Unofficial tracker for 2015 item critiques

[Garrett Guillotte]

As I have the last two years, I'm building a Google Doc that tracks every item posted to the Critique My Item thread, and every review of every item.

Leave comments on the doc if you've got 'em! It's usually a perpetual WIP for months and isn't intended to be updated in real time; if you want to know if an item's been reviewed, the critique thread is always the best and most current source.

[Jeffrey Swank]

You rock!

[Belabras]

Awesome! Thanks for this.

[Mikael Sebag]

What a great resource, thank you!

[Lucus Palosaari]

I always appreciated you doing this in the past, and this year, I appreciate it a little more Garrett!

[Garrett Guillotte]

Thanks to Thomas LeBlanc, every item on the first three four pages already has at least a one-line non-judicial review! Eight items have 4 or more reviews, and 20 have 3 or more reviews.

[Andrew Black]

This makes the CMI Thread so much more manageable. THANKS.

[Brigg]

Ooh! Awesome!!

[frank gori]

thanks for this it is useful every year

[Feros]

This is great! Thank you so much for doing this every year!

[Garrett Guillotte]

Up to date for the moment. Wheeewww.

This year I'm breaking out the judges' comments and the non-official-thread critique threads as it's more expedient, but I'm filing the awesome reviewers tackling every item in the thread in with the rest of the reviews--for now.

Apologies to Thomas, Feros, and everyone else taking on that monumental task in-thread this year! I'll try to come back and break you guys out too once the thread has slowed down, but right now it's way more expedient for me to handle all the in-thread critiques in batches when possible.

[Garrett Guillotte]

And oh yeah, some more stats!

Items in the main critique thread so far: 113 (~14% of submitted non-Top 36 items per the pre-cull list estimates of about 800 total items)

Items with 10 or more reviews: windpath razor, enlightened jian, mail of ash woven ramparts, staff of the vineyard, raven leather, and springheart

Items that don't have comments from the judges: raw meat hook, outrider's band, rod of gravimetric attraction, ring of the deific caster

[Dana Huber]

Mad props for the work level required to do this.

[Acre]

dana huber wrote:

Mad props for the work level required to do this.

Agreed. Incredible job, Garrett. It's impressive the effort you put into help keep this all straight.

[verdigris]

Awesome. Thank you for this.

[Papasteve08]

Last year was my first year doing this, and I remember this list simply blew me away. The amount of time and effort you put into it is astounding, and you, sir, deserve a ton of credit. Thank you!

[Lucus Palosaari]

I get my own special tag! Sweet!

[Garrett Guillotte]

Stats as of about 3:30 p.m. PST Jan. 26

Items in the main critique thread: 139 (~17% of submitted non-Top 36 items per the pre-cull list estimates of about 800 total items)

Estimated reviews in all critique threads: 1,086 (7.8 reviews per item)

Items with 10 or more reviews: 38; all items on page 1 except weapon trap shield and thieving buckler, as well as riftcarver bow, rod of illusory casting, Varisian dancing chain, springheart, shield of the fallen, Cryohydra's coil, and Sarenrae’s desert caller. None of the 60 items on pages 6 onward have 10 or more reviews.

Number of items on each page, and the number of reviews for those items:

Page 1: 33 items with 402 reviews (12.2 reviews per item)
Page 2: 16 items, 155 reviews (9.7 RPI)
Page 3: 8 items, 68 reviews (8.5 RPI)
Page 4: 12 items, 90 reviews (7.5 RPI)
Page 5: 10 items, 78 reviews (7.8 RPI)
Page 6: 10 items, 65 reviews (6.5 RPI)
Page 7: 15 items, 72 reviews (4.8 RPI)
Page 8: 6 items, 29 reviews (4.8 RPI)
Page 9: 3 items, 12 reviews (4 RPI)
Page 10: 9 items, 38 reviews (4.2 RPI)
Page 11: 6 items, 26 reviews (4.3 RPI)
Page 12: 3 items, 13 reviews (4.3 RPI)
Page 13: 5 items, 28 reviews (5.6 RPI)
Page 14: 2 items, 8 reviews (4 RPI)
Page 15: 1 item, 4 reviews (4 RPI)

[frank gori]

For those looking to critique everything this is a tremendous help

[Jacob W. Michaels]

I think I've caught up on all the contestants' entries, so I'm hoping to get back to the CMI thread items in the next few days.

[Lucus Palosaari]

Hey Garrett, you slacker!

You added my Page 5 Critiques, but not my Page 4!

<I tried variously to do it myself but I wasn't sure how to make it work>

[Garrett Guillotte]

Since I'm about to fall into a glorious months-long vat of freelance work, I've unlocked the tracker for anyone to edit!

[Jaragil]

The tracker has now been brought up to date. If your item has received a review, you should be able to find it within. From now on I shall try to keep the tracker updated. If you notice that I've missed a review somewhere, feel free to send me a private message.

[Lucus Palosaari]

Thank you Jaragil!

[Jaragil]

The in-thread completionists have now been given their own letter tags.

[Curaigh]

Thanks again Garrett for doing this. Wonderful tradition :)

Thanks Jaragil for taking the mantle.