
AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 18 unfortunate

BR Yewstance |

Mid-scenario Acquired Cards update.
Mouse (Ally 0)
Covering Heavy Shield (Armor 1)
Leather Armor (Armor 0)
Prayer (Blessing 0)
Torag's Power (Blessing 1)
Flame Staff (Item 0)
Balmberry (Item 0)
Wand of Acid Burst (Item 1)
Mist Horn (Item 1)
Plague Mask (Item 0)
Good Omen (Spell 1)
Deflect (Spell 0)
Knock (Spell 1)
Sword Cane (Weapon 0)

BR Yewstance |

COMPLETED SCENARIO 1A: A CITY GONE MAD - Summary
SCENARIO REWARD:
ACQUIRED CARDS:
Ally 0 x2
Ally 1 x3
Armor 0 x1
Armor 1 x1
Blessing 0 x1
Blessing 1 x2
Item 0 x5
Item 2 x2
Spell 0 x1
Spell 1 x2
Weapon 0 x1
Weapon 1 x1
=========================
1A BR Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 18 -> No effect.
Don't forget to roll for your boons!

Ukuja the sailor |

Presumably Ukuja is free to take one of the 3 ally 1s. I'll roll if 4 or more of us want one.
Using my hero token for power feat +1 hand size.
boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 9

Heggal - ACG kuey |

I think you mean Item 1, not Item 2? :)
Upgrades:
Weapon 1 (Katana +1): 1d1000 ⇒ 411
Item 1 (Pearl of Wisdom): 1d1000 ⇒ 162
Although if someone wants a Weapon 1, he is totally fine to get the Item 1 instead.
Scratch what I said on discord. Forgot that he hadn't gotten the important Power Feat yet. He'll spend the Hero Point on a Power Feat: You may reveal an ally that lists Diplomacy in its check to acquire to add 1d4 (X +1) to your check.
boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 12

Zalarian |

Varian - 1A A City Gone Mad
CAG II Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 5Not today
Scenario Reward
Rally the supporter Amin Jalento
Extra Ally/Blessing
Adventure Reward
N/A
Tier/XP 1.1->1.2
Spend 1 Hero Point for Card Feat (Item - Compass)
Hero Points (Prior + Gained - Used = Current)
0 + 1 - 1 = 0
Loot rolls
Do not believe needed
Deck Upgrades
Life Drain (Spell 1)
Banished Cards: None
Holes Filled: None
Removed: Mind Thrust

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

Quinn would like a Blessing 1 1d1000 ⇒ 671

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

I don't believe I rolled for the first scenario, so
Boon roll for 1*: 1d20 ⇒ 18
Boon roll for 1A: 1d20 ⇒ 8

AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

I'll pass on the upgrades, maybe I'll start taking them when I get a Card Feat
I'll be Tiering Up to Tier 2.
Boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 6

Heggal - ACG kuey |

So I'm assuming Heggal got the Weapon 1 (Katana +1) but think we're still pending Reta. I'm still fine to swap but will post my starting hand.
Katana +1 will replace Mace. If not Pearl +1 will replace Portable Ram.
Also, will replace Standard Bearer with the Core version.

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

So we have:
Ukuja: Ally 1
Heggal: Weapon 1 (probably)
Varian: Spell 1
Quinn: Blessing 1
Aric: --
That just leaves Reta.
There are still 2 Ally 1s, an Armor 1, a Blessing 1, 2 Item 1s, and a Spell 1 uncontested. If Reta wants any of those she can just take it.
If Reta wants the Weapon 1, though, Heggal has said he is prepared to take an Item 1 instead.
So it looks as though everybody can go ahead and upgrade their hands.

Reta Bigbad - PinesAwait |

I'll take an ally 1, and with that I'll get Xoff.
I'll also be using my hero point to add +1 to my dex checks.

