

|
|
RPG Superstar™ 2011 General Discussion
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Competitors: Remember the rules about commenting on your archetype
(Sticky)
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Levis,
Mikko Kallio
and
5
others
|
18
posts
|
by Neil F.
|
|
|
Wondrous Item Auto-reject Advice
(Sticky)
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Sean K Reynolds
|
1
post
|
by Sean K Reynolds
|
|
|
Top 9-16 Locations
|
by Joel Flank
—
JoelF847,
shearsnews
and
Curaigh
|
4
posts
|
by shearsnews
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #21: Item gives a class ability or a feat
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Dire Mongoose,
NotMousse,
Sean K Reynolds
and
15
others
|
27
posts
|
by Goth Guru
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Design Tuesday: Superstar Maps!
|
by tdewitt274
—
tdewitt274,
Scipion del Ferro,
surfbored
and
5
others
|
15
posts
|
by Brother Fen
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #18: Item makes bearer unable to be lost
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Andrew Christian,
Cartigan,
Hyla Arborea
and
24
others
|
62
posts
|
by Interesting Character
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #4: Item Ought to be Not-An-Item
|
|
19
posts
|
by Ross Byers
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #19: Item Involves Vomit
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Freehold DM,
Gorbacz
and
26
others
|
39
posts
|
by VomitLapPingDog
|
|
|
Judges, Please Critique My Item
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Neil Spicer,
RonarsCorruption,
Curaigh
and
58
others
|
1,212
posts
|
by Kryzbyn
|
|
|
Archtypes and Prestige Classes
|
by Cody Coffelt
—
Scipion del Ferro,
Noteleks,
Sean K Reynolds
and
13
others
|
31
posts
|
by Ravingdork
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #9: The Intellectual Property Violation
|
|
31
posts
|
by prosfilaes
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #8: The Random Item
|
|
32
posts
|
by Neil Spicer
|
|
|
Nine Blazing Months
|
by Curaigh
—
Ask A RPGSupersuccubus,
Curaigh,
RonarsCorruption
and
15
others
|
159
posts
|
by Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #10: Item isn't Spell-Checked or Proofread
|
|
64
posts
|
by goodwicki
|
|
|
Wondrous Item lotto siege-hecked advice #26: Item encourages metagaming
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
gbonehead,
TarkXT,
hogarth
and
15
others
|
19
posts
|
by TarkXT
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #25: Item is a child's toy
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Neil Spicer,
0gre,
Sebastian
and
45
others
|
94
posts
|
by Naggarath
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #14: Item is something we can't advertise due to mature or offensive content
|
|
39
posts
|
by Nazard
|
|
|
You don't have to "win" to "win"--so ENTER!
|
|
77
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
I'm getting geeked...
|
|
36
posts
|
by Jerett Schaufele
|
|
|
General Advice?
|
by Matthew Morris
—
John Benbo,
Azmahel,
Matthew Morris
and
7
others
|
15
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
The Corset Design Thread from the Superstar Panel
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Neil Spicer,
RonarsCorruption,
Clark Peterson
and
13
others
|
73
posts
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
|
|
|
Question--are the items in "Treasury of the Macabre" Superstar quality?
|
by Clark Peterson
—
Clark Peterson,
Darkjoy,
Matthew Morris
and
3
others
|
18
posts
|
by Maurice de Mare
|
|
|
RPG Art Superstar?
|
by the Haunted Jester
—
Charles Evans 25,
Cpt_kirstov,
gbonehead
and
2
others
|
5
posts
|
by Charles Evans 25
|
|
|
RPG superstar 2012...when to apply
|
by Hama
—
Gorbacz,
Callum Finlayson
and
Hama
|
5
posts
|
by Gorbacz
|
|
|
RPG Superstar
|
by Shaun Hocking
—
RonarsCorruption,
JoelF847,
Nermal2097
and
gang
|
5
posts
|
by RonarsCorruption
|
|
|
Wondrous Item auto-reject advice #2: Swiss Army Knife
|
|
27
posts
|
by Neil Spicer
|
|
|
Superstar Banner
|
by John Bennett
—
John Benbo
|
1
post
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
A different top-32er's adventure proposal
|
by Erik Freund
—
RonarsCorruption,
Erik Freund
and
Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
|
5
posts
|
by RonarsCorruption
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar 2011 has a winner!
