The cavern is large but isn't that large. It's roughly 20 x 20. They didn't confiscate your things. They got dumped in one of the fancy iron-bound chests at the foot of the best (actually big decrepit wooden crates once the illusion faded). The witches are on the far side of the room chatting quietly. It wouldn't be hard to grab your things and port out but it would definitely be noticed.
To get a free check you need to interact with the Illusion, but you have enough evidence with the Mirage to try and disbelieve other things if you would like to.
Male Gnome Cleric 12 | HP 86/86 | AC 19 | T 11 | FF 19 | CMD 16 | Fort +12 | Ref +7 | Will +17 | Init +4 | Perc +6 | Sense Motive +20
Spellcraft:1d20 + 13 ⇒ (19) + 13 = 32 "Yeah, this isn't going to end well, I suggest we not continue with this tribute. Let's get our stuff, I need my symbol to cast some stuff!"
Ventus frowns at their surroundings, "Siolad, get your spell ready, I'm going to give the ladies a chance to drop the pretenses and deal with us fairly. I'd rather not have to deal with a coven of angry witches."
Concentrating and forcing your will against your own perceptions, the scene shimmers and changes around you. The Mother’s form remains unchanged, glowing with unearthly radiance. The Maid’s perfection melts away and in her place is a beautiful young woman but with mortal limitations. Freckles dot her face and her hair is a fiery orange instead of ebon-dark. The Crone’s transformation is the most drastic. In the place of a stately older woman is a monstrous hag, hunchbacked, with gnarled clawed hands.
Siolad:
Concentrating and forcing your will against your own perceptions, the scene shimmers and changes around you. The Mother and Crone’s forms remain unchanged, glowing with unearthly radiance. The Maid’s perfection melts away and in her place is a beautiful young woman but with mortal limitations. Freckles dot her face and her hair is a fiery orange instead of ebon-dark.
Concentrating and forcing your will against your own perceptions, the scene shimmers and changes around you. The Maid’s perfection melts away and in her place is a beautiful young woman but with mortal limitations. Freckles dot her face and her hair is a fiery orange instead of ebon-dark. The Mother and Crone’s transformation is much more drastic as they are revealed to be monstrous hags, hunchbacked, with gnarled clawed hands.
"Excuse me, ladies," Ventus calls out to the witches, "I believe we have been misled. Can we drop the illusions? My friends and I do not like being lied to or being bargained with under false pretenses."
The Mother and Crone glare at Ventus with cold anger on their features and the Maid's eyes water with unshed tears. Suddenly filled with shame, she hides behind the other women.
"We see what we want to see", the Crone explains. "Some lies are told to as a mercy. Are you certain you know what you're asking?"
Siolad, give me a priority list of equipping stuff.
"I can already see you for what you are," Ventus said, "Some, it seems, are lucky or unlucky enough to see through your weavings. I am not one to break a deal though and I am willing to offer two pieces of my equipment to cover my friends tribute in their stead."
Telekinetic Fist: 8/8|Male Elf Wizard (Transmuter) 12|HP: 50/55|AC: 13/13/10|Saves: Fort +5, Ref +7, Will +8|Init: +5|Perc: +2
Diplomacy:1d20 + 2 ⇒ (12) + 2 = 14 "Please don't take this the wrong way, but... um... isn't it better to bargain on the level, ladies?" Siolad says. He winces.
Male Dwarf Barbarian 12 [ HP 62/185* (0 NL) | AC 28 Tch 13 FF N/A (23) | Fort +18* Ref +10* Will +10* | CMD 33* | Init +4 Perc +15 | Effects: rage, 2 negative levels ]
Back at Camp
Pirknok frowns. "Hope they're okay," he mutters. "Witches shudint be messed with."
Silently he gets up and retrieves his armor, his sword already having been strapped to his waist. Still frowning, he begins putting on his armor. "Tea does sound good, though," he adds after a few seconds.
”Fine!” the Crone barks. ”I’m of the mind that we should turn all of you into field mice and let the hawks outside have their fun but this opportunity might still be salvaged. At least one of you has some decency.”
