Was the Extradimensional School overlooked?

[Nohwear]

Assuming that it is not being reserved for a boon, why do you think that the Extradimensional School from Black Markets was not sanctioned? I am perfectly willing to consider the fact that it is a lot more powerful then I think it is.

[Azouth]

Nohwear wrote:

Assuming that it is not being reserved for a boon, why do you think that the Extradimensional School from Black Markets was not sanctioned? I am perfectly willing to consider the fact that it is a lot more powerful then I think it is.

It is the only one that replaces Summoner's Charm, so maybe that is a clue.

[Ragoz]

Might be a boon. It doesn't look like it was banned for a power reason.

[Azouth]

Now that I think about it does this have any use before 3rd level?
I can't think of any first level spell that this would work on.

[Nohwear]

Azouth wrote:

Now that I think about it does this have any use before 3rd level?

I can't think of any first level spell that this would work on.

Is that much different than the Generation School?

[Serum]

Stumble gap creates extra dimensional space.

[Azouth]

Nohwear wrote:

Azouth wrote:

Now that I think about it does this have any use before 3rd level?

I can't think of any first level spell that this would work on.

Is that much different than the Generation School?

Well at least there are Evocation with a duration greater than instantaneous that are lower then 2nd. Not that the extra round will matter that much for most of them. Great now floating disk last 1 hour and 1 round or you need to cast dancing light 6 less times in an hour.

[Azouth]

Serum wrote:

Stumble gap creates extra dimensional space.

Well at least there is one spell.

[Tindalen]

Remember, banning is not always a case of power. Sometimes it is a case of unnecessary confusion. It is possible they just felt their would be more arguments about implied "extradimensional spaces" than was warranted.

Arcane pocket is also a level 1 spell that creates an extradimensional space.

[John Compton]

Linda and I have compared notes, and we both recall deciding that the subschool presented no problems in the organized play setting. I suspect that its omission was an oversight, and I have made a note to update the Black Markets entry for a future Additional Resources update.

[Nohwear]

John Compton wrote:

Linda and I have compared notes, and we both recall deciding that the subschool presented no problems in the organized play setting. I suspect that its omission was an oversight, and I have made a note to update the Black Markets entry for a future Additional Resources update.

Once again, thank you very much.