|
by morphail
—
joela,
Mark Moreland,
Black Fang
and
47
others
|
53
posts
|
by Jodi Lane
|
|
|
Thoughts / reflections / comments by the RPGSuperstar 2011 Top 32
|
by Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
—
John Benbo,
JoelF847,
Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
and
10
others
|
20
posts
|
by Jerall Toi
|
|
|
In praise of Charles Evans
|
by Sean McGowan
—
Charles Evans 25,
John Benbo,
Shadow-Mask
and
7
others
|
13
posts
|
by Marie Small
|
|
|
Thanks Sean (and the other judges)
|
by Sebastian
—
Arjomanes,
Sebastian,
Gerrard Dixon
and
19
others
|
24
posts
|
by Gerrard Dixon
|
|
|
The Unofficial Top 32 Guildhall 2011
|
by Eric Morton
—
John Benbo,
DankeSean,
Scipion del Ferro
and
20
others
|
592
posts
|
by Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
|
|
|
How "niche" can a module be?
|
by Nicolas Quimby
—
John Benbo,
Boxhead,
Curaigh
and
5
others
|
9
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Round 5 exit poll
|
by Tikael
—
Tikael,
Power Word Unzip,
Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
and
46
others
|
61
posts
|
by CBarkley
|
|
|
Some Thoughts on the Final Round
|
by Ryan Dancey
—
MicMan,
Curaigh,
Enkili
and
5
others
|
8
posts
|
by MicMan
|
|
|
Your Vote Counts!
|
by Vic Wertz
—
Neil Spicer
and
Vic Wertz
|
4
posts
|
by Neil Spicer
|
|
|
What is a passive, and why is it bad? A writing advice thread
|
by Seabyrn
—
Seabyrn,
Sean K Reynolds,
Andrew Christian
and
13
others
|
27
posts
|
by Seabyrn
|
|
|
Am I disqualified from RPG Superstar 2012?
|
by Jikuu
—
Scipion del Ferro,
Jikuu,
Cassey
and
13
others
|
18
posts
|
by Cassey
|
|
|
Final Round Commentary
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
deinol,
Matt Goodall
and
3
others
|
7
posts
|
by deinol
|
|
|
Round 5 rules
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Vic Wertz,
King of Vrock,
Mark Moreland
and
2
others
|
6
posts
|
by Vic Wertz
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar 2011 Final Round Voting Begins
|
by LoreKeeper
—
LoreKeeper
|
1
post
|
by LoreKeeper
|
|
|
Thank you to everyone and I have a present for you!
|
by John Bennett
—
John Benbo,
Hydro
and
Snorter
|
5
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Round Four Commentary
|
by Neil Spicer
—
John Benbo,
The Leaping Gnome,
Neil Spicer
and
15
others
|
32
posts
|
by Nicolas Quimby
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG Superstar 2011: The Top 4!
|
by LoreKeeper
—
Andrew Christian,
Hydro,
Elorebaen
and
25
others
|
29
posts
|
by Nicolas Quimby
|
|
|
Round 4 exit poll
|
by Tikael
—
Tikael,
Quandary,
CC.
and
47
others
|
63
posts
|
by CC.
|
|
|
Those who didn't make it this far, what would your villain have been?
|
by Venerax
—
Andrew Christian,
James Martin,
Steven T. Helt
and
15
others
|
34
posts
|
by Andrew Christian
|
|
|
The Alternates' Archetypes
|
by Mikko Kallio
—
Mikko Kallio,
surfbored,
Andrew Christian
and
19
others
|
35
posts
|
by Jerry Keyes
|
|
|
If I was in the Top 32 I would submit...
