Even Chuck Norris wouldn't survive a photon torpedo bombardment from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.
Turin makes a mental note to use dumbfire torpedoes. Although if Upchuck Norris is an Elder Gawd, Turin also realizes that the massive SAN loss that would inevitably ensue is why he normally doesn't take shots at Upchuck Norris in threads and such in the first place.

Capt. Kirk Moorluck |

Capt. Kirk Moorluck wrote:Everyoneknows....that...Iamthe...greateststarfleet....cap...tian....ofallti me.Oh go tell it to Priceline, you poor excuse for a Comanding Officer. Did you even care about those ensigns you got killed in every episode. And all so you could get another interspecies STD.
Ensigns? Whatarethey.....Oh.... youmustmean....the......zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz....phaserspounges....w e keptthem.....on....everyawayshuttle.....incaseofemergency.

Weeeesley |

Capt. Kirk Moorluck wrote:Everyoneknows....that...Iamthe...greateststarfleet....cap...tian....ofallti me.Oh go tell it to Priceline, you poor excuse for a Comanding Officer. Did you even care about those ensigns you got killed in every episode. And all so you could get another interspecies STD.
You killed my daddieeeeeeeeee..........