BR Yewstance |

Sage (Ally 0)
Porcupine (Ally 0)
Archer's Kite Shield (Armor 1)
Armored Coat (Armor 0)
Slick Leather (Armor 1)
The Uprising (Blessing 1)
Noxious Bomb (Item 0)
Wand of Force Missile (Item 1)
Flame Staff (Item 0)
Spider Venom (Item 0)
Spyglass (Item 0)
War Drum (Item 0)
Sacred Candle (Item 1)
Minor Harrowing (Spell 1)
Elven Curve Blade (Weapon 1)
Dogslicer (Weapon 0)

Ukuja the sailor |

Ukuja would like one of the weapon 1s upgrading Terbutje to Stone Axe +1 mostly to get another magic weapon in the deck.
I think this our 3rd scenario. Ukuja will save the hero point for now.
boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 14

BR Yewstance |

COMPLETED SCENARIO 1B: THE AMBASSADOR'S SECRET - Summary
SCENARIO REWARD:
ACQUIRED CARDS:
Ally 0 x2
Ally 1 x1
Armor 0 x1
Armor 1 x2
Blessing 1 x2
Item 0 x5
Item 1 x2
Spell 1 x1
Weapon 0 x2
Weapon 1 x3
=========================
1B BR Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 16 -> No effect.
Don't forget to roll for your boons!

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

Quinn is most interested in a Blessing 1 1d1000 ⇒ 729
If he doesn't get that he'll take an Item 0.
1B Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 10
He will spend his Hero Point to increase his Intelligence
(which will also add 1 to the bonus he can give against barriers)

Heggal - ACG kuey |

Heggal will take Ally 0 ==> 1d1000 ⇒ 229. Will replace Emissary with Retainer.
boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 11
He'll spend a Hero Point to increase strength.

Varian 12789 |

Varian - CotCT-1B The Ambassador's Secret
CAG II Boon Roll: 1d20 ⇒ 5 Not Today
Scenario Reward
Rally the supporter Vencarlo Orisini.
Adventure Reward
N/A
Tier/XP 1.2->1.3
Spend 1 Hero Point for Skill Feat (Dex+1)
Hero Points (Prior + Gained - Used = Current)
0 + 1 - 1 = 0
Loot rolls
Do not believe needed
Deck Upgrades
Captain's Cutlass (Weapon 1)
Banished Cards: None
Holes Filled: None
Removed: Rapier

AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

Boon?: 1d20 ⇒ 7
I'll use my Hero Point for a Power Feat:
Aric: [X]When you encounter a boon, you may examine the top card of your location deck
TRR: At the end of your move step ([X] or turn), you may examine the top card of your location deck.
Still no upgrade for me.

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

OK - Quinn will take a Blessing 1 to upgrade a Blessing of the Quartermaster to a Blessing of Abadar

Reta Bigbad - PinesAwait |

It doesn't seem like people are going for weapon 1, so I'll take one if that's ok with yall. I'll get a Force Shortbow +1.
I'll hold onto my hero point for now instead of spending it.

BR Yewstance |

Heavy Shield (Armor 0)
Armored Coat (Armor 0)
Half-plate (Armor 0)
Archer's Kite Shield (Armor 1)
Orison (Blessing 0)
Sands of the Hour (Blessing 0)
The Owl (Blessing 1)
The Waxworks (Blessing 1)
Life Drain (Spell 1)
Knock (Spell 1)
Rapier (Weapon 0)
Shortbow (Weapon 0)
Dogslicer (Weapon 0)
Quarterstaff of Vaulting (Weapon 1)

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

Quinn will bank his Hero Point (he's already got three feats at Tier 1).
He will be tiering up.
He's not that concerned about upgrades, but if there's a Weapon 1 or Armor 1 left unclaimed he could find a use for it.

Ukuja the sailor |

4th scenario at tier 1 and spending hero point on card feat Spell.
Hoping for Spell 1 upgrade but if 2 other people want spell 1 I'm fine with Blessing 1.

