Changing Factions After Lantern Lodge


Pathfinder Society

Grand Lodge 1/5

So, I was at a game yesterday and I was speaking with some players and said that I would play Lantern Lodge until the closing adventure.

Now some players said they'd prefer Shadow Lodge.

My response was, that I would transfer to the Shadow Lodge after ending the Lantern Lodge. Which did prompt everyone at my table of lvl. 1s to change their PCs to Lantern Lodge and follow my example.

So, quick question is. Will this be allowed?

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/55/5 **

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Charter Superscriber; Starfinder Charter Superscriber

Ok, I am trying to understand what you are saying here...

Are you asking if a Level 1 PC can change factions?

If so then yes, the Level 1 rebuild rules allow that.

Or are you asking about what will happen when the Lantern Lodge and Shadow go away as factions in a few months?

Shadow Lodge *

Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Starfinder Superscriber

So what I think you're asking is if you can have a character be in the Lantern Lodge, play through the Way of the Kirin, use your free faction change to go to the Shadow Lodge, play through Rivalries' End, and use another free faction change to change to one of the remaining factions.

I *think* you can. Worst case, it would be ruled that you had to pay for that second Faction change with PPs.

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/55/5 **

Pathfinder Battles Case Subscriber; Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Charter Superscriber; Starfinder Charter Superscriber

Since we have actually not seen the rules yet for the free faction change, at least I have not yet, I think it is premature for any of us to be able answer that question if the question is what pH unbalanced saud.

Also, As far as I am aware the free faction change will not happen until Season 5 which at that point you can't become Shadow Lodge.

Grand Lodge 3/5

If you are trying to do what pH said then no, because of what Dragnmoon said. The free faction change isn't granted after Way of the Kirin. It is granted at the conclusion of Season 4 (PaizoCon) and must be made by the start of Season 5 (GenCon).

Grand Lodge 1/5

The way I understood it was that you change factions after you complete the Way of the Kirin, which then gives you the option to change factions or you can hold on to it until the end of S4, when it will automatically be changed for you.

So, if you can change it after the mission, I should be able to pick a new faction, once my faction no longer exists.

Paizo Employee Developer

2 people marked this as a favorite.

The extra-special bonus awarded for playing Way of the Kirin with a Lantern Lodge PC will not stack with the bonus for playing a Shadow Lodge PC in Rivalry's End. If you want to make that change, you can do so, but you'll only get one free faction change at the end of the season, so you'd need to pay for either the switch to the Shadow Lodge or the switch from Shadow Lodge to another one.

Silver Crusade 4/5

Mark Moreland wrote:
The extra-special bonus awarded for playing Way of the Kirin with a Lantern Lodge PC will not stack with the bonus for playing a Shadow Lodge PC in Rivalry's End. If you want to make that change, you can do so, but you'll only get one free faction change at the end of the season, so you'd need to pay for either the switch to the Shadow Lodge or the switch from Shadow Lodge to another one.

Exactly when can faction changes take place? For story reasons, I'd like to play my Lantern Lodge character in Way of the Kirin, then switch factions immediately. I'm really hoping I don't have to wait a month or two to change factions after Way of the Kirin, especially if later season 4 scenarios don't have faction missions for LL any more.

5/5 *

Mark, you may want to clarify because the blog post as well as the podcast mention "character will have up to August 14th to change", implying that you can switch from any point now until gencon.

I think your post that the boons will not stack will answer the OPs question. My guess is you get ONE free faction change due to the elimination of the factions. Any more than that is exploiting the system and you need to pay the required PP for it. Level 1 characters could change now for free, but not later (and they'd need to be 3 by the summer to play in it)

Fromper, my guess is all season 4 scenarios would have LL missions. They can't guarantee when or in what order a character/player will get to play Way of the Kirin.

Silver Crusade 4/5

I'd still like my Lantern Lodge character to leave the Lodge right after playing Way of the Kirin, without having to wait until August 14. I'm just waiting for the official announcement about the details of the faction changes.

And I was also considering the "Can I change from Lantern Lodge to Shadow Lodge and try for both boons?" question even before I saw this thread, so I'm glad we have a clarification on that already.

Grand Lodge 4/5 Pathfinder Society Campaign Coordinator

4 people marked this as a favorite.

If you are Shadow Lodge or Lantern Lodge, You are able to change factions once for free between now and Gen Con. Whenever you decide to do it is solely up to you.