|
by Azmahel
—
Thomas LeBlanc,
Erick Wilson,
Azmahel
and
34
others
|
151
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
Presidents' Day
|
by Cody Coffelt
—
John Benbo,
Scipion del Ferro,
Paul Watson
and
3
others
|
9
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Round 4 Rules
|
by Ross Byers
—
John Benbo,
Sean K Reynolds,
Andrew Christian
and
18
others
|
52
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Votes Cast...Good Luck To All
|
by james knowles
—
Tikael,
Russ Taylor,
Quandary
and
48
others
|
105
posts
|
by Tikael
|
|
|
Items that remove certain limitations of a class feature
|
by Matrixryu
—
Matrixryu,
NIVEUS,
Luthia
and
3
others
|
7
posts
|
by NIVEUS
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: RPG SuperstarTM 2011 Top 8
|
by Enlight_Bystand
—
John Benbo,
LoreKeeper,
hedgeknight
and
5
others
|
9
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Some thoughts on round three
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Neil Spicer,
DankeSean,
Nick Bolhuis
and
10
others
|
16
posts
|
by Cleaver
|
|
|
Happy Valentine's Day
|
|
6
posts
|
by Hydro
|
|
|
Voluntary Reject Bin (Archetype Edition)
|
by Mikael Sebag
—
Scipion del Ferro,
Azmahel,
Ask A RPGSupersuccubus
and
12
others
|
41
posts
|
by Cody Coffelt
|
|
|
Some advice for Round 4
|
by Matt Goodall
—
Charles Evans 25,
The Leaping Gnome,
Standback
and
2
others
|
5
posts
|
by Charles Evans 25
|
|
|
Thoughts on Villains
|
by Matt Goodall
—
Charles Evans 25,
The Leaping Gnome,
Boxhead
and
4
others
|
9
posts
|
by Charles Evans 25
|
|
|
Round 3 Initial Impression
|
by Andrew Christian
—
Standback,
James Martin,
Andrew Christian
and
6
others
|
12
posts
|
by Ziv Wities
|
|
|
A heads-up for round 4!
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Anry,
Matthew Morris,
DankeSean
and
16
others
|
31
posts
|
by Sean McGowan
|
|
|
Advice to the top 32
|
by Charles Evans 25
—
Charles Evans 25,
Matthew Morris,
King of Vrock
and
3
others
|
13
posts
|
by Charles Evans 25
|
|
|
Round Three Commentary
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Neil Spicer,
Scipion del Ferro,
Mark Moreland
and
8
others
|
15
posts
|
by Mark Moreland
|
|
|
If I was in the Top16 I would submit...
|
by Azmahel
—
Azmahel,
Kerney,
Anry
and
7
others
|
14
posts
|
by Kerney
|
|
|
Bomb Saves
|
|
7
posts
|
by 0gre
|
|
|
So who's in the 32 portraits, anyhow?
|
by Sean McGowan
—
DankeSean
and
Mark Moreland
|
3
posts
|
by Sean McGowan
|
|
|
Thoughts on the overall quality of the top 32...
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
—
Thomas LeBlanc,
Dire Mongoose,
Neil Spicer
and
41
others
|
108
posts
|
by gbonehead
|
|
|
Round 3 rules are live!
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Scipion del Ferro,
Anry,
Neil Spicer
and
37
others
|
149
posts
|
by Ryan Marsh
|
|
|
Emergency! Admin please help!
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Nick Bolhuis,
Vic Wertz,
King of Vrock
and
17
others
|
35
posts
|
by Nick Bolhuis
|
|
|
Thanks for all the fish!
|
by Jerry Keyes
—
Kerney,
Nick Bolhuis,
Boxhead
and
surfbored
|
4
posts
|
by Kerney
|
|
|
Congratulations to the Top 16!
|
by Robert Burns Johnson
—
Andrew Christian,
MythrilDragon
and
Robert Burns Johnson
|
6
posts
|
by Andrew Christian
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: The Top 16!
|
by LoreKeeper
—
Scipion del Ferro,
Urizen,
Kerney
and
37
others
|
43
posts
|
by Kerney
|
|
|
Only 4 votes instead of 8 in Round 2?
|
by MicMan
—
Azmahel,
MicMan,
cynarion
and
6
others
|
11
posts
|
by cynarion
|
|
|
So, Class, What Have We Learned Today?
|
by Crowface
—
Abraham spalding,
Sean K Reynolds,
Joe Wells
and
40
others
|
89
posts
|
by FallofCamelot
|
|
|
Formating question
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Nick Bolhuis
and
Sean K Reynolds
|
4
posts
|
by Nick Bolhuis
|
|
|
The Voluntary Reject Bin
|
by Azmahel
—
Azmahel,
DankeSean,
Scipion del Ferro
and
30
others
|
205
posts
|
by Azmahel
|
|
|
R2 Archetypes: prepare for some harsh criticism
|
by Sean K Reynolds
—
Sean K Reynolds,
Matthew McGee,
Mikko Kallio
and
19
others
|
35
posts
|
by Noteleks
|
|
|
Peer Evaluation: 2011 RPG Superstar Wondrous Item Submissions
|
by Mikael Sebag
—
Joe Wells,
RonarsCorruption,
Hydro
and
46
others
|
201
posts
|
by Ma Gi
|
|
|
Plot device items
|
by Nicolas Quimby
—
Hydro,
Vic Wertz,
Sean K Reynolds
and
7
others
|
17
posts
|
by Nicolas Quimby
|
|
|
Where are the winners from?