BR Yewstance |

COMPLETED SCENARIO 1C: THE DEAD WARRENS - Summary
SCENARIO REWARD:
ACQUIRED CARDS:
2x Ally 0
3x Armor 0
1x Armor 1
2x Blessing 0
3x Blessing 1
2x Spell 1
3x Weapon 0
1x Weapon 1
======================
No more boon rolls, unfortunately.

Reta Bigbad - PinesAwait |

I'll use my hero point to gain a card feat feat for Blessing- I'd like to get a blessing 1 and get a blessing of Shax, but if I can't get it I'll fill the empty spot with a blessing of the gobs.
Blessing 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 803
If I can't get the blessing 1 I'd try for the armor 1, and get Magic Studded Leather Armor.
Armor 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 308
Once I can confirm the upgrades I get I'll skedaddle.

Heggal - ACG kuey |

I notice that some are tiering up but some are not. What are the pros and cons of either?
Heggal will keep his Hero Point since he's maxed out for Tier 1.
Deck Upgrade: He'll like Spell 1 to get Augury to improve his examine capabilities.

Varian 12789 |

Off the top of my head:
Pros: get access to 2nd power, skill and card feat sooner
Cons: Limit the number of times character can be played but usually not an issue if plan is to play character through whole season/adventure path.
Deck upgrades can be taken that have a limit of tier of the character or AD of the adventure; whichever is lower. A tier 1 character playing a tier 2 adventure can use a tier 2 card for deck upgrades but the must choose a tier 1 deck upgrade.
I notice that some are tiering up but some are not. What are the pros and cons of either?
Heggal will keep his Hero Point since he's maxed out for Tier 1.
Deck Upgrade: He'll like Spell 1 to get Augury to improve his examine capabilities.

Varian 12789 |

Varian - CotCT-1C The Dead Warrens
Scenario Reward
Rally the supporter Vencarlo Orisini.
Adventure Reward
N/A
Tier/XP 1.3->1.4
Hero Points (Prior + Gained - Used = Current)
0 + 1 - 0 = 1
Loot rolls
1st Choice Blessing 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 375 Looking to add Blessing of the Starsong
2nd Choice Spell 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 314 TBD on what to add
Deck Upgrades
Blessing 1 (Blessing of the Starsong)
Based on Amounts and current desires, assumption is that Varian's pick is uncontested. Happy to update as needed should it be required.
Banished Cards: None
Holes Filled: None
Removed: BotElements

Ukuja the sailor |

So
Reta - Blessing 1
Ukuja - Spell 1 Charm Animal
Varian - Blessing 1
Heggal - Spell 1
Quinn - Weapon 1 or Armor 1
Aric - unknown

BR Yewstance |

Re: Tiering up.
What Zalarian/Varian said, pretty much. In general, tiering up early makes you more powerful, sooner (more feats) and tiering up later means the 'lifespan' of your character is as long as possible, since you are hard capped to the number of scenarios you can complete before you're forced to tier up.
If you are not planning on playing any other season/scenarios with your character, then tiering up early is pretty much pure upside, because you won't get even close to outleveling any scenario you have to complete during the AP. However, there's a certain "Powergamey" aspect to intentionally leveling faster than the levels of the adventures you're going on, which some players choose not to do.
For reference, there is one more scenario to go of Adventure 1. From Adventure 2 onwards; each CotCT Adventure has 4 scenarios in it, in case you're planning on playing through the entire AP.

Heggal - ACG kuey |

Got it. Then I won't tier up either and wait til the end of this Adventure.
Deck Upgrade: He'll replace Judgement Light with Augury.

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

If Varian isn't taking the Weapon 1, Quinn will replace his Blowgun with a Deathbane Light Crossbow.

AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

I won't be taking any deck upgrades.
I'll spend my Hero Point on a Skill Feat:
Aric: +1 WIS
TRR: +1 DEX

Ukuja the sailor |

Ukuja has 1 of each feat so keeps the second hero point. If the next scenario is tier 2 he'll tier up.
Desired upgrades
blessing 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 702
ally 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 289

AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

Hero Point:I'll take an Ally card feat and fill it in with the Basic Lookout. Then I'll replace the Lookout with the Core version that actually gives me an explore
Upgrade: N/A
Adventure Reward: I'll spend my feat on Trinia Sabor. That one-use soothing word could come in handy

Ukuja the sailor |

Note the Core version isn't all upside. Yes it lets you explore, But the core version recharges to add 1d4 to a local Perception check while the old version reveals to add 1d6 to any Perception check.
Aric has Perception, TRR has Perception, Quinn has Perception, Varian has Perception, Ukuja usually has Perception.
Admittedly I don't think any of us have specific uses for the skill but just pointing out there is a tradeoff between the versions.

Varian 12789 |

Varian - CotCT-1D Kingkiller
Scenario Reward
Rally the supporter Trinia Sabor
Adventure Reward
Each character gains a supporter feat (Cressida Kroft)
Tier/XP 1.4->2.0
Hero Points (Prior + Gained - Used = Current)
1 + 1 - 0 = 2
Loot rolls
1st Choice Ally 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 437 Looking to add Rodrick
2nd Choice Blessing 1: 1d1000 ⇒ 56 Looking to add Blessing of Abadar
3rd Choice Ally 0: 1d1000 ⇒ 20 Looking to add Alaeron
Deck Upgrades
TBD
Banished Cards: None
Holes Filled: None
Removed: If Ally Amadi, if Blessing Blessing of the Spellbound

Heggal - ACG kuey |

Sorry for the late reply. Busy packing up to relocate.
I'll take Armor 0 to switch out Kikko Armor for Chain Mail for its core version.
Keep Hero Point since can't spend it on anything.
Tier up to tier 2.

JohnF-1017 Quinn |

Quinn would be interested in the Item 0 (to upgrade Thieves' Tools to Masterwork Tools)
Edit: Even better idea - he'll replace his Caltrops with the Masterwork Tools
For his supporter feat he chooses Amin Jalento
(Quinn is also tiering up)

Ukuja the sailor |

So Ukuja gets his blessing 1. And I'll pick Vencarlo Orisini for my supporter feat. And Ukuja is tiering up.

AAUGHWHY's PFSACG Aric/TRR |

Aric - Ally 0 / ??? / Amin Jalento
Actually for me its: Ally 0/No Upgrade (Basic trait) - 2.3 - Trinia Sabor

Heggal - ACG kuey |

I've been unexpectedly busier packing for my relocation and together with my upcoming flight, would need botting up til 4 Aug. Sorry I wasn't able to update earlier.

Heggal - ACG kuey |

Sorry I also haven't chosen a supporter feat. Will take Trinia Sabor. Even if just to heal the allies he's used to do more healing.

Varian 12789 |

Varian - CotCT-2A: RATS AND THE SINKING SHIP
Scenario Reward
Rally the supporter Ishani Dhatri
Adventure Reward
Tier/XP 2.0->2.1
Expend Hero Point for Power Feat(At the start of your turn, you may draw up to # cards, then recharge that number of cards.)
Hero Points (Prior + Gained - Used = Current)
2 + 1 - 1 = 2
Loot rolls
1st Choice Ally 2: 1d1000 ⇒ 250 Looking to add Cleric of Nethys
2nd Choice Weapon 2: 1d1000 ⇒ 753 Looking to add Hrym
3rd Choice Ally 0: 1d1000 ⇒ 312 Looking to add Alaeron
Deck Upgrades
TBD
Banished Cards: None
Holes Filled: None
Removed: If Ally Magical Child, if Weapon then Captain's Cutlass

Ukuja the sailor |

First scenario at tier 2. Spending a hero point on a skill feat adding +1 to wisdom.
Taking an ally 1 to upgrade Crow to Raven.
If we are allowed to buy more then 1 feat I'll also take the power feat "...([x] or to add 1d4 plus the discarded card's adventure deck number to your combat check."
And applying a boon that allows me to draw an extra card then recharge a card after drawing my starting hand.