Silver Crusade 4/5

Michael Brock wrote:
If you are Shadow Lodge or Lantern Lodge, You are able to change factions once for free between now and Gen Con. Whenever you decide to do it is solely up to you.

Thanks for the clarification. I just wasn't sure when the starting time period for changing was.

Next question: What happens to a PC who doesn't change in time? As a non-hypothetical example, I have a level 14 Shadow Lodge barbarian who I may never play again. Given that his identity and life story are pretty closely linked to having Grandmaster Torch as his mentor, I've decided that since it'll probably never matter anyhow, I'm not going to bother picking a new faction for him. What happens if I end up playing him in a module or GenCon special or something in a year or two?

Shadow Lodge

Fromper wrote:
Michael Brock wrote:
If you are Shadow Lodge or Lantern Lodge, You are able to change factions once for free between now and Gen Con. Whenever you decide to do it is solely up to you.

Thanks for the clarification. I just wasn't sure when the starting time period for changing was.

Next question: What happens to a PC who doesn't change in time? As a non-hypothetical example, I have a level 14 Shadow Lodge barbarian who I may never play again. Given that his identity and life story are pretty closely linked to having Grandmaster Torch as his mentor, I've decided that since it'll probably never matter anyhow, I'm not going to bother picking a new faction for him. What happens if I end up playing him in a module or GenCon special or something in a year or two?

I would assume that the character simply wouldn't be legal until you chose a new faction.

Paizo Employee Developer

Fromper wrote:
Next question: What happens to a PC who doesn't change in time?

Then the next time that PC plays, it needs to choose a new faction.

Silver Crusade 4/5

Mark Moreland wrote:
Fromper wrote:
Next question: What happens to a PC who doesn't change in time?
Then the next time that PC plays, it needs to choose a new faction.

That's pretty much the answer I was hoping for. That leaves me the option of retiring the character as Shadow Lodge and worrying about it if/when I ever end up playing him again. Given the special title he earned at the end of Eyes of the Ten, I think I already know what faction he'll take for his new one, but I refuse to change until I have to. :P

The Exchange

Sorry if this has already been answered, but I haven't found it yet.

First:
Story wise are the members of the Lantern Lodge (or Shadow Lodge)expected to mostly go toward one or another of the remaining lodges?

For example, while players have a choice, will the storyline expect that most Lanter Lodge members of the society go to say Qadira?

Second:
I have repeatedly heard it mentioned that there will be a special boon for people in Lantern Lodge when it goes away. Are they really just talking about the one you get at the end of Way of the Kirin? Or is there something else?
Because I am unlikely to be 3rd level to play it by this summer.

Shadow Lodge

Selter Sago de'Morcaine PFS wrote:
Are they really just talking about the one you get at the end of Way of the Kirin?

To my knowledge, yes. Characters who play Way of the Kirin while still being members of the Lantern Lodge will earn a boon from that adventure; no other special boons for former Lantern Lodge members appear to be planned.

The same can be said for Shadow Lodge members and Rivalry's End.

5/5

I believe you'd be able to play the adventure with an appropriate level pregen and apply that to a lower level character, so they'd get the boon once they reach the level of the pregen.

The Exchange

zefig wrote:
I believe you'd be able to play the adventure with an appropriate level pregen and apply that to a lower level character, so they'd get the boon once they reach the level of the pregen.

That would be perfect. Thx!

Paizo Employee Developer

Selter Sago de'Morcaine PFS wrote:


Story wise are the members of the Lantern Lodge (or Shadow Lodge)expected to mostly go toward one or another of the remaining lodges?

No, players will be able to choose any faction and the metaplot of the campaign won't urge them toward any faction over the other seven.

Selter Sago de'Morcaine PFS wrote:

I have repeatedly heard it mentioned that there will be a special boon for people in Lantern Lodge when it goes away. Are they really just talking about the one you get at the end of Way of the Kirin? Or is there something else?

Because I am unlikely to be 3rd level to play it by this summer.

The boon will appear on the Way of the Kirin Chronicle sheet and only be applicable to a PC who is a member of the Lantern Lodge when playing the scenario. Since the Lantern Lodge will remain a valid option only until the start of Season 5, after that point no one will qualify for the boon.

The Exchange

Mark Moreland wrote:
...
Selter Sago de'Morcaine PFS wrote:

I have repeatedly heard it mentioned that there will be a special boon for people in Lantern Lodge when it goes away. Are they really just talking about the one you get at the end of Way of the Kirin? Or is there something else?

