pfs witch dedication

Pathfinder Society

Dark Archive

Hey I've done a few searches and all I'm finding is arguements with no answers, so is there a PFS specific ruling on how the familiar from the Witch dedication works?

Specifically "Your familiar has one less familiar ability than normal."
A> Your familiar only gets 1 ability ever unless you take a special feat.
B> It's one less than an actual Witches familiar, which gets bonuses, so 2, but it never goes up because you're not leveling as a witch.
C> It's a Witches familiar minus 1 and it does scale with your level so 2, 3 @6th, 4 @12th, & 5 @18th
D> There's no official PFS guidance and it's up to the whim of your current session GM.

1/5 5/55/5 ** Venture-Agent, Online—VTT

Nope. No special campaign rule. (Special campaign rulings on rules questions like that are not actually very common).

Sczarni 5/5 5/55/5 ***

TiwazBlackhand wrote:
D. There's no official PFS guidance

Yeah this would be a rules question.

The only guidance we could give you here would be to 1) bring up the question to your GM before game starts, and 2) plan your build conservatively.

2/5 5/5 *

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Adventure Path, Lost Omens Subscriber

Having read likely the same discussion threads as you, the conclusion that I came to are this:

The default familiar has 2 abilities.
The witch class feature grants a familiar extra abilities based on witch level.
The witch dedication grants you "a familiar" (not "a familiar like a witch" or "as the witch class feature" or even "a witch's familiar"), which I interpret to mean a default familiar, and deducts one ability from that familiar.

Therefore, a familiar from the witch dedication has a paltry one ability. Trust me, I wanted to come to a different conclusion, but I could not.

So Nefreet's advice is the best: discuss it with your GM (briefly and accept their ruling) and plan conservatively. Sometimes you may have two abilities and sometimes you may have one, depending on the GM.

Sovereign Court 3/5 *

Of course, unless the Witch's familiar is a powerful doesn't really put a familiar into play anyways. They are essentially just a living conduit for a witch to be able to cast their spells.

2/5 5/5 *

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Lost Omens Subscriber

I wouldn't say familiar/master abilities are useless.

Dark Archive 4/5 ** Venture-Lieutenant, Finland—Turku

Just want to point out that normally spellcasting dedications give you 2 cantrips. Witch gives you 1 which you can swap out, plus familiar with "one less ability than normal", plus one trained skill.

Wizard gives you 1 skill and 2 cantrips which you can swap out
Sorcerer gives you 2 skills and 2 cantrips
Oracle gives you 2 skills and 2 cantrips
Bard gives you 2 skills and 2 cantrips

If witch dedication gave you familiar with 2 abilities, it would be strictly better than wizard: You could pick extra cantrip as one ability, and the other whatever you like, resulting in
1 skill, 2 cantrips, and a familiar with 1 ability left. That 1 ability could be "skilled", to get level + int to a single skill of your choice per day.

If it's strictly a familiar with 1 ability, it seems more in line with the rest of the spellcasting dedications: You have less stuff overall, but you have the flexibility to pick and choose what that "last thing you get" is, on day-to-day basis, for 1 skill, 1 cantrip, and 1 free floating ability.

The answer is likely A, probably not B, and definitely should not be C.

Horizon Hunters 2/5 *** Venture-Agent, California—Silicon Valley

Wish they would change it to specify a specific number of abilities, rather than "one less familiar ability than normal". Just say "Your familiar gains only 1 ability, and does not gain more like a witch normally would."

But the existence of the line in Basic Witchcraft, "Your familiar no longer has one less familiar ability than normal." leads me to believe it's 1 until you get that feat, then it's two. You don't gain additional familiar abilities with the archetype.

2/5 5/5 *

Pathfinder Adventure Path, Lost Omens Subscriber

It might be intended to work with the Enhanced Familiar feat, where you'd have 3: one less than the normal 4.

Dark Archive

Since people are talking about this again, I've flagged it as wrong forum.

If a mod sees this, please move it up to rules.

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / pfs witch dedication All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Pathfinder Society