The Crone and Mother gesture briefly revealing their true forms - towering hunchbacked hags. Long limp greasy hair frames their monstrous features and they sneer at Ensu and Siolad. ”Out. Both of you”, the Mother growls.
The Maid continues to cower behind her monstrous kin.
"Hold on," Ventus goes to the chest and takes out his equipment, "One final request, I want to know if this is the path you have chosen for yourself," Ventus says, looking directly at the Maid.
With her arms strategically positioned, the Maid pokes her head out. ”Y-yes”, she stammers weakly. ”These women are my family and you’ve been very rude.”
”See granddaughter, it’s as I told you. Men are not to be trusted”, the Crone warns.
Telekinetic Fist: 8/8|Male Elf Wizard (Transmuter) 12|HP: 50/55|AC: 13/13/10|Saves: Fort +5, Ref +7, Will +8|Init: +5|Perc: +2
The Mother's words finally get Siolad to stop. He turns, his face blank. "Thank the gods above for that."
He addresses the Maiden. "Is this really the sort of life you want for yourself? I won't lie--there are countless men who are shallow and cowardly, but does hiding your true self from them make you any better? Are you doing this because *you* want to? Or are you doing this because you want your family to accept you? How far are you willing to go for that?"
He turns back to the cavern entrance. "Think on it. That's what a person would do, not a pawn." He leaves.
Diplomacy:1d20 + 2 ⇒ (18) + 2 = 20
”We had agreed to help you in your conflict with the ogres that have claimed the caves above but since you and the elf have betrayed our agreement, you should be grateful that I haven’t set my mind to picking the flesh from your bones with my teeth”, the Crone says with plain hostility. ”If you insist on staying and witnessing your companion’s coupling with my granddaughter, I suggest you remain utterly silent.”
Hags/Witches often gather in covens, the most common being a trio - the Maid, Mother, and Crone. Together their magic is multiplied several fold and they're capable of feats far outside their individual power. The ritualistic nature of their magic requires covens to strictly adhere to their positions including physically. The maid's deflowering likely marks and an important time in the coven's history.
The Crone is furious, on the verge of ending all civility and attacking. The only thing holding her back is the continued faith that the coupling between Ventus and the Maid will still happen. The Maid seems honest.
You'll need Nature to learn about the actual hags.
Male Gnome Cleric 12 | HP 86/86 | AC 19 | T 11 | FF 19 | CMD 16 | Fort +12 | Ref +7 | Will +17 | Init +4 | Perc +6 | Sense Motive +20
"If I may, I'd like to confer with my companion here before he does this. I believe he might need some pointers from someone more...experienced than he is. This is an important rite for the Maid here and I'd like to see it happen appropriately."
Without waiting for permission, Ensu steps over to Ventus and turning his back on the hags, he whispers. "I don't trust these things. In order to overcome them, we might need to get them out of their proper physical position. I wish the wizard hadn't left. What might you know about the hags?
Telekinetic Fist: 8/8|Male Elf Wizard (Transmuter) 12|HP: 50/55|AC: 13/13/10|Saves: Fort +5, Ref +7, Will +8|Init: +5|Perc: +2
Siolad pauses at the entrance of the cave. He racks his brain...
I shouldn't have left them behind. Maiden, Mother, Crone... smacks of hags. But what? Knowledge (Nature):1d20 + 14 ⇒ (20) + 14 = 34
He keeps thinking as he starts back inside the cave. Can't leave them in there alone. They'll probably regret it... Knowledge (Arcana):1d20 + 19 ⇒ (7) + 19 = 26
He makes sure to cast his extended stoneskin spell before he goes too far.
The Mother is a Storm Hag, a monstrous creature with power over nature including several spell-like abilities. They can fly and charge where claws and fangs with electrical energy. She is generally resistant to magic.
The Crone is a Blood Hag. She can charge herself with fiery energy and literally explode if angered. She is also resistant to magic.
The Maid is a normal human girl, nervous and self-conscious. She does not appear to have any monstrous or otherworldly traits.