Because I am unlikely to be 3rd level to play it by this summer.
The boon will appear on the Way of the Kirin Chronicle sheet and only be applicable to a PC who is a member of the Lantern Lodge when playing the scenario. Since the Lantern Lodge will remain a valid option only until the start of Season 5, after that point no one will qualify for the boon.

Is it possible, as zefig suggested, to play the pregen and apply the chronicle sheet (with boon) to a character who is in the lantern lodge but not yet 3rd level (when it eventually does reach 3rd level).

1/5

[tongue-in-cheek]Are there even going to be other faction missions for The Way of the Kirin?[/tongue-in-cheek]

In all seriousness though, is the lantern lodge mission going to be exceptionally difficult due to the fact that just about everyone at the table will be lantern lodge?

Shadow Lodge

Selter Sago de'Morcaine PFS wrote:
Is it possible, as zefig suggested, to play the pregen and apply the chronicle sheet (with boon) to a character who is in the lantern lodge but not yet 3rd level (when it eventually does reach 3rd level).

I don't know, to be honest. The pregen is supposed to be Grand Lodge, and if you don't actually apply the chronicle until AFTER the start of Season 5...

Also, you'd need to reach at least level four, since you apply the chronicle once you reach the level of the pregen played, and there are no level three pregens.

2/5

If I have no chance to play the adventure, but can run it, will the boon also apply?

Sovereign Court

Michael Brock wrote:
If you are Shadow Lodge or Lantern Lodge, You are able to change factions once for free between now and Gen Con. Whenever you decide to do it is solely up to you.

Just want to verify whether or not there's a process to this, or if I can just go to my character and 'edit' his faction...

Thanks in advance.

Shadow Lodge 3/5

Are the boons the same mechanically? (assuming they don't stack)

Shadow Lodge 3/5

PeteZero wrote:
If I have no chance to play the adventure, but can run it, will the boon also apply?

It'd be the same with any boon; if you run a scenario with a boon on its chronicle sheet, the boon applies to whichever character you apply credit to.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/55/55/55/5 **** Venture-Captain, California—San Francisco Bay Area North & East

When at GenCon? Do the required changes hit at the start of the con, or at the end of it? Pushing to get 40 fame before then is going to be tight.

Lantern Lodge 4/5

thistledown wrote:
When at GenCon? Do the required changes hit at the start of the con, or at the end of it? Pushing to get 40 fame before then is going to be tight.

You have had to switch factions by the time Gen Con begins. You don't have the whole con to build up prestige.

The Exchange

I don't think anybody asked this and if they did I am sorry for the repeat.

What happens to any faction traits you make have? Will those go away and you must take a new trait or will they stay as a trait for your character from now on?

So for a little more clarification of the questions: I believe that if you switch factions using prestige points you do keep your faction traits, should you have any. Therefore will the same be true of the free switch?

And I did see that someone said that the official rules have not been released so I guess this is all speculation at this point anyway.

Scarab Sages 4/5

I believe on the podcast Mike, Mark, and John said yes, you get to keep your faction vanities and traits. I don't think anything has been said to change that. I sure hope it's the case, anyway, as my ninja is 1 Fame away from qualifying for Master (failed one faction mission, due to a lack of the Intimidate skill). Also, she'd lose her weapon proficiency in her primary weapon if she lost the faction trait.

Grand Lodge 4/5

I believe that you, in general, keep your faction traits, however, there is one faction trait, for Lantern Lodge, that is also being retired when the faction goesa away as PC-playable.

I believe it is mentioned in the blog. For what it's worth, my weak memory thinks it is Master, but definitely check the blog to verify.

Scarab Sages 4/5

The blog doesn't say anything about faction traits or vanities from what I can see. You even responded in the feedback about needing to be almost to 8th level to qualify for Master. It's possible that was said somewhere else, which would be mildly disappointing. I still have the option of not spending the prestige, and I suppose I'd immediately qualify for whatever faction I change to's 40 fame vanity, but for Lantern Lodge character's that already have Master, they'd be out their title, 10prestige points, and the benefit of the vanity (+2 Init). So I hope you're remembering incorrectly, but if anyone knows if this was said somewhere, can you link to it?

Grand Lodge 5/5

Runnetib wrote:
Michael Brock wrote:
If you are Shadow Lodge or Lantern Lodge, You are able to change factions once for free between now and Gen Con. Whenever you decide to do it is solely up to you.