|
by Marusaia
—
DankeSean,
Anry,
The Leaping Gnome
and
46
others
|
105
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
Wondrous Item pricing. Is it new math?
|
|
18
posts
|
by Blueluck
|
|
|
Reliable and Steadfast weapon enchanments
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
—
|
1
post
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
|
|
|
Which Items Make Your Top 5?
|
by Neil Spicer
—
Matthias_DM,
DankeSean,
Power Word Unzip
and
29
others
|
37
posts
|
by Curaigh
|
|
|
So, I'm fairly new here, and this is definitely my first Superstar
|
by Dumb Paladin
—
Dumb Paladin,
Arjomanes
and
Nick Bolhuis
|
5
posts
|
by Dumb Paladin
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: Round 2: Vote for your favorite Archetypes!
|
by Ryan. Costello
—
Ryan. Costello
|
1
post
|
by Ryan. Costello
|
|
|
Big day today!
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Nick Bolhuis,
King of Vrock,
Neil Spicer
and
7
others
|
16
posts
|
by Scott Fernandez
|
|
|
Top 32 - Please Tell Me More About You
|
by Herremann the Wise
—
ryric,
Erik Freund,
The Leaping Gnome
and
26
others
|
38
posts
|
by ryric
|
|
|
Entries from Alternates
|
by eric kiser
—
Mikko Kallio,
Mike Kimmel,
kwixson
and
10
others
|
35
posts
|
by Mikko Kallio
|
|
|
Wondrous Items 2.0
|
by Thomas Miller aka tqmillerusa
—
Thomas Miller aka tqmillerusa,
kwixson,
Nick Bolhuis
and
7
others
|
13
posts
|
by kwixson
|
|
|
Some thoughts on adventure design
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Nick Bolhuis,
Vic Wertz,
Bats Kabber
and
14
others
|
26
posts
|
by Charles Dunwoody
|
|
|
I didn't make it, but congrats to those who did!
|
by Jeremiziah
—
Anry,
OamuTheMonk,
Charles Dunwoody
and
45
others
|
49
posts
|
by James Olchak
|
|
|
What I Really Learned From RPG Superstar
|
by Thomas LeBlanc
—
Lars Lundberg,
Ian Eastmond,
Sean K Reynolds
and
Eric Stelle
|
5
posts
|
by Ian Eastmond
|
|
|
When do we see the archetypes?
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
Neil Spicer,
Sean K Reynolds,
James Martin
and
14
others
|
26
posts
|
by Russ Taylor
|
|
|
On Criticism
|
by James Martin
—
Clark Peterson,
DM_aka_Dudemeister,
DM Barcas
and
9
others
|
13
posts
|
by DM_aka_Dudemeister
|
|
|
Guide to the Inner Sea
|
by Eric Hindley
—
Boxhead,
John Benbo,
Mikko Kallio
and
4
others
|
10
posts
|
by Mikko Kallio
|
|
|
Who's done?
|
by Nick Bolhuis
—
John Benbo,
Nick Bolhuis,
The Leaping Gnome
and
20
others
|
35
posts
|
by John Bennett
|
|
|
Can There Be Spaces? (Round 2)
|
by Cody Coffelt
—
Neil Spicer,
Sean K Reynolds,
Scipion del Ferro
and
4
others
|
11
posts
|
by Power Word Unzip
|
|
|
Is it possible to commission a Battle map design?
|
|
1
post
|
by Fat Jozka
|
|
|
Quick question...
|
by Trevor Watson
—
Luz,
Ross Byers
and
Nick Bolhuis
|
5
posts
|
by Trevor Watson
|
|
|
Paizo Blog: The Top 32
|
by Mairkurion {tm}
—
Zuxius,
Anry,
Neil Spicer
and
72
others
|
81
posts
|
by Charles Dunwoody
|
|
|
|