Just want to verify whether or not there's a process to this, or if I can just go to my character and 'edit' his faction...

Thanks in advance.

I'd like an answer to this as well. Do we just go online to our character hit edit and pick a new faction? Then all the points suddenly show up for that faction?

My Account > Pathfinder Society (make changes) > edit character > click on new faction?

1/5 *

Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

No link, but my memory is that the one item no longer available would be the Shadow Lodge's discounted body retrieval service (No one left behind). Not sure why that needed to be called out specifically as gone, but it was. I believe ex Lantern Lodge PCs can keep all traits and vanities purchased.

The Exchange

And as a further clarification if they are 1st level would they get to keep a Lantern/Shadow Lodge trait?

My train of thought is because they can switch for "free" anyway would they be forced to only have legal things at the time of play and not the time of creation?

Does that make any sense?

Scarab Sages 4/5

First World Bard wrote:
No link, but my memory is that the one item no longer available would be the Shadow Lodge's discounted body retrieval service (No one left behind). Not sure why that needed to be called out specifically as gone, but it was. I believe ex Lantern Lodge PCs can keep all traits and vanities purchased.

Well that's a relief. I'm not sure why that vanity would need to be called out either, since once you've switched factions, you wouldn't have access to it.

Shadow Lodge 4/5

What about "Don't Sully the Name"? I still have a lot of Season 2 scenarios I haven't played, and it would be a nice bonus to keep.

Scarab Sages 4/5

Good question. I assume without a statement saying you can't keep it, and the previous statement saying you can keep vanities, that you'd be allowed to keep it. It would hardly seem fair for Shadow Lodge characters to lose all their vanities, while Lantern Lodge characters keep theirs. Though that would be exactly like the Decemvirate, trying to break the union.

Are Shadow Lodge agents in Season 2 falsely claiming they represent Torch? Or do they actually represent Torch? I guess I remember some scenarios with rogue shadow lodge in season 2.

Also, man, compared to the other factions, Shadow Lodge got the short end of the stick when it comes to vanities. They have a few good traits, but save 2pp on a body recovery compared to save 8pp on a raise dead for Osirion? Don't Sully the Name compared to most other 20 fame vanities is extremely specialized. And those are their only two options. At least they only have to suffer the insult a little while longer. My Shadow Lodge character might get to 20 fame, but it's just not the same appeal as Master or even Honorific. No title and a situational bonus that will likely only become less able to be used going forward.

Lantern Lodge, on the other hand, has some of the best traits and vanities.

Sovereign Court 5/5 ***

Ferious Thune wrote:
Lantern Lodge, on the other hand, has some of the best traits and vanities.

You, Sir, should have a look at Taldor!

Shadow Lodge 4/5

Ferious Thune wrote:
Are Shadow Lodge agents in Season 2 falsely claiming they represent Torch? Or do they actually represent Torch? I guess I remember some scenarios with rogue shadow lodge in season 2.

That's the doublethink getting to you. In season 2, they were all really Shadow Lodge. In Season 3 and 4, they were "Rogue" Shadow Lodge. Now, with SL no longer a playable faction in Season 5, they may go back to being "real" Shadow Lodge agents.

1/5

Mystic Lemur wrote:
Ferious Thune wrote:
Are Shadow Lodge agents in Season 2 falsely claiming they represent Torch? Or do they actually represent Torch? I guess I remember some scenarios with rogue shadow lodge in season 2.
That's the doublethink getting to you. In season 2, they were all really Shadow Lodge. In Season 3 and 4, they were "Rogue" Shadow Lodge. Now, with SL no longer a playable faction in Season 5, they may go back to being "real" Shadow Lodge agents.

I thought that during Season 2 they were 'rogue' in the sense that the majority of Shadow Lodge agents had betrayed Torch and tried to leave him twisting in the wind, and the PC faction was basically the few remnants that stayed loyal to Torch during the whole mess plus whoever he could recruit to replace the assets that were destroyed over the course of the season.

Grand Lodge 4/5

Season 2 Shadow Lodge were, mainly, a bunch of anti-Pathfinders, mainly former/existing Pathfinders, who worked for someone besides Grandmaster Torch. Indeed, in one Season 2 scenario, your Pathfinder mission, IIRC, is to prevent GT from being assassinated...

Spoiler:
The Spider (Spyder?), and that is why certain reveals in Season 4 can cause some people at a table to go "Say what?!?"

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / Changing Factions After Lantern Lodge All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Pathfinder Society